Quote ASCPFC at 25 Sep 2015 4.07pm
Barritt seems to play nearly always as a defensive center and seems to do a lot of hard work that isn't noticed.
He's a defensive organiser, and he's very good at it. The problem is, he offers absolutely nothing in attack. It's pretty pointless having two great wings, which we do, when you play a 10-12-13 who will never get the ball out that wide.
Quote ASCPFC at 25 Sep 2015 4.07pm
Whereas Ford has played well in defence maybe Lancaster feels Burgess and Farrell are stronger in the tackle and a little more athletic than Ford.
The problem isn't Ford or Farrell as much as the total change in tactics at the very last minute that the change represents. If you build your entire tactical plan through the warm-up games and first game based on, to use a metaphor, 4-4-2, then it reeks of panic and disorganisation if you suddenly, and for no apparent reason, switch to 3-5-2 for the second game, especially when imperfect as it was, the first game yielded a 5-point win. Bomber isn't so much changing out-halves as completely confusing his team. How are they supposed to have faith in a coach who doesn't know his own mind? How is Ford supposed to react? Farrell is stronger than Ford in the tackle, yes. He is not more athletic. Neither point on its own should be a basis for selection.
Quote ASCPFC at 25 Sep 2015 4.07pm
In this respect I feel that Burgess and Farrell are a better physical match for Wales - I just hope Burgess is smart enough in defence as well as being strong. I would like to see Burgess and Farrell run with the ball and hand off.
First, young Henry Slade may be our best centre of all. He is exactly the player needed at 13 to cover JJ. If Bomber isn't going to use him in the role he was selected for (and instead completely change tactics) then why is Slade in the squad? It makes the selection look incompetent (which, indeed, it was.) As for Burgess, nail...head. Is he strong? Yes. Is he smart? No. Not in rugby union terms. He has no instincts. He's not even playing the position he plays for his club (in his short union career). It's madness. Yes, he can run with the ball but not in a way that will have Wales quaking in their boots, although that's not to say that he can't be effective getting over the gain line.
Quote ASCPFC at 25 Sep 2015 4.07pm
I wonder if England can handle the pressure? - if they can they should win. The media are being as helpful as ever with their comments on selection.
The media are absolutely right. Most of the commentators have a far deeper knowledge of the game than their football equivalents. I have yet to find a serious rugby expert who thinks Bomber's selection is sensible. And as for pressure, well, if you completely abandon your tactical approach the week before a big game and ask players to play a style they have not trained for months for, that's where the pressure comes from. When the coach panics, the players do the same.
Quote ASCPFC at 25 Sep 2015 4.07pm
I agree with Lancaster on the Farrell selection; I don't agree with comments about just because he is related to the coaching team.
Those comments are slightly tongue in cheek. It's an awful selection though, as noted, for tactical continuity rather than individual reasons. Also, bosh (which is now our tactic...stuff it up the jumper rugby) is NOT the way to beat Wales. We already know that from past experience.
Quote ASCPFC at 25 Sep 2015 4.07pm
Saracens have done really well in Europe, making the final of the Heineken Cup with Farrell as out-half. What more can a player do to prove his worth?
We (Northampton) have done really well in Europe, making the final of the Heineken Cup too. Much as I love him, I really wouldn't want to see Steven Myler at 10 tomorrow, even though he's done everything possible to prove his worth. I'm not saying Farrell isn't an international level 10. But he's not the right man for the job tomorrow, something Bomber has already implicitly acknowledged by building his entire team around Ford (until the start of this week.)
Quote ASCPFC at 25 Sep 2015 4.07pm
Yes, he went through a flat period with England but I suspect that challenging for his place will have done him good. He has looked good when coming on as a replacement recently and deserves his place.
Coming on for 20 minutes against tired opponents is a very different proposition than starting. Farrell is arguably much better suited to the former role, when bosh rather than nous can evade tired opposition legs.
Quote ASCPFC at 25 Sep 2015 4.07pm
I do agree with Syd and Sash about Burrell - I would prefer him over Barritt and Burgess but what's done is done so will just have to put up with it; shame Tuilagi has been so stupid too.
Edited by ASCPFC (25 Sep 2015 4.08pm)
Tuilagi stupid? Well he does play for them up the road (Leicester)...so what do you expect? LOL
The bottom line is that Bomber, I say it again, has bottled it. Faced with a must-win game after a slightly iffy performance, rather than sticking to his beliefs and principles and his game plan, he's gone totally conservative, parked the bus, and taken creativity out of the side to replace it with bosh. Could England win? Of course they could, particularly in light of Wales' injuries. Either way, it will be a very, very close game. But they have thrown away their advantage and gone from clear favourites to, at best, narrow ones.
Edited by sydtheeagle (25 Sep 2015 8.32pm)
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|