This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well yeah Jamie....antifa are a pain in the arse but their aren't Islamic terrorists looking to murder westerners....I'll give antifa that. Ah, good ol' "Antifa". Because even the conservative base was getting fed up with the answer to every question being "but...BENGHAZI!" Edited by Ray in Houston (17 Aug 2017 9.57pm)
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by wordup
Most of these statues were placed several decades after the civil war, at the height of KKK activity more for political than historical reasons. Their very presence was a statement to others rather than a lesson to learn from the past. I'm not one to say that they should be airbrushed out, but many were certainly graffitied in. If people become overly attached some are possibly as attached to the message as they are the monument, hence the type of person who showed up to defend it. On the other hand if individuals decide to deface or destroy they should be arrested as they are not the voice of the community or elected body. It should ideally be down to local communities to decide their future. Interestingly General Robert E. Lee was invited to attend a meeting to plan granite statues in 1869. His reply: " “My engagements will not permit me to be present, & I believe if there I could not add anything material to the information existing on the subject. I think it wiser moreover not to keep open the sores of war, but to follow the examples of those nations who endeavored to obliterate the marks of civil strife & to commit to oblivion the feelings it engendered.” There's more than one way to learn from history, I'm sure he'd agree.
Not just Lee though - few Confederates attended and many from both sides and none shared his view that the war should be allowed to rest.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Ah, good ol' "Antifa". Because even the conservative base was getting fed up with the answer to every question being "but...BENGHAZI!" Edited by Ray in Houston (17 Aug 2017 9.57pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Really? Do explain.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The Holocaust was a genocide of one group by an enemy. We don't want to forget the Nazis because they are a symbol of where you get to if you allow prejudice created by self-interest to go unbridled. That story is told by the victors. You have to ask yourself where you draw the line. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (17 Aug 2017 6.43pm) You're right political tokenism is stupid but largely harmless if it is a token gesture then it doesn’t mean anything, but this does not look like tokenism.If it is tokenism then the tearing down of statues would cause no reaction from unite the right groups which obviously has .It is because these statues are symbols of the prejudices that still exists in the minds of some and the prejudices that was in living memory legitimised by law at state levels that they should be taken. Retrospect implies we have all moved on, which clearly hasn't happened.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
Unless I'm missing something the ‘alr-right’ who turned up on Friday to protest at the statues being taken down main concern wasn’t with the historical context or fear of airbrushing history, they weren’t the militant wing of the Smithsonian. If that is the case then I take it the unite the right group would have no problem with other statues and memeorials been placed in town squares to remember the slaves ,segregation lynching’s and other aspects of the Southern states ‘culture’ to help place the General Lee statue in context. They are statues of historical figures who defended the southern way of life which at that time included the legal slavery.
|
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
They are statues of historical figures who defended the southern way of life which at that time included the legal slavery. It's like iconoclasm of the Puritans - daft then, daft now. The new left are the new Puritans.
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
They are statues of historical figures who defended the southern way of life which at that time included the legal slavery. I would agree with you if the statues were neutral pieces of art or symbols of long resolved wars and conflicts but evidently they are not to the people living Virginia and other southern states in the U.S. We have largely come to terms with both Wallace and Cromwell as symbols , Cromwell I would say is seen for his role in curbing the power of the asserting the role and power of parliament but that his reign led to tyranny, but those issues are resolved absolute monarchist and puritans are no longer kicking off on St Stephens green. Yes Scottish independence is a still a live issue but it is pursued through legal and democratic means it. Wallace and Cromwell statues no longer have the associated symbolism. A statue of Cromwell would still in Ireland and Sean Russell’s still does cause controversy .
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
They are statues of historical figures who defended the southern way of life which at that time included the legal slavery. Hmm and when were many of these statues put up? 1924 - 59 years after the end of the civil war. The south sure was in a rush to commemorate their war hero (ironically a man who personally objected to the idea of Confederate War Memorials). Oddly it seems that most of these statues went up in the 20s during the Jim Crow laws, and during the 50s and 60s during the civil rights campaign... hmm
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
I would agree with you if the statues were neutral pieces of art or symbols of long resolved wars and conflicts but evidently they are not to the people living Virginia and other southern states in the U.S. We have largely come to terms with both Wallace and Cromwell as symbols , Cromwell I would say is seen for his role in curbing the power of the asserting the role and power of parliament but that his reign led to tyranny, but those issues are resolved absolute monarchist and puritans are no longer kicking off on St Stephens green. Yes Scottish independence is a still a live issue but it is pursued through legal and democratic means it. Wallace and Cromwell statues no longer have the associated symbolism. A statue of Cromwell would still in Ireland and Sean Russell’s still does cause controversy . I understand your point, but statues and monuments do nothing except sit there getting green. It's people that are the problem. All the time we have Nazis, anti Nazis, identity politics, Black Power etc, we have a problem.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
Have we? You speak for yourself there. Wallace I understand, but Cromwell in Ireland was an unnecessary butcher. However, I understand his historical significance and I'm not an over-reactionary virtue signaler like so many 'progressives' especially in the US.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Hmm and when were many of these statues put up? 1924 - 59 years after the end of the civil war. The south sure was in a rush to commemorate their war hero (ironically a man who personally objected to the idea of Confederate War Memorials). Oddly it seems that most of these statues went up in the 20s during the Jim Crow laws, and during the 50s and 60s during the civil rights campaign... hmm
Yeah, and this is the bone of contention. One wonders precisely why the statues were erected.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Hmm and when were many of these statues put up? 1924 - 59 years after the end of the civil war. The south sure was in a rush to commemorate their war hero (ironically a man who personally objected to the idea of Confederate War Memorials). Oddly it seems that most of these statues went up in the 20s during the Jim Crow laws, and during the 50s and 60s during the civil rights campaign... hmm
Jamie, I remember you previously making the argument that people shouldn't feel a connection to past events that other generations did. They shouldn't feel pride in achievements or transgressions that didn't personally involve them. When you made that argument I completely disagreed of course and still do....however, if this is what you believe then why do you even have an opinion on this?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| pefwin |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Jamie, I remember you previously making the argument that people shouldn't feel a connection to past events that other generations did. They shouldn't feel pride in achievements or transgressions that didn't personally involve them. When you made that argument I completely disagreed of course and still do....however, if this is what you believe then why do you even have an opinion on this? Let them be. When you see a statue pulled down you generally feel it is a revision of history. Be it Stalin, Saddam, or Thatcher.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once." "When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support." |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Have we? You speak for yourself there. Wallace I understand, but Cromwell in Ireland was an unnecessary butcher. However, I understand his historical significance and I'm not an over-reactionary virtue signaler like so many 'progressives' especially in the US.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by pefwin
Let them be. When you see a statue pulled down you generally feel it is a revision of history. Be it Stalin, Saddam, or Thatcher. We agree as in a democracy no one should be pulling down anything. What I do recognise is that times change as the generations and demographics change and so if the local people don't want or do want the statue that should be respected. Nothing wrong with moving it if that is what is decided. But this was antifa, the local people have grown up with that there. Idiotic hot-heads, who think they are on a mission when all they are doing is creating more fights for others later on. Far right numbers had been going down in the US for decades and it's only been since the moronic nature of 'identity' politics from progressives reared its head that you have seen a counter white 'identity' politics in opposition to it..... with the far right taking stage. The whole lot of them are morons.
Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Aug 2017 7.00pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
Do you have to be Irish or a monarchist then to take exception to a statue of Cromwell? I don't intend to divert from the thread either. I just wanted to answer that particular point. The reality is that all statues will have supporters and detractors. It should be about the local opinion around it.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I understand your point, but statues and monuments do nothing except sit there getting green. It's people that are the problem. All the time we have Nazis, anti Nazis, identity politics, Black Power etc, we have a problem. Fair enough but the 'statues don't lynch people racist do' arguement is a bit of a cop out. Staues are erected for a reason they are not de-contexulised peice of art.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
They are statues of historical figures who defended the southern way of life which at that time included the legal slavery. I don't think you read what Wordup posted. These statues were not put up by the Confederate forces. They were put up as anti-abolition, anti equal rights symbols much more recently. They are disgraceful in their intent. They ARE a symbol of white supremacy, that is why they were erected. Edited by Mapletree (18 Aug 2017 7.17pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.