You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.
November 16 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle fan- I come in peace.


Page 8 of 15 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 12.08pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe
My point is that everyone is failing at Newcastle. perhaps there is a wider problem you should spend your time on rather than stalking our club. That's inaccurate though. It's not true that everyone is failing at Newcastle. Also, my time is easily shared between many things.



Well he didnt keep you up did he - and has had a worse start to the season than Pardew but is our club you choose to stalk

No he didn't but to blame him for that is to ignore a whole host of reasons that pain a far broader picture of the situation h inherited.


Given the personal abuse that Pardew experienced that is a hilarious comment.

Ad hominem attacks don't move a discussion forward, unfortunately it's not possible for a fanbase to have a meaningful discussion with a manager like Pardew, the soundbites need to be pithy and quotable. Hence the "Welsh town" banner, but on the whole the abuse Pardew got was for his ability or his demonstrated behaviour, not his character.



I think it is thoroughly unhealthy that you are letting Pardew take over your life. Get a girlfriend or something.

I mean, this is just creative writing course now, isn't it? None of this has any basis in reality and is another logical fallacy

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 17 Aug 16 12.08pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Have you noticed how many "Pardew out" threads there are on this forum? Does that make us vindictive scum too?


its nothing to do with Palace supporters wanting Pardew out or not. It is supporters of a club previously managed by Pardew (or anyone else) stalking him into later jobs. For example Palace supporters going on to Hull forums and stirring things up.

We get to choose or even abuse our own manager. We dont need help from outsiders with ill intent

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 17 Aug 16 12.12pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I mean, this is just creative writing course now, isn't it? None of this has any basis in reality and is another logical fallacy

You are way too occupied with what your former managers are doing - especially when things aren't exactly going well out the moment. You would have a shred of credibility if you are able to argue how much better things have gone since you forced him out.

instead your argument is - sack Pardew get relegated.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 17 Aug 16 12.13pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I mean, this is just creative writing course now, isn't it? None of this has any basis in reality and is another logical fallacy

The fat, gravy stained shirt, horse punching Jawdee Nation sh*tehawk's back I see. Shouldn't you be posting on a Rotherham board or something?

 

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 12.41pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

You are way too occupied with what your former managers are doing - especially when things aren't exactly going well out the moment. You would have a shred of credibility if you are able to argue how much better things have gone since you forced him out.

instead your argument is - sack Pardew get relegated.

That is not my argument at all. I can't imagine why you would claim that was my argument. My argument is; "If I were you I'd replace Pardew before it's too late"

Also, there are parts of my clubs that have improved since Pardew's departure. The chasm between the club and the fanbase is being bridged, the backroom staff are competent and ambitious, there has been investment in the community, and on the facilities at the club. Our fortunes on the pitch will improve too and I'm confident they'll surpass our performances under Alan Pardew.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 17 Aug 16 12.53pm

Originally posted by TheFish

That is not my argument at all. I can't imagine why you would claim that was my argument. My argument is; "If I were you I'd replace Pardew before it's too late"

Also, there are parts of my clubs that have improved since Pardew's departure. The chasm between the club and the fanbase is being bridged, the backroom staff are competent and ambitious, there has been investment in the community, and on the facilities at the club. Our fortunes on the pitch will improve too and I'm confident they'll surpass our performances under Alan Pardew.


Given your clubs history of under-performance and lack of self awareness why would we care what you think?


As I say you would have a scintilla of credibility if you were successful after forcing Pardew out but things got even worse. Newcastle have become a by-word for "do the opposite to them". You even make Sunderland look competent at the moment and they, as Dave Kitson has written they really are a shambles of a club.

 

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 1.11pm

I wonder if adrianB has ever been on a train to Newcastle.

 




ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Aug 16 1.27pm

Pardew must have shagged a lot of wives and girlfriends up there considering the obvious ire still directed towards him.
I guess it must be Pards fault that Toon are still deluded and average championship material at best. Perhaps I will start a website 'deluded Toon fans out' and write some stupid articles and say they are complete fact - as maybe they are part of the problem by failing to back their team even when they were doing ok.
The one fact completely skirted around is that Newcastle were 8th in the league when Pards left. They then survived by one point with 'one of their own'. Then 'one of their own' basically put them down. Then a Spaniard came in and was give loads of money. He got a couple of results but is failing with a squad of stars in the second tier of football.
I would say there is a problem at the club bigger than once having Pardew as a manager - and everyone should recognise it - before it's too late.
And yes - put this on your Geordie boards. As I have previously stated Pardew will go soon enough if result are bad. That's the business we are in. We really don't need Newcastle fans to worry about us. The fascination with Pards is really quite unbelievable. I reckon most of these guys are Brighton trolls fuelled by a couple of recent results.

 


Red and Blue Army!

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 1.27pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe
Given your clubs history of under-performance and lack of self awareness why would we care what you think?


As I say you would have a scintilla of credibility if you were successful after forcing Pardew out but things got even worse. Newcastle have become a by-word for "do the opposite to them". You even make Sunderland look competent at the moment and they, as Dave Kitson has written they really are a shambles of a club.

You keep trying to win internet points by insulting me and my club; will you be able to move past that and have an actual conversation if I pretend you've really upset me?

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 17 Aug 16 1.43pm

Originally posted by TheFish


You keep trying to win internet points by insulting me and my club; will you be able to move past that and have an actual conversation if I pretend you've really upset me?


Not interested in "points" I simply struggle to understand

a) what in your team's recent history makes you an expert in giving other teams "advice" over who their manager should be. For instance if you sacked Pardew and were now in the Europa League that would be of interest

b) how someone can be so fixated with an ex-manager that you still need to follow him around. Aren't there more rewarding things to focus on?

c) Why you think we are interested in the views of other teams fans when deciding on who our manager would be.

My view is you are nothing more than a s***-stirrer hoping to foment a bit more hate towards your nemesis and hence there is no "conversation" to be had.

 

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 1.48pm

I think he has proven he is a sh*t stirrer given that I have asked twice as to what he believes we ought to do with his "warning" about Pardew and he hasn't responded.

I am suspicious that he didn't actually come here looking to assist a club he has a soft spot for given that he hasn't yet clarified how this warning ought to manifest itself as something productive and constructive. The only logical conclusion, until I am proven wrong with a suggestion of a plan of action, is that he is here on the (so far successful) mission to wind us up.

 




Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 17 Aug 16 1.51pm

Originally posted by TheFish

You keep trying to win internet points by insulting me and my club; will you be able to move past that and have an actual conversation if I pretend you've really upset me?

Or possibly you could have some sense of self awareness and realise that your input on this board isn't appreciated?

 

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 1.51pm

And FYI, coming on here to wind us up isn't something I necessarily find annoying. I actually quite enjoy the response it gets!

 




TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 1.59pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe
Not interested in "points" I simply struggle to understand

a) what in your team's recent history makes you an expert in giving other teams "advice" over who their manager should be. For instance if you sacked Pardew and were now in the Europa League that would be of interest
If a bloke has been to a bad restaurant, he can advise you not to go there. That he now has the s***s doesn't make his review any less valid.

b) how someone can be so fixated with an ex-manager that you still need to follow him around. Aren't there more rewarding things to focus on? I'm perfectly able to spare 3 minutes every now and then throughout the day to chat about a common threat with such a welcoming crowd.

c) Why you think we are interested in the views of other teams fans when deciding on who our manager would be. because I've suffered Pardew's football and have an insight that those who, by their own admission, blindly support a manger may not.

My view is you are nothing more than a s***-stirrer hoping to foment a bit more hate towards your nemesis and hence there is no "conversation" to be had.


Nemesis... I'm not Holmes and Pardew is no Moriarty.

I'm honestly interested in hearing people's defence of the man, but I've seen none. All I've seen is 1 or 2 Newcastle fans, and a number of Palace fans criticising Alan Pardew's ability and being met with little more than a stream of abuse.

 

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 2.01pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I think he has proven he is a sh*t stirrer given that I have asked twice as to what he believes we ought to do with his "warning" about Pardew and he hasn't responded.

I am suspicious that he didn't actually come here looking to assist a club he has a soft spot for given that he hasn't yet clarified how this warning ought to manifest itself as something productive and constructive. The only logical conclusion, until I am proven wrong with a suggestion of a plan of action, is that he is here on the (so far successful) mission to wind us up.

I have made a suggestion, but I'll reiterate.

Apply pressure on your owner to make a change. This can be done with protests, chants, boycotts* or public appeals for change.


*I don't think you need to go that far just yet.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Aug 16 2.06pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I have made a suggestion, but I'll reiterate.

Apply pressure on your owner to make a change. This can be done with protests, chants, boycotts* or public appeals for change.


*I don't think you need to go that far just yet.

We don't have the most patient ownership and they will sack Pardew if league results continue to be poor. There is no way we are silly enough to start a campaign about it - well I hope not anyway.

I will make some defence of Pardew if you like. Our footballing style is far easier on the eye than it was probably in the whole time since Coppell. Problem seems to have been that we had injuries and went on a run of bad form. We seem to lack confidence but a couple of wins could change that.
You can always come back to the HOL and say I told you so when we lose another couple of league games. You may, or may not, have long to wait.

Edited by ASCPFC (17 Aug 2016 2.07pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 2.07pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I have made a suggestion, but I'll reiterate.

Apply pressure on your owner to make a change. This can be done with protests, chants, boycotts* or public appeals for change.


*I don't think you need to go that far just yet.

My personal opinion though is that protests, after one league game of the season (and possibly further into the season) are probably going to make things worse on the pitch. We've had a pretty decent and positive atmosphere at Selhurst for a while now and I am not entirely convinced us boycotting Palace, chanting Pardew out or painting protest signs are actually going to make things better. Innocent question, but did you feel those things at Newcastle resolved anything when that kind of thing was going on? I'm not trying to point score, you might actually say yes.

 




Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 2.09pm

I should add, that I don't think firing Pardew is something I want right now anyway. I have some serious doubts, but I have bigger doubts about what would happen if we booted him out now. I also have some doubts as to whether, as fans, we know all the facts about the stalled transfer deals.

 




Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 17 Aug 16 2.09pm

Originally posted by TheFish


Nemesis... I'm not Holmes and Pardew is no Moriarty.

I'm honestly interested in hearing people's defence of the man, but I've seen none. All I've seen is 1 or 2 Newcastle fans, and a number of Palace fans criticizing Alan Pardew's ability and being met with little more than a stream of abuse.

Firstly I simply don't believe you are somehow interested in our views in a mutual exchange of bonhomie. You have too much history with Pardew.

You are getting the same response as we would get on your forums if we came on telling you what was wrong at your club.

Thirdly there is more of a tendency to keep our criticism of club or personalities in house rather than have dozens and dozens phoning in to 606 every week like your fans. Not saying it doesn't happen just that we don't have the same culture of victimhood are you have.


Bye

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 17 Aug 16 2.11pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

Firstly I simply don't believe you are somehow interested in our views in a mutual exchange of bonhomie. You have too much history with Pardew.

You are getting the same response as we would get on your forums if we came on telling you what was wrong at your club.

Thirdly there is more of a tendency to keep our criticism of club or personalities in house rather than have dozens and dozens phoning in to 606 every week like your fans. Not saying it doesn't happen just that we don't have the same culture of victimhood are you have.


Bye

The scousers of the North East.

 

Page 8 of 15 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.