You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Niasse Dive
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Niasse Dive


Page 8 of 15 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
jeeagles Flag 22 Nov 17 6.36pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

The problem is with punishment in real time. You get a yellow card if the referee sees it during the match, but a two-match ban if found out afterwards.

Diving has got to be a red card offence.

Agreed. And if you weren't caught, you should get a ban greater than that of a red card, particularly if you're team benefitted.

 

The Dolphin Flag 22 Nov 17 6.37pm

We suffer on the day whist our immediate rivals benefit.
You just know this is not our season!

Edited by The Dolphin (22 Nov 2017 6.38pm)

 

Texas Eagle Flag San Antonio, Texas (via Adelaide) 22 Nov 17 7.11pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think, the very fact that the PL is even considering bringing in video reviews is sufficient evidence that they believe too many contentious issues are being missed by the refs. Slightly different angle to the contention that the refs are poor, just that they are missing important moments, perhaps because of the pace of the game and being incorrectly positioned.

This is a straightforward choice for me, I am firmly in the camp of video evidence although I would temper this by saying it is only necessary where a goal is likely to be scored, has been scored or a penalty is disputed.

In the case of Niasse, it would be a simple, the ref would say, "I saw contact on Niasse from my position, firstly penalty or no penalty. Secondly, was the contact the cause of the player going to ground." This would not have taken long to resolve and the answer would have been, " No penalty, Niasse went to ground without any contact to his legs and minor contact to the upper body". Yellow card for Niasse for simulation, free kick to Palace. I would add to this that if Niasse had gone down without any contact whatsoever then this should be a red card for simulation.

An alternative solution to the ref issue is to play the game as they do with basketball, with a leading ref in front of the game and a trailing ref behind the game. Either ref can make the call and if they have a difference of opinion then they discuss it before making their decision.

Great, just what we need, another official on the pitch! What if they both disagree, is there a senior ref and a junior ref with the senior having the final word. I agree it wasn't a penalty and Niasse should have been booked for simulation. Taylor got it wrong (and it wasn't the only decision he screwed up on) and no doubt the referee's inspector at the game will have noted his performance and duly marked him on it. Football is a simple game, why complicate it!

 


"Billy Gilbert really is God"

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 22 Nov 17 7.17pm

Originally posted by YT

Sorry if another HOL has already made a similar point, but surely the ban should be for the next 2 league games against the offended club; regardless of which club the offender may end up playing for.

Might never happen, particularly if Everton fall through the trapdoor

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 22 Nov 17 7.23pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

We suffer on the day whist our immediate rivals benefit.
You just know this is not our season!

Edited by The Dolphin (22 Nov 2017 6.38pm)

Yep if West Ham and Southampton beat Everton and and/all three teams avoid the drop by two points whilst we go down.

Well this is gonna look like a gut wrenching decision. Surprised more people aren't commenting on this.

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 22 Nov 17 7.44pm

i was speaking to my everton mate about this, regardless of whether it was a dive or not, what a load of rollocks, whats the point of it all, do we get the points? er no, going to be interesting when its a player from a top 4 club, then we will see what the ole duffers do...totally pointless waste of time this whole business

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 22 Nov 17 7.53pm

Banning the player for two games could benefit other clubs which could then be detrimental to the club that was originally wrongly penalised. Where's the justice then?

if the infringement never occurred then the penalty should not have been given and the goal so scored therefore disallowed. The final result should then be adjusted accordinly.

In this case Everton would forfeit a point and Palace gain two points.

Yes it could at some time work against us but am sure that potentially loosing points will stop diving - managers will ensure that!

Edited by rob1969 (22 Nov 2017 7.55pm)

Edited by rob1969 (22 Nov 2017 7.56pm)

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 22 Nov 17 8.44pm

David Unsworth has blown his chance of getting the Everton job permanent, because he's quite clearly on drugs!! The poor deluded fool

 

chateauferret Flag 22 Nov 17 9.19pm

Originally posted by monkey

David Unsworth has blown his chance of getting the Everton job permanent, because he's quite clearly on drugs!! The poor deluded fool

Have you seen all the Everton fans saying it was a fair penalty, that Palace were diving all over the pitch, and Wilf is a persistent cheat?

Nutters the lot of them.

Edited by chateauferret (22 Nov 2017 9.20pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Glazier#1 Flag 23 Nov 17 5.45am

Most of them are saying that they support cheating if it gives you 'an edge'.

Probably true of most football fans, don't you reckon?

Not me though. I still remember Benteke's hideous cheating against us. Never liked him since, I'm afraid. I don't care if he's 'ours' or not.

Ooh! Controversial.

Oh, by the way. I got a red line under the word 'Benteke's' and when I right-clicked it, the suggestion was 'absentee's'.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 23 Nov 17 9.21am

Originally posted by rob1969

Banning the player for two games could benefit other clubs which could then be detrimental to the club that was originally wrongly penalised. Where's the justice then?

if the infringement never occurred then the penalty should not have been given and the goal so scored therefore disallowed. The final result should then be adjusted accordinly.

In this case Everton would forfeit a point and Palace gain two points.

Yes it could at some time work against us but am sure that potentially loosing points will stop diving - managers will ensure that!

Edited by rob1969 (22 Nov 2017 7.55pm)

Edited by rob1969 (22 Nov 2017 7.56pm)

You can't "adjust results accordingly". There is a whole world of gambling /the pools / winning / losing / drawing etc that revolves around the final score. Rightly or wrongly the result at the end of the game will always stand.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 23 Nov 17 9.30am

Originally posted by babylonjohn

You can't "adjust results accordingly". There is a whole world of gambling /the pools / winning / losing / drawing etc that revolves around the final score. Rightly or wrongly the result at the end of the game will always stand.

I don't think that would matter too much. Bookies would just stipulate that they would Pay based on the Score when The whistle blew, and irrespective of any retrospective action.
What happens now in the 'Player gets red card' market?

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

chateauferret Flag 23 Nov 17 9.46am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I don't think that would matter too much. Bookies would just stipulate that they would Pay based on the Score when The whistle blew, and irrespective of any retrospective action.
What happens now in the 'Player gets red card' market?

You place your bet then leave your brown envelope containing £70,000 in the dead letter box you've agreed with the ref.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 9.46am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Nov 17 10.07am

Originally posted by babylonjohn

You can't "adjust results accordingly". There is a whole world of gambling /the pools / winning / losing / drawing etc that revolves around the final score. Rightly or wrongly the result at the end of the game will always stand.

You could adopt the horse racing system where bets aren't paid out until the horses are weighed in and any stewards enquiries have been conducted.

If they really wanted to stamp out diving then the only way will be for the cheating club to forfeit any points earned in the game

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 23 Nov 17 10.16am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You could adopt the horse racing system where bets aren't paid out until the horses are weighed in and any stewards enquiries have been conducted.

If they really wanted to stamp out diving then the only way will be for the cheating club to forfeit any points earned in the game

As someone else suggested, make it this plus 1 more point, this will punish the clubs who will then make more of an effort to stop their players doing it.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Nov 17 10.27am

If VAR had been in operation on Saturday then the referee could have reviewed the incident and one would imagine there would have been a different outcome with the penalty not awarded and the player booked.Whether of course this should be a 'Red' or 'Yellow' is debateable with other factors bring taken into consideration and would need a 'Law' change.

That said, VAR is not a panacea, with subjectivity perhaps leading to more controversy.The technology is available but how it is used is open to debate with the devil being very much in the detail.

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Nov 17 10.53am

Originally posted by Willo

If VAR had been in operation on Saturday then the referee could have reviewed the incident and one would imagine there would have been a different outcome with the penalty not awarded and the player booked.Whether of course this should be a 'Red' or 'Yellow' is debateable with other factors bring taken into consideration and would need a 'Law' change.

That said, VAR is not a panacea, with subjectivity perhaps leading to more controversy.The technology is available but how it is used is open to debate with the devil being very much in the detail.

The use of VAR would need to be carefully designed oc course but FFS it would be hard to make the quality of decision-making any worse than it is now.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 23 Nov 17 11.02am

Originally posted by babylonjohn

You can't "adjust results accordingly". There is a whole world of gambling /the pools / winning / losing / drawing etc that revolves around the final score. Rightly or wrongly the result at the end of the game will always stand.


Quite correct ^^^^

We have CCTV/video play-back technology, and this should be used.
at the moment we is being @r$e-fvcked by the current system, to the benefit of our rivals.

Cheats should be put in stocks outside selhurst

because CHEATS (and I include Snodgrass) should be fcked right off

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

chateauferret Flag 23 Nov 17 11.08am

Perhaps this is why Koeman wouldn't pick Niasse or give him a locker. As well as getting banned he's been an embarrassment to his club.

 


============
The Ferret
============

essetwentyone Flag london 23 Nov 17 11.10am

VAR is essential to stop situations like this. A review of the dive would have resulted in no pen and a yellow card which would have later seen Niasse sent off for his next yellow card offence. 1-0 up against 10 men !! This would stop all the feeling of injustice now and other teams benefitting instead of us. Even if the VAR decision had been for a pen it would’ve been final and an end to it.

 

Page 8 of 15 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Niasse Dive