You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR this weekend
November 22 2026 8.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR this weekend


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Feb 23 3.19pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I think you've both arguing for, and against VAR at once there - and I totally agree !

VAR will be good for football, in it's evolved state. Right now it's not fit for purpose.
Take it away, get it right, then redeploy it properly. Don't employ a half baked, untested system on your Platinum product, test it out, iron out the kinks somewhere else first.

When the Technology is good enough to accurately track and Map ALL elements at play, i.e. ball position, defenders arm position etc, allowing for instant(ish) decisions (which will happen eventially) Then i'll be behind it.

right now it's a good idea badly implemented.

VAR magnifies issues that have always been there in football e.g. offside. Now that the technology is being used FIFA should consider changing the rules I think most of us think it silly that someones toe or arm is offside by a few inches.

In athletics the winner of a race is based on a line through the chest so other body parts are irrelevant for example.

Edited by Badger11 (15 Feb 2023 3.20pm)

 


One more point

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Feb 23 3.21pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The VAR system as it operated last Saturday, in favour of Crystal Palace, is one I support.

Please do not tinker with it !!!!!


Didn't work for Jota running into Guaita smiling though. It's just the same as before - usually favouring the big teams
Also just as incorrect and as subjective as before. But a good point, however.

 


Red and Blue Army!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Feb 23 3.24pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Feels as though there's an element of justifying its existence.

This seems to be correct. Pushing ahead with it without it being liked by the fans - who everyone seems to forget are ultimately your customers. Football must be the only business that pisses off its customers constantly, yet they always come back. That and selling fags, heroin, crack or drink to alcoholics.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Teddy Eagle Flag 15 Feb 23 3.31pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

This seems to be correct. Pushing ahead with it without it being liked by the fans - who everyone seems to forget are ultimately your customers. Football must be the only business that pisses off its customers constantly, yet they always come back. That and selling fags, heroin, crack or drink to alcoholics.

Or U2 records when Bonio is larging it.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 15 Feb 23 3.44pm

Personally I'd be in favour of a challenge system. Instead of reviewing everything. It works well in other sports.

The one thing I particularly hate is sending the ref over to view it on the monitor. If he's got it wrong call it, if its marginal/debatable, let the original decision stand.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Feb 23 4.25pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Personally I'd be in favour of a challenge system. Instead of reviewing everything. It works well in other sports.

The one thing I particularly hate is sending the ref over to view it on the monitor. If he's got it wrong call it, if its marginal/debatable, let the original decision stand.

I said this from the very beginning!

Each manager should get 2/3 and applied same as Tennis - Correct challenge you keep it if not you lose it.

Might just fuel further controversy when inevitably VAR still gets things wrong however might also mitigate moaning from teams/managers as it'd be on them. Might also help with cheating too.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Feb 23 4.28pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Or U2 records when Bonio is larging it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 23 4.39pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

If the lines were drawn in the wrong place or not at all, that is negligence of duty surely?

I appreciate that 'Negligence/Negligent" is used in everyday parlance to describe similar scenarios, however legally what you have described does not meet the elements of the tort of 'Negligence'.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Feb 23 4.43pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I said this from the very beginning!

Each manager should get 2/3 and applied same as Tennis - Correct challenge you keep it if not you lose it.

Might just fuel further controversy when inevitably VAR still gets things wrong however might also mitigate moaning from teams/managers as it'd be on them. Might also help with cheating too.

They will still complain when a manager has used up his challenges and can't on a blatant mistake.

 


One more point

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Feb 23 4.49pm

Originally posted by Badger11

They will still complain when a manager has used up his challenges and can't on a blatant mistake.

True, but you'd hope they'd firstly start using them wisely in the first instance and secondly stop the antics of the likes of Klopp/Conte as they could either challenge or face up to the fact they can't as they'd already been wrong on a few occasions. Would therefore be their own fault if they could not challenge something else!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 15 Feb 23 5.26pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

True, but you'd hope they'd firstly start using them wisely in the first instance and secondly stop the antics of the likes of Klopp/Conte as they could either challenge or face up to the fact they can't as they'd already been wrong on a few occasions. Would therefore be their own fault if they could not challenge something else!

It's a nice suggestion, but you'd also have to weigh up the negative effects of it being introduced, eg. time wasting and tactical use. Much like players using it to their advantage in tennis – allowing time for recovery, or breaking an opponents concentration, stopping the momentum and so on. You're also adding to the amount of stoppages across the game.

It's not a silver bullet.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 15 Feb 23 5.28pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

You prefer football since VAR? You have every right to say so.

You read? See above, 1.26pm.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (15 Feb 2023 5.28pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 15 Feb 23 5.49pm


We don't need a challenge system - it's still based on a flawed technology, or at least one that needs refining.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 15 Feb 23 5.50pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I think you've both arguing for, and against VAR at once there - and I totally agree !

VAR will be good for football, in it's evolved state. Right now it's not fit for purpose.
Take it away, get it right, then redeploy it properly. Don't employ a half baked, untested system on your Platinum product, test it out, iron out the kinks somewhere else first.

When the Technology is good enough to accurately track and Map ALL elements at play, i.e. ball position, defenders arm position etc, allowing for instant(ish) decisions (which will happen eventially) Then i'll be behind it.

right now it's a good idea badly implemented.

I sort of agree here, but not about the 'test it somewhere else' bit. The only way you get to where it's going quickly and properly is by going for it in real world scenarios – it's the fastest way to learn and iterate. Real data is always better to learn off than practice data.

I do however think they went a season too early with it, there were some pretty obvious changes they could have made and 12 months more testing would have been beneficial.

Calling for it to be taken away until it's vastly improved... not sure we'd ever get there though as the whole point of throwing it out there in the real world is to improve it faster but also more crucially demonstrate it works vs the goals that the governing bodies have set (and it does, the stats speak for themselves).

So yeah, it's a rapidly improving prototype in some ways, but if the end result is going to benefit and ultimately improve the game significantly and measurably then short term growing pains are an acceptable trade off.

It doesn't seem to be affecting the popularity of the product, really, other than fans grumbling about change. The amount of correct decisions has increased significantly. Yes the flow of the game has been affected but that will improve over time, and it's not done so fundamentally – i.e. people stopping coming to games and popularity waning. If anything it's more popular now than it ever has been.

In a way it's similar to this viewpoint regarding self driving car software prototypes being allowed on the road in their millions (although obviously without the saving lives bit, but the point is more or less transferrable)

Short of forbidding all testing of prototypes, there is no way to demand perfection. It is difficult to craft a regulatory regime that would ban self driving testing that doesn’t also ban or slow down the development of very important technology that will in time save millions of lives.

Nonetheless, we could define a set of rules for who can supervise a prototype system, and it might stop Tesla’s activity. But to do so would be to fall into the paradox of “the better it is, the more we don’t like it.” We don’t want to make it harder to cross that valley to becoming a better system. The real question is why we would want to even go there if nobody is being hurt. Right now there are not reports of people being hurt, certainly not at any levels that would indicate there is more risk than that from ordinary driving. We don’t want to fall into the trap of banning things because we have an intuition that they are dangerous. We only want to ban things that actually are dangerous.

So, is it dangerous and an existential threat to football itself? No. So it's here to stay (and improve)

Edited by SW19 CPFC (15 Feb 2023 5.51pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 16 Feb 23 8.58am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

I sort of agree here, but not about the 'test it somewhere else' bit. The only way you get to where it's going quickly and properly is by going for it in real world scenarios – it's the fastest way to learn and iterate. Real data is always better to learn off than practice data.

I do however think they went a season too early with it, there were some pretty obvious changes they could have made and 12 months more testing would have been beneficial.

Calling for it to be taken away until it's vastly improved... not sure we'd ever get there though as the whole point of throwing it out there in the real world is to improve it faster but also more crucially demonstrate it works vs the goals that the governing bodies have set (and it does, the stats speak for themselves).

So yeah, it's a rapidly improving prototype in some ways, but if the end result is going to benefit and ultimately improve the game significantly and measurably then short term growing pains are an acceptable trade off.

It doesn't seem to be affecting the popularity of the product, really, other than fans grumbling about change. The amount of correct decisions has increased significantly. Yes the flow of the game has been affected but that will improve over time, and it's not done so fundamentally – i.e. people stopping coming to games and popularity waning. If anything it's more popular now than it ever has been.

In a way it's similar to this viewpoint regarding self driving car software prototypes being allowed on the road in their millions (although obviously without the saving lives bit, but the point is more or less transferrable)

Short of forbidding all testing of prototypes, there is no way to demand perfection. It is difficult to craft a regulatory regime that would ban self driving testing that doesn’t also ban or slow down the development of very important technology that will in time save millions of lives.

Nonetheless, we could define a set of rules for who can supervise a prototype system, and it might stop Tesla’s activity. But to do so would be to fall into the paradox of “the better it is, the more we don’t like it.” We don’t want to make it harder to cross that valley to becoming a better system. The real question is why we would want to even go there if nobody is being hurt. Right now there are not reports of people being hurt, certainly not at any levels that would indicate there is more risk than that from ordinary driving. We don’t want to fall into the trap of banning things because we have an intuition that they are dangerous. We only want to ban things that actually are dangerous.

So, is it dangerous and an existential threat to football itself? No. So it's here to stay (and improve)

Edited by SW19 CPFC (15 Feb 2023 5.51pm)

Not saying do not put it in a real-world Scenario, as thats important for all the reasons you state, but not on the premium product, i.e the premier League. What's wrong with putting it in the Championship first, for example.

I've been largely behind VAR up til now, but it should be so much more effective than what it is. For whatever reason, the powers that be in this country are not implementing it correctly. We cannot have another weekend like the one just gone. The whole point of VAR was to eliminate these exact errors. It was so bad that no VAR would have got more right. What's the point of it if that is the case?

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 16 Feb 23 11.43am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Not saying do not put it in a real-world Scenario, as thats important for all the reasons you state, but not on the premium product, i.e the premier League. What's wrong with putting it in the Championship first, for example.

I've been largely behind VAR up til now, but it should be so much more effective than what it is. For whatever reason, the powers that be in this country are not implementing it correctly. We cannot have another weekend like the one just gone. The whole point of VAR was to eliminate these exact errors. It was so bad that no VAR would have got more right. What's the point of it if that is the case?

Cost

There's no way the Championship would be able to implement it as it's far too expensive. There also is less of a business case, less money at stake etc. Not to mention you then have to maintain it in perpetuity – once the genie is out of the bottle... Plus the complexity of teams getting promoted having to pay up to have the system installed, lower league grounds not being up to standard to effectively implement it and so on. Not practical

On the latter point – VAR was brought in to reduce errors. It can't eliminate human error, which is always going to be present in an augmented system. The point is howlers like the weekend are happening with much less frequency because of the system. Significantly more decisions are being called correctly than ever before. It is working. The point of it is not perfection – that's impossible. So if you're asking for that before it gets introduced then its never going to happen.

It is better than it was at launch, and it will continue to improve until a point where errors become less and less frequent. But there will always be errors unless it is a fully automated system and you do away with refs and humans augmenting the process (not happening any time soon).

A weekend of big errors is not a valid reason to bin the whole thing off. Doesn't make any sense. It is an excellent reminder that the human component is the fallible element of the system and things like automated offsides need to be brought in faster.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (16 Feb 2023 11.44am)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Feb 23 12.19pm

I'm still completely unconvinced. If an issue is still open to interpretation it's still just the same as it was. Technology can only answer yes or no, in or out, one or zero. It can't give intention or any nuance at all. So technology for goal line - really good. Things like that. Anything with interpretation is literally just a replay watched by another ref. And there are always issues with replays and interpretations due to bias, human error, eyesight - anything really.
Just something else for saying about cricket and tennis - cricket still has umpire's call. Which, off the top of my head I believe is something to do with the technology having 99.7 percent accuracy or something like that. That could be centimetres or even inches across a football pitch. Certainly millimetres.
Clear and obvious - a whole other issue. Surely the common sense approach is that something is clear and obvious if it can be seen with the naked eye. It's not clear and obvious if you need several replays, computer generated lines and a few minutes to find it
I'm not saying it's a threat to the game - I'm saying it doesn't work, which it doesn't. But also that it detracts from the game as a spectacle. It's supposed to be sporting entertainment, not a drudge through several people's viewpoints on the same angle every time there is an incident or goal. It reminds me of NFL: a play every once in a while once taken to the nth degree. I like NFL by the way - I know what to expect. And I don't expect that at football.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 16 Feb 23 12.40pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I'm still completely unconvinced. If an issue is still open to interpretation it's still just the same as it was. Technology can only answer yes or no, in or out, one or zero. It can't give intention or any nuance at all. So technology for goal line - really good. Things like that. Anything with interpretation is literally just a replay watched by another ref. And there are always issues with replays and interpretations due to bias, human error, eyesight - anything really.
Just something else for saying about cricket and tennis - cricket still has umpire's call. Which, off the top of my head I believe is something to do with the technology having 99.7 percent accuracy or something like that. That could be centimetres or even inches across a football pitch. Certainly millimetres.
Clear and obvious - a whole other issue. Surely the common sense approach is that something is clear and obvious if it can be seen with the naked eye. It's not clear and obvious if you need several replays, computer generated lines and a few minutes to find it
I'm not saying it's a threat to the game - I'm saying it doesn't work, which it doesn't. But also that it detracts from the game as a spectacle. It's supposed to be sporting entertainment, not a drudge through several people's viewpoints on the same angle every time there is an incident or goal. It reminds me of NFL: a play every once in a while once taken to the nth degree. I like NFL by the way - I know what to expect. And I don't expect that at football.


You're right, cricket has umpires call. And it works well.

However, this is effectively the same using VAR... it's not just the incidents that get pulled that are the ones that get reviewed. The game is being reviewed constantly, and they are making decisions in real time that an incident is either not worthy of a review or that it's not conclusive enough to escalate and therefore better to stick with the onfield decision (effectively umpires call).

You're also right that anything that requires interpretation is an issue. However this happens with replays in Rugby and no-one sees that as an issue as they accept that the addition of the review allows the right decision to be made more often than not (and more often than before) which is also the point of VAR.

Regarding offsides, which I personally think is the biggest time drain and most fallible use of VAR, as soon as the semi-automated system comes in next season the issues with time taken and line drawing will disappear. The only time contention will feature is for issues like the Rashford offside earlier in the season where the decision is down to an interpretation of what 'interfering with play' means, rather than the offside/onside itself.

I agree it's not a threat to the game, I don't agree that it doesn't work, as the facts prove it does – significantly more correct decisions are being made than ever before, and at elite level that is gold dust.

Your gripe seems to come down to whether it improves or detracts from the game as a spectacle, which is of course entirely subjective.

As previously stated I do agree that VAR can work a lot better and there are still too many stoppages and time wasting because of it, but I also think this will improve exponentially over time, and the incidents that do require more consideration take no longer than the time it used to take for the referee to disperse hoards of angry players desperately trying to influence him, wander over to his assistant and discuss what happened before making a final call.

NFL is an extreme example – it's hyperbole to try and say Football is now the same in terms of stoppages and time wasting.

On the point about 'its meant to be sporting entertainment' – is Rugby not entertaining then? Cricket? Tennis?

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 16 Feb 23 1.16pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

It's a nice suggestion, but you'd also have to weigh up the negative effects of it being introduced, eg. time wasting and tactical use. Much like players using it to their advantage in tennis – allowing time for recovery, or breaking an opponents concentration, stopping the momentum and so on. You're also adding to the amount of stoppages across the game.

It's not a silver bullet.

Of course, noting is going to completely fix this, but managers already waste time with 89th min subs etc.

But as Nicholas91 said I think it will help in 2 areas:

Only reviewing a couple of things per game vs loads

Players and managers shouting and arguing with the ref. If they think he is wrong challenge, if not, shut up

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 16 Feb 23 1.43pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Of course, noting is going to completely fix this, but managers already waste time with 89th min subs etc.

But as Nicholas91 said I think it will help in 2 areas:

Only reviewing a couple of things per game vs loads

Players and managers shouting and arguing with the ref. If they think he is wrong challenge, if not, shut up

Ah you mean instead of VAR instead of in addition to it

Possibly. You'd have to look at statistics re. how many critical incorrect decisions were made per game over the years pre VAR though to see if it would be enough/worthwhile.

The other problem with it is managers and players could challenge for anything, effectively, rather than just critical decisions. So all those reviews could be wasted on relatively unimportant incidents and when a critical one pops up they're screwed as they've run out. On that basis I'm not sure it would be any better, really. At least with VAR there's no limit on what can be reviewed and it's as neutrally assigned as possible.

Also as someone has already pointed out players and manages would still continue to abuse the ref regardless.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (16 Feb 2023 1.44pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR this weekend