You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 2.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 68 of 166 < 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 >
briandavis Flag Udon Thani 11 Apr 18 6.10am

Years back, down at Mitcham, I had the pleasure of watching Ray Lewington 'work' a Palace player (I think Bruce Dyer) intensely on goalscoring, balls coming from everywhere, with the emphasis on scoring, working the 'keeper, at least hitting the target. Some of his time spent with Benteke MIGHT just build some confidence.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 11 Apr 18 8.33am

Originally posted by briandavis

Years back, down at Mitcham, I had the pleasure of watching Ray Lewington 'work' a Palace player (I think Bruce Dyer) intensely on goalscoring, balls coming from everywhere, with the emphasis on scoring, working the 'keeper, at least hitting the target. Some of his time spent with Benteke MIGHT just build some confidence.

That sounds like a good idea. Trouble is that there is still no viable alternative. That is not Benteke’s fault.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 11 Apr 18 8.36am

Originally posted by briandavis

Years back, down at Mitcham, I had the pleasure of watching Ray Lewington 'work' a Palace player (I think Bruce Dyer) intensely on goalscoring, balls coming from everywhere, with the emphasis on scoring, working the 'keeper, at least hitting the target. Some of his time spent with Benteke MIGHT just build some confidence.

I'm sure roy and ray hadn't thought of that.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Apr 18 8.39am

Originally posted by briandavis

Years back, down at Mitcham, I had the pleasure of watching Ray Lewington 'work' a Palace player (I think Bruce Dyer) intensely on goalscoring, balls coming from everywhere, with the emphasis on scoring, working the 'keeper, at least hitting the target. Some of his time spent with Benteke MIGHT just build some confidence.

It didn't do Dyer any good!

 

AERO Flag 11 Apr 18 1.43pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke scores a Hatrick' by Midlands Eagle

Unlikely,but what if he scored one on Saturday ,would all be forgiven ?

 

leejaneagles Flag 11 Apr 18 1.57pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke scores a Hatrick' by Midlands Eagle

Erm, depends what you define as forgiven.

If he scored a hat-trick against our fiercest rivals and that in turn dragged us over the line to safety then I wouldn't be very hard on him for the rest of the season.

I'd still want him sold in the summer and new striker brought into the club.

If he scores a hat-trick and then misses sitters for the rest of the season which result in us being relegated I'd still blame him for a lot of it after the chances he's missed and stealing that penalty in the Bournemouth game.

To be truly redeemed he'd need to score a hat-trick, then score and assist several more helping us win all 5 games remaining and finishing comfortably. He'd then cry at the end of the season speech on the pitch and beg for one more chance and I'd say he should stay until January.

That last ones a bit unlikely so I guess the answer is to your initial question is temporarily yes, but not really, I'd still dislike him a lot.

 

Woolsy Flag Essex 11 Apr 18 2.07pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke scores a Hatrick' by Midlands Eagle

I'd forgive him & sing his name until 5pm on 13th May, then he can p**s off!
He's now becoming an embarrassment. Even my wife doesn't know anything about football, calls him the useless lump upfront!

 

npn Flag Crowborough 11 Apr 18 2.29pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke scores a Hatrick' by Midlands Eagle

I don't think there's anything to forgive as such. He's having a disastrous season, undoubtedly, but it can only require forgiveness if he's either doing it on purpose, or disobeying management orders, which I don't think he is. Even if lack of work rate in tracking back is an issue, you'd have to think that's on management orders to preserve his energy for what it's needed for up front (and if it's not, it's down to management to kick his backside)

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 11 Apr 18 2.37pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke scores a Hatrick' by Midlands Eagle

I hope he scores loads in any of our final games. Then we might be able to sell him to someone, and get him off our wage bill and get a good price for him.

Who wants a 5hlt striker who can't score ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 11 Apr 18 2.50pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke scores a Hatrick' by Midlands Eagle

even if he scores just one goal it would be a hattrick of sorts I suppose

 

AshfordEagle94 Flag Canterbury 11 Apr 18 3.49pm

Honestly this whole 'would you want Benteke playing against you?' question, i think is stupid. If I was an opposition defender, the answer would be yes please he'll do my clearing work for me

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 11 Apr 18 7.48pm

Maybe we can appeal to the PL Goals Accreditation Panel. [Link]

Benteke was on the pitch when some of our other goals went in. If we can credit a lot of these to Benteke, he could end up being our top scorer this season.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 12 Apr 18 2.11am

I do think the current system doesn't favour him which is why he is not looking so great also just think of it this way you are being asked to do something you are not best at and dont like this tends to effect you I think this is large case with him.

the other things are his attitude he does appear lie nice guy but he has that vibe about him like a arrogance/cockiness which doesn't come across well his penalty misses show this (just compare ronaldo penalty to bentekes last minute ones big difference)

with the players we have defoe would of been perfect for us but i do think if roy changed it so zaha and townsend put balls in box benteke could be scoring more we dont really do this anymore and when we do both players mostly zaha mess about on the ball rather then quick ball in.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 12 Apr 18 10.57am

So now Wilf holding up the ball is messing about rather then taking pressure of our defense and giving us an actual chance to build. Amazing. I have to agree the crossing is often poor, however what has been very conspicuous is that crosses at the far post mainly seem to disappaer in nomansland. You would think that Roy would have sorted that. Either the crossing is poorer then I would imagine possible, or the running both into and around the box could be a lot more smarter too.

Originally posted by grumpymort

I do think the current system doesn't favour him which is why he is not looking so great also just think of it this way you are being asked to do something you are not best at and dont like this tends to effect you I think this is large case with him.

the other things are his attitude he does appear lie nice guy but he has that vibe about him like a arrogance/cockiness which doesn't come across well his penalty misses show this (just compare ronaldo penalty to bentekes last minute ones big difference)

with the players we have defoe would of been perfect for us but i do think if roy changed it so zaha and townsend put balls in box benteke could be scoring more we dont really do this anymore and when we do both players mostly zaha mess about on the ball rather then quick ball in.


 

VKR1888 Flag London 12 Apr 18 11.17am

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

So now Wilf holding up the ball is messing about rather then taking pressure of our defense and giving us an actual chance to build. Amazing. I have to agree the crossing is often poor, however what has been very conspicuous is that crosses at the far post mainly seem to disappaer in nomansland. You would think that Roy would have sorted that. Either the crossing is poorer then I would imagine possible, or the running both into and around the box could be a lot more smarter too.


I have to agree with Grumpy. We do not play to Big Bens strengths. We don't whip in enough balls with height. We like to play it low and last minute rather than high and early. Which is why we see the likes of Jimmy getting on to the end of things and scoring more.

I just think he is not an ideal fit. So we have two options, play more to his strengths or change personal. The latter is not a great option as we have no other strikers!

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Apr 18 11.18am

Only the top six clubs have had more shots than us this season:

[Link]

...but with regard to Tekkers it doesn't make good reading though. 57 shots, 19 on target, only 2 goals.

[Link]

On a positive note, only Townsend has provided more assists this season, and he is runaway leader in the PL for aerial battles won:

[Link]

He is clearly devoid of confidence and the question is whether he can get it back. Whatever happens what we can't do is sell him before we get an adequate replacement.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Apr 18 11.34am

Originally posted by grumpymort

I do think the current system doesn't favour him which is why he is not looking so great also just think of it this way you are being asked to do something you are not best at and dont like this tends to effect you I think this is large case with him.

the other things are his attitude he does appear lie nice guy but he has that vibe about him like a arrogance/cockiness which doesn't come across well his penalty misses show this (just compare ronaldo penalty to bentekes last minute ones big difference)

with the players we have defoe would of been perfect for us but i do think if roy changed it so zaha and townsend put balls in box benteke could be scoring more we dont really do this anymore and when we do both players mostly zaha mess about on the ball rather then quick ball in.

Maybe it's just me. But although we maybe haven't played to his strengths (by which I asume you mean crossing the ball straight onto his head on the penalty spot),surely we should expect a 30m striker on 120k a week to he able to score with his feet too? He's had 22 very good chances this season, quite a few one on ones with the keeper and scored 2. So although we may not be playing to his strengths, surely we should expect a lot better?

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 12 Apr 18 11.56am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Maybe it's just me. But although we maybe haven't played to his strengths (by which I asume you mean crossing the ball straight onto his head on the penalty spot),surely we should expect a 30m striker on 120k a week to he able to score with his feet too? He's had 22 very good chances this season, quite a few one on ones with the keeper and scored 2. So although we may not be playing to his strengths, surely we should expect a lot better?

He used to score goals like this:

[Link]

I don't think he has the confidence to do so at the moment and would probably just blast it against the keepers legs.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 12 Apr 18 1.24pm

Originally posted by Direwolf

He used to score goals like this:

[Link]

I don't think he has the confidence to do so at the moment and would probably just blast it against the keepers legs.

I assume he's scoring in training (at least I hope he is)

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 12 Apr 18 1.40pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Maybe it's just me. But although we maybe haven't played to his strengths (by which I asume you mean crossing the ball straight onto his head on the penalty spot),surely we should expect a 30m striker on 120k a week to he able to score with his feet too? He's had 22 very good chances this season, quite a few one on ones with the keeper and scored 2. So although we may not be playing to his strengths, surely we should expect a lot better?

Completely agree, all this system chat might explain him not scoring 17 again, but it doesn't explain the clear cut chances he is spurning week in week out. We are actually making decent chances, he has missed a league high chances.

 

Page 68 of 166 < 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread