This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I also agree we've contributed, we must have but it's the degrees our input has affected climate change. That's where the study should be. Not an all in its all us. The earth is constantly evolving and with evolution there are changes. It will and has adapted to our input and will still be the green and pleasant land it is now, many millenia after we've gone. The green revolution should happen but as a natural thing, not as a forced thing in a few years. Whose to say the earth and its environment hasn't adapted to our input in whichever amount it is and like an alcoholic or a drug addict it needs weaning off over a period of time, not overnight. That could infact make our climate a lot worse. Yeah this is mainly complete bollocks according to scientific consensus, and on that point I quite logically trust the scientific community more than partisan hacks. Ultimately whether we are having a significant effect or not on one area of the debate (climate change) is a moot point. Belching out trillions and trillions of pollutants, plastics and forever chemicals into the environment is quite obviously not a good thing, or something that can simply be waved away. The sooner we move away from that model of living to a more sustainable, and then ideally regenerative one the better. Your point on adaptation is also too general - the earth will always adapt, but the outcome of that adaptation is not positive by default, which you are insinuating, somehow. Also your point re, ‘it will always be…’ is laughable - simply, it won’t. Potentially if you just said to hell with it all and took an 80s/90s mindset and raped the whole thing until it died, including us, yeah, it might eventually produce a new wave of animal and plant species in a few million years. But it certainly wouldn’t ‘still be the green and pleasant land it is now*’ *try pre industrial era. Was.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You seem to be missing the point. Trump couldn't point anything out. No-one knew then, and they still don't. He used the speculation and amplified it from being a theoretical possibility to being the probable cause. The outbreak started in China. Whether the virus originated there remains unknown and is possibly unknowable. China does suppress the truth, but when they don't know the truth either, then they have nothing to suppress. Other theories, which by the way I also dismiss as highly unlikely, suggest the virus was planted in China by the USA to discredit it. This makes no sense. How can it be “a theoretical possibility” when “the outbreak started in China”?
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Yeah this is mainly complete bollocks according to scientific consensus, and on that point I quite logically trust the scientific community more than partisan hacks. Ultimately whether we are having a significant effect or not on one area of the debate (climate change) is a moot point. Belching out trillions and trillions of pollutants, plastics and forever chemicals into the environment is quite obviously not a good thing, or something that can simply be waved away. The sooner we move away from that model of living to a more sustainable, and then ideally regenerative one the better. Your point on adaptation is also too general - the earth will always adapt, but the outcome of that adaptation is not positive by default, which you are insinuating, somehow. Also your point re, ‘it will always be…’ is laughable - simply, it won’t. Potentially if you just said to hell with it all and took an 80s/90s mindset and raped the whole thing until it died, including us, yeah, it might eventually produce a new wave of animal and plant species in a few million years. But it certainly wouldn’t ‘still be the green and pleasant land it is now*’ *try pre industrial era. Was. OK so what comparison in net carbon emission is there between say the last 40 years and the 100 before then.
|
|
|
Thank you for your reply. It doesn't matter what mankind does, the Earth and nature will naturally produce events that change the climate. What I object to is the control that the climate lobby want to place on the rest of us, be that extra taxes, not eating meat, not driving, not going on holiday etc. I believe Extinction Rebellion say that we are in either the 4th or 5th extinction event; all the previous ones occurred before man existed. Hence nature has a way of killing species off 'naturally' by tilts, volcanoes, meteors and whatever. I have no problem with a incentivised move to greener technology (I have solar panels on my roof, have a solar powered watch and have an electric car in the pipeline)...but that is my choice. I don't want to be forced by some movement to do those things. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
This is bs, pure and simple. Not the research into tilting, but your conclusions. There will be future ice ages, but they won't arrive in a century, but over thousands of years. By the time the next arrives, mankind will either have destroyed itself or decamped to another planet. We can safely leave the worries about that to future generations. As I have said here before, I had the privilege of knowing one of the UK's leading climate scientists on a personal level a few years ago. She knew the truth, and I knew her. She told the truth. It's real, I would bet my life on it. All of the natural causes have been factored in, but the evidence for man made warming, since the industrial revolution, makes this a fact and not a theory. That some now spin conspiracy theories of the type you offer is, I suppose, inevitable in today's world. As only the gullible believe them, it's a little ironic you think everyone else is.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
This makes no sense. How can it be “a theoretical possibility” when “the outbreak started in China”? Because the "theoretical possibility" is the "escape from the lab" hypothesis that Trump exploited for his own ends. Not where the first cases were seen.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Thank you for your reply. It doesn't matter what mankind does, the Earth and nature will naturally produce events that change the climate. What I object to is the control that the climate lobby want to place on the rest of us, be that extra taxes, not eating meat, not driving, not going on holiday etc. I believe Extinction Rebellion say that we are in either the 4th or 5th extinction event; all the previous ones occurred before man existed. Hence nature has a way of killing species off 'naturally' by tilts, volcanoes, meteors and whatever. I have no problem with a incentivised move to greener technology (I have solar panels on my roof, have a solar powered watch and have an electric car in the pipeline)...but that is my choice. I don't want to be forced by some movement to do those things. Whilst natural climate change is obviously a fact, it occurs slowly. How we will have to adjust to it in the future is important, but unknown. Whether we can moderate it, mitigate its impact, or just have to live elsewhere and differently is for tomorrow. Man-made change is relative recent and rapid. We do have the means to control it. All the forecasts indicate this is an urgent problem, requiring co-ordinated, co-operative action. It simply cannot just be left to the winds of chance and the goodwill of individuals. Incentives and, if needed, compulsion, are required. Not because BIG BROTHER wants to control your life but because your life, and those of your children and grand children, matter and are worth saving. This is an issue in which collective action is required, and we all need to accept that. Libertarianism does not serve us well for this kind of problem.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Whilst natural climate change is obviously a fact, it occurs slowly. How we will have to adjust to it in the future is important, but unknown. Whether we can moderate it, mitigate its impact, or just have to live elsewhere and differently is for tomorrow. Man-made change is relative recent and rapid. We do have the means to control it. All the forecasts indicate this is an urgent problem, requiring co-ordinated, co-operative action. It simply cannot just be left to the winds of chance and the goodwill of individuals. Incentives and, if needed, compulsion, are required. Not because BIG BROTHER wants to control your life but because your life, and those of your children and grand children, matter and are worth saving. This is an issue in which collective action is required, and we all need to accept that. Libertarianism does not serve us well for this kind of problem. So basically we have to do what the scientists tell us today. All scientific theory is gospel until another scientist disproves or amends it, and then that scientific theory becomes gospel (e.g. Newton and Einstein). My remark re climate change being used as control is confirmed by your comments...in days past YOU would burn in hell if you didn't do the right thing, now if you don't follow the script, YOU, YOUR CHILDREN AND GRANDCHILDREN will burn on Earth. Fear of the unknown being used to control. Now, you and your scientist friend may well be right; I can accept that is possible, maybe even probable, but I'm not going to beat myself up over it. Take single use plastic bags...if they are so bad, ban them. Make us go back to using paper bags. Same with plastic bottles, go back to returnable glass ones..but that wouldn't raise 10p per use towards whatever the money is used for.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
So basically we have to do what the scientists tell us today. All scientific theory is gospel until another scientist disproves or amends it, and then that scientific theory becomes gospel (e.g. Newton and Einstein). My remark re climate change being used as control is confirmed by your comments...in days past YOU would burn in hell if you didn't do the right thing, now if you don't follow the script, YOU, YOUR CHILDREN AND GRANDCHILDREN will burn on Earth. Fear of the unknown being used to control. Now, you and your scientist friend may well be right; I can accept that is possible, maybe even probable, but I'm not going to beat myself up over it. Take single use plastic bags...if they are so bad, ban them. Make us go back to using paper bags. Same with plastic bottles, go back to returnable glass ones..but that wouldn't raise 10p per use towards whatever the money is used for. Today's science is rather more precise than in the past, especially in this area, with research groups all over the world reaching broadly similar conclusions. Their view is that man made climate change is no longer a hypothesis, but a fact. Facts don't get disproved. New facts can add knowledge, but the underlying truth won't disappear. So this isn't "fear of the unknown" being used to control you. It's knowledge being used to protect you, even if you are reluctant to accept the need. Why not ban things? Best ask the behavioural scientists that question, but I guess the view is that a better result is obtained with co-operation than with coercion. I doubt whether the 10p makes any difference in the overall costs involved, so won't be the motivating factor.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
So basically we have to do what the scientists tell us today. All scientific theory is gospel until another scientist disproves or amends it, and then that scientific theory becomes gospel (e.g. Newton and Einstein). My remark re climate change being used as control is confirmed by your comments...in days past YOU would burn in hell if you didn't do the right thing, now if you don't follow the script, YOU, YOUR CHILDREN AND GRANDCHILDREN will burn on Earth. Fear of the unknown being used to control. Now, you and your scientist friend may well be right; I can accept that is possible, maybe even probable, but I'm not going to beat myself up over it. Take single use plastic bags...if they are so bad, ban them. Make us go back to using paper bags. Same with plastic bottles, go back to returnable glass ones..but that wouldn't raise 10p per use towards whatever the money is used for. I applaud you for recognising the powers that be controlling us through fear.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Because the "theoretical possibility" is the "escape from the lab" hypothesis that Trump exploited for his own ends. Not where the first cases were seen. This supposed exploitation is pure speculation. Where’s the evidence let alone the proof?
|
|
|
If things are so bad, they should be banned. 10p may not be much on it's own but multiply that out by the number of plastic bags dished out and it becomes a useful amount. It was 5p when it was first introduced, so the slippery slope of acceptance is already there. With knowledge comes power...said by Bacon and used by Thomas Jefferson. That is where my concern is. Half of me wants to be wrong and in twenty years time we're all living in a stable climate that everybody is in love with. But then Yellowstone erupts and all my efforts are laughed at by nature! Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Today's science is rather more precise than in the past, especially in this area, with research groups all over the world reaching broadly similar conclusions. Their view is that man made climate change is no longer a hypothesis, but a fact. Facts don't get disproved. New facts can add knowledge, but the underlying truth won't disappear. So this isn't "fear of the unknown" being used to control you. It's knowledge being used to protect you, even if you are reluctant to accept the need. Why not ban things? Best ask the behavioural scientists that question, but I guess the view is that a better result is obtained with co-operation than with coercion. I doubt whether the 10p makes any difference in the overall costs involved, so won't be the motivating factor.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
If things are so bad, they should be banned. 10p may not be much on it's own but multiply that out by the number of plastic bags dished out and it becomes a useful amount. It was 5p when it was first introduced, so the slippery slope of acceptance is already there. With knowledge comes power...said by Bacon and used by Thomas Jefferson. That is where my concern is. Half of me wants to be wrong and in twenty years time we're all living in a stable climate that everybody is in love with. But then Yellowstone erupts and all my efforts are laughed at by nature! The big question is: will we be out of lockdown by then?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Yes, because of the timing and motivation. When Trump made the claim it was just speculation which he then exploited to divert attention from the criticism of his weak response. He politicised the pandemic by describing it as the"China virus". The WHO are not now saying that this was what happened, but that the possibility ought not be so firmly discounted as they first did. Totally different. One deserves support. The other condemnation. Within a week of of the virus going public a university in beijing had concluded that the virus had most likely come from the wuhan lab, the crux of their findings was the species of bat responsible were not native to wuhan but another region the other side of china. This was public knowledge and the news was broken by Tucker Carlson on his show, it fell on death ears because Trump.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
This supposed exploitation is pure speculation. Where’s the evidence let alone the proof? It's far from speculation. You only had to observe Trump's behaviour last year to witness it for yourself. No need for the filters of TV reporters or other opinions. It was there in plain view. Maybe you didn't follow him quite as avidly as I did! Someone in the US intelligence community raised this idea as a possibility. Trump was being castigated at the time for his lack of action and jumped all over it. It then became the "China Virus", which was at best a careless release and at worse, a deliberate one. It was typical Trump. Never apologise. Never accept blame. Accuse others of that you have done yourself. He learned this from Roy Cohn and sticks to it even today. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (21 Jul 2021 3.32pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
Within a week of of the virus going public a university in beijing had concluded that the virus had most likely come from the wuhan lab, the crux of their findings was the species of bat responsible were not native to wuhan but another region the other side of china. This was public knowledge and the news was broken by Tucker Carlson on his show, it fell on death ears because Trump. There was a great deal of speculation and theories at the time. Some plausible, others not, but none proved. Which remains the case. People like Tucker Carson ought never be allowed behind a microphone. He might claim it was "news" but it's about as reliable as something from Alex Jones. OK, perhaps not quite as bad, but you get the point. Tucker Carson has always been a sycophantic apologist for Trump. People like him did his PR. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (21 Jul 2021 3.39pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There was a great deal of speculation and theories at the time. Some plausible, others not, but none proved. Which remains the case. People like Tucker Carson ought never be allowed behind a microphone. He might claim it was "news" but it's about as reliable as something from Alex Jones. OK, perhaps not quite as bad, but you get the point. Tucker Carson has always been a sycophantic apologist for Trump. People like him did his PR. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (21 Jul 2021 3.39pm) And yet this scientific investigation conducted by this chinese university exists irrespective of who broke the news. The findings were ignored/buried, this is an indisputible fact.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It's far from speculation. You only had to observe Trump's behaviour last year to witness it for yourself. No need for the filters of TV reporters or other opinions. It was there in plain view. Maybe you didn't follow him quite as avidly as I did! Someone in the US intelligence community raised this idea as a possibility. Trump was being castigated at the time for his lack of action and jumped all over it. It then became the "China Virus", which was at best a careless release and at worse, a deliberate one. It was typical Trump. Never apologise. Never accept blame. Accuse others of that you have done yourself. He learned this from Roy Cohn and sticks to it even today. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (21 Jul 2021 3.32pm) Yes, pure speculation. No evidence beyond your own extrapolation. The virus started in China and he said so. The motives you are imputing are guesswork.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
And yet this scientific investigation conducted by this chinese university exists irrespective of who broke the news. The findings were ignored/buried, this is an indisputible fact. You are wasting your time. It is obvious that WE hatred of Trump outweighs any rational arguments.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
You are wasting your time. It is obvious that WE hatred of Trump outweighs any rational arguments. Like I said trump could cure cancer, eliminate world poverty, find the solution to perpetual motion, create world peace ( he was on his way in the middle east and Russia) and get 100% of the American vote and WE would still find a flaw.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.