You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Mandanda
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Steve Mandanda


Page 8 of 19 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
slubglurge Flag welling 06 Nov 16 6.31pm

Hes brought in a ball playing goalkeeper to play out from the back but we dont have one defender comfortable with the ball at their feet so all it is going to do is cause problems

 

chateauferret Flag 06 Nov 16 7.52pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Funny how it was Henessey or Mcarthys fault but never Speroni and now Mandandas.

I don't recall not complaining about Hennessey cockups last season and I do remember observing that his confidence seemed shot at one point and needed to be rebuilt.

I also don't recall seeing Hennessey exposed by such absent defending on more than an occasional basis.

The goalkeeping isn't the problem. Expose the goalkeeper like this and you could have Neuer in goal and still lose.

 


============
The Ferret
============

bicycle repair man 06 Nov 16 8.20pm

Mandanda is doing fine with no major calamities occurring. People were going on about his terrible blunder for the 2nd goal at Burnley ,but having watched it for me he did well to get something on the ball and was very unlucky with the ricochet.
At the moment it must be a nightmare playing behind that defence.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 06 Nov 16 9.11pm

There is quite difference of opinion. I hope it doesn't go like other threads and just descend into open abuse, but I think he's not performed well. First and second goals yesterday he could and should have done better and I remain of the view that he could have done better against Liverpool as well.
What do we do, drop him for WH? I like Wayne, but as someone has said AP is stubborn and unless he has an absolute nightmare I think he will stick with him. But he is certainly NOT one of the best goalkeepers in the PL and I suspect the only ones who do think so are palace diehards.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

bicycle repair man 06 Nov 16 9.21pm

I expect he is used to playing behind defenders who know what they are doing.Most of the top keepers are at teams with decent defences.

 

SeagullHunter Flag Reading 06 Nov 16 10.14pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I don't recall not complaining about Hennessey cockups last season and I do remember observing that his confidence seemed shot at one point and needed to be rebuilt.

I also don't recall seeing Hennessey exposed by such absent defending on more than an occasional basis.

The goalkeeping isn't the problem. Expose the goalkeeper like this and you could have Neuer in goal and still lose.

Correct. If it wasn't for Mandanda Liverpool would have scored a minimum of 6, and people seem to be forgetting the double save made against Burnley, which I felt redeemed his earlier error.

 


Dont let Cabaye go

HeathMan Flag Purley 06 Nov 16 10.40pm


I don't recall not complaining about Hennessey cockups last season and I do remember observing that his confidence seemed shot at one point and needed to be rebuilt.

I also don't recall seeing Hennessey exposed by such absent defending on more than an occasional basis.

The goalkeeping isn't the problem. Expose the goalkeeper like this and you could have Neuer in goal and still lose.

Correct. If it wasn't for Mandanda Liverpool would have scored a minimum of 6, and people seem to be forgetting the double save made against Burnley, which I felt redeemed his earlier error.

Steve is approaching starting for France - he is certainly showing he is capable.

 

chateauferret Flag 06 Nov 16 10.40pm

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

Correct. If it wasn't for Mandanda Liverpool would have scored a minimum of 6, and people seem to be forgetting the double save made against Burnley, which I felt redeemed his earlier error.

Indeed. Had that gone in it would probably have been over and done with there and then.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Nov 16 10.47pm

One cannot dispute that Mandanda could have done much better with the 2nd goal.It was somewhat embarrassing for him.I cannot help thinking that if Hennessey had failed to keep out that shot in similar fashion he would have pilloried to the heavens on here.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 06 Nov 16 10.57pm

Last season people on here said that the defence didn't trust Hennessey hence all the goals.

Now we are in the same position it's not the keepers fault it's the defence.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

cpj Flag Kent 06 Nov 16 11.43pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

Mandanda is doing fine with no major calamities occurring. People were going on about his terrible blunder for the 2nd goal at Burnley ,but having watched it for me he did well to get something on the ball and was very unlucky with the ricochet.
At the moment it must be a nightmare playing behind that defence.

Sorry, but are you SM? You really think we're lucky that our keeper managed to get anything on a shot aimed at the middle of the goal? Good grief.

 

Flightsequence Flag 07 Nov 16 6.08am

Originally posted by cpj

Sorry, but are you SM? You really think we're lucky that our keeper managed to get anything on a shot aimed at the middle of the goal? Good grief.

I also agree with BRM. I thought he did well to get anything on it. It was travelling like a bullet and he was lucky to react at all. Think of the pens that are smashed down the middle and keepers get something on it but cant stop it. Granted its closer, but still. Henessey struggled to get down to daisy cutters that were heading to the corners! I think if Mandanda had got the luck and it went over, it would have been logged as a great save.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 07 Nov 16 11.50am

Originally posted by cpj

Sorry, but are you SM? You really think we're lucky that our keeper managed to get anything on a shot aimed at the middle of the goal? Good grief.

Wayne, you'd have still been looking for the ball now and we're halfway through monday

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Nov 16 12.03pm

Originally posted by Flightsequence

I also agree with BRM. I thought he did well to get anything on it. It was travelling like a bullet and he was lucky to react at all. Think of the pens that are smashed down the middle and keepers get something on it but cant stop it. Granted its closer, but still. Henessey struggled to get down to daisy cutters that were heading to the corners! I think if Mandanda had got the luck and it went over, it would have been logged as a great save.

With respect, I don't agree.

It's not as if he would have made a conscious effort to divert it over.Many would deem that he got lucky as he should have made a much better show of dealing with the shot.I'm sure Mandanda himself is disappointed that he never gathered it cleanly.

 

cpj Flag Kent 07 Nov 16 12.04pm

Originally posted by paperhat

Wayne, you'd have still been looking for the ball now and we're halfway through monday

Why are you calling me 'Wayne'?

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 07 Nov 16 12.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect, I don't agree.

It's not as if he would have made a conscious effort to divert it over.Many would deem that he got lucky as he should have made a much better show of dealing with the shot.I'm sure Mandanda himself is disappointed that he never gathered it cleanly.

Better Keeper than Hennessey yes or No ?

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

paperhat Flag croydon 07 Nov 16 12.18pm

Originally posted by cpj

Why are you calling me 'Wayne'?

sorry , my bad.

Mr Hennessy......

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Glazier#1 Flag 07 Nov 16 1.20pm

I thought the shot was whacked really hard and was travelling across the keeper. Steve managed to get a decent touch to it but it was just unlucky that the the ball took that weird ricochet.

I don't think it would have been possible to 'gather cleanly' a ball hit at that pace.

Hardly the greatest error for a goalkeeper we'll ever see. Before I saw it, the way people were talking, it sounded like a proper 'clanger'.

It wasn't.

Originally posted by Willo

With respect, I don't agree.

It's not as if he would have made a conscious effort to divert it over.Many would deem that he got lucky as he should have made a much better show of dealing with the shot.I'm sure Mandanda himself is disappointed that he never gathered it cleanly.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Nov 16 1.26pm

Originally posted by dannyh

Better Keeper than Hennessey yes or No ?

DannyH

I have mentioned on here that to-date I haven't seen anything to suggest that Mandanda is an improvement on Hennessey.Maybe, in time this will change as he adjusts to the PL and defenders in from him.

Regards the 2nd goal on Saturday, some are defending him but from my perspective he made a real hash of it.Differing opinions make up the rich tapestry of HOL !

Edited by Willo (07 Nov 2016 1.39pm)

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 07 Nov 16 1.37pm

I think people are forgetting just what a nightmare was having between the sticks before he got dropped. Mandanda has made saves (like the gorodn banks-esque one against Liverpool that Hennessey could only dream about.

I tend to agree that the 2nd one against us at the weekend was down to an error, and i think his reaction showed that. However he also made a double save later on that more than made up for it.

he is a quality keeper playing behind a less than quality back four and he knows it.

Plus how the f*** is Andy woodman a coach at anything bar darts and drinking the fat git, it's no wonder good keepers come here and go to rats !

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Page 8 of 19 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Mandanda