You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish unable to progress us


Page 7 of 16 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 13 Feb 18 4.44pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Well do you actually provide anything other than Parish is great, analysis or criticism is tosh and signing Sakho was good value if he plays and what happens is inevitable or unavoidable?

I purely find it strange the number of Holers (many are trolls) (fans) criticising Parish non stop.
We are where we are,and have an excellent chance of a 6th Season.
That will do for me on on this thread.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 13 Feb 18 4.50pm

Originally posted by Hansy

Keeper situation is far from ideal however we had number 1 target all window and unfortunately his club wanted more

We offered 2m Euros apparently, and his release clause was 4......

Just googled and there's a few versions. Apparently Guaita believed his buy out clause was £3.5 mill and the club said it was £7 mill. If that particular report is to be believed. by Ed Maylon so should be accurate

[Link]

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

palace99 Flag New Mills 13 Feb 18 4.52pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It isn't the manager who negotiates and deals.

Roy will give the name of the players he wants to Parish, sometimes Freedman giving Roy the names first.

The 'transfer policy' is not the manager's responsibility. He will meet with the chairman to discuss what the chairman agrees or provides that allows the transfer policy to be.


The transfer policy is to come up with a list of players to buy - as you say this is the manager's job, not the chairman.

Therefore the POLICY must be driven by the manager.

BFS chose to get 2 left backs in rather than a striker and Pardew asked for and got Benkete.

Yes the chairman determines the overall budget and negotiates the purchases and contracts but the policy is dictated by the manager. Budget and policy are not the same thing.

100% of British managers would walk if they didn't have final say in who their club buys and (to a lesser extent) sells.

If a manager says they want player X and they are in budget any decent chairman would support their manager's opinion as if not why give them the job. SP has over the last few years been pretty supportive of managers in that respect.

Obviously you've never liked SP so consider our current unbalanced squad all his fault.

 

Hansy Flag 13 Feb 18 4.54pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Just googled and there's a few versions. Apparently Guaita believed his buy out clause was £3.5 mill and the club said it was £7 mill. If that particular report is to be believed. by Ed Maylon so should be accurate

[Link]

So the club were weary of handing over 7m Euros considering we've been crying out for a goalkeeper for the past two years?

Also the 4m figure is more than likely what they will have accepted considering he was leaving at the end of the season.

 

Hansy Flag 13 Feb 18 4.57pm

Originally posted by palace99


The transfer policy is to come up with a list of players to buy - as you say this is the manager's job, not the chairman.

Therefore the POLICY must be driven by the manager.

BFS chose to get 2 left backs in rather than a striker and Pardew asked for and got Benkete.

Yes the chairman determines the overall budget and negotiates the purchases and contracts but the policy is dictated by the manager. Budget and policy are not the same thing.

100% of British managers would walk if they didn't have final say in who their club buys and (to a lesser extent) sells.

If a manager says they want player X and they are in budget any decent chairman would support their manager's opinion as if not why give them the job. SP has over the last few years been pretty supportive of managers in that respect.

Obviously you've never liked SP so consider our current unbalanced squad all his fault.

Roy also had a wafer thin squad, yet got 3 players with no experience in the top leagues in Europe. Yes they might come good, but two of them aren't even fit with 10 games to go.

Amadou, Guaita, Sorloth and reports suggested others were left until the last day. We've had 4 months to get things ready for the transfer window.

Roy's interviews gave the suggestion it wasn't him handling the transfer business. So it is down to D*ugie and SP.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 13 Feb 18 4.59pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

I purely find it strange the number of Holers (many are trolls) (fans) criticising Parish non stop.
We are where we are,and have an excellent chance of a 6th Season.
That will do for me on on this thread.

I cant agree more, so many its not my money but i will still complain because I can, because it hasnt cost me millions, im giving my 30 pound every other week means we should be top 4 by now, all the trolls need life counseling because they have no grasp on reality, simple without parish&co you would need to spit your venom elsewhere, we was gone nobody wanted us,in my book someone safes my life im indebted to them the rest of my life no matter what

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 13 Feb 18 5.19pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

I cant agree more, so many its not my money but i will still complain because I can, because it hasnt cost me millions, im giving my 30 pound every other week means we should be top 4 by now, all the trolls need life counseling because they have no grasp on reality, simple without parish&co you would need to spit your venom elsewhere, we was gone nobody wanted us,in my book someone safes my life im indebted to them the rest of my life no matter what

What I find interesting is if you are critical you are a troll. If that’s the case the let’s be blindingly positive yay Parish apologist brigade are every bit a troll.

 

Hansy Flag 13 Feb 18 5.22pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

I cant agree more, so many its not my money but i will still complain because I can, because it hasnt cost me millions, im giving my 30 pound every other week means we should be top 4 by now, all the trolls need life counseling because they have no grasp on reality, simple without parish&co you would need to spit your venom elsewhere, we was gone nobody wanted us,in my book someone safes my life im indebted to them the rest of my life no matter what

Didn't Jordan 'save' us too? Hope you saved your Jordan Points too

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 13 Feb 18 5.22pm

Originally posted by Hansy

So the club were weary of handing over 7m Euros considering we've been crying out for a goalkeeper for the past two years?

Also the 4m figure is more than likely what they will have accepted considering he was leaving at the end of the season.

According to reports we bid the 4

As for the rest of the January window I’m glad we didn’t spunk a load of money on overpriced players. January is renowned for being poor. Look at what deals actually happened. Most players are overpriced and what we spend on January has an impact on the summer.

The one signing that is a bit beyond me is the loan. Bought by Benfica and straight to us. Odd. Still we could have spent nearly £30 million on tosun

We (SP) has made mistakes but he has backed managers. As much as they’d like? Maybe not but we’ve certainly spent a few bob. Now we have or are in the process of correcting those mistakes people still moan.

Football is fickle. Not so long ago huw Jenkins at Swansea was a hero, now hated. Same for the Saints board. FSG etc

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 13 Feb 18 5.24pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1
I purely find it strange the number of Holers (many are trolls) (fans) criticising Parish non stop.
We are where we are,and have an excellent chance of a 6th Season.
That will do for me on on this thread.

I cant agree more, so many its not my money but i will still complain because I can, because it hasnt cost me millions, im giving my 30 pound every other week means we should be top 4 by now, all the trolls need life counseling because they have no grasp on reality, simple without parish&co you would need to spit your venom elsewhere, we was gone nobody wanted us,in my book someone safes my life im indebted to them the rest of my life no matter what


The above 2 comments sum it up. Too many on here want us to go from a totally skint club staring administration in the face to world beaters in less than 10 seasons.

It would be lovely wouldn't it, but this isn't fantasy league football, it is reality and in reality we are doing well in my opinion to be where we are. So before anyone else moans on here about anyone and everyone in the management structure of our club, take a step back, draw breath and try and think of the reasons why transfers and other significant matters haven't been dealt with exactly the way you want them to, rather than just simply complaining.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 13 Feb 18 5.26pm

Originally posted by Hansy

Didn't Jordan 'save' us too? Hope you saved your Jordan Points too

So did uncle Ron ,Jordon f*cked up by not getting into bed with uncle Ron and lied about the ground, but that cost him 40 million at the time did you offer to help with your millions

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 13 Feb 18 5.28pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

What I find interesting is if you are critical you are a troll. If that’s the case the let’s be blindingly positive yay Parish apologist brigade are every bit a troll.

oh dear someones tired (cap fits and all that)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 13 Feb 18 6.05pm

I'll just repeat: im convinced Benteke was a yanky signing and strongly believe they led on Sakho too. I think Parish would not have bought either of them without the Americans involvement. I also think they were the wrong signings for us.

whether we stay up or drop (I think the former), I believe we are in the financial s*** a bit now. will they dig us out of it?

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (13 Feb 2018 6.06pm)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Feb 18 6.14pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

What I find interesting is if you are critical you are a troll. If that’s the case the let’s be blindingly positive yay Parish apologist brigade are every bit a troll.

Bingo. Parish is beyond reproach. He cannot be criticized or cast in a negative light. How blinkered is that?

When Parish kicks a poodle, its the dog's fault. Or it was the condition of the pavement which made him kick the dog. Or it was the dog's agent. Or the last guy who kicked a dog was kicking it so much harder. Or the next guy might just take a dog's head off with a huge bicycle kick, and everyone should live in fear of that.

Maybe the next guy wouldn't kick the poor little poodle at all.

Deal with the fact that some fans dont think Parish is the right person to lead this club forward and out of perennial relegation scraps, year after year. My evidence behind that statement is our league position, and p&ss poor squad depth in goal and up front - 2 fairly important areas.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

michaelpearce Flag grays 13 Feb 18 6.17pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I'll just repeat: im convinced Benteke was a yanky signing and strongly believe they led on Sakho too. I think Parish would not have bought either of them without the Americans involvement. I also think they were the wrong signings for us.

whether we stay up or drop (I think the former), I believe we are in the financial s*** a bit now. will they dig us out of it?

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (13 Feb 2018 6.06pm)

you may have a point about teke, but as financial wise we are in a lot stronger place the club is not going to put (us) sorry they are not going risk losing millions again and go into liquidation, hence the tight reins

 

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 13 Feb 18 6.23pm

For all the comments about the transfer policy I think as we are not the most attractive club, we will normally find ourselves having to wait and hope that players do not get other offers. Sadly this is something that will continue unless some multi billionaire takes over(I would not want this).

We just have to accept this will happen most transfer windows, plus teams will push for as much as possible and unless we are prepared to continue to pay over the odds we need to stick to our guns.

Parish has always said he does not want to see the club end up in the same mess as in the past, and therefore needs to continue to be careful with how he spends the cash we have. We also have the stadium to consider which is in desparate need of an upgrade.

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

michaelpearce Flag grays 13 Feb 18 6.29pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Bingo. Parish is beyond reproach. He cannot be criticized or cast in a negative light. How blinkered is that?

When Parish kicks a poodle, its the dog's fault. Or it was the condition of the pavement which made him kick the dog. Or it was the dog's agent. Or the last guy who kicked a dog was kicking it so much harder. Or the next guy might just take a dog's head off with a huge bicycle kick, and everyone should live in fear of that.

Maybe the next guy wouldn't kick the poor little poodle at all.

Deal with the fact that some fans dont think Parish is the right person to lead this club forward and out of perennial relegation scraps, year after year. My evidence behind that statement is our league position, and p&ss poor squad depth in goal and up front - 2 fairly important areas.

there you go its parish at fault the yanks have no say, there worth more, money wise. so do you honestly think they have no say with the running of the club.who do you think is funding the work to the ground,also any transfers lets go into admin again just to keep you happy,the yanks and parish are doing best with the budget they have, glad your not running the club we would be dead and gone within a year

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 13 Feb 18 6.52pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Bingo. Parish is beyond reproach. He cannot be criticized or cast in a negative light. How blinkered is that?

When Parish kicks a poodle, its the dog's fault. Or it was the condition of the pavement which made him kick the dog. Or it was the dog's agent. Or the last guy who kicked a dog was kicking it so much harder. Or the next guy might just take a dog's head off with a huge bicycle kick, and everyone should live in fear of that.

Maybe the next guy wouldn't kick the poor little poodle at all.

Deal with the fact that some fans dont think Parish is the right person to lead this club forward and out of perennial relegation scraps, year after year. My evidence behind that statement is our league position, and p&ss poor squad depth in goal and up front - 2 fairly important areas.

If you can't live with it find a different team to support. Chelsea Man U Man City. Face the fact we are punching above our weight. Have one of the most expensive squads in Europe. Our squad depth is poor this is mainly due to the fact we have spent our transfer funds on a few players not increase squad depth. Many people on the Hol were calling for Sakho Cabaye and Benteke to be signed and Wilf to get his wage increase. I am not saying these were all wrong but this is where the money went. Due to FPP we have a limited spend.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 13 Feb 18 7.02pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

you may have a point about teke, but as financial wise we are in a lot stronger place the club is not going to put (us) sorry they are not going risk losing millions again and go into liquidation, hence the tight reins

I'm sure they are utterly ruthless and palace are a column in a spreadsheet

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

michaelpearce Flag grays 13 Feb 18 7.07pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I'm sure they are utterly ruthless and palace are a column in a spreadsheet


i think that could be true

 

Page 7 of 16 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us