You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mark Clattenburg
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mark Clattenburg


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 09 Jun 18 8.59pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

With respect Ferret . . .

I was replying to an earlier post i was NOT condonning Cluterfcuk at all. I do however take issue with you in regards to assessing. You have NO idea what is involved or how it works. Your opinion is just that nothing more or less.

I have been involve & know a hell of more than you ever will oh & please NEVER say that im not a true Palace fan. Im now entering my 57th season supporting/tolerating/cursing them OK

so why not explain what happens? Willo never would....all we as fans see is referees getting worse and worse with NO punishment/sanctions whatsoever!!

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 10 Jun 18 8.23am

Originally posted by the silurian

so why not explain what happens? Willo never would....all we as fans see is referees getting worse and worse with NO punishment/sanctions whatsoever!!

Will find out the process from my Ref mates,there is alot before a ref is down graded which come from refs match report and clubs match report,so watch this space

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 10 Jun 18 8.26am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Willo clone. Ignore.

your out of order, if you dont know what goes on, facts over fiction dont post until you do

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 10 Jun 18 10.11am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

your out of order, if you dont know what goes on, facts over fiction dont post until you do

I thought it was funny.

 

chateauferret Flag 10 Jun 18 11.01am

Originally posted by BarEagle

I thought it was funny.

This has all been done to death in Willo threads over the years since long before our know-it-all friend wandered in. Suffice it to say that if this "process" worked (which he now admits he doesn't know inside out after all) then the standards of officiating would steadily improve; instead we have seen a consistent and continuing pattern of decline and, last season, quite a lot of really embarrassing performances.

None of that is under much dispute round here and anyone who walks in singing the praises of Cl*****burg and claiming to be a Palace fan is bound to get flamed to toast for obvious reasons.

 


============
The Ferret
============

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Jun 18 12.32pm

Originally posted by the silurian

so why not explain what happens? Willo never would....all we as fans see is referees getting worse and worse with NO punishment/sanctions whatsoever!!

I will happily explain to you or anyone that wants know. However, there are certain things im not allowed to divulge ie personnel hearings etc due to legal ramifications. Hope you understand.

Now, atm im on holibobs, but please feel free to ask & i will get back to you asap.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 10 Jun 18 1.52pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

I will happily explain to you or anyone that wants know. However, there are certain things im not allowed to divulge ie personnel hearings etc due to legal ramifications. Hope you understand.

Now, atm im on holibobs, but please feel free to ask & i will get back to you asap.

Ok when you get back tell us all what happens on a general basis, we dont wanna know names, we all know the bad ones.Just interested in what happens when they get a series of bad reports, as plenty of them must. If some of us did our jobs as badly as they do we'd be sacked, they never seem to be!

 

chateauferret Flag 10 Jun 18 3.42pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

I will happily explain to you or anyone that wants know. However, there are certain things im not allowed to divulge ie personnel hearings etc due to legal ramifications. Hope you understand.

Now, atm im on holibobs, but please feel free to ask & i will get back to you asap.

Yeah, Willo explained this once before and then we found his words verbatim on the PGMOL website.

The only thing you need to explain is why these performance reviews result in performances getting worse instead of better. Good luck.

Edited by chateauferret (10 Jun 2018 3.57pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

michaelpearce Flag grays 10 Jun 18 8.43pm

the report from ref is submitted to the league, the same is for clubs reports with a grading.
if below a mark of 51 they are then down graded if more than 2 match grading in a row are below 51 which has happened,
most league games there is a assessor who marks the refs performance,regardless what the assessor marks the clubs marks hold sway,
TV is used because there is 30 cameras to catch all foul play as i said before ref only has 2 eyes
So reason we still have the same refs are the clubs dont want todo the paperwork when marking ref below 51

Being a ref in football is one of the hardest jobs in football to get right, as you only give what you see, standing in the wrong position having players run across you so on and so on
Clattenberg has been the ref 23 times for us, but we all remember the final because he was so bad.
not defending him but showing how blinked we are when result doesnt go our way

 

chateauferret Flag 10 Jun 18 9.03pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

the report from ref is submitted to the league, the same is for clubs reports with a grading.
if below a mark of 51 they are then down graded if more than 2 match grading in a row are below 51 which has happened,
most league games there is a assessor who marks the refs performance,regardless what the assessor marks the clubs marks hold sway,
TV is used because there is 30 cameras to catch all foul play as i said before ref only has 2 eyes
So reason we still have the same refs are the clubs dont want todo the paperwork when marking ref below 51

Being a ref in football is one of the hardest jobs in football to get right, as you only give what you see, standing in the wrong position having players run across you so on and so on
Clattenberg has been the ref 23 times for us, but we all remember the final because he was so bad.
not defending him but showing how blinked we are when result doesnt go our way

Well since refs get suspended or demoted about as often as my cat greets me in Japanese one can see you have to do pretty badly to fall below the pass mark. Or are you really telling us that a club that's been clearly wronged, and has said as much in its presser to that effect as is allowed, "can't be bothered to fill in the form" to report serious incompetence? Pull the other one. Anyway if that's the case it's clear that the referees are s***e but aren't getting called on it, and that the system doesn't work. Quod erat demonstrandum.

And how often have we seen refs give things that they quite clearly can't have seen but have simply guessed? Wilf "diving" the other week, for instance.


Edited by chateauferret (10 Jun 2018 9.07pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 11 Jun 18 2.43pm

He even admitted to thinking about his record refereeing us as he was doing so? If he was impartial, why would this matter? The least we should expect from a ref is impartiality but it often looks like there is a bias towards sides, in my opinion.
This was also backed up by research a few years back. Refs need a major shake-up.
My conjecture is that, when the Premier League started controlling their own refs, they were told to make the games 'more entertaining'; hence the controversial decisions every week.

 


Red and Blue Army!

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 11 Jun 18 4.17pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

the report from ref is submitted to the league, the same is for clubs reports with a grading.
if below a mark of 51 they are then down graded if more than 2 match grading in a row are below 51 which has happened,
most league games there is a assessor who marks the refs performance,regardless what the assessor marks the clubs marks hold sway,
TV is used because there is 30 cameras to catch all foul play as i said before ref only has 2 eyes
So reason we still have the same refs are the clubs dont want todo the paperwork when marking ref below 51

Being a ref in football is one of the hardest jobs in football to get right, as you only give what you see, standing in the wrong position having players run across you so on and so on
Clattenberg has been the ref 23 times for us, but we all remember the final because he was so bad.
not defending him but showing how blinked we are when result doesnt go our way

Id like to know where you get your info from as this is so bollox its bit like talkshie/mirror/dailyfail

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Jun 18 4.40pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Id like to know where you get your info from as this is so bollox its bit like talkshie/mirror/dailyfail

i talked to refs i know, one who will next season be refereeing in the fourth tier, he is 28 he has 5 years to get to the top leagues,that his when the refs are at there best supposedly,as someone said it is hard to get down graded and yes i think thats wrong,
there bad refs and really bad refs, so once var comes in and it takes 4 hours for a game, we get all decisions correct, then what are we going to complain about after a game, we will all be to tired and going to bed

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Jun 18 4.53pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Well since refs get suspended or demoted about as often as my cat greets me in Japanese one can see you have to do pretty badly to fall below the pass mark. Or are you really telling us that a club that's been clearly wronged, and has said as much in its presser to that effect as is allowed, "can't be bothered to fill in the form" to report serious incompetence? Pull the other one. Anyway if that's the case it's clear that the referees are s***e but aren't getting called on it, and that the system doesn't work. Quod erat demonstrandum.

And how often have we seen refs give things that they quite clearly can't have seen but have simply guessed? Wilf "diving" the other week, for instance.


Edited by chateauferret (10 Jun 2018 9.07pm)

they are told they must be %100 sure before they give a foul or not,it does stand out when they are guessing we have all seen it and heard it when the ref doesnt listen to his linesman(old school)

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Jun 18 4.55pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

He even admitted to thinking about his record refereeing us as he was doing so? If he was impartial, why would this matter? The least we should expect from a ref is impartiality but it often looks like there is a bias towards sides, in my opinion.
This was also backed up by research a few years back. Refs need a major shake-up.
My conjecture is that, when the Premier League started controlling their own refs, they were told to make the games 'more entertaining'; hence the controversial decisions every week.

all leagues control the refs they have, all the way down to sunday football

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 11 Jun 18 5.31pm

He rejoices and celebrates his own fvcktitude with the passing of filthy lucre (or should that be lycra ?)
money, you know what I mean.

Going by some slang definitions on on-line dictionaries, Mark Clattenburg is the epicentre of cvntishness, in my opinion.

After all, the game of football is about opinions, and even Mark Clattenburg has been wrong on a couple of occasions.

My opinion is just timeless, and undeniable, in this instance

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 11 Jun 18 6.10pm

Pfft . . Attention seeker.

Get back to your 'Pet Shop Boys' on the mp3 thread &#128514;&#128518;&#128521;

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 11 Jun 18 6.22pm

Having already had one post deleted for, I assume (as no one told me), daring to suggest a member was trolling and should be carded accordingly (which I stand by), I still support my assertion and opinion that the system is broken when a ref gets so much publicity and airtime - often a lot more so than a number of the players we all actually pay to go to see. We don’t pay to see that bell!
That, in itself, should be a reason to be cautious.
Regardless of the assessment process (which should work and I agree should be behind closed doors) the fact that this bloke is allowed by the football authorities to bang on and on and court so much negativity from so many supporters of so many teams is disgraceful. They have allowed him to bring the profession into disrepute (in my view).

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 11 Jun 18 7.22pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

all leagues control the refs they have, all the way down to sunday football

I must have been wrong in thinking PGMOl controls refs and the Select Group ones ref the Premier League. I could be wrong in thinking there have been no new Select Group refs and no English Refs have recently been promoted into international refs. I must also be wrong that Mark Halsey accused PGMOl of instructing him to fabricate match reports whilst a select group ref.

 


Red and Blue Army!

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Jun 18 9.25pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I must have been wrong in thinking PGMOl controls refs and the Select Group ones ref the Premier League. I could be wrong in thinking there have been no new Select Group refs and no English Refs have recently been promoted into international refs. I must also be wrong that Mark Halsey accused PGMOl of instructing him to fabricate match reports whilst a select group ref.

you are and your not, the system is set to allow refs normally young ones to progress this is started from grass roots, sadly we are losing that because of what we say and do to young refs means the pot is getting smaller,
the abuse they receive for making one or two mistakes is unfair yes they shouldn't but could you work with thousands of eyes watching you,remember they got this all the way up the ladder,even with threats of violence,so you will get some like Clattenburg who are thick skinned and arrogant, and you will never get a ref who doesnt make a error or two,its just the nature of the beast
why do you think lower division players wont come forward to ref once they call it a day,because its easier to criticize than do the job themselves

Edited by michaelpearce (11 Jun 2018 9.27pm)

Edited by michaelpearce (11 Jun 2018 9.31pm)

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mark Clattenburg