This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Sorry to derail your prejudices (and move away from the travails of the state of California),but I can speak as someone who represented a former para at the Bloody Sunday inquiry,so may know just a tad more about what actually happened than yourself. The following are however clear to me: Bloody Sunday was an abomination and the actions of the army that day were something all right thinking people should condemn.Innocent civilians were killed wrongly by the paras. There was a collective cover up within the army following Bloody Sunday.That should be condemned. Being able to condemn such things and for those unlawfully killed's families to get redress is not equatable to being anti-army or pro Provos but is a sign of strength of a vigorous democracy, not weakness. I agree that the cover up was wrong if it existed. As for what happens in the heat of stressful situations once someone is attacked by gunfire I regard your legalistic opinions as about as befitting for someone who doesn't know what that's actually like in real life. There's a reason your claimed profession is held in such low esteem. 'Sign of strength'....Jesus! If we have released IRA murderers why are we arresting our own ex soldiers?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Not the best situation but we could have compromised stopping the troubles if not. It's a crap price to pay,but worth it for the peace it has brought about. Mmmmmm. Not when you start arresting your own ex soldiers it isn't.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Mmmmmm. Not when you start arresting your own ex soldiers it isn't. So if you were in charge the troubles would still be going on because you are unwilling to give and take.
|
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I agree that the cover up was wrong if it existed. As for what happens in the heat of stressful situations once someone is attacked by gunfire I regard your legalistic opinions as about as befitting for someone who doesn't know what that's actually like in real life. There's a reason your claimed profession is held in such low esteem. 'Sign of strength'....Jesus! If we have released IRA murderers why are we arresting our own ex soldiers?
And your own personal experience of being in that situation in N Ireland is,I presume,zero? I have at least heard about what happened and the run up from people who were para squaddies on the ground. As for which of us might have encountered more "real life" situations personally,let's just say I don't feel challenged by you in that regard..you have no idea what I might have or not have encountered but it doesn't prevent you stating what is purely a personal bias as if it were fact.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
So if you were in charge the troubles would still be going on because you are unwilling to give and take. If I think what I would have done to the IRA if I had been in power and to the people who would have looked to stop me.....This isn't a topic I can speak that rationally on. I would not have came to the agreement that emerged no. But I would have been open to discussions. The IRA were not in a strong position at the time and I think what has happened is the long term abandonment of the unionists via the cowards way out. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jan 2018 1.32pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
And your own personal experience of being in that situation in N Ireland is,I presume,zero? I have at least heard about what happened and the run up from people who were para squaddies on the ground. As for which of us might have encountered more "real life" situations personally,let's just say I don't feel challenged by you in that regard..you have no idea what I might have or not have encountered but it doesn't prevent you stating what is purely a personal bias as if it were fact. Well half my family are unionists in Belfast....so I don't know...how about I've spoken quite a lot to people who lived through it. Plus my half brother did two tours of Northern Ireland and ended up marrying an Irish girl, whom he had to marry in the UK due to threats. As for my experience of violence and knowledge of how people react under it. I was a bouncer for a short time as a younger man and helped run a pub in Bermondsey so I know a bit about confrontation and how people react during violence. It's a bit different to the boxing ring. You talk from the position of a 'legal' person. It isn't something I have much time for no. What happened was the responsibility of the British army....that much I agree on. Our response should have been compensation to the victim's families......where is the compensation from the IRA to the British victims.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Stirling,I talk from the position of "me"...notwithstanding my (admittedly naff) username I chose on the spur of the moment years ago And remember,I was talking about the events of Bloody Sunday specifically,not the Troubles generally. Well, your right to a viewpoint is valid even if I don't agree with it. This is a topic I get quite angry about and I find it hard to be balanced on so perhaps I should look to limit myself on it. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jan 2018 1.40pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Being a patriot I have a side. We were at fault by over reaction on bloody Sunday....but not to the extent that we arrest soldiers that we put there and who were attacked and in a highly pressured situation.....soldiers are not Policemen. The good friday agreement releases IRA murderers....and actually allows these scum into political power sharing over British citizens and then that?
The Good Friday agreement also released Loyalist murderers as well. I think pragmatically it was the right decision - especially with hindsight - as its massively reduced the problems of Northern Ireland and largely resulted in a unprecedented level of peace as well as positive changes socially. The cost of that peace and stability, I'm not keen on, but I think the days of the paramilitaries are all but dead, and generations of Irish kids have grown out of the sectarianism and division, sufficiently, that I suspect within the next generation the likes of Sinn Fein and the DUP will be more benign political entities. As for Bloody Sunday, there should have been a proper enquiry, and those troops responsible for firing, should have been held accountable along with their officers. They acted unlawfully, and the result was a massive recruiting drive for the Provisional IRA, an escalation in violence and derailed the mostly civil rights movement. Bloody Sunday, I can't abide by that. Unarmed civilians shot and killed by the army, without any real provocation. The state then protected and covered up afterwards, and engaged in a series of attempts to paint those killed as terrorists, inc planting evidence. Unacceptable in any country that claims to be a democratic authority of law. Even in a war zone, their actions were criminal. Protecting them envigorated the Provisional IRA, ended the non-partisan civil rights movement at its height - and resulted in an escalation of violence that lasted decades; resulting in a rise in casualties, both British and Northern Irish. At the time, it was the civil rights movement, not the Provos or the Loyalists, that were the most dominant political movement in Northern Ireland - Bloody Sunday ended that in a day - resulting in the domination of the political scene by terrorist factions such as the DUP and Sinn Fein that still exists. The impact of Bloody Sunday was catastrophic for generations of Northern Irish.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well half my family are unionists in Belfast....so I don't know...how about I've spoken quite a lot to people who lived through it. Plus my half brother did two tours of Northern Ireland and ended up marrying an Irish girl, whom he had to marry in the UK due to threats. As for my experience of violence and knowledge of how people react under it. I was a bouncer for a short time as a younger man and helped run a pub in Bermondsey so I know a bit about confrontation and how people react during violence. It's a bit different to the boxing ring. You talk from the position of a 'legal' person. It isn't something I have much time for no. What happened was the responsibility of the British army....that much I agree on. Our response should have been compensation to the victim's families......where is the compensation from the IRA to the British victims.
The IRA are a criminal organisation and terrorists. The British Government is a lawful state. There is an obligation on states to act lawfully, and enforce to rule of law, even when its politically inconvenient or unpopular. Those people killed on Bloody Sunday, weren't terrorists, they were innocent British Citizens, killed unlawfully, but agents of the British State.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
No, you just 'straw-manned' as it's a separate argument. The original point was about allowing licenced carry holders on school grounds as it would more likely SAVE lives, and lots of evidence (and common sense) indicates this. I think that the important phrase here has to be that it will/may save more lives than it costs. This is the problem of the 'more guns solution', it best equation situation is that it would reduce the number of people killed, rather than prevent a situation. Of course its hypothetical in the extreme. You have to assume that a) those guns are available b) those who have access to them are sufficently trained to respond and don't panic c) that the police responding don't shoot the armed individual d) that the armed staff are themselves not killed first e) that the armed individuals don't shoot the wrong people (given the panic) The last two are significant. When we look at the background of these crimes, we see that they're planned and orchestrated by the perpetrators. Likely as not they'd start with eliminating the armed teacher / staff first (as it will likely be well known who at the school is an armed response trainee). Plus they'd need to obtain those weapons following the incident. Handguns aren't really ideal, as most mass shootings tend to involve rifles, and assault weapons - and in a number of cases body armour. So realistically you're going to need to have Combat grade hardware locked up in the school, with ammo - Which is problematic in its own right When we look at the Colombine shootings, those kids were prepaired, heavily armed and in possession of explosives, and followed a pattern of attack. They didn't just start shooting randomly. Plus the entire place was in chaos of panic with kids running, hiding etc. Thats a very dangerous situation to be armed in. The NRA based solutions aren't particually well thought out; and its not common sense when you think about it. The solution to tragedy of mass shootings is to at best reduce the number of kids killed in a school shooting. Its a false arguement, because it ignores the contextual variables of the situation. Of course you could make it illegal for anyone under 21 to own guns. Its odd that in many states you can own a military grade weapon, before you're trusted to be able to drink a beer.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
The IRA are a criminal organisation and terrorists. The British Government is a lawful state. There is an obligation on states to act lawfully, and enforce to rule of law, even when its politically inconvenient or unpopular. Errrr....hang on....the same people there on that day....one found with a gun was put into governance......If you are going to elevate one set of murderers over what you consider another then yeah....get your money out mate....that lot murdered people even after the agreement. That's why democracies lose wars to scum like them....and lawyers and post modernists gain. Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Those people killed on Bloody Sunday, weren't terrorists, they were innocent British Citizens, killed unlawfully, but agents of the British State. 'Unlawfully' Arresting ex British soldiers who had been fired upon doesn't stand in my book especially when you release murderers in the IRA. Anyone joining the army today.....hell even the police needs to take a good long look at the type of people ruling over them. Maybe the next time the IRA plan to fire mortars at your residence and you rightly protect them....you should also remember how strongly these people back you. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jan 2018 4.31pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
'Unlawfully' Arresting ex British soldiers who had been fired upon doesn't stand in my book especially when you release murderers in the IRA. Anyone joining the army today.....hell even the police needs to take a good long look at the type of people ruling over them. Maybe the next time the IRA plan to fire mortars at your residence and you rightly protect them....you should also remember how strongly these people back you. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jan 2018 4.31pm) I think part of the good Friday agreement should have also been an amnesty for those who fired on Bloody Sunday - and an independent inquiry. Same as for the IRA, UVF UFF, INLA etc. Same rules apply. I don't see the Good Friday as protecting the IRA, but protecting the ordinary people of Northern Ireland who were caught between the British, The Provos and the Loyalist Terrorist. In the end, it was for them, not the IRA or UVF, Sinn Fien or DUP etc that the Good Friday Agreement served. The people who lived through the troubles, without picking up guns or bombs, and their kids. The others who benefited, were just necessary sacrifice.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Another example of the authoritarian left that is running California. It's slowly becoming a Communist state... California Considers $1,000 fine or jail for waiters offering unsolicited plastic straws [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
Another example of the authoritarian left that is running California. It's slowly becoming a Communist state... California Considers ,000 fine or jail for waiters offering unsolicited plastic straws [Link] Not sure what's communist or even left wing about right-on rabid hipster authoritarianism. Also, I note that one "lawmaker" does not a state make. Having fixed that for you, I agree that the actual suggestion is totally bonkers :-)
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
Not sure what's communist or even left wing about right-on rabid hipster authoritarianism. Also, I note that one "lawmaker" does not a state make. If the other lawmakers agree, then it is. Plus, you may not have seen the other laws passed here which I have posted in this thread. Edited by Penge Eagle (26 Jan 2018 5.49pm)
|
|
| pefwin |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
Another example of the authoritarian left that is running California. It's slowly becoming a Communist state... California Considers ,000 fine or jail for waiters offering unsolicited plastic straws [Link] That's called eco-fascism.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once." "When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support." |
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
If the other lawmakers agree, then it is. Plus, you may not have seen the other laws passed here which I have posted in this thread. Edited by Penge Eagle (26 Jan 2018 5.49pm) Ok. Do any of them involve forced collectivisation, re-education camps, state control of the means of production, mass employment public projects or restrictions on democracy? No? Not communist. Not by a very very long way. Do these new laws include: Punitive taxes on private sector entities and corrrsponding public sector investment? Nationalisation of power, water, prisons and transport infrastructure? Increasing access to health and justice services for the poor? Reducing education costs? All good left wing stuff. Nanny States are authoritarian. Authoritarian regimes aren't the preserve of left or right. I suggest that Cal may well be well left of somewhere like Texas, but that doesn't make it left wing. Is California run along the same lines as Norway? When it is, you've got me bang to rights.
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
Ok. Do any of them involve forced collectivisation, re-education camps, state control of the means of production, mass employment public projects or restrictions on democracy? No? Not communist. Not by a very very long way. Do these new laws include: Punitive taxes on private sector entities and corrrsponding public sector investment? Nationalisation of power, water, prisons and transport infrastructure? Increasing access to health and justice services for the poor? Reducing education costs? All good left wing stuff. Nanny States are authoritarian. Authoritarian regimes aren't the preserve of left or right. I suggest that Cal may well be well left of somewhere like Texas, but that doesn't make it left wing. Is California run along the same lines as Norway? When it is, you've got me bang to rights. I was thinking more of the left-wing ideology rather than economic aspect, in this case. Jailing someone for handing out straws is definitely authoritarian and the Democrats are left wing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
I was thinking more of the left-wing ideology rather than economic aspect, in this case. Jailing someone for handing out straws is definitely authoritarian and the Democrats are left wing. Jailing someone for handing out straws would be great, if they were handing out $1000 fines to companies for each and every piece of unsolicited plastic they used in packaging :-) Economic aspects ARE the left vs right ideologies, good sir. Have a good weekend, no more HoL as I'm keen to try and trade all these isms for playing a long game with Mrs G in the hopes of an asm later on ;-)
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.