This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Like I said, I think you'd need to make exception for people who are investors in companies, shareholders, partners etc. because they have an additional financial commitment to the firm and consequently additional risks. I like the idea, but you'd need to specifically allow for people to earn income off their investments as being separate from their salary. The commitment of time is different from personal financial risk. I don't think you can see investments in the same light as Salaried income from working - nor should we. If I earned 200k and then my investment pays me 400k in a year, I don't think it would be fair to consider that 400k salary. Just to clarify. I prefer and agree with these aims from an ethical standpoint. The changes from pay inequality from say the late sixties to now is dramatic. These restrictions would be the better system. I just remain to be convinced in terms of practical effectiveness in terms of business confidence and effect. I know the free market works on many levels...but that the system around it isn't about fairness. I'm definitely less confidence in talking around this field. I'm probably of the view of more effective tax collection....perhaps if their could be harmonizing with the EU to that aim. Though due to the EU's aggressive stance towards the city...which is a significant proportion of our tax base...I would be very careful.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I was surprised at JM mocking my post and I repeat as it is concise and only pointing out 1 thing which all the reports and inquiries miss. If Sadaam had complied with UN resolutions and not ignored them all the UK would not have been legally able to go to war. Sadaam did not have weapons of mass destruction and all that was necessary was to say that at the UN, that would have complied with the UN. resolutions. The attorney general would have advised that there was no legal basis for war and in fact I am sure it was the govts. position. Tony Blair is an experienced lawyer he would not go to war if UN resolutions were complied with, as a resulting war would be illegal and he would be responsible. Why did Sadaam not comply with this simple resolution when he did not have WOMD anyway?? TB prosecuting a war when UN resolutions were complied with? I don't think so. Ok the USA would have by-passed the UN but Blair took the matter to the UN to make the case for war water-tight. If you don't reply or acknowledge the law there is no option but to find you guilty. Which the UN veto'd, and the US and UK had no real authority to enforce against the Security Councils vote. Also, the pretext for war was selective intelligence that just fitted Blairs agenda, and any counter intelligence was ignored. But the reality is that the evidence for WMD in Iraq was an utter shame of informants and sources picked deliberately to build a case for war - That the Prime Minister sold the UK as 'certainity' when at best it was questionable. Able to strike the UK in 45 minutes... The only WMD found (in 2005) were unfit for even storage, let alone use, and seemed to have been in the ownership of a single individual and the US and UK purchased these from that person. Bear in mind the UN Weapons inspectors countered that certainity. Interestingly, during the late 90s, when the Inspectors reported that Iraq was not complying with the UN weapons inspectors - the US and UK did nothing, and in fact hampered the UN from taking further action. Its important to remember that it was the UK and US that asserted that Iraq had retained weapons of mass destruction, which the UN Inspectors could find no evidence of, and that Iraq claimed it had already destroyed. This was the basis of trying to get the UN Resolution 1441 for military action engaged. That the UN inspectors couldn't find something, that Iraq had claimed was destroyed - which turned out to be true. So when you say Iraq wasn't complying, there reality is the UK and US were pursuing a war based on the inability of Iraq to prove something didn't exist, which the UN Inspectors themselves said, did not exist - Which of course meant that Iraq wasn't complying because they couldn't prove that something didn't exist... Yeah, not dodgy at all. You really think Blair was trying to avoid a war, the Bush administration was looking for reasons to invade Iraq from Sept 11 2001, the Blair went along to legitimise it.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Just to clarify. I prefer and agree with these aims from an ethical standpoint. The changes from pay inequality from say the late sixties to now is dramatic. These restrictions would be the better system. I just remain to be convinced in terms of practical effectiveness in terms of business confidence and effect. I know the free market works on many levels...but that the system around it isn't about fairness. I'm definitely less confidence in talking around this field. I'm probably of the view of more effective tax collection....perhaps if their could be harmonizing with the EU to that aim. Though due to the EU's aggressive stance towards the city...which is a significant proportion of our tax base...I would be very careful.
My primary concern would be that it would be an excuse for companies to pay people less at the upper end of the pay scale - Sorry Gerrard, we like you, we love what your doing, but we can't afford to pay the entire minimum wage staff more, so we can't offer you more than 300k and nor can anyone else.... Because capitalists tend to react to ideological issues, with pragmatic resolutions - look at how people reduce their tax burdens - That's the pragmatism of capitalism, its very good at exploiting loopholes.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Could you clarify how Poland's legislative change (which was part of the ruling party's election manifesto) differs from the German* parliament appointing judges to it's highest court? Actually... don't even bother. You're just sucking deep and hard on the pro-EU anti-anything-EUsceptic propaganda that Poland = Bad because Poland = right. * Or Sweden, or the US, or the Netherlands, or Austria. Here's an example article of how Germany appoints judges: Poland wants the ability to do the same. This initiative, proposed by a right-wing government, automatically triggers the EUloons, as they cannot stand it if a nation state thus-aligned begins to exercise it's democratic and sovereign rights. Hence all the (on-doubt) Soros et al. funded EUwailing. I would suggest the EU take Poland to the European Court of Justice, so they can face the judges appointed by... um... oh, member state governments. Oops As to the rest of your post - the old "it's not really socialism" trope wears a bit thin when Corbyn et al have in the past praised it as the enlightened way forwards. Now listen to the weasel-worded prikc: Swap/replace with his IRA spiel. Same old. And yeah, Maduro is indeed a "bit" authoritarian, but (silly me) I would ask that the alternative is to NOT "disappear" your political opponents. You've somehow managed to spend a whole post attacking me for being pro-EU, even though I didn't vote in the referendum and in general am very sceptical of it as an institution. Let's get back to the thread topic. Maduro is, evidently, leading the country towards dictatorship. He has postponed three elections in the past few years and has threatened to use the army had he not won the latest one. That's sh*t politics, and from what I've read and heard, many of the drivers of Chavismo have turned away from him and gone back to grassroots community projects. But another interesting poll I read showed the approval ratings of South American governments. Maduro is on 20%, which is incredibly low, but still higher than the governments of Mexico, Brazil and Columbia. Again, why is it that this thread is so empty of knowledge about these countries? Because while they are irrelevant, Venezuela is supposedly more significant because it is symbolic of Socialism's failure, and thus people starving and dying on the streets in Caracas is evidence against Corbyn in this country. I'm sorry, but this argument is f*cking nonsense. Venezuela's economy is driven by a 97% reliance on oil. It has thousand year old indigenous communities. It suffered under centuries of colonial rule, and until Chavez, the majority of the country lived in poverty. To compare it to Britain, and the form of Socialism which Corbyn is suggesting, is simplistic red-scare crap. Despite it all, I will defend the social policies of Chavez. He raised literacy levels, gave people access to healthcare, subsidised food and improved the rights of women and the LGBT community. Socialism in action.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
You've somehow managed to spend a whole post attacking me for being pro-EU, even though I didn't vote in the referendum and in general am very sceptical of it as an institution. Let's get back to the thread topic. Maduro is, evidently, leading the country towards dictatorship. He has postponed three elections in the past few years and has threatened to use the army had he not won the latest one. That's sh*t politics, and from what I've read and heard, many of the drivers of Chavismo have turned away from him and gone back to grassroots community projects. But another interesting poll I read showed the approval ratings of South American governments. Maduro is on 20%, which is incredibly low, but still higher than the governments of Mexico, Brazil and Columbia. Again, why is it that this thread is so empty of knowledge about these countries? Because while they are irrelevant, Venezuela is supposedly more significant because it is symbolic of Socialism's failure, and thus people starving and dying on the streets in Caracas is evidence against Corbyn in this country. I'm sorry, but this argument is f*cking nonsense. Venezuela's economy is driven by a 97% reliance on oil. It has thousand year old indigenous communities. It suffered under centuries of colonial rule, and until Chavez, the majority of the country lived in poverty. To compare it to Britain, and the form of Socialism which Corbyn is suggesting, is simplistic red-scare crap. Despite it all, I will defend the social policies of Chavez. He raised literacy levels, gave people access to healthcare, subsidised food and improved the rights of women and the LGBT community. Socialism in action. Do you reckon the 20% poll approval comes from his core support which he has effectively bribed with concessions, benefits, free healthcare, etc? Happens all the time with despots.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I agree that comparing Venezuela with Britain in regards to socialism isn't really relevant. However, where it is relevant is where Corbyn supported the form of socialism that Chavez advanced. Effectively Chavez destroyed private industry in Venezuela because of the form of pure socialism he pursued.....Now It can be valid to criticise how capitalism operated in Venezuela before Chavez....sure....but he destroyed it...He didn't alter it. Who wanted to invest after Chavez...I'll tell you who...China...Says everything that. Where was the Corbyn observation or criticism of this? All I can find of Corbyn is praise for Chavez.....This is even at a time when Chavez's human rights record was absolutely terrible. There is most definitely valid criticism that can be aimed at Corbyn. His judgement can be most definitely questioned. I would highly question his knowledge of how economic systems work. He praised Chevez to the hilt.....Chevez ruined Venezuela....He left it worse than before. When you look at that country's resources even half decent leadership would have it amongst the riches in South America.
I would argue against the idea he destroyed private enterprise...he nationalised oil but most other sectors he left untouched if you qctually look at it. But how can you argue it was worse when he died than when he came in? More dependent on oil was a bad thing, but almost every human index factor improved. He took millions out of poverty and gave them education, healthcare and welfare.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
I would argue against the idea he destroyed private enterprise...he nationalised oil but most other sectors he left untouched if you qctually look at it. But how can you argue it was worse when he died than when he came in? More dependent on oil was a bad thing, but almost every human index factor improved. He took millions out of poverty and gave them education, healthcare and welfare. Really, how come they are scavenging on rubbish dumps for food then?
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Venezuela has become an all-out political football for Western powers. This poor country has one major asset, its oil, which represents 95 per cent of its export economy. Venezuelan oil was always in the hands of large American and British multi-national companies who creamed of the profits. The people remained wretchedly poor while oil companies enriched themselves. The poverty gained little sympathy from our media as long as the rich could exploit Venezuela’s only natural asset. With the coming to power of the Socialist President, Hugo Chavez, in 1999, things began to change. He used the record-high oil revenues and nationalised key industries, including oil to expand and create access to food, housing, healthcare, and education to raise the poor from the abject misery they had to endure while watching their wealth syphoned away by the oil companies. Chavez was charismatic and loved by the poor of Venezuela, but hated by the privileged class, which led to a group of high-ranking anti-Chávez military officers launching a coup against Chávez, who was arrested in April 2002. The coup was supported by the United States, the so-called middle-class and the oil companies. It failed miserably after only 3 days and the coup leaders escaped to America. People had taken to the streets in support of Chavez and he was re-installed as President. It was the West’s first attempt to overthrow the democratically elected Socialist government in Caracas. In 2006, there was a presidential election with a 74 per cent turnout. Chavez was re-elected with a vote of 63 per cent. Regardless of this American and Western propaganda consistently portrayed him as a dictator, just as they do now with President Nicolas Maduro. Maduro was elected after the untimely death of Chavez from cancer. Almost at once the new President faced a major crisis when in November 2014 the global oil price collapsed. The right-wing saw their chance and, as the country suffered, they implemented their plan to overthrow Maduro. America has implemented economic sanctions on this poor country with the clear intention to destroy its economy while it is stricken with the collapse of the oil price. The Western media is portraying Maduro has a dictator even though democratically elected. Western powers see a chance for another coup, this time an economic one, so they can again take ownership of the country’s massive oil wealth. If they succeed, any concern for the poor of Venezuela will quickly evaporate. Maduro is no dictator, he is the democratically elected President. The attacks on him contrast sharply with the sycophantic treatment by the West of Saudi Arabia, its completely undemocratic regime, religious extremism and inhuman executions for trivial offences. Publicly beheading any women accused of adultery is common place, sometimes in front of a football crowd.
What Corbyn knows is this: If he condemns Maduro the next question is: Doesn’t this mean that left-wing policies can never succeed? Is it not a failure of Socialism? Capitalism has failed the people of Venezuela and most of the countries in South America. If Venezuela falls the next targets for sure will be Evo Morales, Socialist President of Bolivia and Rafael Correa, Socialist President of Ecuador. Thus far, Corbyn has continued to stand firm and he must continue to do so as the media attacks, and those from within his own Party, intensify.
Which left wing propaganda web-page did you cut and paste this load of nonsenses from?
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Which left wing propaganda web-page did you cut and paste this load of nonsenses from? It says at the bottom, which shows you didn't read it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
I would argue against the idea he destroyed private enterprise...he nationalised oil but most other sectors he left untouched if you qctually look at it. Business fled. Where do you get this idea he left them alone? Here is a Guardian 2010 article on Chavez's affect on private business amongst other things. Originally posted by serial thriller
But how can you argue it was worse when he died than when he came in? More dependent on oil was a bad thing, but almost every human index factor improved. He took millions out of poverty and gave them education, healthcare and welfare. If you want to be intellectually honest, you need to take account of the reality instead of the idealism. Corbyn showed that he was far more interested in the idealism over and above the practical realities of policies that cause practical economic harm....He never mentioned the problems. The reality is that the nature of policies Chavez pursued destroyed the business environment.....People with money do not invest in regimes that don't like them...They have no stability or trust....It should be a no brainer. Initially it looks that all the social programs that Chavez started were good because they improved the lives of the poor. But the logic of that doesn't really follow through does it? It's like taking the skinny kid and fattening them up before starving them to death.....What's the point of those social programs if you are left shooting dogs for food, a crazy murder rate, with gangs murdering you on the streets and German 20s inflation?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
I would argue against the idea he destroyed private enterprise...he nationalised oil but most other sectors he left untouched if you qctually look at it. But how can you argue it was worse when he died than when he came in? More dependent on oil was a bad thing, but almost every human index factor improved. He took millions out of poverty and gave them education, healthcare and welfare. I guess if you define 'taking people out of poverty' by killing them or creating the conditions for death (look at the huge infant mortality rate in Venezuela), then you are correct.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Really, how come they are scavenging on rubbish dumps for food then? Yeah but at least now they can read what the label says
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
I'll leave this here and let people make their minds up...
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
This is the f*cked up state of affairs we have in our country. We can sell arms to someone and train their security services, but you should also denounce their regime as authoritarian and call for it to be replaced. It's almost as if the free market disregards any concept of morality. I guess most countries are a bundle on contradictions. Where there is money to be made it's kind of thing sadly has an inevitability to it I'm afraid. It's certainly not an industry I'd work in though.
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
--- Edited by wordup (11 Aug 2017 10.47pm)
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
This is the f*cked up state of affairs we have in our country. We can sell arms to someone and train their security services, but you should also denounce their regime as authoritarian and call for it to be replaced. It's almost as if the free market disregards any concept of morality. How come selling weapons to Maduro is less bad than someone saying violence needs to cease on all sides?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.