This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Yeah don't trust the proles with a vote leave it to their lords and masters. They aren't though our "lords and masters" are they? We are theirs. We choose who represents us. Once we do, we need to allow them to do their job. We have done ours. Taking our responsibilities more seriously would encourage them not to take us for granted. We have the collective power to choose people who deliver what we need and, if they don't, we replace them.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
What was Corbyn's Brexit policy, I can't remember. I remember Thornberry talking some rubbish about renegotiating from a position of wanting to remain but best to ignore the stuff she spouts. Edited by HKOwen (13 Jan 2022 9.46pm) Throughout his political career, Corbyn was very much against us being a member of the EU. He changed his official line when becoming leader of the Labour party and pretended that he wanted us to remain.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Matov
It fairness Corbyn clearly wasn't pro remai, and even if Labour had gone along with Brexit without question, a serious proportion of their voters would've reacted negatively to that. In short through circumstance, there wasn't any path to victory anyway. At least with Brexit now done, people are able to vote on issues beyond that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I'm very happy we are out, as are many others. I believe it was absolutely correct to put the question directly to the people. You would though, wouldn't you? You are typical fodder for a populist's agenda, dutifully lapping up their simple answers to complex issues. I don't doubt you would like to replace our representative democracy with one where we elected delegates who are told by a local cabal of the majority party in their constituency how to vote on everything.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
But Parliament did permit. Voted by a huge margin to hold the referendum and then by a huge margin to invoke Article 50. The referendum only came about because of the Parliamentary process. And then in 2017, we have a general election fought on both Labour and the Conservatives making clear manifesto promises to honour the vote. Boris won because Labour decided to try and over-turn the 2016 result. Utter insanity for a whole host of reasons I have bored people with on numerous occassions so will not do so now but Boris is in number 10 because of people who refused to accept that 52, when expressed as a %, is bigger than 48. Get Brexit Done. Remember that slogan? You want to slate Boris for what he has done since, then fill your boots. No issues from me on that. But people like you are the primary reason why he is able to enjoy 'wine and nibbles' in Downing Street. Own that. Accept responsibility for that. The campaign for a second referendum, which was only ever about over-turning the Leave vote, handed Boris his win in 2019 on a plate. I realise that Parliament voted to both hold and honour the referendum, so as a consequence everything was done legally. That's not the issue. Our Parliament failed to do their duty. The Tories only agreed to hold one to stave off UKIP, and there were sufficient weaklings in the opposition scared of losing their seats to ensure it happened. Parliament bottled it when they needed to stand up and be counted. If that meant being counted out that was just tough. Johnson didn't win because Labour tried to over-turn the result. That's garbage. He won because of clever marketing, boredom, trickery and the lack of any kind of rational opposition. No-one wanted to over-turn the result. What was asked for was for the people to confirm, after a 4 year delay, lots of revelations and time for re-thinking, that it was still their wish to take such a momentous step. If the Brexiteers were so confident of their case, what were they fearful of? Surely any true democrat welcomes the opportunity to verify the will of the people? Of course 52 is bigger than 48 but anyone who believes that's part of the argument, let alone the end of it, really doesn't get it at all. Of course, I don't "own" any of Johnson's failings. I could see them years ago. For the reasons I explained above Johnson's victory had nothing to do with any attempt to over-turn the referendum result. It was clever work by Cummings and a desperately awful opposition, combined with a very tired electorate that just wanted it over. Clever marketing slogans are what you use to sell soap powder. It's not the way to run a country.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Gina Miller has launched her new party but only 13 people turned up to the launch. I think she's about to find out there is a big difference in winning a few court cases on point of law and actually stepping into the lions den of politics where you have to have policies. I suspect she will go the way of Laurence Fox. That's quite sad. She is a principled and honest lady who would make an excellent MP. Launching a new party demands much more than that though. It needs an organisation, and that needs lots of money, so backing from somewhere. How that can happen in 2022 is difficult to imagine. Perhaps, let's hope, George Soros is getting one of his Foundations primed to try to save British democracy. Both the Tories, and Labour, are now demonstrably past their sell by dates and seemingly incapable of re-inventing themselves. We need a reset.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Bring back Robert Kilroy-Silk
Vive le Roy! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I realise that Parliament voted to both hold and honour the referendum, so as a consequence everything was done legally. That's not the issue. Our Parliament failed to do their duty. The Tories only agreed to hold one to stave off UKIP, and there were sufficient weaklings in the opposition scared of losing their seats to ensure it happened. Parliament bottled it when they needed to stand up and be counted. If that meant being counted out that was just tough. Johnson didn't win because Labour tried to over-turn the result. That's garbage. He won because of clever marketing, boredom, trickery and the lack of any kind of rational opposition. No-one wanted to over-turn the result. What was asked for was for the people to confirm, after a 4 year delay, lots of revelations and time for re-thinking, that it was still their wish to take such a momentous step. If the Brexiteers were so confident of their case, what were they fearful of? Surely any true democrat welcomes the opportunity to verify the will of the people? Of course 52 is bigger than 48 but anyone who believes that's part of the argument, let alone the end of it, really doesn't get it at all. Of course, I don't "own" any of Johnson's failings. I could see them years ago. For the reasons I explained above Johnson's victory had nothing to do with any attempt to over-turn the referendum result. It was clever work by Cummings and a desperately awful opposition, combined with a very tired electorate that just wanted it over. Clever marketing slogans are what you use to sell soap powder. It's not the way to run a country. 'For the many, not the few' ring a bell then !
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by the.universal
Bring back Robert Kilroy-Silk
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Sir Keir using same excuse as Boris. ""Sir Keir was seen having a beer while standing close to two other people. The image was taken from outside the window of a constituency office in Durham in the days leading up to the Hartlepool by-election."" "The (Labour) party said in a statement: "Keir was in the workplace, meeting a local MP in her constituency office and participating in an online Labour Party event. And the difference between that and 10 Downing Street garden is? They are all as bad as each other.
Edited by Badger11 (14 Jan 2022 9.35am) Beat me to it Badger . . . Here's the link to the report published earlier . . . [Link]
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You would though, wouldn't you? You are typical fodder for a populist's agenda, dutifully lapping up their simple answers to complex issues. I don't doubt you would like to replace our representative democracy with one where we elected delegates who are told by a local cabal of the majority party in their constituency how to vote on everything. That is just your perception, which is in itself simplistic. The complexity of an issue does not determine policy. Too often, policy is decided for short term benefit which reflects the nature of our parliamentary system. Immigration is an example of this.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
'For the many, not the few' ring a bell then ! Not in my ears. Maybe you have tinnitus?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
No-one wanted to over-turn the result. What was asked for was for the people to confirm, after a 4 year delay, lots of revelations and time for re-thinking, that it was still their wish to take such a momentous step. Usual disemmbling from the self-identifying 'one nation tory'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That is just your perception, which is in itself simplistic. The complexity of an issue does not determine policy. Too often, policy is decided for short term benefit which reflects the nature of our parliamentary system. Immigration is an example of this. Where do I suggest it does? I am referring to the use of one line terms by populist politicians to describe simple answers to complex issues. This, of itself, will often produce exactly the kind of result you complain about. Your obsession with immigration as the primary fault line blighting both our social development, and our politics, is indeed an example. It's an example of a populist's response to a complex problem.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Where do I suggest it does? I am referring to the use of one line terms by populist politicians to describe simple answers to complex issues. This, of itself, will often produce exactly the kind of result you complain about. Your obsession with immigration as the primary fault line blighting both our social development, and our politics, is indeed an example. It's an example of a populist's response to a complex problem. It's not an obsession, it is an observation and criticism. Whether you accept it or not, it is a major factor in many of our current problems. That is not my invention. You should talk about obsession. You are still whining about Brexit on every thread.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Usual disemmbling from the self-identifying 'one nation tory'. There were many decent, responsible and visionary politicians, one nation Tories among them, who saw the need for confirmation and were shafted as a consequence by a despicable PM and his backers. I didn't want that myself. I wanted Parliament to take charge, but saw the political wisdom of having made the mistake of allowing a referendum to be held in 2016 it would be wise to hold another. Of course there that would have been the end of it. You cannot go on endlessly with such a programme, but there were solid, indeed overwhelming reasons, to verify as so much had been revealed that was obscured in 2016. If Brexit was indeed still what the country wanted why should any Brexiteer resist checking it? It seems to me they knew the game was going to be lost, so they were desperate to blow the whistle. This isn't forgotten and will be served up cold when the time is right and the mood of the country ready to receive it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There were many decent, responsible and visionary politicians, one nation Tories among them, who saw the need for confirmation and were shafted as a consequence by a despicable PM and his backers. I didn't want that myself. I wanted Parliament to take charge, but saw the political wisdom of having made the mistake of allowing a referendum to be held in 2016 it would be wise to hold another. Of course there that would have been the end of it. You cannot go on endlessly with such a programme, but there were solid, indeed overwhelming reasons, to verify as so much had been revealed that was obscured in 2016. This isn't forgotten and will be served up cold when the time is right and the mood of the country ready to receive it. But it doesn't work the other way? Did you argue that we should check if we were still OK in the EU? 40 years we were denied a vote by the major parties even though the EU changed out of all recognition from the Common Market. you weren't complaining then even though the EU was not what we signed up for. Edited by Badger11 (14 Jan 2022 1.25pm)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I realise that Parliament voted to both hold and honour the referendum, so as a consequence everything was done legally. That's not the issue. Our Parliament failed to do their duty. The Tories only agreed to hold one to stave off UKIP, and there were sufficient weaklings in the opposition scared of losing their seats to ensure it happened. Parliament bottled it when they needed to stand up and be counted. If that meant being counted out that was just tough. Johnson didn't win because Labour tried to over-turn the result. That's garbage. He won because of clever marketing, boredom, trickery and the lack of any kind of rational opposition. No-one wanted to over-turn the result. What was asked for was for the people to confirm, after a 4 year delay, lots of revelations and time for re-thinking, that it was still their wish to take such a momentous step. If the Brexiteers were so confident of their case, what were they fearful of? Surely any true democrat welcomes the opportunity to verify the will of the people? Of course 52 is bigger than 48 but anyone who believes that's part of the argument, let alone the end of it, really doesn't get it at all. Of course, I don't "own" any of Johnson's failings. I could see them years ago. For the reasons I explained above Johnson's victory had nothing to do with any attempt to over-turn the referendum result. It was clever work by Cummings and a desperately awful opposition, combined with a very tired electorate that just wanted it over. Clever marketing slogans are what you use to sell soap powder. It's not the way to run a country. Thank you for giving me such a laugh on a cold, murky Friday. Not for many years have I read such a disconnected, desperate, biased and misguided take on Brexit, the referendum, the endorsement in the European Elections and the overwhelming message sent in the 2019 General Election.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.