You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another black man shot by police in USA
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another black man shot by police in USA


Page 8 of 36 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 16 10.29am

Originally posted by 7mins

They used a taser on the man in Baton Rouge. On Sean Hannity show, BLM said the amount of violence and death committed by blacks on blacks "wasn't their priority right now"
Factually speaking, police don't shoot black people more than they do people of other races.
Factually speaking black people kill me more people than any other race.
My family in Ohio have zero fear of being killed by police, my aunt does fear my nephew being killed or hurt by mainly (but not entirely) black criminals.
BLM have rallies where they do the stupid chant about "putting wings on pigs" then when police get killed by their members (NY and Dallas). They say nothing to do with us.

Its a false argument though, because it presents separate issues. Yes, there is a problem with violence in black America, but that's besides the point when talking about the issue of cops perpetrating excessive lethal force in situations where the use of deadly force is not necessary.

These other issues are besides the point. It doesn't matter who you or your family are afraid of, or that more black people are killed by black people. Its that police officers are flagrantly getting away with flagrant abuse of power.

BLM was set up to deal with this issue, not other issues of the black community, but this specific issue of excessive police brutality against black people.

People start shooting back, and it seems that BLM should be apologising for the actions of people who aren't part of the group, where as the police and sheriffs department, that have shot restrained prisoners avoid any recriminations or apologies. Of course the people who shot those five officers should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. Which they will be, which certainly won't be the case of most of the police officers in the cases raised by BLM over the last year or so.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 16 10.35am

Originally posted by 7mins


[Link]

It's purely a numbers game to me... The biggest threat by far to black people is other black people.

The stats for crimes committed by black people are horrendous, remember they make up 13% of the population. For every crime, there's a victim. There is also a young black man going to prison, two families devastated. The link above shows black people aren't more likely to be shot than any other race.

As for BLM... They have a disregard for tackling crime, the only crime that interests them is crime committed by people of a different race to them. Also the cop killing chants are pretty vile.

BLM isn't about tackling crimes committed by black people, the US has an entire system of justice that is supposed to deal with that. Its about the injustice faced by the black community by that apparatus of state power, and how it gets away with flagrant abuse of power by its officers.

I would be surprised if however it was just black people on the receiving end of excessive police force in the US - I suspect its poor people in general. Its just that Black America, has an entire civil rights network in place, from its assorted campaigns for equality.

It doesn't matter if the police shoot as many white people as black people, in the same circumstances, they're still shooting people in a manner that should concern any free society.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Jul 16 11.15am

"The notion that America's cops simply are gunning down innocent black people is one of today's biggest and deadliest lies."

 

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Jul 16 11.20am

"Black Lives Matter (BLM) is an activist movement, originating in the African-American community, that campaigns against violence toward black people. "

But stated that black on black violence isn't their concern.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 16 11.49am

Originally posted by 7mins

"The notion that America's cops simply are gunning down innocent black people is one of today's biggest and deadliest lies."

Innocent isn't the issue, it people, that matters. Police should only be responding with lethal force in situations where there is a clear threat to either the officers or to bystanders.

For me, the issue isn't whether they are black or not, or whether they have a criminal record, its whether the use of deadly force was reasonable.

A restrained man, even if he's guilty, isn't by default fair game to shoot, irrespective of his race. There is a racial element here, but I feel there is more, but that's for other groups to raise as an associated issue (if police are shooting white suspects on a highly dubious grounds, then that also is just as bad).

A lot of the criticism of BLM deals with protecting the right of the police to just shoot people if they may be armed, or a physical threat, not an existential one.

The issue, at base, isn't about race per se, its about whether police officers use of force in these circumstances, is justified.

And it isn't. Shooting a restrained man, when the police discover a gun on him, isn't justified. Shooting a bloke in a car reaching for his licence, isn't justified. The actions of these officers is deplorable, and unacceptable - as is the protection of such officers by the establishment around them.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 16 11.52am

Originally posted by 7mins

"Black Lives Matter (BLM) is an activist movement, originating in the African-American community, that campaigns against violence toward black people. "

But stated that black on black violence isn't their concern.

Quite, and it isn't. There are plenty of other activist movements that tackle inner city gangs, gang violence, poverty, school programs etc. This is specifically about one issue. Makes sense to me. Different groups focus on different problems.

The concern is how willingly people are happy to dismiss the idea that many, if not all, of these issues where police have gunned down and killed unarmed people, are acceptable.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Jul 16 1.12pm

Both the people shot recently were armed.
Police very rarely go round shooting unarmed people. Fill a country with guns and these incidents are bound to happen. What is dangerous is people using terms like "executing" and "putting wings on pigs".

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 16 1.26pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Both the people shot recently were armed.
Police very rarely go round shooting unarmed people. Fill a country with guns and these incidents are bound to happen. What is dangerous is people using terms like "executing" and "putting wings on pigs".

Neither person was displaying a weapon. In one incident the individual was physically restrained by two officers before discovery of a firearm. In the second the individual was in possession of a licenced, legal firearm and a carry permit, which he had reported to the officer on scene, just prior to the officer shooting him five times.

So their being armed is irrelevant to the actions of the officer opening fire.

If you think that's justified you're looking at exactly why some people think its just to shoot five police officers in response. They did this, so we can do that. The point everyone misses is that people are being killed in a manner that is unacceptable in any civilised society.

Only 39% of black males shot by the police were armed. That's a worryingly low figure that to me, and any sensible person, shows a complete lack of restraint and regard for lives by the Police.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 16 1.27pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Both the people shot recently were armed.
Police very rarely go round shooting unarmed people. Fill a country with guns and these incidents are bound to happen. What is dangerous is people using terms like "executing" and "putting wings on pigs".

What would you call shooting a man to death, by legal authority, who is not a threat?

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Jul 16 2.58pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

What would you call shooting a man to death, by legal authority, who is not a threat?

Who said he wasn't a threat? That's your opinion from suburban England. You can't see if he was reaching for the gun in the video, the officer shouts, "he has a gun" if it was in his pocket, how did he know he was in possession of a gun? Maybe he just guessed... Maybe he thought... We'll taser him, and if that don't work we'll shoot him, and hope he has a gun on him.
The officer seems pretty upset at the end of the video.

The 2nd incident... Seems a little more dodgy... But even then the officer says he told the man not to move after he declared he had a (legal) firearm on him.

Like officers say... Comply and we both go home.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Jul 16 3.00pm

BLM wasn't formed to fight police brutality. It was formed in response to violence against blacks, after the Zimmerman case. They now concentrate on police shootings.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 13 Jul 16 3.15pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Both the people shot recently were armed.
Police very rarely go round shooting unarmed people. Fill a country with guns and these incidents are bound to happen. What is dangerous is people using terms like "executing" and "putting wings on pigs".


So how many people can they shoot before it gets above your tolerance threshold? Does it make a difference if you know any of them or are related to any of them? How about if it's you, would that still be ok because it was "rare"?

I have cops come up to me with hand-on-hilt on two occasions, both in the early hours of the morning. This was years ago, and I never thought anything of it until the recent highlighting of the unnecessary use of lethal force (and subsequent lying about it) by police. Now it gives me serious pause: I may be here now purely by dint of my skin colour.

Edited by Ray in Houston (13 Jul 2016 3.16pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 13 Jul 16 3.20pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Who said he wasn't a threat? That's your opinion from suburban England. You can't see if he was reaching for the gun in the video, the officer shouts, "he has a gun" if it was in his pocket, how did he know he was in possession of a gun? Maybe he just guessed... Maybe he thought... We'll taser him, and if that don't work we'll shoot him, and hope he has a gun on him.
The officer seems pretty upset at the end of the video.

The officers had both his arms pinned. After the shooting, they pulled the gun from his pocket. He never had the gun and never looked like being able to get it.

I'm glad you're sympathetic to the officer's feelings. He has the rest of his life to feel bad about killing this man...


Originally posted by 7mins
The 2nd incident... Seems a little more dodgy... But even then the officer says he told the man not to move after he declared he had a (legal) firearm on him.

Like officers say... Comply and we both go home.


And in what way did Philando Castile not comply? He told the officer about the gun, told him his ID was in his back pocket, was asked to produce it, reached for his pocket and took 4 bullets to the chest.

How the f*** does Castile manage that situation better so as not to be shot?!!!

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 13 Jul 16 3.25pm

This about sums it up.

13669823_1123862744327312_4036848073299527944_n.jpg Attachment: 13669823_1123862744327312_4036848073299527944_n.jpg (42.24Kb)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 13 Jul 16 3.56pm

Does make you wonder - Imagine we gave some of the authority over here guns. Some of these American officers can barely tie their laces yet are trusted with a firearm.

Edited by sxp55 (13 Jul 2016 3.56pm)

 


@sxp55555

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 13 Jul 16 5.05pm

"To understand the lack of police legitimacy in black communities, consider the contempt in which most white Americans hold O.J. Simpson. Consider their feelings toward the judge and jury in the case. And then consider that this is approximately how black people have felt every few months for generations. It’s not just that the belief that Officer Timothy Loehmann got away with murdering a 12-year-old Tamir Rice, it is the reality that police officers have been getting away with murdering black people since the advent of American policing. The injustice compounds, congeals until there is an almost tangible sense of dread and grievance that compels a community to understand the police as objects of fear, not respect."
[Link]

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Jul 16 5.20pm

How did they know he had a gun if it was in his pocket?
Was Tamir Rice murdered? The story I read was the cops were called to a person with a gun, when the police turned up, the gun was pointed at them, they shot the person. Why do people lie... When the counter argument comes out with this s***, I just think they have a agenda. Terms like murdered and executed are used because they are powerful words, but who cares if they're lies huh?
The 2nd dude reached for his drivers license, after being told not to, the cop probably panicked thought he was reaching for a gun and reacted wrongly.,. Not right, but not murder or execution.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Jul 16 5.21pm

... And as stated.., you are no more likely to be shot by police if you are black.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Jul 16 5.31pm

I love people telling police officers... If someone points a gun at you, don't shoot, because it might be a replica.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 16 5.46pm

Originally posted by 7mins

How did they know he had a gun if it was in his pocket?
Was Tamir Rice murdered? The story I read was the cops were called to a person with a gun, when the police turned up, the gun was pointed at them, they shot the person. Why do people lie...

A twelve year old kid with a replica airsoft gun. The police shot him within two seconds of arriving on scene. Wasn't the police officers fault, the dispatcher however did neglect to mention that the witness calling the police believed the gun to be fake and that the offender was a child.

Neither officer attempted to give first aid, nor a warning to the suspect. There is some doubt as to whether the officers claims of events are genuine, as the surveillance video only backs up some of their claims. The firing officer doesn't seem to give a warning, despite his claim of having shouted three times from the car, and shoots Rice, twice within two seconds of leaving the car. The video isn't clear as to whether the kid was reaching for a gun as the officers stated.

Now I can get behind why Rice was shot, its reasonable I think if someone has a fake gun that looks like a gun, to believe them to be armed. It is however very unprofessional and rash conduct to open fire almost immediately on arrival, when its a kid.

The officer who fired was of questionable mentality to be in a position of being an armed police officer, according to his own training record.

So its not quite as clear cut as you make out.

Originally posted by 7mins

The 2nd dude reached for his drivers license, after being told not to, the cop probably panicked thought he was reaching for a gun and reacted wrongly.,. Not right, but not murder or execution.

Only if the copper was a complete f**king idiot, would he believe that someone who was sitting in a car, who just informed him that he was in possession of a legal carry permit and a fire arm, was then going to draw and shoot over a broken tail light.

He shot him five times. He probably panicked, but given that in the US there is no law against having a legal carry permit, one has to ask why police officers would panic when faced with someone whos informed them that a) they have a carry permit and b) they are in possession of a legal firearm.

That's some pretty s**t training and self control, for someone who's been professionally trained and given lethal weapons.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 8 of 36 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another black man shot by police in USA