This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
No surprise to see you not actually make a point and throw insults around - the signature of you and your right wing boy band on here. Please explain to me what the 'splendid analogy' sums up, if you can. I think the point is tolerance.... Easy really,and you are the one throwing insults about. I suppose you will call me racist now,that's what your lot usually do.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well first of all. We're a democracy, so we the people are responsible for those politicians being in power in the first place, and politicians are supposedly accountable to us, the people. They're also the people as well. Its not about compromising a belief system. Its about incorporating some people into their own society where possible. We the people, includes all of us, every single person with British Citizenship, irrespective of age, colour, religion, gender etc. Also, its worth noting that there was no trouble with Islamic militants in the UK until very recently in history. Most Muslims in the UK are third generation, and until 2005, not a single incident of suicide bombing etc. I'm sorry but we are in 2016 and what has gone before is not important. Things have changed across Europe. The irony of your position is that you say that nothing is sacred in terms of our principles as a Western nation and that claiming so is extremism and dealing in absolutes and then in the next breath you say that we can change our laws to pander to someone else's sacred beliefs. Yes a few million Britons are Muslim and most are just getting on with life but they are in a Western country and in a tiny minority. Why on earth should we change our laws simply because the extremist branch of their religion are systematically attacking our citizens? That would be appeasement plain and simple. That, however well intentioned, would be a very grave error and one that the vast majority of British people would reject. They would see such a move for what it is. We must think about the future of Britain and how our decisions now will impact on it. We failed to do so in the past. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Jul 2016 7.00pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well yes, but then if it wasn't defined as a picture of Mohammed, it wouldn't be illegal. We have stupid rules for a bloke who died 1300 years before that, that prevent say Gay people getting married in church, or women for having jobs as his spokesman etc. We could live with a few rules that prevent people needlessly provoking British citizens. Sikh's can carry knives and not wear crash helmets, Catholic nurses and Doctors can refuse any association to work related to abortion and the UK even allows for religious polygamy, provide marriage occurred outside the UK and so on and so forth. But I understand that making similar exceptions for Muslims would bring down all of western civilisation. Personally, I think the question isn't whether you have the freedom to do something, but why your doing it. If all you can achieve with freedom of speech is deliberately antagonising people, then its wasted on those people. I means sure, you could create a picture of a nun sucking a donkey with a crucifix up her arse, and stick it on a magazine cover - but there's only one reason your doing it, to court controversy and upset people. We can probably get by with legislating that publishing pictures or images of the prophet Mohammed should only be accepted where artistic merit can be established.
I'd happily see the end of all religious nonsense and I'd make them pay taxes in the meantime. The churches have had to adapt to modern life in regard to gay marriage and women clergy, not that either of those issues have led to mass murder in recent years. A Sikh couldn't get on a plane with their dagger and the exemption from head protection rules is absurd. Especially as they don't have to wear a turban, just cover their hair and head. See Monty Panesar in cricket.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
I'd happily see the end of all religious nonsense and I'd make them pay taxes in the meantime. The churches have had to adapt to modern life in regard to gay marriage and women clergy, not that either of those issues have led to mass murder in recent years. A Sikh couldn't get on a plane with their dagger and the exemption from head protection rules is absurd. Especially as they don't have to wear a turban, just cover their hair and head. See Monty Panesar in cricket. This isn't about religion - this is about how people CHOOSE to b******ise religion and then have gullible followers jump onto the band wagon, primarily through social media that cannot be adequately policed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sportyteacher
This isn't about religion - this is about how people CHOOSE to b******ise religion and then have gullible followers jump onto the band wagon, primarily through social media that cannot be adequately policed. I don't think you've read the conversation jamie and I have been having if you don't think it's about religion. That, and the law, have been the crux of it. If you can't acknowledge that a certain religion has been a common theme amongst multiple incidents of late, you're blind. They've been different nationalities, different ages, born there or immigrated to there, acted as a group or as an individual. The theme isn't Facebook or Twitter ffs.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
The Burka is an affront to Women's rights & has no place in a relatively free & democratic society. It is worn in the desert, made of cheap nylon & it is almost always black & designed to cover as much as possible. Why on earth anyone who wants to stand up for womens rights would choose to turn a blind eye to this is taking society backwards & reeks of hypocrisy. Islam by & large is deeply homophobic. Halal slaughter is f***ing evil. Seperation of religion & state These are lines in the sand among many many reasons & there should be absolutely no movement from us. Instead we allow the suffering of women and even celebrate it. Turn a blind eye to the absolutely disgusting levels of homophobia that exist within the British muslim community. Halal slaughter is tolerated, f*** we even give tax breaks to religious slaughter houses giving them the advantage over traditional abbattoirs (this being the real reason why it is impossible to get non halal meat anymore) Then theres the Cultural things like, acid attacks, honour killings, illegal sharia courts set up to settle disputes within Muslim communities all are two fingers up to a British legal system that has stood the test of time for centuries. This country gives and gives and gives in the hope that the next Generation of Muslims will somehow get on board and be more tolerant yet the evidence shows that it is indeed the opposite that is happening.
Edited by Ouzo Dan (19 Jul 2016 8.18pm)
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall
apologies if posted elsewhere. Went looking for the news as not many are covering it. What makes a man holidaying with his own family decide to throw away his own life, destroy the lives of his own children and try to kill a mother & her three children? In this case Islam... Of course people will say that she should have dressed herself and her children more appropriately.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
The Burka is an affront to Women's rights & has no place in a relatively free & democratic society. It is worn in the desert, made of cheap nylon & it is almost always black & designed to cover as much as possible. Why on earth anyone who wants to stand up for womens rights would choose to turn a blind eye to this is taking society backwards & reeks of hypocrisy. Islam by & large is deeply homophobic. Halal slaughter is f***ing evil. Seperation of religion & state These are lines in the sand among many many reasons & there should be absolutely no movement from us. Instead we allow the suffering of women and even celebrate it. Turn a blind eye to the absolutely disgusting levels of homophobia that exist within the British muslim community. Halal slaughter is tolerated, f*** we even give tax breaks to religious slaughter houses giving them the advantage over traditional abbattoirs (this being the real reason why it is impossible to get non halal meat anymore) Then theres the Cultural things like, acid attacks, honour killings, illegal sharia courts set up to settle disputes within Muslim communities all are two fingers up to a British legal system that has stood the test of time for centuries. This country gives and gives and gives in the hope that the next Generation of Muslims will somehow get on board and be more tolerant yet the evidence shows that it is indeed the opposite that is happening.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
Halal slaughter is tolerated, f*** we even give tax breaks to religious slaughter houses giving them the advantage over traditional abbattoirs (this being the real reason why it is impossible to get non halal meat anymore) I'm not having any problems buying non Halal meat. Maybe if you live in West Ham, parts of Oldham and Rotherham or you only eat out of the cheapest fried chicken shops you have difficulty.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I'm not having any problems buying non Halal meat. Maybe if you live in West Ham, parts of Oldham and Rotherham or you only eat out of the cheapest fried chicken shops you have difficulty. Every meat product in a supermarket apart from pork & fish is slaughtered in the halal way, supermarkets even have the cheek to have halal sections when the 'non halal' meat is actually the same just with a different label, it's also why a couple of years back the house of commons voted out the idea of correctly labelling where your meat was slaughtered.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
I dare say to many non of these actually happened. Now with some bloke from Afghan attacking four people on a train in Germany and three people from one family knifed for wearing just tee-shirts and shorts because it didn't agree with his religion. Someone tell me why we should bow down to their way of life. If I went to a muslim country and asked to open a church for Christians do you think I;d be able to get away with. No of course I wouldn't. So why do we allow this to happen here? Thats right because most of the local councils are run by NON British people. And please, no one give me the human rights sh1t please. FFS
|
|
|
Originally posted by sniffer dagenham
I dare say to many non of these actually happened. Now with some bloke from Afghan attacking four people on a train in Germany and three people from one family knifed for wearing just tee-shirts and shorts because it didn't agree with his religion. Someone tell me why we should bow down to their way of life. If I went to a muslim country and asked to open a church for Christians do you think I;d be able to get away with. No of course I wouldn't. So why do we allow this to happen here? Thats right because most of the local councils are run by NON British people. And please, no one give me the human rights sh1t please. FFS It's a shocking and, sadly, true headline and only around 50-60 perpetrators in total committed those acts. Mass murder by the few out of the 1.1billion Muslims.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
It's a shocking and, sadly, true headline and only around 50-60 perpetrators in total committed those acts. Mass murder by the few out of the 1.1billion Muslims. Not all Germans were Nazis either.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
IS and their like are to Islam what the Klan is to Christianity. Borrowed from the West Wing 9/11 episode.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
Not all Germans were Nazis either. No, but then most Muslims aren't fighting in a war. Whilst not all Germans were Nazis, plenty of Germans fought in the war, for their government, who were Nazis and carried out their orders. I don't think the analogy holds, given the number of Muslims that are engaged in the war against IS in Syria and Islamic extremists (who generally are fighting against other Muslims).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
I don't think you've read the conversation jamie and I have been having if you don't think it's about religion. That, and the law, have been the crux of it. If you can't acknowledge that a certain religion has been a common theme amongst multiple incidents of late, you're blind. They've been different nationalities, different ages, born there or immigrated to there, acted as a group or as an individual. The theme isn't Facebook or Twitter ffs. I don't think you can rule Islam out of the equation - Radical Islamic Sunni and Sufist movements in particular. Its a complex picture. However Islam is a very broad category.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I'm sorry but we are in 2016 and what has gone before is not important. Things have changed across Europe. The irony of your position is that you say that nothing is sacred in terms of our principles as a Western nation and that claiming so is extremism and dealing in absolutes and then in the next breath you say that we can change our laws to pander to someone else's sacred beliefs. Yes a few million Britons are Muslim and most are just getting on with life but they are in a Western country and in a tiny minority. Why on earth should we change our laws simply because the extremist branch of their religion are systematically attacking our citizens? That would be appeasement plain and simple. That, however well intentioned, would be a very grave error and one that the vast majority of British people would reject. They would see such a move for what it is. We must think about the future of Britain and how our decisions now will impact on it. We failed to do so in the past. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Jul 2016 7.00pm) I'm not advocating compromising with the extremists, but with the inclusion and social integration of the 99% unhostile every day, run of the mill, bloke next door Muslim and addressing their political issues, concerns and experiences. Extremists like IS, have made their choice. But its important to remember that in fighting the threat of the Provisional IRA, broadly targeting Republicans and Catholics and effectively treating them as 'the same' only created greater influence and power for the IRA.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I'm not advocating compromising with the extremists, but with the inclusion and social integration of the 99% unhostile every day, run of the mill, bloke next door Muslim and addressing their political issues, concerns and experiences. Extremists like IS, have made their choice. But its important to remember that in fighting the threat of the Provisional IRA, broadly targeting Republicans and Catholics and effectively treating them as 'the same' only created greater influence and power for the IRA. What you are proposing is changing British law to pander to religious nonsense. The guilt or innocence of Muslims with regard to terrorism is secondary.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
No, but then most Muslims aren't fighting in a war. Whilst not all Germans were Nazis, plenty of Germans fought in the war, for their government, who were Nazis and carried out their orders. I don't think the analogy holds, given the number of Muslims that are engaged in the war against IS in Syria and Islamic extremists (who generally are fighting against other Muslims). Is that a fact ? well I suggest you visit Afghan, Western Africa, Iran, Iraq, the Balkans, basically everywhere were the Muslim faith is the ruling religion there is trouble,(bar the kingdom of saudi and we all know why that it.) there is no getting away from it Jamie, as unpalatable as it may be for some, the religion of Islam has no place in a modern progressive society that tolerates all.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.