You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > one less to blow us up
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

one less to blow us up


Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 18 Jun 15 4.42pm

Serial answer me this then.

In what religion in this country are you most at risk from radicalisation ?

Before you answer consider :

Although Jehovah’sitnesses are a pain in the arse, not a single one has knocked on my door, waited for me to answer and blew him self up all over my front gardenn, nor has the Bhuddist who lives next door, hacked my head off whilst I was off to the shops, even the mentalist catholic up the road decided not to set me on fire because I didnt agree with his sky fairy on gay marriage.

As I said right at the start it is purely and simply risk management.


Edited by dannyh (18 Jun 2015 4.45pm)

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

ghosteagle Flag 18 Jun 15 5.00pm

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 3.55pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 3.33pm

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 3.27pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 2.46pm

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 1.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 11.47am

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.57am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 10.49am

Turkey, among many listed above, are NOT Islamic countries, though they do have majority Muslim populations, Turkey for example is largely secularist (like pakistan, though both have increasing Islamist problems).

Having a large, or dominant Muslim population doesn't make you Islamic, anymore than having a large Catholic or Protestant population makes you a Christian Country (even the US has separation of Church and State).

I think that's a fair point Jamie, but in the context of the argument around whether Islam itself is somehow more inherently backward than other religions and beliefs, Turkey is a fairly good example of progressive Islam, be it on a population scale rather than a governmental one.

You can't really view Islam or Christainity as religions, because each comprises of a wide scope of different religions, including some very liberal and some very extremist sects (the difference between the Ismaili and Wabbi sects is very dramatic, as dramatic as the difference between the US Christian Right and the UK Quakers).

I wouldn't say any religion is more or less backwards, than the nation in which its active. You'll probably find that Catholics in the UK are more progressive than those of Uganda. Similarly Loyalists in Northern Ireland couldn't be much more different than Church of England Protestantism.

Religion tends to reflect the views and mores of the people practicing it, within a country, rather than the religion itself.



That's essentially what I'm trying to argue to Derben: no religion is inherently bad or good, the environmental and material circumstances within which it is practiced have a large impact on how scripture is accepted. Ahmadiyya Muslims, for example, who are particularly prominent in the UK which has been fairly stable, are far more liberal and tolerant than Wahabbists in Saudi Arabia, who have been subjected to wars and despots for hundreds of years.

As for not calling Christianity or Islam religions, I think that's a semantic issue. For me you can still identify them as religions, conforming to similar creeds, scriptures and historical perceptions, while also acknowledging the hundreds of sects within those wider networks. Certainly it's easier to homogenise Buddhism or Catholicism, with central divine authorities, than Islam, which makes up 1/4 of the world's population yet has no central institution.

This is getting absurd. There are hardly any (perhaps Turkey) Muslim countries that you could call democratic. The vast majority of them treat women as second class citizens. Many of them have the death penalty and other barbaric penalties for religious offences. Homosexuals are persecuted. Yet you describe them as 'wonderful'. Many too are anti-Semetic and generally hate the West. Just look at what is in front of your nose rather than filtering everything through your politically correct lens.


Malaysia have had free democratic votes for decades. Egypt have held democratic elections, as has Senegal and Tunisia. I would agree that most aren't fully democratic, but then I'd say the same for our parliament, where a party gaining nearly 4 million votes gets just 1 seat. Let's not forget too, that in the 2000 years of Christianity, democracy has only been incorporated in the past 300 or so, and continues to be lacking in many many Christian nations.

I think it's important to recognise what we're arguing here Derbs. You're attempting to argue that Islam is inherently morally inferior to other religions and cultures, and that this is epitomised in Muslim countries. All I'm trying to prove to you (and anyone who's still reading this) is that there is nothing inherently bad about Islam, that it can promote peace and tolerance just as easily as violence and oppression, in the same way that any belief can. That's why I'm offering these examples of Turkey, Malaysia etc - not because I see them as ideal societies - but because they directly negate the point you're trying to make, and challenge the widespread ignorance towards Islam that the majority of people in this country hold.

Egypt! That went well didn't it!

I don't think I am attempting to argue that Islam is inherently morally inferior to other religions and cultures. I am arguing that it is generally (note, generally) not democratic, misogynistic, intolerant, and vindictive.


So exactly like pretty much every belief system, from Christianity to Monarchism, in human history then?

Jainism?

 

derben Flag 18 Jun 15 5.02pm

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 3.55pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 3.33pm

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 3.27pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 2.46pm

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 1.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 11.47am

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.57am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 10.49am

Turkey, among many listed above, are NOT Islamic countries, though they do have majority Muslim populations, Turkey for example is largely secularist (like pakistan, though both have increasing Islamist problems).

Having a large, or dominant Muslim population doesn't make you Islamic, anymore than having a large Catholic or Protestant population makes you a Christian Country (even the US has separation of Church and State).

I think that's a fair point Jamie, but in the context of the argument around whether Islam itself is somehow more inherently backward than other religions and beliefs, Turkey is a fairly good example of progressive Islam, be it on a population scale rather than a governmental one.

You can't really view Islam or Christainity as religions, because each comprises of a wide scope of different religions, including some very liberal and some very extremist sects (the difference between the Ismaili and Wabbi sects is very dramatic, as dramatic as the difference between the US Christian Right and the UK Quakers).

I wouldn't say any religion is more or less backwards, than the nation in which its active. You'll probably find that Catholics in the UK are more progressive than those of Uganda. Similarly Loyalists in Northern Ireland couldn't be much more different than Church of England Protestantism.

Religion tends to reflect the views and mores of the people practicing it, within a country, rather than the religion itself.



That's essentially what I'm trying to argue to Derben: no religion is inherently bad or good, the environmental and material circumstances within which it is practiced have a large impact on how scripture is accepted. Ahmadiyya Muslims, for example, who are particularly prominent in the UK which has been fairly stable, are far more liberal and tolerant than Wahabbists in Saudi Arabia, who have been subjected to wars and despots for hundreds of years.

As for not calling Christianity or Islam religions, I think that's a semantic issue. For me you can still identify them as religions, conforming to similar creeds, scriptures and historical perceptions, while also acknowledging the hundreds of sects within those wider networks. Certainly it's easier to homogenise Buddhism or Catholicism, with central divine authorities, than Islam, which makes up 1/4 of the world's population yet has no central institution.

This is getting absurd. There are hardly any (perhaps Turkey) Muslim countries that you could call democratic. The vast majority of them treat women as second class citizens. Many of them have the death penalty and other barbaric penalties for religious offences. Homosexuals are persecuted. Yet you describe them as 'wonderful'. Many too are anti-Semetic and generally hate the West. Just look at what is in front of your nose rather than filtering everything through your politically correct lens.


Malaysia have had free democratic votes for decades. Egypt have held democratic elections, as has Senegal and Tunisia. I would agree that most aren't fully democratic, but then I'd say the same for our parliament, where a party gaining nearly 4 million votes gets just 1 seat. Let's not forget too, that in the 2000 years of Christianity, democracy has only been incorporated in the past 300 or so, and continues to be lacking in many many Christian nations.

I think it's important to recognise what we're arguing here Derbs. You're attempting to argue that Islam is inherently morally inferior to other religions and cultures, and that this is epitomised in Muslim countries. All I'm trying to prove to you (and anyone who's still reading this) is that there is nothing inherently bad about Islam, that it can promote peace and tolerance just as easily as violence and oppression, in the same way that any belief can. That's why I'm offering these examples of Turkey, Malaysia etc - not because I see them as ideal societies - but because they directly negate the point you're trying to make, and challenge the widespread ignorance towards Islam that the majority of people in this country hold.

Egypt! That went well didn't it!

I don't think I am attempting to argue that Islam is inherently morally inferior to other religions and cultures. I am arguing that it is generally (note, generally) not democratic, misogynistic, intolerant, and vindictive.


So exactly like pretty much every belief system, from Christianity to Monarchism, in human history then?

Taking the contemporary world situation, Islam is of magnitudes greater than Christianity in being non-democratic, misogynistic, intolerant, and vindictive - quite the opposite to your remarkable assertion that Islamic countries are "far more tolerant and inclusive than ours". Would the flogging of the woman in Indonesia (a country you have described as "wonderful"have happened in the UK?

While you are at it, perhaps you could explain how Islamic countries are "far more tolerant and inclusive than ours" on the issue of homosexuality?

Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 5.31pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 18 Jun 15 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)

 

ghosteagle Flag 18 Jun 15 7.42pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)


Damn you and your facts and reason, always getting in the way of the bigoted. I hope you're happy!

 

derben Flag 18 Jun 15 8.27pm

[Link]

 

johnfirewall Flag 18 Jun 15 8.29pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)

These are just examples of countries where Islam isn't the worst religion or the local religion ALSO promotes persecution.

 

derben Flag 18 Jun 15 8.53pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)

Have any of these countries executed anyone for being gay? Muslim countries have.

 

legaleagle Flag 18 Jun 15 9.05pm

Quote johnfirewall at 18 Jun 2015 8.29pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)

These are just examples of countries where Islam isn't the worst religion or the local religion ALSO promotes persecution.


Religion is responsible for repression and persecution in China and N Korea?

If you want to run an argument that history shows us that fundamentalist interpretations of a religion can be used to promote the basis of a repressive regime promoting persecution ,I wouldn't disagree.The relevant factor perhaps being slavish adherence to "fundamentalist" interpretations of a religion or using such "fundamentalist" interpretations as a cover for plain old common garden repressive regimes engaging in persecution.

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 9.51pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 18 Jun 15 9.32pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 8.53pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)

Have any of these countries executed anyone for being gay? Muslim countries have.

Uganda (c.85% Christian) only narrowly avoided having the death sentence for homosexuality put on the statute book in December 2013.Now,people who regularly engage in gay sex only face life imprisonment.The Church in Uganda supported this continuing criminalisation of gay sex.

In some of the "non muslim"examples I mentioned,like Argentina under the junta,I would be surprised if some people had not received the "death sentence",ie summary state-sanctioned execution by means of a bullet to the head for "offences" of a level objectively no less unoffensive than engaging in gay sex.

Some overseas might think it ludicrous for us having a life sentence, death penalty until 1998, on the statute book for having sex (gay or straight) with the sovereign's (the Defender of the Faith's) eldest unmarried daughter.


Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 9.51pm)

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 18 Jun 15 10.20pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Jun 2015 4.42pm

Serial answer me this then.

In what religion in this country are you most at risk from radicalisation ?

Before you answer consider :

Although Jehovah’sitnesses are a pain in the arse, not a single one has knocked on my door, waited for me to answer and blew him self up all over my front gardenn, nor has the Bhuddist who lives next door, hacked my head off whilst I was off to the shops, even the mentalist catholic up the road decided not to set me on fire because I didnt agree with his sky fairy on gay marriage.

As I said right at the start it is purely and simply risk management.


Edited by dannyh (18 Jun 2015 4.45pm)


First, I'll answer your question simply: Islam.

Second, how many Muslims do you know directly who have blown themselves up/hacked off their heads/set fire to you? This is the problem I was trying to explain to you Danny, you can accept that radical Islam is a problem AND not tar all Muslims with the same brush. Less than 0.1% of British Muslims have gone out to join IS, thus to make any assumptions on the faith in general is absolutely f*cking nuts.

Why are Muslims more impressionable to extremism? As I said, I don't know for certain, but my guess would be they see comments like yours, where there is an implicit conflation of all Muslims with their radical terrorist associates and they feel like this country doesn't accept them. Why aren't we focusing on the thousands of Muslims in this country who dedicate their lives to helping people, or the millions who give to charity?

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

derben Flag 18 Jun 15 10.26pm

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.20pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Jun 2015 4.42pm

Serial answer me this then.

In what religion in this country are you most at risk from radicalisation ?

Before you answer consider :

Although Jehovah’sitnesses are a pain in the arse, not a single one has knocked on my door, waited for me to answer and blew him self up all over my front gardenn, nor has the Bhuddist who lives next door, hacked my head off whilst I was off to the shops, even the mentalist catholic up the road decided not to set me on fire because I didnt agree with his sky fairy on gay marriage.

As I said right at the start it is purely and simply risk management.


Edited by dannyh (18 Jun 2015 4.45pm)


First, I'll answer your question simply: Islam.

Second, how many Muslims do you know directly who have blown themselves up/hacked off their heads/set fire to you? This is the problem I was trying to explain to you Danny, you can accept that radical Islam is a problem AND not tar all Muslims with the same brush. Less than 0.1% of British Muslims have gone out to join IS, thus to make any assumptions on the faith in general is absolutely f*cking nuts.

Why are Muslims more impressionable to extremism? As I said, I don't know for certain, but my guess would be they see comments like yours, where there is an implicit conflation of all Muslims with their radical terrorist associates and they feel like this country doesn't accept them. Why aren't we focusing on the thousands of Muslims in this country who dedicate their lives to helping people, or the millions who give to charity?

Thought so - it is all the fault of people complaining about the latest case of someone having their head cut off or being burned alive. I think we can judge who is "absolutely f*cking nuts".'

 

derben Flag 18 Jun 15 10.32pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 9.32pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 8.53pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)

Have any of these countries executed anyone for being gay? Muslim countries have.

Uganda (c.85% Christian) only narrowly avoided having the death sentence for homosexuality put on the statute book in December 2013.Now,people who regularly engage in gay sex only face life imprisonment.The Church in Uganda supported this continuing criminalisation of gay sex.

In some of the "non muslim"examples I mentioned,like Argentina under the junta,I would be surprised if some people had not received the "death sentence",ie summary state-sanctioned execution by means of a bullet to the head for "offences" of a level objectively no less unoffensive than engaging in gay sex.

Some overseas might think it ludicrous for us having a life sentence, death penalty until 1998, on the statute book for having sex (gay or straight) with the sovereign's (the Defender of the Faith's) eldest unmarried daughter.

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 9.51pm)


So none of the non-Muslim countries have executed gay people (whether you are surprised or not by some summary execution in Argentina, that may or may not have been linked to perhaps someone who may or may not have been gay, is irrelevant).

It is absurd to pretend that anti-gay legal harassment is not worse in Muslim countries - it clearly is. It is like saying anti-Semitism in Nazi Gernmany was not that bad and was on a par with anti-Semitism in Britain.

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 18 Jun 15 10.51pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 5.02pm


Taking the contemporary world situation, Islam is of magnitudes greater than Christianity in being non-democratic, misogynistic, intolerant, and vindictive - quite the opposite to your remarkable assertion that Islamic countries are "far more tolerant and inclusive than ours". Would the flogging of the woman in Indonesia (a country you have described as "wonderful"have happened in the UK?

While you are at it, perhaps you could explain how Islamic countries are "far more tolerant and inclusive than ours" on the issue of homosexuality?

Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 5.31pm)


First, let's place my comment back in to it's context: I claimed Indonesia and Turkey are 'far more tolerant and inclusive than ours', a statement I later admitted was an exaggeration. I didn't mention any other Islamic countries, so please have a grown up argument and don't manipulate everything I say.

Of course the flogging for adultery which both the man and woman were subjected to in Indonesia was barbaric, as are there laws against drug smuggling and murder, which are punishable by death. As I said, these are by no means ideal societies, but to claim that it is solely their submission to Islam which causes these atrocities is to be totally blinkered. Cambodia, which neighbours Indonesia and is primarily a Buddhist country, has committed hundreds of human rights violations and is one of the most corrupt nations in the world. Is that because of their religion? What about Christian Papua New Guinea, just south of Indonesia, where nearly half of men admit to having raped a woman. Is that religiously motivated? These issues often transcend the religion of a particular nation and are influenced by the cultural and economic situations of the region, which lead to less tolerant societies (although Indonesia is, in many ways, fairly tolerant of minorities in contrast to its neighbours).

I don't know why you're asking me the final question as if I've ever claimed Islam is that tolerant of homosexuality. But I couldn't name one country on the planet which is tolerant of homosexuality, and certainly Christianity's relationship with the LGBT community, even in a 'progressive' country like America, is similarly worrying. It is far from exclusive to Islam.

Oh, and as a side note, for anyone who thinks I'm some encyclopaedia on all nations' human rights records, I have Wikipedia to thank for a lot of the content of my posts!

Edited by serial thriller (18 Jun 2015 10.53pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

derben Flag 18 Jun 15 11.04pm

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.51pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 5.02pm


Taking the contemporary world situation, Islam is of magnitudes greater than Christianity in being non-democratic, misogynistic, intolerant, and vindictive - quite the opposite to your remarkable assertion that Islamic countries are "far more tolerant and inclusive than ours". Would the flogging of the woman in Indonesia (a country you have described as "wonderful"have happened in the UK?

While you are at it, perhaps you could explain how Islamic countries are "far more tolerant and inclusive than ours" on the issue of homosexuality?

Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 5.31pm)


First, let's place my comment back in to it's context: I claimed Indonesia and Turkey are 'far more tolerant and inclusive than ours', a statement I later admitted was an exaggeration. I didn't mention any other Islamic countries, so please have a grown up argument and don't manipulate everything I say.

Of course the flogging for adultery which both the man and woman were subjected to in Indonesia was barbaric, as are there laws against drug smuggling and murder, which are punishable by death. As I said, these are by no means ideal societies, but to claim that it is solely their submission to Islam which causes these atrocities is to be totally blinkered. Cambodia, which neighbours Indonesia and is primarily a Buddhist country, has committed hundreds of human rights violations and is one of the most corrupt nations in the world. Is that because of their religion? What about Christian Papua New Guinea, just south of Indonesia, where nearly half of men admit to having raped a woman. Is that religiously motivated? These issues often transcend the religion of a particular nation and are influenced by the cultural and economic situations of the region, which lead to less tolerant societies (although Indonesia is, in many ways, fairly tolerant of minorities in contrast to its neighbours).

I don't know why you're asking me the final question as if I've ever claimed Islam is that tolerant of homosexuality. But I couldn't name one country on the planet which is tolerant of homosexuality, and certainly Christianity's relationship with the LGBT community, even in a 'progressive' country like America, is similarly worrying. It is far from exclusive to Islam.

Oh, and as a side note, for anyone who thinks I'm some encyclopaedia on all nations' human rights records, I have Wikipedia to thank for a lot of the content of my posts!

Edited by serial thriller (18 Jun 2015 10.53pm)

I note that Indonesia is no longer "wonderful" but is now "no means ideal"! You couldn't name one country on the planet which is tolerant of homosexuality! In our own UK we now have full gay rights, including 'marriage' and the prosecution of cake makers that refuse to support their cause.


Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 11.13pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 18 Jun 15 11.59pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 10.32pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 9.32pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 8.53pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)

Have any of these countries executed anyone for being gay? Muslim countries have.

Uganda (c.85% Christian) only narrowly avoided having the death sentence for homosexuality put on the statute book in December 2013.Now,people who regularly engage in gay sex only face life imprisonment.The Church in Uganda supported this continuing criminalisation of gay sex.

In some of the "non muslim"examples I mentioned,like Argentina under the junta,I would be surprised if some people had not received the "death sentence",ie summary state-sanctioned execution by means of a bullet to the head for "offences" of a level objectively no less unoffensive than engaging in gay sex.

Some overseas might think it ludicrous for us having a life sentence, death penalty until 1998, on the statute book for having sex (gay or straight) with the sovereign's (the Defender of the Faith's) eldest unmarried daughter.

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 9.51pm)


So none of the non-Muslim countries have executed gay people (whether you are surprised or not by some summary execution in Argentina, that may or may not have been linked to perhaps someone who may or may not have been gay, is irrelevant).

It is absurd to pretend that anti-gay legal harassment is not worse in Muslim countries - it clearly is. It is like saying anti-Semitism in Nazi Germany was not that bad and was on a par with anti-Semitism in Britain.

I am not aware of having pretended anything.

We got involved in this discussion because of points I was trying to make generally about somewhat more than degrees of punishment for engaging in gay sex.There is,of course,a difference between a death sentence and life imprisonment in any context.But,if you want to advance a general argument about the "unique" attitude of "muslim" countries towards criminalisation and punishment of people for having gay sex, it is not the most convincing argument IMO for making "inherent" distinctions between Muslim countries" and "non muslim" countries to rely on a difference between giving people a life sentence as opposed to the death penalty,in terms of the general argument.

To compare what I'm saying to anti semitism here and in Nazi Germany doesn't stand up.If you want to make a comparator,it might be between giving people the "death penalty" in large numbers just for their religion as opposed to simply sending them to prison (sometimes potentially for life) for their religion.The comparison might be more akin to being gassed by the Nazis as opposed to being sent to prison by Stalin for a stretch.One is worse,though neither is desirable or capable of one lecturing the other too much about inherently superior morality,which is exactly one of my general points.

You are right,anti semitism here has not been remotely in either of those leagues though it has existed and anti-semitic attitudes are still around sometimes. Some people would even leave their locality if too many people of a different race,ethnicity or religion moved in. Jews tend to be of a different religion to such people,even perhaps ethnicity too.Some jews might even think a person who moved out because some jews moved in,could be a person harbouring anti-semitic feelings.They might feel that, were such a person to speak to them repeatedly about the "inherent" deficient morality of followers of Islam,it would be somewhat ironic.

You may disagree,and we are all entitled to our opinions.


Edited by legaleagle (19 Jun 2015 12.30am)

 

legaleagle Flag 19 Jun 15 12.24am

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 11.04pm


I note that Indonesia is no longer "wonderful" but is now "no means ideal"! You couldn't name one country on the planet which is tolerant of homosexuality! In our own UK we now have full gay rights, including 'marriage' and the prosecution of cake makers that refuse to support their cause.


Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 11.13pm)


Is N. Ireland no longer a part of the UK?

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 19 Jun 15 7.32am

Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.20pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Jun 2015 4.42pm

Serial answer me this then.

In what religion in this country are you most at risk from radicalisation ?

Before you answer consider :

Although Jehovah’sitnesses are a pain in the arse, not a single one has knocked on my door, waited for me to answer and blew him self up all over my front gardenn, nor has the Bhuddist who lives next door, hacked my head off whilst I was off to the shops, even the mentalist catholic up the road decided not to set me on fire because I didnt agree with his sky fairy on gay marriage.

As I said right at the start it is purely and simply risk management.


Edited by dannyh (18 Jun 2015 4.45pm)


First, I'll answer your question simply: Islam.

Second, how many Muslims do you know directly who have blown themselves up/hacked off their heads/set fire to you? This is the problem I was trying to explain to you Danny, you can accept that radical Islam is a problem AND not tar all Muslims with the same brush. Less than 0.1% of British Muslims have gone out to join IS, thus to make any assumptions on the faith in general is absolutely f*cking nuts.

Why are Muslims more impressionable to extremism? As I said, I don't know for certain, but my guess would be they see comments like yours, where there is an implicit conflation of all Muslims with their radical terrorist associates and they feel like this country doesn't accept them. Why aren't we focusing on the thousands of Muslims in this country who dedicate their lives to helping people, or the millions who give to charity?


Apologist hand wringing at its very best.

If someone doesnt like me, does that giveme the excuse to kill them ?

Does it fcuk as like.

And a point to note for you at virtually every Juncture possible I have made it clear that I do not tar all Muslims with the same brush.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

derben Flag 19 Jun 15 7.54am

Quote legaleagle at 19 Jun 2015 12.24am

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 11.04pm


I note that Indonesia is no longer "wonderful" but is now "no means ideal"! You couldn't name one country on the planet which is tolerant of homosexuality! In our own UK we now have full gay rights, including 'marriage' and the prosecution of cake makers that refuse to support their cause.


Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 11.13pm)


Is N. Ireland no longer a part of the UK?

It is, and even though same-sex marriage is illegal there, they have successfully prosecuted Ashers Bakery for not supporting it! Which seems to demonstrate a very high, if contradictory, tolerance of homosexuality.

Edited by derben (19 Jun 2015 8.08am)

 

derben Flag 19 Jun 15 8.04am

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 11.59pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 10.32pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 9.32pm

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 8.53pm

Quote legaleagle at 18 Jun 2015 7.17pm

There can be many similarities between counties that are "muslim" and "non muslim" ,just like with human beings (shock horror!).

I think its worth not overlooking some of the regimes whose leaders would have seen and proclaimed themselves as upholders of christian civilisation,for example Franco's Spain,Salazar's Portugal,the junta in Argentina (1976-83,estimated 400 torture camps and 30,000 killed).

N.Korea,Zimbabwe and China,currently pretty high up on many's scale of intolerance and repression of human rights, are not "muslim" countries.

If we take a "muslim" country like Malaysia,there is inbuilt discimination in the "system" against people of non Malay origin,ie Indian and Chinese.This is more straight racism as opposed to religious.

In Myanmar/Burma ,we presently see intense persecution of a muslim minority by a "buddhist "majority.

I believe there are 79 countries at present where homosexuality is illegal,including such "non-muslim" countries as Angola,Ethiopia,Singapore,Antigua,Jamaica,Solomon Islands et al.

13 US states still have "anti-sodomy" laws on the books (notwithstanding the Supreme Court overruling their use).Many likely resulting in part at least from the influence of "christian fundamentalism".

Russia in 2013 enacted a law prohibiting any positive mention of homosexuality in the presence of minors, including online. EU member Lithuania has a similar law.

Its not a simple and inherent link of "Islamic":anti gay,and intolerant versus "non Islamic states:the opposite.

A linking factor may be repressive regimes with little history of effective democracy coupled with the susceptibility of countries from varied "religious backgrounds" to fall under the yoke of dictatorship at times.

The "Freedom House" organisation's list (hardly lefties) in 2012 of the 16 most repressive states had only 5 that would generally be thought of "Islamic" plus places like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan which,though having majority muslim populations suffer from regimes of the more traditional dictatorial kind and the majority of the population would be thought of as not "very religious".

Which IMO goes to show things can be complex to analyse rather than simplistically in terms of "muslim":"non-muslim".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 7.24pm)

Have any of these countries executed anyone for being gay? Muslim countries have.

Uganda (c.85% Christian) only narrowly avoided having the death sentence for homosexuality put on the statute book in December 2013.Now,people who regularly engage in gay sex only face life imprisonment.The Church in Uganda supported this continuing criminalisation of gay sex.

In some of the "non muslim"examples I mentioned,like Argentina under the junta,I would be surprised if some people had not received the "death sentence",ie summary state-sanctioned execution by means of a bullet to the head for "offences" of a level objectively no less unoffensive than engaging in gay sex.

Some overseas might think it ludicrous for us having a life sentence, death penalty until 1998, on the statute book for having sex (gay or straight) with the sovereign's (the Defender of the Faith's) eldest unmarried daughter.

Edited by legaleagle (18 Jun 2015 9.51pm)


So none of the non-Muslim countries have executed gay people (whether you are surprised or not by some summary execution in Argentina, that may or may not have been linked to perhaps someone who may or may not have been gay, is irrelevant).

It is absurd to pretend that anti-gay legal harassment is not worse in Muslim countries - it clearly is. It is like saying anti-Semitism in Nazi Germany was not that bad and was on a par with anti-Semitism in Britain.

I am not aware of having pretended anything.

We got involved in this discussion because of points I was trying to make generally about somewhat more than degrees of punishment for engaging in gay sex.There is,of course,a difference between a death sentence and life imprisonment in any context.But,if you want to advance a general argument about the "unique" attitude of "muslim" countries towards criminalisation and punishment of people for having gay sex, it is not the most convincing argument IMO for making "inherent" distinctions between Muslim countries" and "non muslim" countries to rely on a difference between giving people a life sentence as opposed to the death penalty,in terms of the general argument.

To compare what I'm saying to anti semitism here and in Nazi Germany doesn't stand up.If you want to make a comparator,it might be between giving people the "death penalty" in large numbers just for their religion as opposed to simply sending them to prison (sometimes potentially for life) for their religion.The comparison might be more akin to being gassed by the Nazis as opposed to being sent to prison by Stalin for a stretch.One is worse,though neither is desirable or capable of one lecturing the other too much about inherently superior morality,which is exactly one of my general points.

You are right,anti semitism here has not been remotely in either of those leagues though it has existed and anti-semitic attitudes are still around sometimes. Some people would even leave their locality if too many people of a different race,ethnicity or religion moved in. Jews tend to be of a different religion to such people,even perhaps ethnicity too.Some jews might even think a person who moved out because some jews moved in,could be a person harbouring anti-semitic feelings.They might feel that, were such a person to speak to them repeatedly about the "inherent" deficient morality of followers of Islam,it would be somewhat ironic.

You may disagree,and we are all entitled to our opinions.


Edited by legaleagle (19 Jun 2015 12.30am)

I think the Jewish community in the UK have been a great asset, as have the Indian community - in stark contrast to certain other communities. I would welcome them as neighbours, but of course still move if I found that the characteristic of the locality changed to such an extent that I would prefer to live elsewhere.

When did I say there are " 'inherent' deficient morality of followers of Islam ".

I have not talked about a " 'unique' attitude of 'muslim' countries towards criminalisation and punishment of people for having gay sex ", merely pointed out that anti-gay laws are much more severe in Muslim countries, why do you think that is?

 

Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > one less to blow us up