|
Good post. I appreciate the reasoned rather than emotional response and while I don't agree with a lot of what you've said, I do think your position is cogent. I will try to answer as best I can.
Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Sep 2015 1.40am
The point is you choose to emphasize right wing economic figures when the real difference between the past and now is mass communication.
This is the only thing I really don't agree with. Yes, you're right -- as I said before -- that mass communications is the main difference between postwar society and today. But as I said, that merely fans the flames of resentment. It doesn't cause the resentment. So the point isn't really relevant to this argument as far as I can see if what we're arguing about is what's caused the resentment in society today.
Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Sep 2015 1.40am
What minority in history hasn't had 'resentment'? I made the example of the miners, I could pick out many examples throughout history.
Likely every minority has had resentment. But they haven't all handled it in the same way. This is where your point about mass communications comes in. It's easier to make a molotov cocktail when you can download a recipe from the Internet. Mass communications has made it easier for resentment to proliferate and become violent. I also think you need to note that while many and possibly all minorities have been burdened with some degree of resentment, an equal number have flourished. It's therefore not fair to conclude that all minorities = resentment and problems. The Asian American experience, for instance, has been one of considerable success and very little (if not no) resentment. It can be done.
Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Sep 2015 1.40am
Name me a country that's ungone large scale unasked for immigration..... made up of minority groups originally from different countries that doesn't contain 'resentment'.
What you want is an impossibility.
See above. Of course there will be some resentment, but there will be some resentment in the indigenous classes of a country with or without immigration. Imagining a completely happy world is a pipe dream. The real question is whether immigration is the real cause of the resentment (as opposed to whether people want to believe it is.) I don't think so -- although that is not to say I believe that unfettered immigration is warranted. I also think, in this case, we need to distinguish between "immigrants" and "refugees", two different classes and it's the latter we are talking about at the present time.
Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Sep 2015 1.40am
Your version of the left want open borders and when those coming in don't like the society they came into....You blame the society.....I and most people didn't ask for immigrants to come here and worsen the housing crises.....I am of course talking about a minority within a minority here. Integrated Muslims in my experience are fine (though polls on their views are mixed).
I don't think I have said I want open borders (for the record, I recognise there needs to be some degree of control. It's what that degree is that we may differ on) and I don't think you can speak of "my version of the left" when you (and probably I) don't really know what that is. I don't blame society...I blame a very specific political party with a very specific economic policy for the breakdown of society we face today. I could argue, though you would disagree, that with investment in infrastructure rather than austerity, we could quickly ameliorate the housing crisis and more easily accommodate refugees. The argument is not so simple (on either side) that right and wrong can be distinguished with a single statement or observation. What you last line hints at is that where there is integration, experiences are better. That tells me that improving integration is the answer; not shutting the borders to refugees.
Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Sep 2015 1.40am
I can't see how people with your views really care about the struggling working class of this country.
The English working class and refugees and/or immigrants are all people. If you better their lot in life by improving services, investing in housing and bettering social infrastructure, everyone benefits. You don't have to invest in or debate about one group or the other; the answer is the same for both. If you create a better society, everyone benefits. To that extent, I care about all because I think the same remedy that applies to the British working classes also applies to the refugee community. My belief is that we simply invest in or prioritize the wrong things/policies, which is why we end up with the fractured society we've got. Policy change (to the left) would remove a lot of the resentment problem (obviously, you will not agree with that.)
Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Sep 2015 1.40am.
The practical outcome of your views is to make their situation worse......And then point fingers at others.
See above. I don't think that's true. What makes things worse are policies like austerity. The only people I point fingers at are those who pursue it.
Edited by sydtheeagle (29 Sep 2015 7.12am)
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|