You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

9 dead in USA Church Shooting.


Page 8 of 14 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.
People like Roof should be made to suffer.

Except of course when the execute people who aren't guilty, or have the misfortune of having commited the offence in a different state, or happen to be treated differently because of race / social class / press coverage etc.

Of course by the time it gets around to most peoples executions, they're often changed people, having spent 12-25 years in prison, often dramatically so.

The real problem with execution is it doesn't really do anything other than kill someone else


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 11.35am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.
People like Roof should be made to suffer.

Except of course when the execute people who aren't guilty, or have the misfortune of having commited the offence in a different state, or happen to be treated differently because of race / social class / press coverage etc.

Of course by the time it gets around to most peoples executions, they're often changed people, having spent 12-25 years in prison, often dramatically so.

The real problem with execution is it doesn't really do anything other than kill someone else


It removes the possibility of them doing it again, acts as a deterrent and applies a just retribution for their act.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 11.37am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.

javascripttylebut(0);
Wrong.
Society should not make people suffer, That is not what a civilised society needs. If he is a danger to society then he should be removed from it. Emotional responses are totally understandable but cannot be the basis of a legal system. The electric chair is an abomination and although I can accept that there might be a case made for the execution of mass killers, I am not in favour of it. Any execution should be carried out painlessly and the United States or any other country that carries out barbaric executions should be ashamed. It's not like it has even been shown to reduce murder. Retribution should not be state funded, even for murdering scum like this man.

Entirely agree with this, except for the execution bit, and even then, when you do have executions, I agree.

Notably most executions are 'pretend humane' in so much as it looks humane to those witnessing and conducting it. In reality something like a shotgun, 12ga, both barrels to the back of the head, would be a pretty quick and painless death (where as lethal injection arguably makes it impossible for the victim to manifest pain). Of course a quick, painless but brutal to witness execution wouldn't be popular...

In reality, there are very few humane ways of killing someone, ones that would inevitably be problematic (ie really brutal, pleasurable or have medical legal implications)


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 22 Jun 15 11.37am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.26am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 10.47am
Provocation does not justify violence. What sort of world will we have if we regress to that position ?
I am provoked every day by what I see other people do and say. I am not planning on killing any of them.
You are just making excuses for savage and irrational behaviour. Lampoonery and satire have been part of western society for hundreds of years.

I'm not saying it justifies violence, however by its very defintion, it does cause it, and there is a very big difference in terms of causation and blame, when an incident is provoked as opposed to unprovoked. Obviously those responsible for violence have to be dealt with, but we should be cautious about subscribing those provoking others as blameless in all this.

So they are to blame for exercising their rights to make a statement ?
So if I come round your house and kill you because I don't agree with your opinion, it's your fault for provoking me ?
Think about the ramifications of what you are suggesting.

 

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 11.38am

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Jun 2015 11.21am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 10.56am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 10.41am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 10.12am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 10.09am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 9.55am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 9.39am

Quote beagle at 21 Jun 2015 9.36pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm


No special revisions of British society should be made for any group within it......This is Britain, you take the rough with the smooth or you can always bugger off.

No. Where you find rough you try to change things for the better. A healthy society is in a constant state of self-examination and revision. It's not static and f*** off if you don't like it. That's what hallmarks a democracy which, thank God, we are.

Depends what the 'special revisions' the OP is referring to, doesn't it?

If a 'special revision' was that, lets say, 'Sharia Law' was permitted within certain sections of the community then I'd agree with the OP. One law for one people. Not a mix and match. To mind that would be the antithesis of democracy.


Of course the law in the UK is already different for Scots, Northern Irish and people from the Isle of Man. I'd be hesitant about incorporation of aspects of Sharia law more because not all Muslims want Sharia law, its massively open to interpretation and abuse and varies according to different Islamic faith.

That said, I also think that its many people also deliberately disrespect Islamic faith in a way that's deliberately antagonistic, for their own ends, and call it free speech / expression.


They probably call expressing an opinion free speech, because that is what it is. I suppose you appreciate why cartoonist are killed and the likes of Rushdie have to go into hiding for exercising free speech. Why shouldn't people be free to 'disrespect' Islam - Jerry Springer, the Opera was free to disrespect Christianity.

Free speech isn't free of consequences. Rushdie, I feel somewhat sorry for, but I do feel less sympathy when its people who have persistently poked the snake with a stick, and then complained that its bitten them.

If you keep deliberately antagonizing people for your own ends, you shouldn't be too surprised if the crazy's among those people retaliate. Charlie Hebdo was notably targeted because its cartoons were specifically stating that the actions of Islamists were a disgrace and an insult to Islam, and the Prophet.

But if you keep insulting people, without reason, it shouldn't come as a great surprise when people get very upset with it.


I'm afraid I don't share you attitude on this.
It can never be acceptable to use violence toward people just because you don't like what they say.
It is a slippery slope backward toward the savage.
We are a civilized society in the West and I for one want to keep it that way.

I'm not saying it justifies it, but that maybe you're not quite the victim you claim to be if you've been poking a bear with a stick.

I'd argue that just because you have the right to do something, doesn't necessarily mean you should. Free Speech is a good and noble thing, but we should never separate the consequences of speech, that is deliberately aimed at provoking hate or unrest, even if it presents itself innoculously. Deliberately insulting large sections of the population is just provocation.


Provocation does not justify violence. What sort of world will we have if we regress to that position ?
I am provoked every day by what I see other people do and say. I am not planning on killing any of them.
You are just making excuses for savage and irrational behaviour. Lampoonery and satire have been part of western society for hundreds of years.

At the root of all this is yet again problems with multiculturalism and the clash of cultures - but of course this will be strenuously denied - must never question the fallacy that we all get along famously, shush, keep quite and it all might go away.


You do know people from the same culture clash and argue too sometimes, don't you? You seem to want a version of Utopia where the only way to avoid contretemps or worse is for us all to live a hermit existence. Having said that I you'd be moaning about downwind cooking smells even then no doubt.

The world is a small place and lots of people live on it. Waste of time being the curmudgeonly neighbour. It's not going to achieve anything.

Of course people from the same culture clash too, but the level of clashes and problems is of greater magnitude amongst groups of different cultures despite you pretending it isn't.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 11.39am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.

It will be a frightening day for all of us when the purpose of the penal/legislative system is to make people suffer. To punish, yes. And to punish without comfort, yes again. But to induce suffering to no end other than to sate the apparent bloodlust of a broader community? Not for me.

The death penalty achieves nothing. How do you account for the fact of multiple mass shootings in a country that has the death penalty (America) yet by comparison almost none in a country that doesn't (the UK?)

Killing people is murder, whether sanctioned by the state or not. When the state can kill, killing as a means to an end becomes implicitly legitimised. Our refusal to adopt the death penalty is one of the best things about Britain and reflects well on political parties from across the spectrum.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 11.43am

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 11.39am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.

It will be a frightening day for all of us when the purpose of the penal/legislative system is to make people suffer. To punish, yes. And to punish without comfort, yes again. But to induce suffering to no end other than to sate the apparent bloodlust of a broader community? Not for me.

The death penalty achieves nothing. How do you account for the fact of multiple mass shootings in a country that has the death penalty (America) yet by comparison almost none in a country that doesn't (the UK?)

Killing people is murder, whether sanctioned by the state or not. When the state can kill, killing as a means to an end becomes implicitly legitimised. Our refusal to adopt the death penalty is one of the best things about Britain and reflects well on political parties from across the spectrum.

Americans being armed to the teeth? A long tradition of mayhem?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 11.43am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 11.35am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.
People like Roof should be made to suffer.

Except of course when the execute people who aren't guilty, or have the misfortune of having commited the offence in a different state, or happen to be treated differently because of race / social class / press coverage etc.

Of course by the time it gets around to most peoples executions, they're often changed people, having spent 12-25 years in prison, often dramatically so.

The real problem with execution is it doesn't really do anything other than kill someone else


It removes the possibility of them doing it again, acts as a deterrent and applies a just retribution for their act.

So does life imprisonment. Arguably, more so as its then possible to rectify mistakes.

I'd suggest that retribution is never really capable of being justly applied, when it doesn't allow for rehabilition or atonement. Sometimes I think we let people off too lightly in terms of the later, and that those who's actions are harmful, should maybe be required on parole to atone for their actions, for a period of time.

But killing people because they killed people, isn't a deterent to murder, simply because people who kill other people usually do so for very powerful personal reasons (usually deseperate, or 'accidental' ones).

Obviously, this is an extreme case, where you could probably wrap it up nicely with a quick lynching after a fair trial (if thats possible given the TV coverage).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 22 Jun 15 11.44am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.


Right.

don't you all for one minute think that Roof new there would be a consequence for his actions?

well guess what he killed nine people.

i don't csre weather weather Roof is white or black anyone who does this should be made to suffer as i say.

hopefully he will be sentenced to death.

Hears hoping anyway.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 11.47am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 11.43am

How do you account for the fact of multiple mass shootings in a country that has the death penalty (America) yet by comparison almost none in a country that doesn't (the UK?)

Americans being armed to the teeth? A long tradition of mayhem?

Yes, those facts may explain the number of shootings but they also expose the fact that the death penalty does nothing to mitigate the problem. So why have it? Is it ever really appropriate for a civilised country to assassinate its own citizens? Or is that something you'd like us to have in common with Sharia Law?

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 11.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.43am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 11.35am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.
People like Roof should be made to suffer.

Except of course when the execute people who aren't guilty, or have the misfortune of having commited the offence in a different state, or happen to be treated differently because of race / social class / press coverage etc.

Of course by the time it gets around to most peoples executions, they're often changed people, having spent 12-25 years in prison, often dramatically so.

The real problem with execution is it doesn't really do anything other than kill someone else


It removes the possibility of them doing it again, acts as a deterrent and applies a just retribution for their act.

So does life imprisonment. Arguably, more so as its then possible to rectify mistakes.

I'd suggest that retribution is never really capable of being justly applied, when it doesn't allow for rehabilition or atonement. Sometimes I think we let people off too lightly in terms of the later, and that those who's actions are harmful, should maybe be required on parole to atone for their actions, for a period of time.

But killing people because they killed people, isn't a deterent to murder, simply because people who kill other people usually do so for very powerful personal reasons (usually deseperate, or 'accidental' ones).

Obviously, this is an extreme case, where you could probably wrap it up nicely with a quick lynching after a fair trial (if thats possible given the TV coverage).

Expensive though. Also a significant number of murderers have killed again after being released.

 

TheJudge Flag 22 Jun 15 11.48am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.37am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.

javascripttylebut(0);
Wrong.
Society should not make people suffer, That is not what a civilised society needs. If he is a danger to society then he should be removed from it. Emotional responses are totally understandable but cannot be the basis of a legal system. The electric chair is an abomination and although I can accept that there might be a case made for the execution of mass killers, I am not in favour of it. Any execution should be carried out painlessly and the United States or any other country that carries out barbaric executions should be ashamed. It's not like it has even been shown to reduce murder. Retribution should not be state funded, even for murdering scum like this man.

Entirely agree with this, except for the execution bit, and even then, when you do have executions, I agree.

Notably most executions are 'pretend humane' in so much as it looks humane to those witnessing and conducting it. In reality something like a shotgun, 12ga, both barrels to the back of the head, would be a pretty quick and painless death (where as lethal injection arguably makes it impossible for the victim to manifest pain). Of course a quick, painless but brutal to witness execution wouldn't be popular...

In reality, there are very few humane ways of killing someone, ones that would inevitably be problematic (ie really brutal, pleasurable or have medical legal implications)



Well there are ways to kill people painlessly I assure you but the knowledge that are going to die is unavoidable unless you do it with a mafia style "wacking" when you never see it coming. Not sure that is going to happen.
Certainly all the current forms of execution unacceptable.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 11.50am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 11.43am

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 11.39am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.

It will be a frightening day for all of us when the purpose of the penal/legislative system is to make people suffer. To punish, yes. And to punish without comfort, yes again. But to induce suffering to no end other than to sate the apparent bloodlust of a broader community? Not for me.

The death penalty achieves nothing. How do you account for the fact of multiple mass shootings in a country that has the death penalty (America) yet by comparison almost none in a country that doesn't (the UK?)

Killing people is murder, whether sanctioned by the state or not. When the state can kill, killing as a means to an end becomes implicitly legitimised. Our refusal to adopt the death penalty is one of the best things about Britain and reflects well on political parties from across the spectrum.

Americans being armed to the teeth? A long tradition of mayhem?

I suspect that the US isn't actually a much more violent place than the UK. The difference probably lies in the distrust people have within that society, high levels of prejudice, high stressful working environments, poor education and piss poor public services (not least mental health).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 11.52am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 11.48am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.37am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.

javascripttylebut(0);
Wrong.
Society should not make people suffer, That is not what a civilised society needs. If he is a danger to society then he should be removed from it. Emotional responses are totally understandable but cannot be the basis of a legal system. The electric chair is an abomination and although I can accept that there might be a case made for the execution of mass killers, I am not in favour of it. Any execution should be carried out painlessly and the United States or any other country that carries out barbaric executions should be ashamed. It's not like it has even been shown to reduce murder. Retribution should not be state funded, even for murdering scum like this man.

Entirely agree with this, except for the execution bit, and even then, when you do have executions, I agree.

Notably most executions are 'pretend humane' in so much as it looks humane to those witnessing and conducting it. In reality something like a shotgun, 12ga, both barrels to the back of the head, would be a pretty quick and painless death (where as lethal injection arguably makes it impossible for the victim to manifest pain). Of course a quick, painless but brutal to witness execution wouldn't be popular...

In reality, there are very few humane ways of killing someone, ones that would inevitably be problematic (ie really brutal, pleasurable or have medical legal implications)



Well there are ways to kill people painlessly I assure you but the knowledge that are going to die is unavoidable unless you do it with a mafia style "wacking" when you never see it coming. Not sure that is going to happen.
Certainly all the current forms of execution unacceptable.

Problem is that most of the 'painless methods' are either brutal, pleasant or would have legal consquences for Medicine. Thats before you get onto the ethical issue of keeping people on death row for 12-25 years, and then killing them irrespective of whether they prevent a threat or have rehabilitated.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 11.53am

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 11.47am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 11.43am

How do you account for the fact of multiple mass shootings in a country that has the death penalty (America) yet by comparison almost none in a country that doesn't (the UK?)

Americans being armed to the teeth? A long tradition of mayhem?

Yes, those facts may explain the number of shootings but they also expose the fact that the death penalty does nothing to mitigate the problem. So why have it? Is it ever really appropriate for a civilised country to assassinate its own citizens? Or is that something you'd like us to have in common with Sharia Law?

It is not clear whether a death penalty has or has not affected the figures. They are not 'assassinating' citizens, they are executing criminals after due process. Sharia law has the death penalty for such things as apostasy, adultery and being gay, I certainly would not agree with that, or with prolonged methods of execution such as stoning.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 11.58am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.44am

Right.

don't you all for one minute think that Roof new there would be a consequence for his actions?

well guess what he killed nine people.

i don't csre weather weather Roof is white or black anyone who does this should be made to suffer as i say.

hopefully he will be sentenced to death.

Hears hoping anyway.

I'm not sure how you think the fact that Roof knew there would be consequences as a result of his actions serves as a justification for the death penalty. Every criminal, indeed every sane person, knows that life is a matter of cause and effect. In the case of the law the criminal chooses the cause and society chooses the effect. When society administers an effect that doesn't solve the cause (the death penalty does NOT reduce the number of murders) then what's the point of it? If anything, it simply dulls our view of and increases our tolerance of violence as a means to an end; if the state can do it, anyone can. Put another way, don't we teach our children that if someone hits you, hitting him or her back isn't the answer?

Colour indeed doesn't matter. But the function of a civilised government is not and never will be to induce suffering, no matter what crime has been committed. That is antithetical with being civilised. Even where a punishment results in suffering, it cannot explicitly seek to do so or we would compromise every value we hold in the west.

Roof will almost certainly be sentenced to death, I suspect. It's an easy way out, and his demise will be greeted by a religious fervour not unlike that generated, I suspect, by advocates of Sharia Law. His death will achieve nothing; his rehabilitation if he is sentenced to life in prison just might. Perhaps we should let the families of the victims decide his fate; they've already demonstrated more dignity and courage than most of the trigger-happy death penalty advocates in this thread.


 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

TheJudge Flag 22 Jun 15 12.02pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.52am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 11.48am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.37am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.

javascripttylebut(0);
Wrong.
Society should not make people suffer, That is not what a civilised society needs. If he is a danger to society then he should be removed from it. Emotional responses are totally understandable but cannot be the basis of a legal system. The electric chair is an abomination and although I can accept that there might be a case made for the execution of mass killers, I am not in favour of it. Any execution should be carried out painlessly and the United States or any other country that carries out barbaric executions should be ashamed. It's not like it has even been shown to reduce murder. Retribution should not be state funded, even for murdering scum like this man.

Entirely agree with this, except for the execution bit, and even then, when you do have executions, I agree.

Notably most executions are 'pretend humane' in so much as it looks humane to those witnessing and conducting it. In reality something like a shotgun, 12ga, both barrels to the back of the head, would be a pretty quick and painless death (where as lethal injection arguably makes it impossible for the victim to manifest pain). Of course a quick, painless but brutal to witness execution wouldn't be popular...

In reality, there are very few humane ways of killing someone, ones that would inevitably be problematic (ie really brutal, pleasurable or have medical legal implications)



Well there are ways to kill people painlessly I assure you but the knowledge that are going to die is unavoidable unless you do it with a mafia style "wacking" when you never see it coming. Not sure that is going to happen.
Certainly all the current forms of execution unacceptable.

Problem is that most of the 'painless methods' are either brutal, pleasant or would have legal consquences for Medicine. Thats before you get onto the ethical issue of keeping people on death row for 12-25 years, and then killing them irrespective of whether they prevent a threat or have rehabilitated.



Hypoxia would be the simplest painless method I believe, but there is really no good way to kill someone. As for death row, well if you are guilty of a murder then it is hard to sympathise. The process is probably not ideal, but as long as the intention is not to make the prisoner suffer then and is unavoidable then we are stuck with it I suppose. As for rehabilitation. I'm sure it is possible in some cases but the safety of the majority must come before the rights of an individual convicted of murder.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 12.08pm

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 12.02pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.52am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 11.48am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 11.37am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 11.32am

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 11.02am

As i mentioned before on here Roof deserves the electric chair for what he did,he is pure evil and showed no remorse.

America and other countries are doing the right thing having the death penalty.

People like Roof should be made to suffer.

javascripttylebut(0);
Wrong.
Society should not make people suffer, That is not what a civilised society needs. If he is a danger to society then he should be removed from it. Emotional responses are totally understandable but cannot be the basis of a legal system. The electric chair is an abomination and although I can accept that there might be a case made for the execution of mass killers, I am not in favour of it. Any execution should be carried out painlessly and the United States or any other country that carries out barbaric executions should be ashamed. It's not like it has even been shown to reduce murder. Retribution should not be state funded, even for murdering scum like this man.

Entirely agree with this, except for the execution bit, and even then, when you do have executions, I agree.

Notably most executions are 'pretend humane' in so much as it looks humane to those witnessing and conducting it. In reality something like a shotgun, 12ga, both barrels to the back of the head, would be a pretty quick and painless death (where as lethal injection arguably makes it impossible for the victim to manifest pain). Of course a quick, painless but brutal to witness execution wouldn't be popular...

In reality, there are very few humane ways of killing someone, ones that would inevitably be problematic (ie really brutal, pleasurable or have medical legal implications)



Well there are ways to kill people painlessly I assure you but the knowledge that are going to die is unavoidable unless you do it with a mafia style "wacking" when you never see it coming. Not sure that is going to happen.
Certainly all the current forms of execution unacceptable.

Problem is that most of the 'painless methods' are either brutal, pleasant or would have legal consquences for Medicine. Thats before you get onto the ethical issue of keeping people on death row for 12-25 years, and then killing them irrespective of whether they prevent a threat or have rehabilitated.



Hypoxia would be the simplest painless method I believe, but there is really no good way to kill someone. As for death row, well if you are guilty of a murder then it is hard to sympathise. The process is probably not ideal, but as long as the intention is not to make the prisoner suffer then and is unavoidable then we are stuck with it I suppose. As for rehabilitation. I'm sure it is possible in some cases but the safety of the majority must come before the rights of an individual convicted of murder.

Overdose of diamorphine is fairly effective, especially if administered with a euphoric, but that would make prescribing many painkillers impossible (and requires a qualified doctor to prescribe and a qualified nurse to administer).

Slow hypoxia isn't a particually horrible way to die, but suffocation / drowing is horribly painful. The problem of hypoxia is its very slow, and executions have to be witnessed.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 22 Jun 15 12.12pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 11.38am

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Jun 2015 11.21am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 10.56am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 10.41am

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 10.12am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 10.09am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 9.55am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 9.39am

Quote beagle at 21 Jun 2015 9.36pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm


No special revisions of British society should be made for any group within it......This is Britain, you take the rough with the smooth or you can always bugger off.

No. Where you find rough you try to change things for the better. A healthy society is in a constant state of self-examination and revision. It's not static and f*** off if you don't like it. That's what hallmarks a democracy which, thank God, we are.

Depends what the 'special revisions' the OP is referring to, doesn't it?

If a 'special revision' was that, lets say, 'Sharia Law' was permitted within certain sections of the community then I'd agree with the OP. One law for one people. Not a mix and match. To mind that would be the antithesis of democracy.


Of course the law in the UK is already different for Scots, Northern Irish and people from the Isle of Man. I'd be hesitant about incorporation of aspects of Sharia law more because not all Muslims want Sharia law, its massively open to interpretation and abuse and varies according to different Islamic faith.

That said, I also think that its many people also deliberately disrespect Islamic faith in a way that's deliberately antagonistic, for their own ends, and call it free speech / expression.


They probably call expressing an opinion free speech, because that is what it is. I suppose you appreciate why cartoonist are killed and the likes of Rushdie have to go into hiding for exercising free speech. Why shouldn't people be free to 'disrespect' Islam - Jerry Springer, the Opera was free to disrespect Christianity.

Free speech isn't free of consequences. Rushdie, I feel somewhat sorry for, but I do feel less sympathy when its people who have persistently poked the snake with a stick, and then complained that its bitten them.

If you keep deliberately antagonizing people for your own ends, you shouldn't be too surprised if the crazy's among those people retaliate. Charlie Hebdo was notably targeted because its cartoons were specifically stating that the actions of Islamists were a disgrace and an insult to Islam, and the Prophet.

But if you keep insulting people, without reason, it shouldn't come as a great surprise when people get very upset with it.


I'm afraid I don't share you attitude on this.
It can never be acceptable to use violence toward people just because you don't like what they say.
It is a slippery slope backward toward the savage.
We are a civilized society in the West and I for one want to keep it that way.

I'm not saying it justifies it, but that maybe you're not quite the victim you claim to be if you've been poking a bear with a stick.

I'd argue that just because you have the right to do something, doesn't necessarily mean you should. Free Speech is a good and noble thing, but we should never separate the consequences of speech, that is deliberately aimed at provoking hate or unrest, even if it presents itself innoculously. Deliberately insulting large sections of the population is just provocation.


Provocation does not justify violence. What sort of world will we have if we regress to that position ?
I am provoked every day by what I see other people do and say. I am not planning on killing any of them.
You are just making excuses for savage and irrational behaviour. Lampoonery and satire have been part of western society for hundreds of years.

At the root of all this is yet again problems with multiculturalism and the clash of cultures - but of course this will be strenuously denied - must never question the fallacy that we all get along famously, shush, keep quite and it all might go away.


You do know people from the same culture clash and argue too sometimes, don't you? You seem to want a version of Utopia where the only way to avoid contretemps or worse is for us all to live a hermit existence. Having said that I you'd be moaning about downwind cooking smells even then no doubt.

The world is a small place and lots of people live on it. Waste of time being the curmudgeonly neighbour. It's not going to achieve anything.

Of course people from the same culture clash too, but the level of clashes and problems is of greater magnitude amongst groups of different cultures despite you pretending it isn't.


And your point is....?

Look, the majority of the world today shows people from differing backgrounds are living and working side by side and just getting on with it. No harm done. That's your multi-culturalism. Doesn't always have to harmonious all the time, like most human relationships, but the fact is is that that majority represent something which you don't quite get even if they are peaceful, hard-working and worry more about family, friends and money than they do about skin colour and religion.

That majority doesn't represent you because you are not of a like-mind. You see strongly the differences whereas others may see strongly the similarities.

Biggest multi-cultural city in the world? Gotta be New York hasn't it? It must have its problems but for a city of 10million if those problems were not insurmountable by the natives just going about their day then there would be serious clashes happening all over the five boroughs, surely? Explain to me why New York is not at some kind of civil war boiling point if cultures clash so badly? Why has it not turned into Sarajevo '92? How do these people exist?

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 12.13pm

Quote TheJudge at 22 Jun 2015 12.02pm

Thats before you get onto the ethical issue of keeping people on death row for 12-25 years, and then killing them irrespective of whether they prevent a threat or have rehabilitated.

As for death row, well if you are guilty of a murder then it is hard to sympathise.

Jamie raises the key point; the person you are today is rarely the person you were a decade ago. This is a fundamental problem with the death penalty. You can't rush it through because taking away someone's life requires due diligence to be thorough and rights of appeal to be exhausted but if you execute someone a decade or longer after the crime was committed, they may to all intents and purposes have become a "different" person. To me, it's one of many reasons why the death penalty just doesn't work.

Of course it's hard to sympathise with a murderer but believing the death penalty is wrong doesn't require you to be sympathetic. It simply requires you to believe that it's an ineffective and even immoral form of punishment. The purpose of the law surely is to protect society? It has not to the best of my knowledge been demonstrated conclusively that the death penalty helps to achieve that. Until there is conclusive proof...while there is even a shred of doubt...I don't think the state should go around killing people.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Page 8 of 14 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.