You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Steve Parish thread
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Steve Parish thread


Page 7 of 14 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 May 18 2.23pm

Originally posted by Painter

But, they did replace Arnautovic with players that weren’t any good. Selling Jonathan Walters was a mistake they must now regret.

They must have assessed the situation regarding Walters and reflected on the fact that he was 33, had only scored 4 goals for them last season and the fee was a sum up to £3 Mill so they concluded it was a good deal all round.
Furthermore perhaps he hadn't performed as well as they would have liked in the games he did play.

At Burnley this season he has only made a handful of appearances and hasn't scored - not sure if he has been plagued with injuries.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 May 18 3.11pm

Originally posted by Willo

They must have assessed the situation regarding Walters and reflected on the fact that he was 33, had only scored 4 goals for them last season and the fee was a sum up to £3 Mill so they concluded it was a good deal all round.
Furthermore perhaps he hadn't performed as well as they would have liked in the games he did play.

At Burnley this season he has only made a handful of appearances and hasn't scored - not sure if he has been plagued with injuries.

They could of done with those 4 goals this season and his passion! They got £3m for him, but are now to languish in the Championship for years losing £100ms of revenue.
Not a good decision by a Chairman.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 May 18 3.38pm

Originally posted by Painter

They could of done with those 4 goals this season and his passion! They got £3m for him, but are now to languish in the Championship for years losing £100ms of revenue.
Not a good decision by a Chairman.

Even last season they were an ageing squad and decided to sell Walters,Bardley and Whelan all in their 30s.I believe at present they have 9 players in their 30s.

Wimmer cost £18 Mill but has hardly featured, Berahino signed the season before for 12 Mill rising to £15 Mill and Imbula who cost just over £18 Mill was on Loan to Toulouse so near enough £50 Mill for talent who simply haven't made any significant contributions at all last season.

 

mileend Flag East London 11 May 18 3.55pm

Originally posted by Painter

They could of done with those 4 goals this season and his passion! They got £3m for him, but are now to languish in the Championship for years losing £100ms of revenue.
Not a good decision by a Chairman.

hindsight a wonderful thing
but we have similar decisions to make for our out of contract and ageing players (and low scoring forwards)

let's hope our Chairman does better

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 May 18 3.56pm

Originally posted by Painter

They could of done with those 4 goals this season and his passion! They got £3m for him, but are now to languish in the Championship for years losing £100ms of revenue.
Not a good decision by a Chairman.

As mileend said a lot of it is down to luck. Stoke got rid of Walters and perhaps suffered because of it and we got rid of Murray but managed to get away with it.

If one was a bad decision by the chairman then the other must also be although I'm sure you'll find a reason why it was different

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 May 18 7.26pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

As mileend said a lot of it is down to luck. Stoke got rid of Walters and perhaps suffered because of it and we got rid of Murray but managed to get away with it.

If one was a bad decision by the chairman then the other must also be although I'm sure you'll find a reason why it was different

I agree a lot of decisions in football have an element of luck. Its about trying to get a good balance to reduce any bad luck.
For example, if Luca and Zaha were injured for large parts of last season, things could of been different.
But, if you employ Pardew or Hughes after a disastrous reign at another club, that's not bad luck, but stupid.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 May 18 7.50pm

Originally posted by Painter

I agree a lot of decisions in football have an element of luck. Its about trying to get a good balance to reduce any bad luck.
For example, if Luca and Zaha were injured for large parts of last season, things could of been different.
But, if you employ Pardew or Hughes after a disastrous reign at another club, that's not bad luck, but stupid.

Stoke appointed Hughes to replace Pulis after Hughes had a disappointing time at QPR.

In Pulis' last season, Stoke finished 13th but then Hughes engineered 9th place finishes in each of his first 3 seasons in charge so this was very creditable for a club of Stoke's stature. It has only been in the last 2 seasons when Stoke's fortunes have dipped under Hughes, finishing 13th last season and when he was sacked this season they were 20th.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 11 May 18 8.37pm

Originally posted by Willo

Stoke appointed Hughes to replace Pulis after Hughes had a disappointing time at QPR.

In Pulis' last season, Stoke finished 13th but then Hughes engineered 9th place finishes in each of his first 3 seasons in charge so this was very creditable for a club of Stoke's stature. It has only been in the last 2 seasons when Stoke's fortunes have dipped under Hughes, finishing 13th last season and when he was sacked this season they were 20th.

'Sparky' has a gpod record and has really motivated Saints, a manager is restricted by the funds and ambition of the club, the manager cannot have a blank cheque we are not all Man City.

Also a really well balanced person, doubt if he will manage us, not really a Palace man but would not mind if RH retired and he was available.


 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 11 May 18 9.36pm

Not that fussed on Stoke but Hughes had been there long enough to have a fair degree of influence on transfers.

He, Cartwright and Scholes probably shoulder an equal amount.

Arnoutavic is a talisman but looks capable of behaving like a kn0b.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 11 May 18 9.40pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

[Link]

I hope, and I mean I seriously hope, that Steve Parish really will learn from his mistakes of this season, and every season so far in this league.

I hope more than anything that we will conduct our business in the upcoming transfer window in a shrewd, smart, and where possible in a fair way that doesn't leave bad tastes in players/other club's hierarchies mouths.

I pray that we will sign most, if not all of the players that we need before the final 1 hour of the transfer window. Though with the earlier window at least we will benefit from that either way.

I dearly wish that we will back our manager, reward him adequately for the excellent finishing position we will attain, and dont make a fool out of him once again. RH said many, many times that we needed to sign a goalie in January and we fouled it up, making him look a mug. I really hope we dont do that again.

I hope come the first game of next season that RH is still our manager and hasnt decided with 3 days left until the first game that he needs to resign or retire from the game completely, out of the blue as far as the fans can see.

I hope that we dont play silly games on one of our main targets, like we did on Sakho. Using the press to plant stories about not being able to afford the player, and generally playing silly buggers up until the last minute.

I hope we dont repeat any of these dimwitted approaches, that have been the hallmark of how we have operated lately.

Most of these points have been made over and over when we were struggling not least by you.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (11 May 2018 9.54pm)

 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 11 May 18 10.07pm

Originally posted by elgrande

I hope you give it a rest with your negative s***e.

I think Bashy2 has a point. It isn't negative to hope that we keep the manager that saved us the previous season and sign players who have an opportunity to train with the team before the new season starts. If we do that will be against recent trend.

This season ended well. But lets not forget that we have a habit of losing managers that have saved us or that the threadbare squad last year nearly sent us down.

Parish has overseen a great period for the club and we are stronger than when he took over or than we have ever been. But let us nor be blind to trouble we were in last year and why.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 May 18 11.43pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Not that fussed on Stoke but Hughes had been there long enough to have a fair degree of influence on transfers.

He, Cartwright and Scholes probably shoulder an equal amount.

Arnoutavic is a talisman but looks capable of behaving like a kn0b.

A reference to Head Scout Kevin Cartwright who has been at the club for 5 years and Chief Exec Tony Scholes.

Apropos Arnautovic, I believe that Mourinho said he is a fantastic person with the attitude of a child.In his youth in Vienna, the player used to hang out with gangs and suffered regular expulsions from junior football.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 May 18 8.36am

Originally posted by mileend

I am very happy with Parish but he knows he needs to improve and one reason might be is that rather than being better than Coates, Peace or Jenkins is that he is in an identical position to them in terms of unfashionable clubs having an extended stay in the premier league.

It's just that this year their luck ran out and Parish's luck held. The fact that he earned his luck by ditching FDB and hiring Roy when nearly all thought him mad to do so is all credit to him.

Like them he has maxed out on wages and reluctant to put in large amounts of his personal fortune to try and guarantee safety with more and more signings. One year you are going to pick the wrong players or make bad managerial selections (or both) and you are gone.

This year is special because he has a big proportion of the less important players for the future coming to the end of their contract. No criticism of their contribution to the club in the past - eg Ward, Cabaye but their careers are on the wane - so that is an opportunity for him to get them on lower wages as squad players or replace them with better players on lower salaries. That is Dougie's job if you are wondering what he is supposed to be doing.

What will keep us in the Premier League until the new stand is built, after which we will have extra income to give us breathing space, is excellence in recruitment. That is not easy but our squad management has been non-existent since we reached the Premier League and that is what needs to improve. Happy that Parish is the guy to try and make it happen.

Good post. I was thinking the same in bold this week. Parish must at some point use the opportunity to nail us as prem certainties for a couple of years, especially with the new man stand. But that’ll require successful scouting so those can never be 100%.

 


COYP

chateauferret Flag 12 May 18 8.41am

Originally posted by Willo

Apropos Arnautovic, I believe that Mourinho said he is a fantastic person with the attitude of a child.

It takes one to know one. Although you might think that Mourinho is more like a t*** with the attitude of a child.

Edited by chateauferret (12 May 2018 8.42am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 12 May 18 9.10am

Am I alone in being somewhat uncomfortable with this thread?

To take the club from the edge of oblivion to where we are now, with the prospect of a fantastic new stand and continuing our record run in the top flight....it's pinch yourself stuff.

Everyone makes mistakes in business, especially one as unscientific and risk-laden as professional football. I do not feel comfortable debating those mistakes though and instead just want to shake the bloke's hand.

 


Spirit of 1974

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 May 18 9.21am

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Am I alone in being somewhat uncomfortable with this thread?

To take the club from the edge of oblivion to where we are now, with the prospect of a fantastic new stand and continuing our record run in the top flight....it's pinch yourself stuff.

Everyone makes mistakes in business, especially one as unscientific and risk-laden as professional football. I do not feel comfortable debating those mistakes though and instead just want to shake the bloke's hand.

A very good post.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 May 18 9.25am

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Am I alone in being somewhat uncomfortable with this thread?

To take the club from the edge of oblivion to where we are now, with the prospect of a fantastic new stand and continuing our record run in the top flight....it's pinch yourself stuff.

Everyone makes mistakes in business, especially one as unscientific and risk-laden as professional football. I do not feel comfortable debating those mistakes though and instead just want to shake the bloke's hand.

It’s been great, but 1 striker in the premier League, anyear after 1 left back or 6 defenders plus Fryers? Parish knows this isn’t the level required and it goes some way to managers leaving.

 


COYP

coulsdoneagle Flag London 12 May 18 9.34am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It’s been great, but 1 striker in the premier League, anyear after 1 left back or 6 defenders plus Fryers? Parish knows this isn’t the level required and it goes some way to managers leaving.

We don’t know why managers left. BFS saved his reputation over a short period then had a break for 6 months.

Pulis was a money grabbing c*nt and he lost a legal battle to prove it.

Sure FdB was an error, but it was a well intentioned one. Apart from recruitment this season Parish has hardly put a foot wrong. As for the striker situation, we have been pretty unlucky, but also not having someone there in front of Zaha is arguably the reason why this season has gone the way it has, and if we keep him I’m sure his new position will play a big part.

I think judging recruitment after this window is a better barometer because we will have got rid of a lot of deadweight.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 May 18 9.56am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle


Pulis was a money grabbing c*nt and he lost a legal battle to prove it.

When you spout rubbish like that it casts doubt on everything else that you post

 

chateauferret Flag 12 May 18 10.02am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

When you spout rubbish like that it casts doubt on everything else that you post

How so? Pulis walked out with no warning two days before the season started and then tried to claim a bonus he wasn't due, a fact that was upheld in the resulting court case. I'd say "money-grabbing c***", if a trifle uncouth, covers it like a bedspread.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 7 of 14 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Steve Parish thread