You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson


Page 7 of 27 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 23 5.07pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Not defending Freedman/Parish here as their transfer decision making has been odd to say the least. But....

Richards - is actually quite decent. Had either Guehi or Andersen been out he would be very good cover.

Ahamada - you just don't know whether he was worth 12m, never been given a decent chance. Certainly not under Roy

However......

Franca - again you don't know, but to pay £20m + on an unknown for a club like palace was irresponsible.

Henderson - I know that Giuita had thrown his toys out of the pram but why spend 17m on an known injury prone backup keeper. Joe Whitworth has been picked for England development squad or something.

Add to that Rob Holding an unnecessary addition, now injured and taking up valuable wages. Nathan Ferguson taking up valuable wages. Mateta who should have been sold in the summer, keeping both Ward and Clyne taking up a valuable weekly wage.

Money being wasted on multiple levels.

Two experienced players and of course replacing them with those costing fees will have cost much more than retaining the services of Ward and Clyne.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 08 Dec 23 5.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

Two experienced players and of course replacing them with those costing fees will have cost much more than retaining the services of Ward and Clyne.

It was more a situation of keeping both on, when really only 1 of them should have been kept.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 08 Dec 23 5.26pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Not defending Freedman/Parish here as their transfer decision making has been odd to say the least. But....

Richards - is actually quite decent. Had either Guehi or Andersen been out he would be very good cover.

Ahamada - you just don't know whether he was worth 12m, never been given a decent chance. Certainly not under Roy

However......

Franca - again you don't know, but to pay £20m + on an unknown for a club like palace was irresponsible.

Henderson - I know that Giuita had thrown his toys out of the pram but why spend 17m on an known injury prone backup keeper. Joe Whitworth has been picked for England development squad or something.

Add to that Rob Holding an unnecessary addition, now injured and taking up valuable wages. Nathan Ferguson taking up valuable wages. Mateta who should have been sold in the summer, keeping both Ward and Clyne taking up a valuable weekly wage.

Money being wasted on multiple levels.


W

I would add Tomkins, to the wasted money. But beyond that , any club in our position not just should but must bring in players that improve what you have, yes you can speculate a bit, and they have, only two players have come close in actually improving our team since three windows back.
I have watched Franca, a few times ,and if it wasn’t for his price tag, I would accept out of hand he is only promising and a bit rough at the edges. . If he is any good he might need a really smart Championship regime to get going.
Ahamada, Is another expensive chance taken that when I have seen him , which is quiet often since he came , only ever shouts, give me a go in the Champiomship.
These two are a bit further forward than the majority of our under twenty ones .proof of the pudding is the Championship shows little to no interest in players ,people think could play for us.
It’s little wonder we find ourselves up against it, Hodgson could throw any of these in it won’t help.


Edited by Putitout (08 Dec 2023 5.27pm)

Edited by Putitout (08 Dec 2023 5.29pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 08 Dec 23 8.01pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Let’s be honest we have never previously seen this Hodgson, this is a man that has always contained his frustrations in the game. And here he is sitting on a half dead horse hoping to get to the promised land, knowing the horse will never make it
He might flair up at times , but he will always get the blame whether he does or not, only pride can keep him trying, but he might as well throw it in , and let the players and board break another manager, and the fans demand value for money from someone else.

I agree with this. I'm a "fan" put me money where me mouth is for a few years and couldn't give a fvck if he says I'm spoilt. Don't understand why everyone gets so precious about it when they spend half their waking hours battering him.

The disappointment for me is that there's the core of a very decent team but the rest are not near good enough and there's zero contingency for injury. With two or three decent additions this could have been a good season where we build a winning feeling, the better players want to stay and progress is being made. We might even attract a good loan which is harder to do when a team is struggling.

Instead they'll be getting the hump and their agents will be all over it.


 

Jameston88 Flag Cornwall 08 Dec 23 8.32pm

Regarding Roy. Saying about the fans being spoilt,I know he has since apologised, I like him started supporting Palace in the fourth and third division days,1960 to be exact. I agree with him that compared to those days,we are spoilt. But that was over sixty years ago and times and peoples expectations have changed.
Think he has been good overall for Palace, but every one has their day and I think that day has come.
I do however put most of the blame on Freedman and Parish and Co for not backing him in the transfer market with either the money available or the signings made. Also don't hold your breath on the new stand being built anytime soon.

 

AERO Flag 08 Dec 23 8.51pm

Why is there a lot of talk about the New Stand not happening ?I know Simon Jorden commented on this but couldn't back his claims up .The extra costs is relatively small in premiership terms and planning issues have been overcome.So why would we not proceed ?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 08 Dec 23 9.00pm

Inflationary costs in the building industry are absolutely horrific over the last four years and there's a skill shortage.

Not sure that's the full reason but in the mix I reckon.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 08 Dec 23 9.08pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

I really don't think anyone can come in and do better with the limited number of creative players currently available within the team. Papers are saying we're after Cooper but he's not exactly storming it at Forest. Do we really want him? On the other hand, Dyche might have been the right fit of manager for us when he was available.

We've still got some great players but not enough of them to take us to another level. We need to finish fourth from bottom and should still be able to do that. However, another shambolic season because of poor planning and buying.

Agree

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

AERO Flag 08 Dec 23 9.10pm

Maybe but if not done now after these years in premiership it will never happen. Apparently Everton new ground costs up 150mil .

 

lord_kevros Flag Carshalton 08 Dec 23 10.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

Whilst recognizing Will Still's success at Reims he is relatively inexperienced as a manager so perhaps being thrust into the PL might bet a leap too far at this stage of his managerial career. My understanding is that he is on the 'Radar' of Sunderland.

Edited by Willo (08 Dec 2023 4.13pm)

Sunderland are expected to move for Kim Hellberg who has been relatively successful in the Swedish league.

I've previously posted Will Still would be an exciting prospect. He was interviewed in the Times about a week ago.
He describes himself as an introvert "But put me inside a dressing room and I know how to make them feel right about themselves and what we need to do and that we are there to win."

And on taking over the reigns at Reims
"Before, we were very 5-4-1, defensive low block, a bit boring and I said, ‘Stuff it, let’s have a go, we are conceding a s***load of goals in any case.’ So we turned it on its head"

He is absolutely going places, he will become much more widely known in the near future [unfortunately he is a West Ham fan]

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 09 Dec 23 8.29am

I must admit I am intrigued by SJ saying it wont happen because it cant - for sure he has been the chairman of the club & he is in a better position than most to know more about some of the details but why say that & then not substantiate it ?

Originally posted by AERO

Why is there a lot of talk about the New Stand not happening ?I know Simon Jorden commented on this but couldn't back his claims up .The extra costs is relatively small in premiership terms and planning issues have been overcome.So why would we not proceed ?

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 09 Dec 23 9.31am

My concern presently is that Roy, like Pardew previously, is a pragmatic manager and may get "more slack" from the management like him in terms of change due to his stature at the club. That said Pardew had the FA cup run and more points in the bank than Roy, so his possible departure may come quicker.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Uphill Flag Bedford 10 Dec 23 1.23pm

Martin Samuels puts it in perspective:

Hodgson was spoilt at Palace — not the supporters

Now Roy Hodgson has entered the fray by telling disgruntled Crystal Palace fans they have been spoilt. No, they haven’t; but he was, last season, when he took the job. Hodgson’s predecessor, Patrick Vieira, had just completed the fixture sequence from hell when he was sacked, a run of 11 league matches with only a single game against a team who weren’t in the top eight, or part of the failed European Super League elite. When Hodgson took over he had every one of the bottom eight clubs to play, in a sequence that had yielded 16 points earlier in the season. Hodgson started with three straight wins — against every club in the bottom three, all of whom would be relegated. And he took 16 points, the same as Vieira, from that run of games, while appearing a freewheeling football genius.

So, yes, he was spoilt, and this campaign was always going to be different. Hodgson has lost the tough fixtures — all bar the game away to Manchester United — and a few of the tamer ones too. In other words, back to reality. Vieira wasn’t playing Eberechi Eze, a mistake Hodgson rightly corrected, and Wilfried Zaha was always going to be a loss. Yet given the challenges Vieira faced, the outcomes have not been greatly different. Hodgson has said he regretted his comments, which at least shows a degree of awareness about his big break last season.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 13 Dec 23 11.00pm

He's pushes players too hard in training that's why we have so many injuries. SP needs to replace him ASAP

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 13 Dec 23 11.10pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Martin Samuels puts it in perspective:

Hodgson was spoilt at Palace — not the supporters

Now Roy Hodgson has entered the fray by telling disgruntled Crystal Palace fans they have been spoilt. No, they haven’t; but he was, last season, when he took the job. Hodgson’s predecessor, Patrick Vieira, had just completed the fixture sequence from hell when he was sacked, a run of 11 league matches with only a single game against a team who weren’t in the top eight, or part of the failed European Super League elite. When Hodgson took over he had every one of the bottom eight clubs to play, in a sequence that had yielded 16 points earlier in the season. Hodgson started with three straight wins — against every club in the bottom three, all of whom would be relegated. And he took 16 points, the same as Vieira, from that run of games, while appearing a freewheeling football genius.

So, yes, he was spoilt, and this campaign was always going to be different. Hodgson has lost the tough fixtures — all bar the game away to Manchester United — and a few of the tamer ones too. In other words, back to reality. Vieira wasn’t playing Eberechi Eze, a mistake Hodgson rightly corrected, and Wilfried Zaha was always going to be a loss. Yet given the challenges Vieira faced, the outcomes have not been greatly different. Hodgson has said he regretted his comments, which at least shows a degree of awareness about his big break last season.

A load of bollocks. Vieira managed a team with the worst distance covered stats in the Premier League and marginalised a player who's turned out to be our most talented attacker and goalscorer.

Forest were rock bottom when we lost to them and the boxing day performance at home to Fulham was horrific. We lost 3-0 and our goalkeeper was our best player.

Most of the top half teams underperformed with exception of City, Arsenal and Newcastle and we lost twice to Chelsea who we eventually finished above.

 

Norbury Old Git Flag London 14 Dec 23 8.13am

Eze started both the Forest and Fulham matches being substituted after 60 and 78 minutes as he was struggling. Not surprising considering he was still recovering after a horrendous injury after a Roy training session. Nonetheless Vieira played him in every match, some as a sub. It was in fact Roy who dropped him completely from the squad because “he has to learn how to defend”. When, I suspect, Parish learned that his £20m acquisition was was twiddling his thumbs with the Juniors he was hurriedly reinstated. Eze, knowing he had the blessing of the bosses, decided to ignore Roy and play in mid-field. The rest is history.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 14 Dec 23 1.37pm

Originally posted by Norbury Old Git

Eze started both the Forest and Fulham matches being substituted after 60 and 78 minutes as he was struggling. Not surprising considering he was still recovering after a horrendous injury after a Roy training session. Nonetheless Vieira played him in every match, some as a sub. It was in fact Roy who dropped him completely from the squad because “he has to learn how to defend”. When, I suspect, Parish learned that his £20m acquisition was was twiddling his thumbs with the Juniors he was hurriedly reinstated. Eze, knowing he had the blessing of the bosses, decided to ignore Roy and play in mid-field. The rest is history.

And Eze, thought all of Roy’s mistreatment, was what helped him to a full England cap.
Just shows how two faced Eze, must be. Eze, thinks Roy to be the best thing since sliced bread , and I don’t think he is two faced, certainly not in that respect. It was Hodgsons adjustments to the way we defended that released Eze to become the most potent part of our attacking capability.,nothing else . It would seem Eze, knows it only to well.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 14 Dec 23 3.28pm

An observation...

Based on the current Premier League form guide (last 6 games) Liverpool, Everton and Bournemouth are the top three.

My view is that we were on top most of the game against Everton and every time they went forward the seemed to score. It didn't feel like a poor performance.

Luton, certainly not at our stella best, but I think were were rattled after losing two key players within 90 seconds. We had chances and didn't take them. They did.

Bournemouth - felt like a dire performance at the time as we all expected we'd beat them, but Bournemouth are currently on a roll. Is it a case of Bournemouth actually played very well and deserve credit? Again, we probably had more chances than they did and the result might have been different.

Liverpool - given we could barely field 11 players, I thought it was our best performance of the season and the effort from the players showed they are clearly behind Roy.

Point is, we've come up against teams in good form whilst we're carrying significant injuries. We are losing games to fine margins. Roy ain't the problem, that was proved in the Liverpool match.

I've no doubt we'll start picking up wins when key players return. I'd be very worried about relegation if Roy got the boot - no one can drill a team like he can. We all want expansive exciting football but that won't happen unless we've got both Eze and Olise on the pitch. No manager can conjure up flair players from nowhere.


 

Jacey Flag 14 Dec 23 4.20pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

An observation...

Based on the current Premier League form guide (last 6 games) Liverpool, Everton and Bournemouth are the top three.

My view is that we were on top most of the game against Everton and every time they went forward the seemed to score. It didn't feel like a poor performance.

Luton, certainly not at our stella best, but I think were were rattled after losing two key players within 90 seconds. We had chances and didn't take them. They did.

Bournemouth - felt like a dire performance at the time as we all expected we'd beat them, but Bournemouth are currently on a roll. Is it a case of Bournemouth actually played very well and deserve credit? Again, we probably had more chances than they did and the result might have been different.

Liverpool - given we could barely field 11 players, I thought it was our best performance of the season and the effort from the players showed they are clearly behind Roy.

Point is, we've come up against teams in good form whilst we're carrying significant injuries. We are losing games to fine margins. Roy ain't the problem, that was proved in the Liverpool match.

I've no doubt we'll start picking up wins when key players return. I'd be very worried about relegation if Roy got the boot - no one can drill a team like he can. We all want expansive exciting football but that won't happen unless we've got both Eze and Olise on the pitch. No manager can conjure up flair players from nowhere.


Agree with everything you say,although we know Roy signed a one year deal and will be gone at the end of the season and planning for his replacement is a very high priority,or should be.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Dec 23 4.40pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

An observation...

Based on the current Premier League form guide (last 6 games) Liverpool, Everton and Bournemouth are the top three.

My view is that we were on top most of the game against Everton and every time they went forward the seemed to score. It didn't feel like a poor performance.

Luton, certainly not at our stella best, but I think were were rattled after losing two key players within 90 seconds. We had chances and didn't take them. They did.

Bournemouth - felt like a dire performance at the time as we all expected we'd beat them, but Bournemouth are currently on a roll. Is it a case of Bournemouth actually played very well and deserve credit? Again, we probably had more chances than they did and the result might have been different.

Liverpool - given we could barely field 11 players, I thought it was our best performance of the season and the effort from the players showed they are clearly behind Roy.

Point is, we've come up against teams in good form whilst we're carrying significant injuries. We are losing games to fine margins. Roy ain't the problem, that was proved in the Liverpool match.

I've no doubt we'll start picking up wins when key players return. I'd be very worried about relegation if Roy got the boot - no one can drill a team like he can. We all want expansive exciting football but that won't happen unless we've got both Eze and Olise on the pitch. No manager can conjure up flair players from nowhere.



Agree with all you say. I would just like to add my New Year wish here. That out of the blue one of our board members puts enough cash on the table (say £50m) to buy a couple of quality proven fit players who will go straight into the first team. Plus secure a couple more active fit players on loan who are also ready for first team action.


Edited by dreamwaverider (14 Dec 2023 4.40pm)

 

Page 7 of 27 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson