You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Can Benteke redeem himself?
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Can Benteke redeem himself?


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Aray Flag South London 11 Dec 17 2.08pm

I had hoped for a public apology from him. Something like: "I was so desperate to get a goal I let that get in the way of making the right decision for the team/club/fans"

A bit of humility goes a long way. If he's not dropped then he best play a blinder tomorrow.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 11 Dec 17 2.20pm

Originally posted by Aray

I had hoped for a public apology from him. Something like: "I was so desperate to get a goal I let that get in the way of making the right decision for the team/club/fans"

A bit of humility goes a long way. If he's not dropped then he best play a blinder tomorrow.

Hes apologised to roy and is gona play a blinder tomorrow, maybe score, maybe not, but run his heart out, give his all, thats good enough for me!

 

taylors lovechild Flag 11 Dec 17 2.22pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Same.

Unless we get decent points in the next 3 of Watford at home, Leicester away and Swansea away and, if not, Arsenal at home and Man City at home, then I still will be.

It's one player or another or 2 most games who are messing up our chances and we haven't got the room for this kind of error (stupidity often) because of what's happened before.

I probably won't celebrate when or if Benteke scores in the very near future but I guess if everyone did that he'd lose determination from losing the adulation he thinks we've had for him. God, we even had to sign his brother who was out of his depth.

Really?

Hopefully that level of short-sightedness and negativity doesn't seep through to the team. I also really hope for your sake that you start finding enjoyment at Palace again, because you seem almost clinically depressed by everything that happens at club at the moment. Maybe Roy should loan you out to Brighton in January?

 

Den1923 Flag 11 Dec 17 2.24pm

Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke - Need to get over it...' by Midlands Eagle

To be fair, Benteke was incredibly unlucky.

Who'd have imagined that the goalkeeper would be such a fit young man in the peak of condition?

I must admit, like Beneteke, I'd assumed the keeper would be made out of straw at least or, at worst, being kept alive on by a kidney machine and unable to cover the six inches that their keeper moved in order to deprive us of two points.

Still, we must pick up the pieces of our lives and try to love again.

I'm sorry, I have to disagree, that was a feeble penalty from a player who was greedy and only interested in his own egotistical well being he did not care about the team and how important the three points were to us, he want goals on the CV so that he can go to the World Cup next summer. He has missed three from five penalty kicks since he has been with us and that is not the cv of striker, the easiest for all for a good strikers is penalty kicks, he can't even do that job and we are better off without him as he can't score anyway and therefore a waste of space!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Dec 17 2.25pm

Originally posted by Willo

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke - Need to get over it...' by Midlands Eagle

A win tomorrow and that Benteke penalty incident will be forgotten.

And a defeat, what then?

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 11 Dec 17 2.27pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

Hes apologised to roy and is gona play a blinder tomorrow, maybe score, maybe not, but run his heart out, give his all, thats good enough for me!

If he does play - he had better!

 

60 yrs a palace fan Flag 11 Dec 17 2.29pm

Originally posted by Sherlock Holmesdale

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke - Need to get over it...' by Midlands Eagle

Happily. He shouldn't have taken the penalty but otherwise had an excellent game. There's no guarantee Luka would have stuck it away anyway albeit he'd have had abetter effort.

Why did Luka roll over so easily and let Benteke take it? Both Luka and Dann etc need to grow a pair and actually show some leadership in future.

Anyway, we didn't lose the game, we played very well second half and hopefully the whole team, including Benteke,will be up for it tomorrow night.

Lets stick together, move on and get behind the boys

Exactly perhaps we should blame all the other players who missed scoring chances in this game.

We had enough goal scoring chances to win the game before the penalty shambles.

Some team is going to get a proper beating from us soon

Edited by 60 yrs a palace fan (11 Dec 2017 2.29pm)

 

eaglesmy1 Flag slough 11 Dec 17 2.38pm

I think he will be and should be dropped for the next game.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Dec 17 2.49pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Really?

Hopefully that level of short-sightedness and negativity doesn't seep through to the team. I also really hope for your sake that you start finding enjoyment at Palace again, because you seem almost clinically depressed by everything that happens at club at the moment. Maybe Roy should loan you out to Brighton in January?

No pal. Just people at the club who make obviously stupid decisions you can see going badly wrong. Big difference. Mistakes are one thing, walking head first into them is something different. This bloke is paid an absolute fortune and he messed with our future.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Dec 17 2.50pm

Originally posted by 60 yrs a palace fan

Exactly perhaps we should blame all the other players who missed scoring chances in this game.

We had enough goal scoring chances to win the game before the penalty shambles.

Some team is going to get a proper beating from us soon

Edited by 60 yrs a palace fan (11 Dec 2017 2.29pm)

A chance is a bit different to that pathetic effort he's repeated before and we knew was coming when he stood there.

 


COYP

Den1923 Flag 11 Dec 17 3.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke - Need to get over it...' by Midlands Eagle

A win tomorrow and that Benteke penalty incident will be forgotten.

until we are two points short of safety at the end of the season, the club are relegated and lose millions in revenue!

 

big stu Flag milton keynes 11 Dec 17 3.10pm

lets be realistic about this, yes he missed the penalty and yes he shouldn't have gone against orders. to drop him from our next game is surely a case of "cutting our noses of to spite our face". He is our only FORWARD in our entire team at this precise moment in time. what happened on Sat afternoon happened...its Monday now and nothing can change that! he is still getting up to speed from his injuries and although he aint my cup of tea, he does seem to be getting fitter and better. a goal would be great for him and the team. we are Palace and we love the roller coasters, wouldn't be the same without it

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Dec 17 3.20pm

Up to Roy. Roy knows best. He's providing them with everything he can to do the business. It's not he who is getting things wrong, apart from subbing Wilf at geordie fc and claiming the players couldn't get the ball off Benteke, although he probably has good reasons for both.

 


COYP

Simbo2703 Flag Sayers common 11 Dec 17 3.33pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Resect - benteke' by Midlands Eagle

BIG BIG mistake on benteke’s part, by not apologising on social media platforms, to the fans firstly and all at the club, for bullying Luca into the penalty taking.
Has he made a very ‘grave error’ ??
Only a hat - trick will appease us all, I’m still angry now !!
So selfish, looking for the ‘glory’

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 11 Dec 17 3.34pm

Originally posted by Den1923

until we are two points short of safety at the end of the season, the club are relegated and lose millions in revenue!

Like Speroni did in 2005 .
He redeemed himself and wouldn't be stupid enough to do it again would he ?

 

timmyb Flag Banstead 11 Dec 17 3.38pm

Apols if any of this has been said already.

I am not normally one for defending the indefensible...but here goes.

Beneteke's all-round game was not terrible on Saturday.
Far from it. We were sat behind the goal at the Sainsbury's end. He won two huge headers from way beyond the back post, nodding them back into prime danger territory. They should both have been assists for goals, and he was clearly gutted that nobody had gambled on him winning the first balls.

For all our decent possession out wide, I don't recall anyone putting the ball on his head in the danger zone. Sako was more likely to hit the Arthur Wait from the members stand side of the pitch.

When it was played to his feet, CB generally kept it and laid off simple passes.

If a Palace player misses a penalty (and I am old enough to remember Bright, Wright and Pembo all missing in the same game*), I fail to see how booing them before the end of the game will achieve much. Some generous souls up our end were actually booing him as he came back to defend a corner; what utterly self-defeating prattery! I sensed they'd have been happy if he'd banged in an own-goal just to crown the moment.

Here's a thing...that we are a Premier club at all is in (small) part down to the efforts of Cameron Jerome in our first season back...the battering ram who barely scored two league goals all season. CB should never be allowed near a penalty kick ever again, but if he scores a few and others actually get on the end of his knock-downs, we might just stay up.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 11 Dec 17 3.47pm

Originally posted by timmyb

Apols if any of this has been said already.

I am not normally one for defending the indefensible...but here goes.

Beneteke's all-round game was not terrible on Saturday.
Far from it. We were sat behind the goal at the Sainsbury's end. He won two huge headers from way beyond the back post, nodding them back into prime danger territory. They should both have been assists for goals, and he was clearly gutted that nobody had gambled on him winning the first balls.

For all our decent possession out wide, I don't recall anyone putting the ball on his head in the danger zone. Sako was more likely to hit the Arthur Wait from the members stand side of the pitch.

When it was played to his feet, CB generally kept it and laid off simple passes.

If a Palace player misses a penalty (and I am old enough to remember Bright, Wright and Pembo all missing in the same game*), I fail to see how booing them before the end of the game will achieve much. Some generous souls up our end were actually booing him as he came back to defend a corner; what utterly self-defeating prattery! I sensed they'd have been happy if he'd banged in an own-goal just to crown the moment.

Here's a thing...that we are a Premier club at all is in (small) part down to the efforts of Cameron Jerome in our first season back...the battering ram who barely scored two league goals all season. CB should never be allowed near a penalty kick ever again, but if he scores a few and others actually get on the end of his knock-downs, we might just stay up.

Hear Hear

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 11 Dec 17 4.00pm

Originally posted by timmyb

If a Palace player misses a penalty (and I am old enough to remember Bright, Wright and Pembo all missing in the same game*), I fail to see how booing them before the end of the game will achieve much. Some generous souls up our end were actually booing him as he came back to defend a corner; what utterly self-defeating prattery! I sensed they'd have been happy if he'd banged in an own-goal just to crown the moment.

You are missing the point on him taking the penalty. It wasn't just that he missed it, it's that he'd been long relieved of penalty-taking duties because he was bad at them and missed a bunch, while Milevojevic is excellent at them and has yet to miss one in a Palace shirt.

The penalty miss is almost a secondary crime, compared to the out of control egomania and selfishness that had him grab the ball and refuse to follow team orders. Even if he'd dribbled it the other way and it'd somehow gone in, it's still terrible behavior from a paid professional.

If he'd captained himself in his Fantasy team, which might help explain the incident, he got -2 points instead of just -1.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 11 Dec 17 4.30pm

Originally posted by timmyb

Apols if any of this has been said already.

I am not normally one for defending the indefensible...but here goes.

Beneteke's all-round game was not terrible on Saturday.
Far from it. We were sat behind the goal at the Sainsbury's end. He won two huge headers from way beyond the back post, nodding them back into prime danger territory. They should both have been assists for goals, and he was clearly gutted that nobody had gambled on him winning the first balls.

For all our decent possession out wide, I don't recall anyone putting the ball on his head in the danger zone. Sako was more likely to hit the Arthur Wait from the members stand side of the pitch.

When it was played to his feet, CB generally kept it and laid off simple passes.

If a Palace player misses a penalty (and I am old enough to remember Bright, Wright and Pembo all missing in the same game*), I fail to see how booing them before the end of the game will achieve much. Some generous souls up our end were actually booing him as he came back to defend a corner; what utterly self-defeating prattery! I sensed they'd have been happy if he'd banged in an own-goal just to crown the moment.

Here's a thing...that we are a Premier club at all is in (small) part down to the efforts of Cameron Jerome in our first season back...the battering ram who barely scored two league goals all season. CB should never be allowed near a penalty kick ever again, but if he scores a few and others actually get on the end of his knock-downs, we might just stay up.

Hear hear!

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 11 Dec 17 4.33pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Really?

Hopefully that level of short-sightedness and negativity doesn't seep through to the team. I also really hope for your sake that you start finding enjoyment at Palace again, because you seem almost clinically depressed by everything that happens at club at the moment. Maybe Roy should loan you out to Brighton in January?

v.good

 

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Can Benteke redeem himself?