You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Spurs match thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Spurs match thread


Page 7 of 10 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 28 Oct 23 10.44am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think it is very hard for any player to make an impact as an attacking player, and even harder for the younger players, JRS, Franca and Ahamada should start against start against Burnley, so we can see if when everyone is starting cold they perform

------Ayew
Franca-Ahamada-JRS

We are not losing much dropping Hughes, Schlupp and Edouard, they will be on the bench if needed.

It's not just the quality and finishing of our attacking players ... it's also our build up, accuracy and speed of delivery. We're too slow and there's far too much passing to and fro. The opposition are all behind the ball by the time we arrive. We miss Zaha and Olise particularly on the wing and Eze in the middle. The youngsters may well introduce a bit of pace but we could do with taking some points from Burnley and Everton. I'm not sure I saw them make a significant impact when they all came on last night.

Edited by Henry of Peckham (28 Oct 2023 10.56am)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

PatrickA Flag London 28 Oct 23 10.55am

Roy is not going to start the young players next week
He professed himself happy with the first half performance yesterday when the senior players featured, but less happy with the contribution of the young players in the second half.
It's likely to be the same team next week assuming that Mitchell is fit.
Keep it tight and try and nick a goal will be the mantra until Olise and Eze come back, and this will be regardless of the opposition.
For Roy to be more ambitious he needs to feel confident in the ability of his attacking players, and I'm not sure he has this in the absence of Olise, Eze and Zaha.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 28 Oct 23 11.01am

Modern day football is all about speed. Watch the top teams in all top leagues and you see speed of passing, thinking, running, shooting etc. etc. In most cases very exciting to watch.
We rarely seem to see players dummying a shot then turning inside, going round two more then shooting. Occasionally maybe but the game is so quick that they are discouraged to do anything like that. It's like top players are learning from the FIFA computer game.
As ive already said, we are just way too slow. Our best two players are out and we dont have any significant replacements as aired by Roy.
We are safe and we will be ok this season, but to keep up we need to recognise where the game is going and respond, by bringing in the right personnel to deliver. I am somewhat concerned we maybe are not looking with the right eyes in the right places. And Im not convinced we have got the funds to deliver the goods.
Here is hoping for some good fortune in many directions for Christmas. At the moment it is all feeling a bit bleak even though Im convinced we are safe.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Oct 23 11.02am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Roy is not going to start the young players next week
He professed himself happy with the first half performance yesterday when the senior players featured, but less happy with the contribution of the young players in the second half.
It's likely to be the same team next week assuming that Mitchell is fit.
Keep it tight and try and nick a goal will be the mantra until Olise and Eze come back, and this will be regardless of the opposition.
For Roy to be more ambitious he needs to feel confident in the ability of his attacking players, and I'm not sure he has this in the absence of Olise, Eze and Zaha.

Nothing unusual there, until the first goal comes from the opposition, and the well intention plan goes out the window with nothing to replace it. I do realise the conundrum Roy is in, what with his more creative players out injured, but I also realise that Roy is totally incapable of trying anything different. That's just the way it is.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 28 Oct 23 11.06am

We weren't likely to get much out of these two games but if we're sh1t against the bottom teams then questions will inevitably be asked. We need points from our next two - one win minimum.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Putitout Flag Oxford 28 Oct 23 11.16am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

If this is the case why then did the club spend up to £25m on a relatively untried young Brazilian? How does the club expect Franca to exhibit his potential? I was thinking that Franca would be a starter pretty soon, but Roy has always shown preference to his favourites, and increasingly favourite duffers. Certainly Schlupp no longer brings anything to the party , and as for Ward, he's been Championship material for at least two seasons. Both are guaranteed starters under Roy. Up front Roy still gives Mateta the occasional game, despite him being total pony poo.
Easy to blame the subs, but Roy picks the team and devises the increasingly negative tactics. It really is like Groundhog Day round here.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (28 Oct 2023 10.47am)


For your highlight, no good asking me, ask the club? You right to say certain players are no longer better than OK . But none of this is actually Hodgsons fault, I would be surprised if he wouldn’t replace the lot if he could, he can’t and that’s that..
Mateta like many in his squad get game time because there is no one else.
Roy picks the team with what’s at his disposal ,and by your own words many are crap ,so he works with crap, hats off to him.
As I said with a better front three last nights game ,would have probably been won on his tactics, because that would have got the important goal that wasn’t there last night.
He isn’t just frustrated by the kids, for the sake of being, he is frustrated because it’s glaringly obvious he hasn’t got subs that change a game let alone win one.
I hope Franca, comes good , as you say ,a lot of money. I can only think he was feeling the pressure and trying to hard last night, but quite frankly,( no Pune) he was all over the place, looking really rough at the edges. And yes RakSaki was knocked out of the game not for the first time. Didn’t notice the French boy, sort of says it all.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 28 Oct 23 11.24am

Roy proved last season that if he has the right players available to him, he can play a more attacking style of football. Without Eze and Olise, we lack creativity. Unsurprisingly, and quite rightly in my opinion, Roy came up with a game plan last night that worked well until Wards unfortunate own goal.

You can critisise him for not having a ' Plan B ', but everyone, meaning Roy, most on HOL, and the media all recognise that the squad lacks quality and depth. Spending £40m on a goalkeeper and an untried teenager was not and is not the answer.

Edouard's performance last night brought back memories of a contract job I had at Barclays some years ago. I was paid a very handsome day rate for sitting around doing nothing.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

1969eagle Flag manchester 28 Oct 23 11.38am

With Schlupp back, no problems down Mitchell's side. They piled onto Wards wing...of course. On 30% possession we created more chances than them first half. We needed to convert at least one of those. Ward OG was a shocker and game over. Spurs didn't play great for 50 minutes but clearly move the ball much sharper than us (as they should with the cost of their squad). Our defence and holding mids were back to their best. Hurry back Eze and Olise or we will struggle at Burnley/Everton/Luton...games we must win. Rak Saki looked lightweight. Franca had a howler. One awful free kick and an appalling corner asks what on earth is he doing taking set pieces.....let's hope it was just nerves and we haven't been sold a pup. Onwards to Turf Moor COYP!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Oct 23 11.43am

Originally posted by Putitout


For your highlight, no good asking me, ask the club? You right to say certain players are no longer better than OK . But none of this is actually Hodgsons fault, I would be surprised if he wouldn’t replace the lot if he could, he can’t and that’s that..
Mateta like many in his squad get game time because there is no one else.
Roy picks the team with what’s at his disposal ,and by your own words many are crap ,so he works with crap, hats off to him.
As I said with a better front three last nights game ,would have probably been won on his tactics, because that would have got the important goal that wasn’t there last night.
He isn’t just frustrated by the kids, for the sake of being, he is frustrated because it’s glaringly obvious he hasn’t got subs that change a game let alone win one.
I hope Franca, comes good , as you say ,a lot of money. I can only think he was feeling the pressure and trying to hard last night, but quite frankly,( no Pune) he was all over the place, looking really rough at the edges. And yes RakSaki was knocked out of the game not for the first time. Didn’t notice the French boy, sort of says it all.

Ha, yeah. The point I'm belabouring is that when one stands back and has a look from that perspective nothing has really changed since Roy's earlier tenure. Expecting something different from the same style of football and squad limitation is rather too hopeful. I did welcome Roy's intention to break into the top 10, well meaning I guess, but we'd need every player fit and up to it. One can but hope.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 28 Oct 23 11.45am

Lots of sensible opinions on here. With a team like ours you gamble on having your top 6 level players fit, so when Olise and Eze are out we look like strugglers going forward. Solid enough at the back.

It speaks volumes that I get most excited at a player's dribbles when Guehi dummies a pass and goes on one of his little runs. He only tried it once or twice vs Spurs and almost got caught out so didn't try it again.

This next month is crucial. 7 points would be excellent given that I doubt we'll see Eze and Olise back for next weekend. Would bite your arm off for 6 right now though. Anything below that sucks us back into danger.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

palace chick Flag South Croydon 28 Oct 23 12.18pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Roy is not going to start the young players next week
He professed himself happy with the first half performance yesterday when the senior players featured, but less happy with the contribution of the young players in the second half.
It's likely to be the same team next week assuming that Mitchell is fit.
Keep it tight and try and nick a goal will be the mantra until Olise and Eze come back, and this will be regardless of the opposition.
For Roy to be more ambitious he needs to feel confident in the ability of his attacking players, and I'm not sure he has this in the absence of Olise, Eze and Zaha.

Don’t disagree with this assessment. Taking Lerma and Hughes off killed our midfield as those coming on couldn’t fit in and weakened our team. Doucoure was then left on his own. Personally I would have brought on Reidewald to play alongside side Doucoure in the Hope the strength of the midfield from the first half would have been kept. This would have allowed Rak Saki and Franca to attack / receive the ball better. Main problem with starting with Lerma (who isn’t looking match fit at the moment) Doucoure and Hughes is that we don’t have a sub(s) to replace their positions. Hopefully that will change when Eze / Olise are back and then Hughes will be on the bench to replace when needed one of the two central midfielders? We just didn’t have as strong a team for the second half last night and it told when we had to make substitutions. Still thought we did okay last night against a very in form team and could have sneaked a draw with a bit more luck? Let’s see how we go next week before slamming the team and Hodgson?

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 28 Oct 23 12.22pm

Ewan Ferguson at Brighton is not yet 19 - does not seem too nervous to me.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Oct 23 12.34pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Ewan Ferguson at Brighton is not yet 19 - does not seem too nervous to me.

Probably given encouragement by his manager to express himself and not pilloried when things don't go according to plan...

 

The Dolphin Flag 28 Oct 23 12.40pm

Roy keeps picking Ward instead of who Richards warms the bench - nuts!I
Pick the youngsters to start games - not all at the same time of course but give them a go.
Never slag them off in public.
I want him gone now to be honest.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 28 Oct 23 12.50pm

Not quite sure why there is so much fuss over what Roy said about the youngsters.
Aren’t they allowed to be criticised and given a rocket up their backsides? Crikey they are well paid enough. My Dad was fighting the Japanese in Burma at their age .
Truth is the poor transfer window is being exposed for the lack of depth.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Oct 23 12.55pm

There is a lot of sensible commentary on here which is good to see.

I still think we are about 7/11 a very, very good PL side. In dreamland I’d get in a LW, Striker, RB and if I were greedy a LB too (I’m not as harsh in Mitchell as others but don’t dismiss the negative stance on him).

Problem is, we have a couple or more of those out injured and the rest are making up numbers. They’re useful in filling out the squad and replacing the starting XI here and there but when you have a few starters out, we begin to look very weak.

Roy might be doing the practical thing each time but it does look very negative. May just be a reflection of the investment, or lack of, in playing staff. We all want to see fluent, attacking and inspiring football but I’d seriously question the ability of the squad to do so especially with the likes of Eze and Olise out.

I remember us seemingly forever in a relegation fight and when Wilf was out it was almost a write off. The situation with Ebz and Olise out inspired a similar feeling in me yesterday.

I’m clinging to a possibly fantasy based hope that they’ll invest in players to coincide with a new manager end of season, provided we’re not relegated. Until then, unfortunately I’d guess Roy’s thinking is to play for 0-0 against bigger sides and hope for more, and try to win the games in which we stand a chance. A carbon copy of his last spell, which I think the board recognise, hence his employment. We can’t do that forever though and something will have to change at some point.

COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 28 Oct 23 12.56pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

Not quite sure why there is so much fuss over what Roy said about the youngsters.
Aren’t they allowed to be criticised and given a rocket up their backsides? Crikey they are well paid enough. My Dad was fighting the Japanese in Burma at their age .
Truth is the poor transfer window is being exposed for the lack of depth.

None of this is a massive surprise - Roy playing his old favourites, Palace struggling against the top teams, injuries when we gambled on not having many, no progress on the new stand. We’ll get by this season as there are v poor teams below us, but next season’s looking like a perfect storm approaching.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 28 Oct 23 1.05pm

I know nothing - but I would surmise that as the new main stand & the relevant costs attached get closer, Roy has been put under pressure to at least explore playing the youngsters that we have at PL level prior to the club having to spend money outside -

He probably saw last night as an opportunity to do so, we were 0.2 down & seemingly unlikely to drag ourselves back into the game so whatever we were risking the outcome was unlikely to get too much worse (at least in relation to other scenarios where younger players could be used)

Ultimately he is a manager tasked with getting the best out of this season so he will want to use all of the tools at his disposal - the big question is going to be what does the club do when next season comes around & work on the new stand begins.

I still don't think we will sell players to fund it but I do believe we will only buy new players as an absolute last resort.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 28 Oct 23 1.10pm

Not all comment but certainly some seems to think Hodgson only sets us up to contain. End of.
Yes he sets us up to contain, yes always important, Spurs we’re set up to contain us believe it or not. But that’s where the difference is their manager expects them do that, and turn it into offence, he doesn’t have tell them ,he expects it.
Roy’s problem in to many games is he gives them the basis, but only they can turn it into effective offence, on the whole only players can make it happen in the opponents half. Spurs second goal said it all , not an impressive night in my opinion for them but sheer class on that goal, if the manager has a hand in that it’s because he gives a platform, it’s the players class that makes it happen.
We don’t have that quality most know it and why, it’s not anyone’s fault ,because you invariably have to buy that sort of quality, and we and many other clubs can not do that . It’s not all bad we have enough to carry on at our level, but Hodgson would only take us to the promised land if he had the same cards as the rest of the top half of the Premier league.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Oct 23 1.11pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

None of this is a massive surprise - Roy playing his old favourites, Palace struggling against the top teams, injuries when we gambled on not having many, no progress on the new stand. We’ll get by this season as there are v poor teams below us, but next season’s looking like a perfect storm approaching.

Ha, this is said every season, and then we end up on average around 12th place. This is why I mention Groundhog Day, we've found our level and although Parish stands on his office desk and can reach the glass ceiling if he stretches enough he can't break through. Perhaps his main concern is getting the stand built and that will be his lasting legacy.
One day there'll be a surprise and we'll end up top six, or bottom three.

 

Page 7 of 10 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Spurs match thread