This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
You clearly haven't read some of my posts. I have consistently stated that referees are only human and as such DO make err from time to time, as do managers,players etc etc. I have also consistently stated that we all have the benefit of umpteen replays etc etc etc whereas a referee has to make a split-second decision in real-time and often his view is obscured by players in his/her way.I can totally understand why they get some decisions wrong. What I do find galling is the assertion that a PL referee doesn't know "Advantage" or doesn't properly know all the laws.This is totally and utterly ridiculous.There is one thing knowing them and another applying them and of course from time to time they don't apply them correctly for reasons which I have already explained. Edited by Willo (07 Oct 2016 5.49pm) I think you are right in that the refs DO know the laws of the game. The point I think that you consistently miss is that they do not apply them to a consistent level, and whether that is error or deliberate is the thing I cannot get my head around. Your boyfriend clearly knows advantage but failed to allow it for us, which would have led to a credible scoring opportunity and, I suspect, a goal. However, in my personal opinion, he does not seem to make such mistakes in favour of the 'big' teams. The pally pally bit with SAF just wound everybody up and was another error of judgement on the day. Jon Moss just took the easy decision, in a home game and has probably looked at it again and realised he had a very poor game. For that he should be demoted for a while because it was a bad decision. Edited by Helmet46 (08 Oct 2016 7.07am) Edited by Helmet46 (08 Oct 2016 7.14am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Inapickle
..if Lukaku's shot had gone along the ground they would have done their job, everyone enjoys watching De Bruyne. It is very rare for a free-kick to be scored under a wall with most kicks aimed over such a wall.We all saw Mandanda's reaction after the goal was scored.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
I think you are right in that the refs DO know the laws of the game. The point I think that you consistently miss is that they do not apply them to a consistent level, and whether that is error or deliberate is the thing I cannot get my head around. Your boyfriend clearly knows advantage but failed to allow it for us, which would have led to a credible scoring opportunity and, I suspect, a goal. However, in my personal opinion, he does not seem to make such mistakes in favour of the 'big' teams. The pally pally bit with SAF just wound everybody up and was another error of judgement on the day. Jon Moss just took the easy decision, in a home game and has probably looked at it again and realised he had a very poor game. For that he should be demoted for a while because it was a bad decision. Edited by Helmet46 (08 Oct 2016 7.07am) Edited by Helmet46 (08 Oct 2016 7.14am) Are you seriously suggesting that Moss should be demoted because of a single decision ? After each game there is a robust and forensic examination of the performance of the referee by 'Match delegates' etc with 'ProZone' used etc etc.This happens after each and every game and IF any referee consistently falls below the required standard he will be demoted - just ask Stuart Attwell ! Jon Moss is still on the list. I'm NOT getting into any of the accusations made against Clattenburg as I have already answered all these 'Charges' and will refrain from getting involved in any further discussions involving Mark as it only provides ammunition to the 'Bait layers'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Are you seriously suggesting that Moss should be demoted because of a single decision ? After each game there is a robust and forensic examination of the performance of the referee by 'Match delegates' etc with 'ProZone' used etc etc.This happens after each and every game and IF any referee consistently falls below the required standard he will be demoted - just ask Stuart Attwell ! Jon Moss is still on the list. I'm NOT getting into any of the accusations made against Clattenburg as I have already answered all these 'Charges' and will refrain from getting involved in any further discussions involving Mark as it only provides ammunition to the 'Bait layers'.
Probably didn't articulate that well enough. In my opinion Moss should be dropped for the overall performance. In the same way you like to bang on about players and managers making mistakes - a player is dropped if he makes a lot and a manager is sacked. In my view, there were a fair few in that game, so I'd drop him - maybe only for a game or two, but time on the bench so to speak. That is a way to get standards up. You also often wax lyrical about 'one mistake' but that's because the ones in focus are the ones that tend to lead to goals etc. How about the overall inconsistency in approach to holding in the box at corners, free kicks given in the middle of the park when they'd not give a penalty for the same thing etc etc? As to Clattenburg, if you take the time to read my post, the main question I am posing asks that with the low salary refs are on, compared to the rest of the game, in a cash rich sport - could there be temptation there? I am not implying corruption, just asking for thoughts. For example, should they earn more, should more technology be introduced - as both would remove the spectre of temptation (if it exists). I'm also not implying your man would ever take a back hander. That is clearly evidenced by his hair. Anyone with a few quid would have got that sorted, properly, in a salon and by a fully qualified and experienced stylist, I would suggest. Expensive but worth it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
Probably didn't articulate that well enough. In my opinion Moss should be dropped for the overall performance. In the same way you like to bang on about players and managers making mistakes - a player is dropped if he makes a lot and a manager is sacked. In my view, there were a fair few in that game, so I'd drop him - maybe only for a game or two, but time on the bench so to speak. That is a way to get standards up. You also often wax lyrical about 'one mistake' but that's because the ones in focus are the ones that tend to lead to goals etc. How about the overall inconsistency in approach to holding in the box at corners, free kicks given in the middle of the park when they'd not give a penalty for the same thing etc etc? As to Clattenburg, if you take the time to read my post, the main question I am posing asks that with the low salary refs are on, compared to the rest of the game, in a cash rich sport - could there be temptation there? I am not implying corruption, just asking for thoughts. For example, should they earn more, should more technology be introduced - as both would remove the spectre of temptation (if it exists). I'm also not implying your man would ever take a back hander. That is clearly evidenced by his hair. Anyone with a few quid would have got that sorted, properly, in a salon and by a fully qualified and experienced stylist, I would suggest. Expensive but worth it.
People have been banging on about "Inconsistency" since time immorial.Funny that when one's team appears to have been advantaged by what one deems as "Inconsistency" then one never hears a squeak.At the end of the day no two incidents/tackles etc etc etc are the same in terms of detail,severity , besides different referees can have different angles of view, indeed can have players obsuring or partly obscuring their line of sight.Also down to interpretation etc etc so one cannot have 100% consistency across the board. In terms of technology, of course we know it's available but there are question marks about it's application in various circumstances and as the American saying goes "The devil is in the detail". Finally as I mentioned. I'm not going to comment on any comment made in respect of Clattenburg for the reasons I have stated. Edited by Willo (08 Oct 2016 9.50am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
People have been banging on about "Inconsistency" since time immorial.Funny that when one's team appears to have been advantaged by what one deems as "Inconsistency" then one never hears a squeak.At the end of the day no two incidents/tackles etc etc etc are the same in terms of detail,severity , besides different referees can have different angles of view, indeed can have players obsuring or partly obscuring their line of sight.Also down to interpretation etc etc so one cannot have 100% consistency across the board. In terms of technology, of course we know it's available but there are question marks about it's application in various circumstances and as the American saying goes "The devil is in the detail". Finally as I mentioned. I'm not going to comment on any comment made in respect of Clattenburg for the reasons I have stated. Edited by Willo (08 Oct 2016 9.50am) Not even on his hair? You can't agree with that, surely? Edited by Helmet46 (08 Oct 2016 9.57am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
Not even on his hair? You can't agree with that, surely? Edited by Helmet46 (08 Oct 2016 9.57am) Given the amount of money paid to PL players and managers there is a case for saying that the PL Elite referees should earn more. In terms of diving/simulation the players are so good at it that often it is very hard to spot with the 'Naked' eye in real time and I'm happy to say that I have seen referees make terrific decisions when issuing a card for simulation in the penalty area with many thinking it was a cast-iron penalty. Edited by Willo (08 Oct 2016 10.10am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Are you seriously suggesting that Moss should be demoted because of a single decision ? After each game there is a robust and forensic examination of the performance of the referee by 'Match delegates' etc with 'ProZone' used etc etc.This happens after each and every game and IF any referee consistently falls below the required standard he will be demoted - just ask Stuart Attwell ! Jon Moss is still on the list. I'm NOT getting into any of the accusations made against Clattenburg as I have already answered all these 'Charges' and will refrain from getting involved in any further discussions involving Mark as it only provides ammunition to the 'Bait layers'.
I read something in the paper last week, written by an ex ref that was basically saying Moss makes far to many mistakes and far to often. And that in his opinion he should be demoted and not ref any premier league matches for a while. Now that was a hugely experienced ex ref talking about one of his own. And yet you Willo as always defend defend defend. Even when it's obviously a costly error
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
I read something in the paper last week, written by an ex ref that was basically saying Moss makes far to many mistakes and far to often. And that in his opinion he should be demoted and not ref any premier league matches for a while. Now that was a hugely experienced ex ref talking about one of his own. And yet you Willo as always defend defend defend. Even when it's obviously a costly error If the wall had jumped (As most walls do) then the likelihood is they wouldn't have scored.We saw Mandanda annoyed that they hadn't jumped.
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
People.....arguing with Willo about referees is somewhat akin to arguing with porridge...he will defend referees whatever the situation and will always try and deflect the argument by saying that players make mistakes too...yes Willo we know, and we also know that St mark of Clattenberg certainly seems to favour the better sides week in week out! However you will never admit that, even when you see it yourself..re cup final! He made two major errors, every pundit said so, ive had a man u fan here this week and he said we were cheated by the ref, you were/are the only voice defending him...why??? Moss made a big error and once again you defend the referee? I reckon you are a referee fan rather than a Palace fan, but if that floats your boat, fine. Just don't expect many to agree with you It only became a "Big error" in many people's minds because our wall didn't jump ! As for defending Moss, I have said that numerous TV replays and super slow-mos confirmed there was no contact but the referee never had the advantage of seeing them and in real-time it did look as though contact had been made.If Lukaku hadn't have scored we wouldn't be having any discussion, nor Moss pilloried for making what you term a "Big error".
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
If the wall had jumped (As most walls do) then the likelihood is they wouldn't have scored.We saw Mandanda annoyed that they hadn't jumped. So what you're actually saying is it's ok for a ref to make a blatant error if the team on the wrong end of his decision doesn't defend the illegitimate free kick successfully?
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
It only became a "Big error" in many people's minds because our wall didn't jump ! As for defending Moss, I have said that numerous TV replays and super slow-mos confirmed there was no contact but the referee never had the advantage of seeing them and in real-time it did look as though contact had been made.If Lukaku hadn't have scored we wouldn't be having any discussion, nor Moss pilloried for making what you term a "Big error". Seriously? If any contact had been made in that challenge then there is no way Jagielka would've been unmarked/unharmed in any way!
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
So what you're actually saying is it's ok for a ref to make a blatant error if the team on the wrong end of his decision doesn't defend the illegitimate free kick successfully? Not saying that at all. And I don't think it was "Blatant" as it looked for all the world that there was contact.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 08 Oct 16 11.29am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
It only became a "Big error" in many people's minds because our wall didn't jump ! As for defending Moss, I have said that numerous TV replays and super slow-mos confirmed there was no contact but the referee never had the advantage of seeing them and in real-time it did look as though contact had been made.If Lukaku hadn't have scored we wouldn't be having any discussion, nor Moss pilloried for making what you term a "Big error". Why do you constantly repeat the same argument? Saying things over and over again won't wear any of us down or change our opinion of Moss or Clattenburg. I am a qualified referee and have a very close friend that is also fully qualified. Both of us agree that Moss and Clattenburg are inconsistent in the way they apply the laws. Both have ego problems although Moss' is to a lesser degree, but he has fitness issues and regularly makes decisions from too far away from the incident and appears to guess. Please don't respond with the same tired arguments and mantras that you usually resort to. My father taught me that it was noble to stick to your guns, but when everyone else disagrees with you, maybe it's time to re-evaluate your position and rethink it. You are so out of touch on this matter as you have painted yourself into a corner and your credibility is less than zero. Edited by Hoof Hearted (08 Oct 2016 11.30am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Why do you constantly repeat the same argument? Saying things over and over again won't wear any of us down or change our opinion of Moss or Clattenburg. I am a qualified referee and have a very close friend that is also fully qualified. Both of us agree that Moss and Clattenburg are inconsistent in the way they apply the laws. Both have ego problems although Moss' is to a lesser degree, but he has fitness issues and regularly makes decisions from too far away from the incident and appears to guess. Please don't respond with the same tired arguments and mantras that you usually resort to. My father taught me that it was noble to stick to your guns, but when everyone else disagrees with you, maybe it's time to re-evaluate your position and rethink it. You are so out of touch on this matter as you have painted yourself into a corner and your credibility is less than zero. Edited by Hoof Hearted (08 Oct 2016 11.30am) With respect when posters on here come up with the same arguments as part of their pilloring of referees then of course I am only going to respond in similar fashion.For avoidance of doubt, I also qualified as a referee albeit some while ago. As for "Tired arguments" perhaps you should have aimed your 'Fire' at those in the 'Anti-Referee' camp.As this is a forum for debate, I am entitled to respond to the 'Charges' Finally, I don't give a jot what you have concluded about my "Credibility". You are clearly under the mis-apprehension that I actually care about the negatives you hurl in my direction. Edited by Willo (08 Oct 2016 11.40am)
|
|
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
Seriously? If any contact had been made in that challenge then there is no way Jagielka would've been unmarked/unharmed in any way! How do you know that then mate,seriously? Ive been kicked in the head on quite a few occasions challenging for a loose ball and while I had my nose broken twice ive also got up plenty of times without a scratch on me. Just because you think you know doesn't mean you do. Jagielka actually snaps his head back himself at the same time he puts his hands up,its a natural reflex in that situation.How do you unequivocally know that standing in the same position as Moss it wouldn't have looked like Delaneys foot caught Jagielka when he pulled his head back? You f@cking don't,just like all the others on here swinging their dicks about.Willo may well be wrong about Clattenburg but this particular argument has nothing to do with that does it.Willo is imo one of the few who understands that this incident is open to interpretation.The high % of Everton fans will say he got it right until a similar situation costs them,and guess what a similar proportion of Palace fans are screaming foul play.Surprising,hardly.As I said before,unless Moss comes out and explains the reasons for his decision making then its just pure conjecture on what he got wrong and why.
|
|
|
Originally posted by citizensmudge
How do you know that then mate,seriously? Ive been kicked in the head on quite a few occasions challenging for a loose ball and while I had my nose broken twice ive also got up plenty of times without a scratch on me. Just because you think you know doesn't mean you do. Jagielka actually snaps his head back himself at the same time he puts his hands up,its a natural reflex in that situation.How do you unequivocally know that standing in the same position as Moss it wouldn't have looked like Delaneys foot caught Jagielka when he pulled his head back? You f@cking don't,just like all the others on here swinging their dicks about.Willo may well be wrong about Clattenburg but this particular argument has nothing to do with that does it.Willo is imo one of the few who understands that this incident is open to interpretation.The high % of Everton fans will say he got it right until a similar situation costs them,and guess what a similar proportion of Palace fans are screaming foul play.Surprising,hardly.As I said before,unless Moss comes out and explains the reasons for his decision making then its just pure conjecture on what he got wrong and why. Referees are contractually not allowed to speak to the media so they don't have an opportunity to defend themselves.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect when posters on here come up with the same arguments as part of their pilloring of referees then of course I am only going to respond in similar fashion.For avoidance of doubt, I also qualified as a referee albeit some while ago. As for "Tired arguments" perhaps you should have aimed your 'Fire' at those in the 'Anti-Referee' camp.As this is a forum for debate, I am entitled to respond to the 'Charges' Finally, I don't give a jot what you have concluded about my "Credibility". You are clearly under the mis-apprehension that I actually care about the negatives you hurl in my direction. Edited by Willo (08 Oct 2016 11.40am) Everyone's a referee (yawn) which means that we all understand the laws, their application and the stresses of the game - with abuse hurled from all directions. The problem is that any errors you made when reffing little Mark in the U8's don't readily antagonise huge swathes of people and potentially have financial repercussions.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.