You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Staff shortages
November 21 2026 9.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Staff shortages


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Sep 21 10.57am

So NEXT are moaning about staff shortages and a lack of drivers, meaning staff may be laid off. Then they go on to say they knew this would happen with brexit.
British job for British workers ring a bell anyone!
Well excuse me but if you were so clever next; why not employ more staff 5 years ago.
Also hmg needs to start seriously questioning who needs welfare and handouts and get them off their lazy feckless arses. Yes many cannot work but a great many can. Poxed with the hand ringers constantly protecting those who shouldn't need it.

 

DanH Flag SW2 29 Sep 21 11.28am

Hang on - Next should have employed people 5 years ago for when they needed them now?

Next would have gone bust very quickly if they had you making business decisions.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Sep 21 11.49am

Originally posted by cryrst

So NEXT are moaning about staff shortages and a lack of drivers, meaning staff may be laid off. Then they go on to say they knew this would happen with brexit.
British job for British workers ring a bell anyone!
Well excuse me but if you were so clever next; why not employ more staff 5 years ago.
Also hmg needs to start seriously questioning who needs welfare and handouts and get them off their lazy feckless arses. Yes many cannot work but a great many can. Poxed with the hand ringers constantly protecting those who shouldn't need it.

Yup I saw that this morning and thought the same thing. You expected this to happen and did nothing. I think he was referring to the drivers more than store staff so why did they not sort this out a while ago?

I used to be a contingency planner I suggest NEXT employ one.

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Sep 21 11.53am

Originally posted by DanH

Hang on - Next should have employed people 5 years ago for when they needed them now?

Next would have gone bust very quickly if they had you making business decisions.

Making plans and implementing are 2 different things. They should have anticipated this 5 years ago and looked at salaries, training and key staffing areas. They should have looked at where they are vulnerable e.g. drivers.

They should have started to implement these plans in the last year when it became obvious.

Very little sympathy for them or the supermarkets.

 


One more point

DanH Flag SW2 29 Sep 21 11.58am

Originally posted by Badger11

Making plans and implementing are 2 different things. They should have anticipated this 5 years ago and looked at salaries, training and key staffing areas. They should have looked at where they are vulnerable e.g. drivers.

They should have started to implement these plans in the last year when it became obvious.

Very little sympathy for them or the supermarkets.

Businesses were left massively up in the air until the last minute with what the Brexit deal would look like.

You can do all the contingency planning you like based on worst case scenarios as all sensible large scale businesses do, but you can't start throwing money at salaries, training and key staffing areas for something that might not have transpired.

A lot of these businesses have very fragile supply chains relying on 'just in time' procedures and their profit margins per item are actually very slim - it's the volume they rely on to make their profit.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Sep 21 12.01pm

Originally posted by DanH

Businesses were left massively up in the air until the last minute with what the Brexit deal would look like.

You can do all the contingency planning you like based on worst case scenarios as all sensible large scale businesses do, but you can't start throwing money at salaries, training and key staffing areas for something that might not have transpired.

A lot of these businesses have very fragile supply chains relying on 'just in time' procedures and their profit margins per item are actually very slim - it's the volume they rely on to make their profit.

Exactly no contingency so they should have looked at their business model. Whilst the details were not finalised it was quite clear from at least 2 years ago what the issues with the EU were.

As for staffing you identify your key staff and pay them accordingly. Next probably employ thousands of store staff but only a few hundred drivers. I wonder how many they have lost recently.

Edited by Badger11 (29 Sep 2021 12.03pm)

 


One more point

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 29 Sep 21 12.09pm

The same people who dismissed any concerns as Project Fear are now blaming companies for not planning for said concerns.

 

DanH Flag SW2 29 Sep 21 12.15pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Exactly no contingency so they should have looked at their business model. Whilst the details were not finalised it was quite clear from at least 2 years ago what the issues with the EU were.

As for staffing you identify your key staff and pay them accordingly. Next probably employ thousands of store staff but only a few hundred drivers. I wonder how many they have lost recently.

Edited by Badger11 (29 Sep 2021 12.03pm)

What industry did you work in out of interest? It can't have been retail.

Retailers such as Next and supermarkets manage to keep their prices low by offshoring the large majority of their production and importing into the UK as it is much, much cheaper than producing it in the UK.

The rights and wrongs of that are quite rightly to be debated, but if you think a business like Next can rip up and replace its business model just like that by manufacturing everything they sell in the UK then that is just insane naivety.

Brexiters seems to wilfully ignore, or just be plain ignorant to, how businesses operate in the real world and the reason why people are able to enjoy an uninterrupted supply of cheap essentials. If you want this utopia of 'British jobs for British people making British goods' then fine, but by God are we going to pay for it in terms of businesses going bust, major job losses and prices going through the roof. As ever, it's the lowest paid in society that are most affected by this - job losses, price of the weekly shop going up, price of fuel going up etc.

Edited by DanH (29 Sep 2021 12.16pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Sep 21 12.33pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Yup I saw that this morning and thought the same thing. You expected this to happen and did nothing. I think he was referring to the drivers more than store staff so why did they not sort this out a while ago?

I used to be a contingency planner I suggest NEXT employ one.

There’s quite a few large businesses that don’t like sticking their necks out to make a decision. Following the crowd is easier and safer. A bit like politicians and Covid.

 


COYP

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Sep 21 12.36pm

Originally posted by cryrst

So NEXT are moaning about staff shortages and a lack of drivers, meaning staff may be laid off. Then they go on to say they knew this would happen with brexit.
British job for British workers ring a bell anyone!
Well excuse me but if you were so clever next; why not employ more staff 5 years ago.
Also hmg needs to start seriously questioning who needs welfare and handouts and get them off their lazy feckless arses. Yes many cannot work but a great many can. Poxed with the hand ringers constantly protecting those who shouldn't need it.

My son has applied for many jobs in retail, has been unsuccessful as they insist on employing those with experience. So how does one get the experience?
Perhaps these companies could have started training programmes ( apprenticeship) to prepare for their apparent known job losses, so those like my son would have had enough experience to step in.


Edited by Spiderman (29 Sep 2021 12.40pm)

 

Orange1290 Flag 29 Sep 21 12.39pm

Voting for 'brexit' to lose freedom of movement of people and goods has led to.......a shortage of people and goods, nothing whatsoever to do with 'brexit', priceless lol.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Sep 21 12.42pm

Originally posted by Orange1290

Voting for 'brexit' to lose freedom of movement of people and goods has led to.......a shortage of people and goods, nothing whatsoever to do with 'brexit', priceless lol.

I do not believe the shortage of people is as bad as they claim see my post above. A lack of training programmes and foresight on the part of the businesses

Edited by Spiderman (29 Sep 2021 12.45pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Sep 21 12.48pm

Originally posted by DanH

What industry did you work in out of interest? It can't have been retail.

Retailers such as Next and supermarkets manage to keep their prices low by offshoring the large majority of their production and importing into the UK as it is much, much cheaper than producing it in the UK.

The rights and wrongs of that are quite rightly to be debated, but if you think a business like Next can rip up and replace its business model just like that by manufacturing everything they sell in the UK then that is just insane naivety.

Brexiters seems to wilfully ignore, or just be plain ignorant to, how businesses operate in the real world and the reason why people are able to enjoy an uninterrupted supply of cheap essentials. If you want this utopia of 'British jobs for British people making British goods' then fine, but by God are we going to pay for it in terms of businesses going bust, major job losses and prices going through the roof. As ever, it's the lowest paid in society that are most affected by this - job losses, price of the weekly shop going up, price of fuel going up etc.

Edited by DanH (29 Sep 2021 12.16pm)

You sound like a Tory supporting low wages and cheap labour.

The issue here for Next is the small number of HGV drivers they use perhaps if they had invested in them and paid them a decent wage they would be laughing at their competitors now.

 


One more point

DanH Flag SW2 29 Sep 21 1.01pm

Originally posted by Badger11

You sound like a Tory supporting low wages and cheap labour.

The issue here for Next is the small number of HGV drivers they use perhaps if they had invested in them and paid them a decent wage they would be laughing at their competitors now.

That’s why labels are extremely unhelpful. I largely believe in free markets and the most efficient use of capital. What we did was leave a large, frictionless free trade area that allowed for goods and people to flow without barriers. Leaving it was always going to cause issues like this to arise that only have pain in the short term.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Sep 21 1.07pm

Originally posted by DanH

That’s why labels are extremely unhelpful. I largely believe in free markets and the most efficient use of capital. What we did was leave a large, frictionless free trade area that allowed for goods and people to flow without barriers. Leaving it was always going to cause issues like this to arise that only have pain in the short term.

You said it. Many of us voted for a correction in the labour market and that’s what will happen. I find it funny that some remainers claim we didn’t. The companies and governments have been getting away with poor treatment of workers and those WANTING work and this is where we are.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Sep 21 1.09pm

Originally posted by DanH

That’s why labels are extremely unhelpful. I largely believe in free markets and the most efficient use of capital. What we did was leave a large, frictionless free trade area that allowed for goods and people to flow without barriers. Leaving it was always going to cause issues like this to arise that only have pain in the short term.

So nothing to do with employing contract drivers then? Tesco, morrisons and other supermarket petrol stations have been OK with fuel. The same as said stores to a high degree. They employed direct labour as drivers and that's why. Not contractors on self employed status. Tax changes have caused some eu citizens to go home and you should know this danh. Your an accountant!

 

DanH Flag SW2 29 Sep 21 1.11pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You said it. Many of us voted for a correction in the labour market and that’s what will happen. I find it funny that some remainers claim we didn’t. The companies and governments have been getting away with poor treatment of workers and those WANTING work and this is where we are.

And I don’t have a problem with it as long as there’s no moaning from the same people about supply shortages, inflation or businesses going out of business in the short term.

You realise a lot of what we buy these days can also be bought from online retailers outside the U.K. and imported? Our businesses largely compete in a global market, not just a domestic one. No business will survive if they can’t compete with their competitors on the price the market dictates. If they can’t do that for a profit as their costs are too high they won’t survive.

Edited by DanH (29 Sep 2021 1.13pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 29 Sep 21 1.14pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You said it. Many of us voted for a correction in the labour market and that’s what will happen. I find it funny that some remainers claim we didn’t. The companies and governments have been getting away with poor treatment of workers and those WANTING work and this is where we are.

I genuinely don't recall hearing a jot about a correction in the labour market during the referendum campaigns - have you got any quotes or links to support this?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Sep 21 1.23pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I genuinely don't recall hearing a jot about a correction in the labour market during the referendum campaigns - have you got any quotes or links to support this?

Why do you think the north voted Brexit?

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Sep 21 1.24pm

Originally posted by DanH

And I don’t have a problem with it as long as there’s no moaning from the same people about supply shortages, inflation or businesses going out of business in the short term.

You realise a lot of what we buy these days can also be bought from online retailers outside the U.K. and imported? Our businesses largely compete in a global market, not just a domestic one. No business will survive if they can’t compete with their competitors on the price the market dictates. If they can’t do that for a profit as their costs are too high they won’t survive.

Edited by DanH (29 Sep 2021 1.13pm)

So do you want better pay for workers or not?

 


COYP

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Staff shortages