You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: Palace v Everton
November 16 2026 8.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref: Palace v Everton


Page 8 of 13 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Nov 17 8.41pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Its simply the average...

90mins football match divided by 26 fouls committed.

Equals one foul on average every 3.4 minutes.

But again you are deflecting.

Answer the question.

Is a foul on average every 3 minutes by the opposing team persistent infringement.

Yes or no...

A "Persistent infringent" caution is based at an individual player NOT a collective foul count across the team and there is no specific number that equates to it.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 19 Nov 17 8.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

A "Persistent infringent" caution is based at an individual player NOT a collective foul count across the team and there is no specific number that equates to it.

So a foul every three minutes isn't persistent infringement as long as you rotate the fouler.

Ok sounds fair.

Ref had a blinding game then.

Thanks,

 

chateauferret Flag 19 Nov 17 8.54pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

So a foul every three minutes isn't persistent infringement as long as you rotate the fouler.

Ok sounds fair.

Ref had a blinding game then.

Thanks,

I pointed out earlier that the definition of persistent infringement in Law 12 includes persistent infringement by a team. It deals with a situation where a team's players take it in turns to foul a single player (e.g. Wilf) and provides for the ref to card the fourth player to foul him in a short space of time even though the previous fouls were committed by other players.

Have a look here

[Link]

in particular from post 17 onwards and the reference to David Elleray's advice.


So when Willo said

'A "Persistent infringent" caution is based at an individual player NOT a collective foul count across the team and there is no specific number that equates to it.'

... he was talking bollocks.

Incidentally one poster there points out that Messi has been subject to this treatment most of his career. Whom do we know that excels at the same thing as Messi - successful take-ons?

Edited by chateauferret (19 Nov 2017 9.02pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Nov 17 9.01pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I pointed out earlier that the definition of persistent infringement in Law 12 includes persistent infringement by a team. It deals with a situation where a team's players take it in turns to foul a single player (e.g. Wilf) and provides for the ref to card the fourth player to foul him in a short space of time even though the previous fouls were committed by other players.

Have a look here

[Link]

in particular from post 17 onwards and the reference to David Elleray's advice.


So when Willo said

'A "Persistent infringent" caution is based at an individual player NOT a collective foul count across the team and there is no specific number that equates to it.'

... he was talking bollocks.

Edited by chateauferret (19 Nov 2017 8.55pm)

From the FA website :

A player is cautioned if guilty of:

delaying the restart of play
dissent by word or action
entering, re-entering or deliberately leaving the field of play without the referee’s permission
failing to respect the required distance when play is restarted with a corner kick, free kick or throw-in
persistent offences (no specific number or pattern of offences constitutes “persistent”)
unsporting behaviour

Kindly note this refers to "A player" and NOT the team.


 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 19 Nov 17 9.03pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I pointed out earlier that the definition of persistent infringement in Law 12 includes persistent infringement by a team. It deals with a situation where a team's players take it in turns to foul a single player (e.g. Wilf) and provides for the ref to card the fourth player to foul him in a short space of time even though the previous fouls were committed by other players.

Have a look here

[Link]

in particular from post 17 onwards and the reference to David Elleray's advice.


So when Willo said

'A "Persistent infringent" caution is based at an individual player NOT a collective foul count across the team and there is no specific number that equates to it.'

... he was talking bollocks.

Edited by chateauferret (19 Nov 2017 8.55pm)


Thanks for the update, seems like our resident 'authority' on refereeing needs to catch up on the rules.

My next question was gonna be, hasn't the ref got any tools in his arsenal to stop a team fouling on average every 3 minutes. But i think you answered the question.

He clearly has the tools at his disposal but for some reason didn't want to use them.

The club IMO really needs to call the PL out on this on going issue, I can not imagine for the life of me we'd get away with doing this to Man City.

Especially as you have kindly pointed out there are laws in place to punish teams doing it.

[quote=David Elleray] Referees have always been told to look out for a team tactic where different players foul the same opponent.

The advice is that the captain is warned then the next player can be cautioned not for persistent misconduct but for unsporting behaviour.

Edited by Goldfiinger (19 Nov 2017 9.11pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Nov 17 9.07pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger


Thanks for the update, seems like our resident 'authority' on refereeing needs to catch up on the rules.

My next question was gonna be, hasn't the ref got any tools in his arsenal to stop a team fouling on average every 3 minutes. But i think you answered the question.

He clearly has the tools at his disposal but for some reason didn't want to use them.

The club IMO really needs to call the PL out on this on going issue, I can not imagine for the life of me we'd get away with doing this to Man City.

Especially as you have kindly pointed out there are laws in place to punish teams doing it.

Very easy call the captain over and say next foul in the next five minutes gets a yellow. So simple, especially as he has the 'authority' to do it!


There are no "Rules" there are "Laws".
And I have highlighted the relevant "Law" as documented on the FA website.

But clearly there are those who believe that "Persistent infringement" cautions are issued after a set number of fouls committed across the team.I am happy to inform you otherwise.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 19 Nov 17 9.10pm

This has developed into another Willo ego trip give it a rest lads he is like an old record,gets so boring you wished you never heard it in the first place.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Nov 17 9.10pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger


Thanks for the update, seems like our resident 'authority' on refereeing needs to catch up on the rules.

My next question was gonna be, hasn't the ref got any tools in his arsenal to stop a team fouling on average every 3 minutes. But i think you answered the question.

He clearly has the tools at his disposal but for some reason didn't want to use them.

The club IMO really needs to call the PL out on this on going issue, I can not imagine for the life of me we'd get away with doing this to Man City.

Especially as you have kindly pointed out there are laws in place to punish teams doing it.

Very easy call the captain over and say next foul in the next five minutes gets a yellow. So simple, especially as he has the 'authority' to do it!


So the "Next foul" is committed by a player who hasn't committed a foul before and he gets issued a "Yellow" based on the number of fouls committed by the team ?
Good luck with that one.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 19 Nov 17 9.11pm

Originally posted by Willo

There are no "Rules" there are "Laws".
And I have highlighted the relevant "Law" as documented on the FA website.

But clearly there are those who believe that "Persistent infringement" cautions are issued after a set number of fouls committed across the team.I am happy to inform you otherwise.

It seems that you are unable or unwilling to answer a straight question with a simple yes or no answer so for that reason I am out!!!

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 19 Nov 17 9.13pm

Originally posted by Willo


There are no "Rules" there are "Laws".
And I have highlighted the relevant "Law" as documented on the FA website.

But clearly there are those who believe that "Persistent infringement" cautions are issued after a set number of fouls committed across the team.I am happy to inform you otherwise.

How come the team wasn't warned for unsporting behavior and booked for that instead?

Surely that's the relevant rule/law you should be informing us about.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Nov 17 9.18pm

Originally posted by the silurian

It seems that you are unable or unwilling to answer a straight question with a simple yes or no answer so for that reason I am out!!!

I have responded to a number of the points on here and set the record straight about the Law relating to "Persistent infringement".

Seemingly some believe that after a set number of fouls either the whole team should be booked or the player who commits the next foul should be booked even if this was his first foul.Ridiculous.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 19 Nov 17 9.19pm

Originally posted by the silurian

It seems that you are unable or unwilling to answer a straight question with a simple yes or no answer so for that reason I am out!!!

Feed the troll and at some point he'll trip over his own tripe....

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Nov 17 9.20pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Feed the troll and at some point he'll trip over his own tripe....

How ironic that you used the word "Tripe" given the content of your post.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 19 Nov 17 9.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have responded to a number of the points on here and set the record straight about the Law relating to "Persistent infringement".

Seemingly some believe that after a set number of fouls either the whole team should be booked or the player who commits the next foul should be booked even if this was his first foul.Ridiculous.

Unsporting behavior - look it up.

It can be used at the discretion of the referee to caution a player when he believes the team is targeting a player and rotating the fouls.

But you knew this from your training, right?

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 19 Nov 17 9.23pm

Originally posted by Willo

How ironic that you used the word "Tripe" given the content of your post.

You're only making yourself look like a mug.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Nov 17 9.24pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Unsporting behavior - look it up.

It can be used at the discretion of the referee to caution a player when he believes the team is targeting a player and rotating the fouls.

But you knew this from your training, right?

You seriously suggesting that a player can be booked for "Unsporting beahaviour" for his first foul based on the fact that this followed a series of fouls spread across the team ?

Edited by Willo (19 Nov 2017 9.24pm)

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 19 Nov 17 9.27pm

Originally posted by Willo

You seriously suggesting that a player can be booked for "Unsporting beahaviour" for his first foul based on the fact that this followed a series of fouls spread across the team ?

Edited by Willo (19 Nov 2017 9.24pm)

I'm not suggesting anything I'm quoting David Elleray said:

Quote Referees have always been told to look out for a team tactic where different players foul the same opponent.

The advice is that the captain is warned then the next player can be cautioned not for persistent misconduct but for unsporting behaviour.

Its frankly absurd to think the referee hasn't any power to stop a team from persitant fouling. If he wanted he could use unsporting behavior.

The more you defend 26 fouls not being able to be managed by the referee the more you unmask your true colours.

Edited by Goldfiinger (19 Nov 2017 9.30pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Nov 17 9.27pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

You're only making yourself look like a mug.

Those who don't knows the 'Laws' but debate on here from supposed positions of authority could be said to fit this description.

 

chateauferret Flag 19 Nov 17 9.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

From the FA website :

A player is cautioned if guilty of:

delaying the restart of play
dissent by word or action
entering, re-entering or deliberately leaving the field of play without the referee’s permission
failing to respect the required distance when play is restarted with a corner kick, free kick or throw-in
persistent offences (no specific number or pattern of offences constitutes “persistent”)
unsporting behaviour

Kindly note this refers to "A player" and NOT the team.


Complete and utter horses***.

Since you can't be bothered to look up the link I posted to David Elleray's comment, I'll paste it in here for you.

"Referees have always been told to look out for a team tactic where different players foul the same opponent.

"The advice is that the captain is warned then the next player can be cautioned not for persistent misconduct but for unsporting behaviour."

The list of examples of unsporting behaviour in Law 12 is not exhaustive. Elleray makes clear that referees have always been advised to treat the behaviour we're discussing as unsporting behaviour deserving of a yellow card.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 19 Nov 17 9.30pm

Originally posted by Willo

Those who don't knows the 'Laws' but debate on here from supposed positions of authority could be said to fit this description.

Yes, you do indeed.

The authority I quoted was the technical director of the IFAB which is the body that defines the Laws. If you've got a position of authority that comes above that I'd be very surprised.

Edited by chateauferret (19 Nov 2017 9.38pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 8 of 13 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: Palace v Everton