This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
TBF Islam along with the East had a far bigger role to play in our evolution into a ‘civilised’ world than most western education portrays All that said I’m pretty sure we learnt about the Barbary trade at school. Maybe an anomaly Propaganda works both ways. You can find an angle here and find an equivalent there Essentially every culture or civilisation was built upon the slave trade in some form or another, and really it simply depends on what area of the world you’re in as to the demographic that it affects the most. Ultimately, it’s important to always be prepared to challenge history, rather than just accept it or dismiss it as ‘back in the day’. It’s not as simplistic as this, but there is an element of reap what you sow going on. I’m not condoning the more extreme ends of it, or the lack of balance in how it’s been portrayed in some cases, but ultimately it comes down to what it always comes down to - how recent is the memory? How deep do the scars run? Are they a shared cultural pain, passed on for generations? Tick all those boxes and increase minority demographics and your karma is here. I suppose what I’m saying is you can’t just dismiss this, brush it off or play the ‘it happened ages ago’ card. But at the same time you can’t hold people of the ‘now’ accountable for past actions. But you can test them once in a while to see if they’ve learnt from the mistakes of the past - and quarrel with bronzed up idols being celebrated in a square rather than taught about and viewed in a more balanced way. I have no idea where the line is, but some of ‘our’ cultural icons should be reappraised, or at the very least exposed to create healthy debate about our previously held, perhaps ignorant views about them. And why not? Anything else is simply rewriting history for the sake of avoiding the debate. Should every statue be pulled down? No. Should we decide to have a long hard think about our actual history? The one that unobjectively lays bare the truth rather than hides it through western flavoured teachings? I’m more interested in that version, please. The actual facts rather than what really can be equated to religious teachings (all countries and cultures are guilty of this of course, but it really annoys me when people don’t even think to challenge what they’ve been taught). To challenge history in that was it true or was what happened right or wrong. Every, or at least non pedantic person or person benefiting right now would say slavery was wrong; modern day slavery as well. That hasnt even been given a chance of a discussion by blm though from what I see. The assumption seems to be that whitey liked it and agrees with it even in the now. These statues and street names etc are discussion pieces and after sensible discussion the consensus may well be to re locate them out of sight but not in a harbour for example. I sort of get the argument in some cases but to just make a unilateral decision looks like my way or no way or we are rioting. Not really going to help the cause or get the issues about it on the table imo.
|
|
|
So even a plaque explaining the artwork isn’t enough. I would like to know how many complaints have been received.
|
|
|
So all we need this weekend is a terrorists attack and we have a full house
|
|
|
So now we know
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
So even a plaque explaining the artwork isn’t enough. I would like to know how many complaints have been received. I gave up on the National Trust after they banned "Easter" and outed the deceased owner of one of their houses who according to family and friends never wanted that. The National Trust volunteers are good people who care about our heritage and environment unfortunately the management is now "lefty HQ" and more interested in politics which is why many volunteers have left.
One more point |
|
|
Oh, so if you have another view your a toxic blowhard.
|
|
|
Disgraceful. If ever something is designed to widen the gap then this is it. Reads like they want a war, not remove racism.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
TBF Islam along with the East had a far bigger role to play in our evolution into a ‘civilised’ world than most western education portrays Propaganda works both ways. You can find an angle here and find an equivalent there Essentially every culture or civilisation was built upon the slave trade in some form or another, and really it simply depends on what area of the world you’re in as to the demographic that it affects the most. Ultimately, it’s important to always be prepared to challenge history, rather than just accept it or dismiss it as ‘back in the day’. It’s not as simplistic as this, but there is an element of reap what you sow going on. I’m not condoning the more extreme ends of it, or the lack of balance in how it’s been portrayed in some cases, but ultimately it comes down to what it always comes down to - how recent is the memory? How deep do the scars run? Are they a shared cultural pain, passed on for generations? Tick all those boxes and increase minority demographics and your karma is here. I suppose what I’m saying is you can’t just dismiss this, brush it off or play the ‘it happened ages ago’ card. But at the same time you can’t hold people of the ‘now’ accountable for past actions. But you can test them once in a while to see if they’ve learnt from the mistakes of the past - and quarrel with bronzed up idols being celebrated in a square rather than taught about and viewed in a more balanced way. I have no idea where the line is, but some of ‘our’ cultural icons should be reappraised, or at the very least exposed to create healthy debate about our previously held, perhaps ignorant views about them. And why not? Anything else is simply rewriting history for the sake of avoiding the debate. Should every statue be pulled down? No. Should we decide to have a long hard think about our actual history? The one that unobjectively lays bare the truth rather than hides it through western flavoured teachings? I’m more interested in that version, please. The actual facts rather than what really can be equated to religious teachings (all countries and cultures are guilty of this of course, but it really annoys me when people don’t even think to challenge what they’ve been taught). True, but that was before it banned books and regressed. I'm not sure this is about whether certain figures are worthy of statues but if those in authority should be pandering to irrational thinking. History cannot be undone. Removing statues is not a decision for an angry mob. It should be decided democratically either via parliament or by referendum.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dannyboy1978
Who is "we"? From your point of view, god knows. Not sure I want to know From mine, everyone. The royal we. It should be a democratic process. History should constantly be reappraised, reexamined and challenged by those in the present. But a rational ‘everyone’. Not the lunatic fringe from the left, right, centre, BLM or FLA. That said, people have a right to protest - and often a reason. If others don’t listen, dismiss or belittle or at least take time to acknowledge, things often continue to escalate. Standard pattern. It’s not like any of this is going to get solved anytime soon by rational thought
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I found this piece interesting as it introduced a new perspective on these issues and as a consequence is thought provoking :- What this shows is that when you throw a whole load of races, creeds and religions together, they don't get on. What a shocker. A pity the idiot politicians of this country didn't get their faces out of the trough and learn a lesson from America. Humans create division. It is what they do.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dannyboy1978
Oh, so if you have another view your a toxic blowhard. Never listened to it. Best approach would be for people to do the same. Presumably they have advertising, if no-one listens advertisers will withdraw funding... simples.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
What this shows is that when you throw a whole load of races, creeds and religions together, they don't get on. What a shocker. A pity the idiot politicians of this country didn't get their faces out of the trough and learn a lesson from America. Humans create division. It is what they do. No, it doesn't. I suggest you re-read it. It's not what happened in the USA. Races, creeds and religions weren't "thrown together". Most were obliterated and their cultural roots destroyed. People were given entirely new and false identities which categorised them as sub-human. It is this which has resulted in the chaos of today and is absolutely the wrong model to be imitated here. The comparison with the way Germany has handled Nazism is particularly telling I think. Identifying the fact that Trump has magnified the problem after Obama had begun to ameliorate it is also interesting.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
No, it doesn't. I suggest you re-read it. It's not what happened in the USA. Races, creeds and religions weren't "thrown together". Most were obliterated and their cultural roots destroyed. People were given entirely new and false identities which categorised them as sub-human. It is this which has resulted in the chaos of today and is absolutely the wrong model to be imitated here. The comparison with the way Germany has handled Nazism is particularly telling I think. Identifying the fact that Trump has magnified the problem after Obama had begun to ameliorate it is also interesting. It's interesting though that the countries with multi cultural populations tend to be the most racist. Apparently. What does that tell you?
|
|
|
Originally posted by dannyboy1978
It's interesting though that the countries with multi cultural populations tend to be the most racist. Apparently. What does that tell you? Apparently. Apart from Eastern Europe.
COYP |
|
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
No, it doesn't. I suggest you re-read it. It's not what happened in the USA. Races, creeds and religions weren't "thrown together". Most were obliterated and their cultural roots destroyed. People were given entirely new and false identities which categorised them as sub-human. It is this which has resulted in the chaos of today and is absolutely the wrong model to be imitated here. The comparison with the way Germany has handled Nazism is particularly telling I think. Identifying the fact that Trump has magnified the problem after Obama had begun to ameliorate it is also interesting. Abuse removed. Any further abuse and you’re gone from this site. - Guntrisoft. Edited by Guntrisoft (13 Jun 2020 10.20am)
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
No, it doesn't. I suggest you re-read it. It's not what happened in the USA. Races, creeds and religions weren't "thrown together". Most were obliterated and their cultural roots destroyed. People were given entirely new and false identities which categorised them as sub-human. It is this which has resulted in the chaos of today and is absolutely the wrong model to be imitated here. The comparison with the way Germany has handled Nazism is particularly telling I think. Identifying the fact that Trump has magnified the problem after Obama had begun to ameliorate it is also interesting. I have visited the US every year since 2003 and have some good friends there. Believe me Obama wasn’t as popular as you would like to believe. Many people couldn’t wait to see the back of him. Possibly was only elected because of his colour, who knows? The Trump obsession is Alice and kicking I see Edited by Spiderman (13 Jun 2020 10.27am)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.