You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we on a path to disaster ?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we on a path to disaster ?


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
mattteo Flag 31 Dec 19 4.38pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Yeah that's what I'm wondering. If Meyer goes for free, and if he's on 120k a week, he's basically cost us £6.24m a season. Don't get me wrong, that's obscene and he's disappointed relative to our hopes, but we could easily have bought an equivalent player for £15m and 80k a week in wages. (ie about 9m a season).

This. Yes, this sums it up nicely.

Even more so, we could have bought a 7 million player with 60k a week who could have done more than Meyer (at least 2-3 goals are more than Meyer)

That 6.24m a year cost is amazingly high when you offer nothing. Multiply with 3 years and Meyer cost the club 20 million to play 250 minutes per season and never score or assist.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 31 Dec 19 5.17pm

Originally posted by mattteo

This. Yes, this sums it up nicely.

Even more so, we could have bought a 7 million player with 60k a week who could have done more than Meyer (at least 2-3 goals are more than Meyer)

That 6.24m a year cost is amazingly high when you offer nothing. Multiply with 3 years and Meyer cost the club 20 million to play 250 minutes per season and never score or assist.


Exaggerating to make a negative. 7million and 60k a week does not get a better player that Max Mayer, who has scored goals for Palace and has played more than 250 minutes per season.

But back to the point. I feel pleasantly relieved that a working approach that matches largely what we have done over the last couple of years has been explained and would be sustainable and could result in an extended run in the Prem if we continue to execute it well: Guita, Cahill, Ayew, Meyer, McCarthy...

 

est1905 Flag 31 Dec 19 5.22pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

From a conversation I had yesterday, this was apparently discussed on Sky Sports.

With Roy continuing to perform miracles with a non existent transfer budget, aging squad and only creative wanting out, what happens when decides to call it a day ?

We have the ingredients to fall like clubs such as Sunderland and Stoke.

Unless we get bought out or start planning post Roy, we could be falling rapidly.

While I disagree with many doom and gloomers on here I do agree with this post. It is time after 3 windows of doing little to address the real issues for Parish/investors to find the money and identify the players and get the deals done.
We're bored of hearing about how the fans don't understand how hard it is to sign a player blah, blah.
Other clubs don't seem to have any trouble if a problem area needs addressing badly enough.
In short, I think Parish is taking the mick out of Roy. He knows he can keep us up on a shoestring so why goive him any money?
Would serve Parish right if Roy walked

 

mattteo Flag 01 Jan 20 1.11pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster


Exaggerating to make a negative. 7million and 60k a week does not get a better player that Max Mayer, who has scored goals for Palace and has played more than 250 minutes per season.

Lol. Of course it does. There are numerous examples. Do you know Ryan Fraser's salary in the Premier League? 27k a week. Has like 40 assists in 3 seasons.

 

The Dolphin Flag 01 Jan 20 2.57pm

Given the points totals so far for the drop we need to buck up over the next few weeks and supplement our squad!

Edited by The Dolphin (01 Jan 2020 2.58pm)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 4.09pm

..injured will come back that will supplement our squad well enough to survive.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 01 Jan 20 4.40pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

..injured will come back that will supplement our squad well enough to survive.


After 60+ years of following Palace I consider myself pretty philosophical, but as I sit here I'm starting to feel uneasy: Southampton winning, Villa have won, Watford winning and on a roll, Hammers about to get a new-manager bounce.

Well, I suppose we'll just have to win this evening.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 01 Jan 20 4.51pm

It is a very close league this year. I personally think that 45 points would be a more realistic safety target for any club.

Anyway, we have to focus on our own results and let others worry about theirs.

COYP....


After 60+ years of following Palace I consider myself pretty philosophical, but as I sit here I'm starting to feel uneasy: Southampton winning, Villa have won, Watford winning and on a roll, Hammers about to get a new-manager bounce.

Well, I suppose we'll just have to win this evening.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 01 Jan 20 4.51pm

Originally posted by JRW2


After 60+ years of following Palace I consider myself pretty philosophical, but as I sit here I'm starting to feel uneasy
: Southampton winning, Villa have won, Watford winning and on a roll, Hammers about to get a new-manager bounce.

Well, I suppose we'll just have to win this evening.

dont be my friend we have good things to come

 

est1905 Flag 01 Jan 20 5.02pm

Originally posted by JRW2


After 60+ years of following Palace I consider myself pretty philosophical, but as I sit here I'm starting to feel uneasy: Southampton winning, Villa have won, Watford winning and on a roll, Hammers about to get a new-manager bounce.

Well, I suppose we'll just have to win this evening.

From the position we sit currently we'd have to go on an epic implosion of a poor run to get sucked in. I mean, this is Palace we're talking about so its conceivable although highly unlikely

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 8.16pm

Connor Wickham totally immense when he came on today, we would've been bashing that barn door all night and all day tomorrow without him, all he has to do is stay fit and we will have no striker problems whatsoever.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 8.31pm

Originally posted by JRW2


After 60+ years of following Palace I consider myself pretty philosophical, but as I sit here I'm starting to feel uneasy: Southampton winning, Villa have won, Watford winning and on a roll, Hammers about to get a new-manager bounce.

Well, I suppose we'll just have to win this evening.

We very nearly threw this game away in the first few minutes didn't we, very poor unconfident defending just could not cope with Norwich's wide play, Sheffield.U are going to thrash us at home! Kelly again unsure and not in line for their goal poor distribution and on the other side Riedewald hesitant and unsure what to do with Norwich's quick movement but having said that they were excellent and should have beaten Spurs in their last home game, but Riedewald is actually brilliant shielding the ball at his feet and he looks very comfortable moving forward so I'm overall actually pleased with him to be honest our back up appears to be top notch so far, even less for me to worry about in regards to us being on a path to disaster.

Edited by Tickled pink (01 Jan 2020 8.34pm)

 

mattteo Flag 01 Jan 20 11.09pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Connor Wickham totally immense when he came on today, we would've been bashing that barn door all night and all day tomorrow without him, all he has to do is stay fit and we will have no striker problems whatsoever.

Even before his injury Connor Wickham was pretty average. Scored 17 in 108 Premier League matches. So even if fit, don't expect more than 2-3 moments like this in a season from him.

For a team like Palace to keep Benteke and Wickham beyond this winter....is something I can't understand. Center forward is maybe the most important position in the team. Without goals, we'll soon be fighting relegation

 

jeeagles Flag 02 Jan 20 1.57am

Originally posted by mattteo

Even before his injury Connor Wickham was pretty average. Scored 17 in 108 Premier League matches. So even if fit, don't expect more than 2-3 moments like this in a season from him.

For a team like Palace to keep Benteke and Wickham beyond this winter....is something I can't understand. Center forward is maybe the most important position in the team. Without goals, we'll soon be fighting relegation

He played in a very poor Sunderland team, mostly out of position. His goal scoring record per game isn't bad at all. 1 in 67 minutes this season, 1 in 170 minutes last season. 1 in 200 minutes the year before.
2015/16 he got 5 in 15 starts. 2013/2014 5 in 15 appearances.

If only he wasn't injured ALL the time.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Jan 20 12.36pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

He played in a very poor Sunderland team, mostly out of position. His goal scoring record per game isn't bad at all. 1 in 67 minutes this season, 1 in 170 minutes last season. 1 in 200 minutes the year before.
2015/16 he got 5 in 15 starts. 2013/2014 5 in 15 appearances.

If only he wasn't injured ALL the time.

..and I remember him scoring twice at West Brom and then doing the same at Sunderland, it was either in between after or before that he scored another so five in three games! ....then he injured himself again that was the last time he actually played a few games on the bounce.
He is definitely good enough if able.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 02 Jan 20 12.44pm

thing is the whole squad are apart from Wilf good solid players. the thing that is working is Roys management and trainning method have forged a team working toegther. nothing lasts so enjoy it the success we having at the moment.

 

mattteo Flag 02 Jan 20 1.07pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

He played in a very poor Sunderland team, mostly out of position. His goal scoring record per game isn't bad at all. 1 in 67 minutes this season, 1 in 170 minutes last season. 1 in 200 minutes the year before.
2015/16 he got 5 in 15 starts. 2013/2014 5 in 15 appearances.

If only he wasn't injured ALL the time.


Man....you can't make a goalscoring record from 200 minutes played. You have to wait a greater period than that. There could pass another 1.000 minutes until he scores again.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Jan 20 2.14pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

A few years ago I remember Stoke had started to feel secure in the Premiership and wanted to play more attractive football.

We scored the goal that relegated them down to the Championship.

Hodgeson has been great for Palace.....and to play attacking attractive football you need the players....and for that you need the money and a seriously good coach.

People need to accept that Palace have been punching above our weight for years.....there are plenty of clubs with better grounds and clubs with higher attendances than us in the Championship.


Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Dec 2019 12.10pm)

Yep, Let's not forget that this is our longest ever stint in the top division. Let's also remember Salvation Sunday at Hillsborough and why that was necessary (points deduction etc.)
I'm content if we can keep surviving (hopefully more comfortably this year) whilst we build up resources, including the academy.
You mention Stoke - a current example is Wet Spam who seem to have recognized that their ambitions were misplaced and who will now be thankful if Moysie can keep them up.

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 02 Jan 20 3.30pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Roy is not performing miracles.
He's sucking the life out of the club.

We've got a team that can stay up fairly comfortably. We should have got 6 points from the last 3 games, but he stuck everyone behind the ball and we came away with 2.

He's got a well organised side, but individual skill levels seem to be deteriorating, too much pressure on our star player.

With the tactics, training, and refusal to play certain players it's no wonder that players we have want to leave, and player recruitment is difficult.

Words fail me!

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 02 Jan 20 3.32pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

A few years ago I remember Stoke had started to feel secure in the Premiership and wanted to play more attractive football.

We scored the goal that relegated them down to the Championship.

Hodgeson has been great for Palace.....and to play attacking attractive football you need the players....and for that you need the money and a seriously good coach.

People need to accept that Palace have been punching above our weight for years.....there are plenty of clubs with better grounds and clubs with higher attendances than us in the Championship.


Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Dec 2019 12.10pm)

Insightful (& correct)

 

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we on a path to disaster ?