This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It’s not up to the member of any group to decide if they have been harmed. It’s up to the Police and, ultimately, the courts to decide, and there is a pretty high bar. The government isn’t using the law to do anything. They make the law and then the regular processes take over to administer it. You cannot be harmed by words alone. It’s the intent behind them that cause the harm. You can be threatened and intimidated by hate speech, and others encouraged to do harm. The assessment is made not on the words, but on the intent. See JK Rowling. Policing this shouldn’t demand a lot of Police resources but if it does then any complaints need to go to the government for increasing workload without providing resources, if other areas suffer. The Police will do what they have to do. I suppose the reference to the same protected groups being the perpetrators of crime is a dig at immigrants. Firstly, they aren’t protected. Secondly, it’s a statistical fact that the level of criminality among the immigrant community as a whole is lower than among those born here. The true state of the UK is known, it’s in a mess. That though has nothing to do with these ideas. Brexit, the pandemic and Putin alongside the stupidity of PMs like Johnson and Truss are the causes. “You cannot be harmed by words alone. It’s the intent behind them that cause the harm.”
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Ah the overly verbose partisan conservative at it again This reaction is simply a lazy pile on after postage stamp cross gate. If any of you had bothered to look at various countries Olympic apparel (winter and summer) over the last 20 years you’d see a wide range of variation year on year, veering from conformist to abstract and everything in between. Some staying faithful to traditional elements and colours, some not. In other words - this constant reinvention is nothing new, has been happening for quite some time, and in an increasingly commercial and brand/merch driven world absolutely essential to drive revenue. You all seem to have completely forgotten the 2012 Team GB branding, which veered between white light blue, purple and dark blue to red, crimson and white depending on application. Check out the recent Winter Olympics kits as well, while you’re at it. All sports technical wear and beyond has long departed from the ‘put a flag on it and do that every year’. These items have to appeal to the casual wearer as a semi-fashion item as well as being marketable and brand distinctive. It’s a commercial cycle. Nationalism takes a back seat to brand these days. Traditional > reinvention then back round again. Ideological storm in a teacup. Well said! It’s what I have been pointing out for a couple of days, but without any apparent recognition that this is a manufactured situation. Let’s see if your analysis does.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It’s not up to the member of any group to decide if they have been harmed. It’s up to the Police and, ultimately, the courts to decide, and there is a pretty high bar. The government isn’t using the law to do anything. They make the law and then the regular processes take over to administer it. You cannot be harmed by words alone. It’s the intent behind them that cause the harm. You can be threatened and intimidated by hate speech, and others encouraged to do harm. The assessment is made not on the words, but on the intent. See JK Rowling. Policing this shouldn’t demand a lot of Police resources but if it does then any complaints need to go to the government for increasing workload without providing resources, if other areas suffer. The Police will do what they have to do. I suppose the reference to the same protected groups being the perpetrators of crime is a dig at immigrants. Firstly, they aren’t protected. Secondly, it’s a statistical fact that the level of criminality among the immigrant community as a whole is lower than among those born here. The true state of the UK is known, it’s in a mess. That though has nothing to do with these ideas. Brexit, the pandemic and Putin alongside the stupidity of PMs like Johnson and Truss are the causes. This is wrong as regards Scotland where the police have said a hate crime is: Any crime which is perceived by the victim or any other person as motivated (wholly or partly) by malice or ill will toward a social group. They have also pledged to investigate every report of claimed hate crime.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
“You cannot be harmed by words alone. It’s the intent behind them that cause the harm.” Don’t ask me! I wasn’t responsible for looking at those incidents and deciding whether any had broken the law and/or whether a warning was sufficient.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It’s not up to the member of any group to decide if they have been harmed. It’s up to the Police and, ultimately, the courts to decide, and there is a pretty high bar. The government isn’t using the law to do anything. They make the law and then the regular processes take over to administer it. You cannot be harmed by words alone. It’s the intent behind them that cause the harm. You can be threatened and intimidated by hate speech, and others encouraged to do harm. The assessment is made not on the words, but on the intent. See JK Rowling. Policing this shouldn’t demand a lot of Police resources but if it does then any complaints need to go to the government for increasing workload without providing resources, if other areas suffer. The Police will do what they have to do. I suppose the reference to the same protected groups being the perpetrators of crime is a dig at immigrants. Firstly, they aren’t protected. Secondly, it’s a statistical fact that the level of criminality among the immigrant community as a whole is lower than among those born here. The true state of the UK is known, it’s in a mess. That though has nothing to do with these ideas. Brexit, the pandemic and Putin alongside the stupidity of PMs like Johnson and Truss are the causes. Yes, and the Socialist Constitution of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea states that: "All North Korean citizens have equal rights. Citizens have the right to elect and be elected (Article 66), freedom of speech, the press, assembly, demonstration and association (Article 67), freedom of religious belief (Article 6 There are similar claims in the EU constitution that the EU is democratic.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That seems semantics to me. It’s still necessary for the intentions to be likely. All it does is lower the burden of proof a little. From beyond all reasonable doubt to more likely than not. I don’t think the UK government are happy with it so won’t be following suit. It's not semantics. It's the law. And includes anything you might say in your own home. Lowering the burden of proof a little can end someone up with a 7 year sentence.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
This is wrong as regards Scotland where the police have said a hate crime is: Any crime which is perceived by the victim or any other person as motivated (wholly or partly) by malice or ill will toward a social group. They have also pledged to investigate every report of claimed hate crime. Is the second paragraph a quote or your own interpretation? Assuming it’s a quote, what’s the difference between “motivation” and “intent” in this context? Assuring every complaint will be investigated is good PR but what does it mean? Logging them and observing patterns seems most likely to me, with action once a discernible trend is seen.,
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It’s not up to the member of any group to decide if they have been harmed. It’s up to the Police and, ultimately, the courts to decide, and there is a pretty high bar. The government isn’t using the law to do anything. They make the law and then the regular processes take over to administer it. You cannot be harmed by words alone. It’s the intent behind them that cause the harm. You can be threatened and intimidated by hate speech, and others encouraged to do harm. The assessment is made not on the words, but on the intent. See JK Rowling. Policing this shouldn’t demand a lot of Police resources but if it does then any complaints need to go to the government for increasing workload without providing resources, if other areas suffer. The Police will do what they have to do. I suppose the reference to the same protected groups being the perpetrators of crime is a dig at immigrants. Firstly, they aren’t protected. Secondly, it’s a statistical fact that the level of criminality among the immigrant community as a whole is lower than among those born here. The true state of the UK is known, it’s in a mess. That though has nothing to do with these ideas. Brexit, the pandemic and Putin alongside the stupidity of PMs like Johnson and Truss are the causes. That's what you say, predictably. So to sum up. You think there is no control element to these laws. I would have to ask if there is anything you wouldn't deny in order to keep believing in your ideological fantasy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
It's not semantics. It's the law. And includes anything you might say in your own home. Lowering the burden of proof a little can end someone up with a 7 year sentence. Including what you say at home does seem a step too far to me, but I doubt it will ever be used, other than in very exceptional circumstances. You will still have to be found to have been motivated by hate, which means you had those intentions. Yes, the burden of proof has been lowered but everyone has the opportunity to defend themselves and explain what their motives were, if not hatred. I don’t think the truly innocent have too much to fear, whilst the racists and hate mongers do.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Including what you say at home does seem a step too far to me, but I doubt it will ever be used, other than in very exceptional circumstances. You will still have to be found to have been motivated by hate, which means you had those intentions. Yes, the burden of proof has been lowered but everyone has the opportunity to defend themselves and explain what their motives were, if not hatred. I don’t think the truly innocent have too much to fear, whilst the racists and hate mongers do. Sounds like something Hitler might have said.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Is the second paragraph a quote or your own interpretation? Assuming it’s a quote, what’s the difference between “motivation” and “intent” in this context? Assuring every complaint will be investigated is good PR but what does it mean? Logging them and observing patterns seems most likely to me, with action once a discernible trend is seen., It's a quote from Police Scotland whose pledge is to investigate every report. Not some. All.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Including what you say at home does seem a step too far to me, but I doubt it will ever be used, other than in very exceptional circumstances. You will still have to be found to have been motivated by hate, which means you had those intentions. Yes, the burden of proof has been lowered but everyone has the opportunity to defend themselves and explain what their motives were, if not hatred. I don’t think the truly innocent have too much to fear, whilst the racists and hate mongers do. On what grounds do you doubt it?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That's what you say, predictably. So to sum up. You think there is no control element to these laws. I would have to ask if there is anything you wouldn't deny in order to keep believing in your ideological fantasy. The summing up is wrong from start to finish. Of course there is a control element, as there is in every law. However, how the law is administered is not the responsibility of government. Of course there are some groups now being given extra recognition and consequential protection. Just not all the groups which are frequently targeted here. Especially immigrants. Immigrants, as a whole, are not responsible for any explosion of street crime. There is nothing fanciful in telling the truth and calling out misinformation.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You need to understand the difference between the styling of a sports kit and the national flag. It cannot be that difficult to understand surely. The reaction could have something to do with the fact that the country seems to be being undermined from all directions right now. That might make even the least nation proud individual a little sensitive. Again, have you actually been looking at the various Olympic kits for the last 20 odd years? Again, 2012. You’re absolutely right though. Both instances being discussed in this thread are styling on a sports kit, both instances are using artistic imagination, and both instances are very much not the Union Jack or the St George’s flag. As you say, it is either the national flag or it is not. In both instances, it is not. It ceases to be so the moment it deviates from the accepted pure form of it. They’re abstract interpretations deliberately referencing the actual flags to create something marketable, distinctive, with visual links to the national flag without being the national flag, and designed to be relatively unique (compared to previous kits). No one is going to buy this years kit if it that looks the same as the last one. See football kits. Do I think it’s cynical marketing to make as much money as possible by creating a design system that can be applied to pretty much everything saleable from plush toys to pencil sharpeners? Sure. Is it wokeism? No. The fashion world has been merging with the sports world for years - leading to more and more ‘designer’ approaches that increasingly discard the norms in search of distinctiveness and marketability. These are both excellent examples. Again you could argue 2012 accelerated this trend. The actual flag will be present on the team GB kits, as a patch on the arm. In the case of the ingerlund kits - the three lions, the actual official English crest of the national team, will also be present. The abstract postage stamp on the back references the flag as a piece of styling on a sports kit, but is not the flag. As I said, ideological storm in a teacup. Edited by SW19 CPFC (04 Apr 2024 10.30pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Again, have you actually been looking at the various Olympic kits for the last 20 odd years? Again, 2012. You’re absolutely right though. Both instances being discussed in this thread are styling on a sports kit, both instances are using artistic imagination, and both instances are very much not the Union Jack or the St George’s flag. As you say, it is either the national flag or it is not. In both instances, it is not. It ceases to be so the moment it deviates from the accepted pure form of it. They’re abstract interpretations deliberately referencing the actual flags to create something marketable, distinctive, with visual links to the national flag without being the national flag, and designed to be relatively unique (compared to previous kits).no The fashion world has been merging with the sports world for years - leading to more and more ‘designer’ approaches that increasingly discard the norms in search of distinctiveness and marketability. These are both excellent examples. Again you could argue 2012 started this trend. The actual flag will be present on the team GB kits, as a patch on the arm. In the case of the ingerlund kits - the three lions, the actual official English crest of the national team, will also be present. The abstract postage stamp on the back references the flag as a piece of styling on a sports kit, but is not the flag. As I said, ideological storm in a teacup. If The Olympic team have a Union Jack on their kit, then everyone will be happy (Almost everyone). The actual design of the kit in terms of colours and shapes is not in question. That is just a matter of taste. I think we can call that agreement.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
It's a quote from Police Scotland whose pledge is to investigate every report. Not some. All. That cannot be true. No one could be charged, let alone found guilty, on the say so of someone else. A trained police office must surely determine whether the perception is justified and the COPFS whether a prosecution is both required and would succeed. So I think they must assess intent. If not frivolous charges would soon swamp the courts.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The summing up is wrong from start to finish. Of course there is a control element, as there is in every law. However, how the law is administered is not the responsibility of government. Of course there are some groups now being given extra recognition and consequential protection. Just not all the groups which are frequently targeted here. Especially immigrants. Immigrants, as a whole, are not responsible for any explosion of street crime. There is nothing fanciful in telling the truth and calling out misinformation. OK, so you accept that the law is being used to control the population and not just to protect certain groups. One group who is not protected by these laws are White people, unless they happen to be in a minority group themselves. That can only be described as discriminatory. It is a statistical fact that a huge disproportion of street crime and violent crime in general is committed by minorities. There is a direct relationship between the rise in immigration and crime. You only have to line up the graphs to see that for yourself. As if you really need to. I'm off to bed now, so I will bid you good night. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Apr 2024 10.40pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
If The Olympic team have a Union Jack on their kit, then everyone will be happy (Almost everyone). The actual design of the kit in terms of colours and shapes is not in question. That is just a matter of taste. I think we can call that agreement. If I can jump in and reassure you. The Olympic team have already stated, in response to this story, that their kit includes the Union Flag in traditional colours, as usual. It’s only some merchandise which has been “designed “ with a different colour scheme, as has often been done in the past.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
OK, so you accept that the law is being used to control the population and not just to protect certain groups. One group who is not protected by these laws are White people, unless they happen to be in a minority group themselves. That can only be described as discriminatory. It is a statistical fact that a huge disproportion of street crime and violent crime in general is committed by minorities. There is a direct relationship between the rise in immigration and crime. You only have to line up the graphs to see that for yourself. As if you really need to. I'm off to bed now, so I will bid you good night. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Apr 2024 10.40pm) No, it’s not to “control the population”! Like any law it’s aimed at a restricted number of people and in this case to restrain offensive behaviour. I won’t go down the “white” rabbit hole again, other that to say that as such a group cannot exist it could not be protected, even if it was considered necessary. Which it isn’t. Panorama the other night laid to rest the myth of immigration being the cause of crime. I suggest everyone watches it. Most immigrants, those working in the health and care sectors or studying, are much less likely to be involved in crime than the average Brit.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.