This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by elgrande
I think this about sums it up.... Sums what up? I don't even understand what point it's trying to make.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's all very well to discuss the limits of free speech and the abuse of said but this kind of intellectual discussion just hides the reality. This is really a choice between the better of two evils. I know which side I'm on. There is no reasonable comparison between the two. This over-simplifying of the situation is a massive part of the problem - this 'us v them' mentality does nothing but promote conflict and further entrench each side in their position. 'Intellectual discussion' is exactly what there needs to be more of.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
This over-simplifying of the situation is a massive part of the problem - this 'us v them' mentality does nothing but promote conflict and further entrench each side in their position. 'Intellectual discussion' is exactly what there needs to be more of. It is us v them. It is our culture that defends free speech and is free to criticise and satarise v fanatical religious murderers who want to destroy everything we stand for. We won't be able to defend ourselves with good debating skills.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Sums what up? I don't even understand what point it's trying to make. Really.....FFS
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Sums what up? I don't even understand what point it's trying to make. Which bit is hard for you to understand,or are just being deliberately dumb.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Sums what up? I don't even understand what point it's trying to make. In that case you are either thicker than a whale omelette, or being deliberately obtuse. I'll bet my sweet ass it's the later of the two, because you have precisely sh1tall counter argument against his rather splendid analogy
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
In that case you are either thicker than a whale omelette, or being deliberately obtuse. I'll bet my sweet ass it's the later of the two, because you have precisely sh1tall counter argument against his rather splendid analogy No surprise to see you not actually make a point and throw insults around - the signature of you and your right wing boy band on here. Please explain to me what the 'splendid analogy' sums up, if you can.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It is us v them. It is our culture that defends free speech and is free to criticise and satarise v fanatical religious murderers who want to destroy everything we stand for. We won't be able to defend ourselves with good debating skills. I think if you use the phrase 'religious' in that phrase, it becomes accurate. Of course, we should consider the abuse of free speech to incite hatred, free speech isn't an absolute. Incidents where right wing groups deliberately use the defence of free speech to promote hate and incite others, should be addressed. After all we do all have to live togeather, and that does mean including some respect of the people who make up our society - all of those people.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I think if you use the phrase 'religious' in that phrase, it becomes accurate. Of course, we should consider the abuse of free speech to incite hatred, free speech isn't an absolute. Incidents where right wing groups deliberately use the defence of free speech to promote hate and incite others, should be addressed. After all we do all have to live togeather, and that does mean including some respect of the people who make up our society - all of those people. Right wing groups are beside the point. What they say or do has nothing to do with the basic principle. The law says what they can and can't do.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's all very well to discuss the limits of free speech and the abuse of said but this kind of intellectual discussion just hides the reality. This is really a choice between the better of two evils. I know which side I'm on. There is no reasonable comparison between the two. Firstly, I don't think you can compromise with the likes of IS et al, they've chosen their side, and its us against them. However, that's not to say that Muslims in the UK and issues that are alienating them from society, which is leading to them being radicalised, can't be addressed and resolved. Free Speech and expression can exist alongside curtailing the right to incite and anger. There is no reason why the UK couldn't make it illegal to print images of the prophet Mohammed, provided they made an exception on the basis of artistic merit or for religious purposes. We have to include different subcultures and groups of minorities into society, for society to function, and part of that is compromise (because for a large part most of us, will fit into some minority subculture and group), and its reasonable to compromise 'values' within reason, to allow other citizens a richer existence. You'll always have some people who want more. But the important thing is to engage the majority. As seen in the rise of the Labour movement, accepting some form of socialism and an outlet, has proven far more productive than just ignoring the issue. Hell you can see it with UKIP's rise, on the back of the failure of Labour to represent traditional working class voters that made up the party's core. The rising militancy and radicalisation isn't anything new. Issues, alienation and lack of a means of affecting change, feed into militancy. It did in Ireland, it resulted in the Red Brigades and Baader Meinhoff phenomena, and its been that way throughout history.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Firstly, I don't think you can compromise with the likes of IS et al, they've chosen their side, and its us against them. However, that's not to say that Muslims in the UK and issues that are alienating them from society, which is leading to them being radicalised, can't be addressed and resolved. Free Speech and expression can exist alongside curtailing the right to incite and anger. There is no reason why the UK couldn't make it illegal to print images of the prophet Mohammed, provided they made an exception on the basis of artistic merit or for religious purposes. We have to include different subcultures and groups of minorities into society, for society to function, and part of that is compromise (because for a large part most of us, will fit into some minority subculture and group), and its reasonable to compromise 'values' within reason, to allow other citizens a richer existence. You'll always have some people who want more. But the important thing is to engage the majority. As seen in the rise of the Labour movement, accepting some form of socialism and an outlet, has proven far more productive than just ignoring the issue. Hell you can see it with UKIP's rise, on the back of the failure of Labour to represent traditional working class voters that made up the party's core. The rising militancy and radicalisation isn't anything new. Issues, alienation and lack of a means of affecting change, feed into militancy. It did in Ireland, it resulted in the Red Brigades and Baader Meinhoff phenomena, and its been that way throughout history. This all sounds very reasonable but I do not agree. I think there is every reason not to ban images of the prophet. It would be the thin end of the wedge and run totally counter to our secular principles. This is our country and we set the rules. The rise of UKIP had been partly because a large section of society resents having mass migration forced on them and the cultural effects that has had as well as all the financial issues. How will pandering to religious medievalism go down? It is unthinkable. We have a duty to uphold what is right and true to our beliefs. If people are offended by our attitudes then they should not choose to live in the West. We the people are not responsible for radicalising Muslims. Politicians are the ones who have throw out the welcome mat to Muslims and at the same time have been involved in very questionable military action in predominantly Muslim countries. If any one is to blame for helping radicalise it is them. The vast majority of people in the West cannot compromise their belief systems to pander to a small minority because of the actions of their governments. They created this situation and they need to sort it out by all means necessary bar appeasement. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Jul 2016 10.53am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Firstly, I don't think you can compromise with the likes of IS et al, they've chosen their side, and its us against them. However, that's not to say that Muslims in the UK and issues that are alienating them from society, which is leading to them being radicalised, can't be addressed and resolved. Free Speech and expression can exist alongside curtailing the right to incite and anger. There is no reason why the UK couldn't make it illegal to print images of the prophet Mohammed, provided they made an exception on the basis of artistic merit or for religious purposes. We have to include different subcultures and groups of minorities into society, for society to function, and part of that is compromise (because for a large part most of us, will fit into some minority subculture and group), and its reasonable to compromise 'values' within reason, to allow other citizens a richer existence. You'll always have some people who want more. But the important thing is to engage the majority. As seen in the rise of the Labour movement, accepting some form of socialism and an outlet, has proven far more productive than just ignoring the issue. Hell you can see it with UKIP's rise, on the back of the failure of Labour to represent traditional working class voters that made up the party's core. The rising militancy and radicalisation isn't anything new. Issues, alienation and lack of a means of affecting change, feed into militancy. It did in Ireland, it resulted in the Red Brigades and Baader Meinhoff phenomena, and its been that way throughout history. There are no images of him, only drawings that people say are him. So making a generic image illegal would be impossible. Actual real, living, people struggle to control having their image published so making a law for a circa 1300 year old dead bloke is utter lunacy.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall
apologies if posted elsewhere. Any minute now someone will reply to say that they'll wager that more French children have attacked Moroccans for wearing too many clothes.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
Any minute now someone will reply to say that they'll wager that more French children have attacked Moroccans for wearing too many clothes. what do I know Stuk mate.
horrible times we are living in.
Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents? |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
There are no images of him, only drawings that people say are him. So making a generic image illegal would be impossible. Actual real, living, people struggle to control having their image published so making a law for a circa 1300 year old dead bloke is utter lunacy. Well yes, but then if it wasn't defined as a picture of Mohammed, it wouldn't be illegal. We have stupid rules for a bloke who died 1300 years before that, that prevent say Gay people getting married in church, or women for having jobs as his spokesman etc. We could live with a few rules that prevent people needlessly provoking British citizens. Sikh's can carry knives and not wear crash helmets, Catholic nurses and Doctors can refuse any association to work related to abortion and the UK even allows for religious polygamy, provide marriage occurred outside the UK and so on and so forth. But I understand that making similar exceptions for Muslims would bring down all of western civilisation. Personally, I think the question isn't whether you have the freedom to do something, but why your doing it. If all you can achieve with freedom of speech is deliberately antagonising people, then its wasted on those people. I means sure, you could create a picture of a nun sucking a donkey with a crucifix up her arse, and stick it on a magazine cover - but there's only one reason your doing it, to court controversy and upset people. We can probably get by with legislating that publishing pictures or images of the prophet Mohammed should only be accepted where artistic merit can be established.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
This all sounds very reasonable but I do not agree. I think there is every reason not to ban images of the prophet. It would be the thin end of the wedge and run totally counter to our secular principles. We make all manner of special exemptions in law for religion, and not just Christianity. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
This is our country and we set the rules. The rise of UKIP had been partly because a large section of society resents having mass migration forced on them 4% of the UK population are Muslim. Its their country too. I thought it was about the EU. Notable that Farage isn't actually against migration, it was freedom of movement. Most Muslims in the UK stem from the Commonwealth. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
How will pandering to religious medievalism go down? It is unthinkable. We have a duty to uphold what is right and true to our beliefs. That's the language of the extremist, hyperbole and absolutes. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
If people are offended by our attitudes then they should not choose to live in the West. They're British Citizens. They belong here as much as anyone else, its their country and their attitudes. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
We the people are not responsible for radicalising Muslims. Politicians are the ones who have throw out the welcome mat to Muslims and at the same time have been involved in very questionable military action in predominantly Muslim countries. If any one is to blame for helping radicalise it is them. The vast majority of people in the West cannot compromise their belief systems to pander to a small minority because of the actions of their governments. They created this situation and they need to sort it out by all means necessary bar appeasement. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Jul 2016 10.53am) Well first of all. We're a democracy, so we the people are responsible for those politicians being in power in the first place, and politicians are supposedly accountable to us, the people. They're also the people as well. Its not about compromising a belief system. Its about incorporating some people into their own society where possible. We the people, includes all of us, every single person with British Citizenship, irrespective of age, colour, religion, gender etc. Also, its worth noting that there was no trouble with Islamic militants in the UK until very recently in history. Most Muslims in the UK are third generation, and until 2005, not a single incident of suicide bombing etc.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall
what do I know Stuk mate.
horrible times we are living in. Its always been a bit like that.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well yes, but then if it wasn't defined as a picture of Mohammed, it wouldn't be illegal. We have stupid rules for a bloke who died 1300 years before that, that prevent say Gay people getting married in church, or women for having jobs as his spokesman etc. We could live with a few rules that prevent people needlessly provoking British citizens. Sikh's can carry knives and not wear crash helmets, Catholic nurses and Doctors can refuse any association to work related to abortion and the UK even allows for religious polygamy, provide marriage occurred outside the UK and so on and so forth. But I understand that making similar exceptions for Muslims would bring down all of western civilisation. Personally, I think the question isn't whether you have the freedom to do something, but why your doing it. If all you can achieve with freedom of speech is deliberately antagonising people, then its wasted on those people. I means sure, you could create a picture of a nun sucking a donkey with a crucifix up her arse, and stick it on a magazine cover - but there's only one reason your doing it, to court controversy and upset people. We can probably get by with legislating that publishing pictures or images of the prophet Mohammed should only be accepted where artistic merit can be established.
I obviously get your point of view as seen earlier in the thread, and I still believe that if one of mine was murdered outside Charlie Ebdo, I wouldn't be Je Suis Charlie, but I am far from best pleased Charlie. The difference between the Sikhs, Catholics, Hindus, Chinese, anybody, is that these Islamic fundamentalists hate us and our way of life, and when one allowance is made for them, it won't be the last, so I can see why people don't want to budge on any laws at all. But it was good to get some decent responses, started by Sterlingsays after a few apoplectic 1 line posts.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well yes, but then if it wasn't defined as a picture of Mohammed, it wouldn't be illegal. We have stupid rules for a bloke who died 1300 years before that, that prevent say Gay people getting married in church, or women for having jobs as his spokesman etc. We could live with a few rules that prevent people needlessly provoking British citizens. Sikh's can carry knives and not wear crash helmets, Catholic nurses and Doctors can refuse any association to work related to abortion and the UK even allows for religious polygamy, provide marriage occurred outside the UK and so on and so forth. But I understand that making similar exceptions for Muslims would bring down all of western civilisation. Personally, I think the question isn't whether you have the freedom to do something, but why your doing it. If all you can achieve with freedom of speech is deliberately antagonising people, then its wasted on those people. I means sure, you could create a picture of a nun sucking a donkey with a crucifix up her arse, and stick it on a magazine cover - but there's only one reason your doing it, to court controversy and upset people. We can probably get by with legislating that publishing pictures or images of the prophet Mohammed should only be accepted where artistic merit can be established.
But I don;t want to live by rules designed to appease religious claptrap. That is a massive backward step. We are having this forced upon us by stealth. First it was allowing Muslims here in there thousands. Anyone who objected Enoch Powell style by saying there would be trouble was branded a racist. Now surprise surprise, there is trouble and now we have, let's just cave in to some of their totally unreasonable demands and they will be good citizens approach. What stealth tactic would you like next? Their own quietly created Islamic republic inside the UK perhaps? I will not vote for any government who panders to medievalism. Some of these religious loons are murdering and attacking Westerners on almost a daily basis and your answer is to be make new laws to pander to the kind of lunacy that they draw inspiration from. I'm lost for words.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.