You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish unable to progress us


Page 8 of 16 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Feb 18 7.24pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

The one signing that is a bit beyond me is the loan. Bought by Benfica and straight to us. Odd. Still we could have spent nearly £30 million on tosun

I get the impression that we weren't in for Tosun. He seems to have been someone that Sam wanted when he was here and we could have had him for half what Everton ended up paying for him.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Feb 18 7.26pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops


Too many on here want us to go from a totally skint club staring administration in the face to world beaters in less than 10 seasons.

I think that you'll find that most of us would have been happy with us signing a goalkeeper and a mid table position

 

Painter Flag Croydon 13 Feb 18 8.44pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Painter, you sure are a forgiving character. If Parish egged your house I think you would make an excuse for that - maybe he was letting off some much needed steam.

What previous chairmen have done is completely, utterly, and totally irrelevant to this discussion. As OP I am talking about the next chairmen, or at least the next person to run transfers and managerial matters.

The club is in a completely different state of affairs since the Noades, Jordan and Goldberg era's. Noades, Jordan and Goldberg existed at a time when the game of football was completely and utterly different to what it is today. The sums of money involved for just being in the premier league are at levels that Jordan could only dream of, and the way transfers work now is very different too. The world has changed, sport included, and especially the premier league.

I did not post the OP because we got spanked by a lacklustre Everton, as I pointed out.

Mark my words, print it out, laminate it and put it on the wall. Parish is NOT the right person to move this club forward, that is a fact and cannot be disputed based on the last several seasons.

Here we are, once again, a few points out of the relegation zone.

Parish admitting making mistakes is not quite good enough to explain away the absolutely awful decisions he has made lately involving FDB, and signing players (or failing to do so, time and again).

I have a team of people who work for me, some are good at what they do, some are sh&te. The good ones can be left alone to get the work done, no worries. The sh&te ones keep making the same mistakes over and over again, they cannot, or will not learn from their mistakes.

Their character traits keep influencing their decision making, and they make idiotic decision, after idiotic decision.

I for one dont think I want someone who makes clangers in the magnitude of the FDB fiasco pulling the strings anymore at this club.

Are you happy we have 1 fit keeper? Are you happy we had 1 fit striker when Benteke went down? Its not rocket science or brain surgery level of difficulty for Parish to have not presided over those almighty cock ups. He just had to act decisively and firmly and address those transfers. Alas...he was unable.

I read your post with some relief that you aren't perfect and have employed some sh_te people, but you don't accept that other people can make the same error.

Referencing past Chairmen is relevant, as they have all had an opportunity to progress the club and all failed. It doesn't matter what era it is, the task is the same.

I doubt you were or any other poster privy to the negotiations on any transfers, but prefer to make up your own version to suit your agenda.

The harsh reality is, we and all apart from about 8 clubs are going to be relegated at some point. So what is the progression you want? we don't generate the same income as a lot of Premier teams as our match day revenue is limited due to the size of the Stadium, which Parish is trying to address, until then is always going a them and us situation. Past Chairmen haven't been able to improve the Stadium as Noades held the keys and stopped us trying to progress.

Southampton always seem to be held up, as a well run club, we should aspire to be, but it looks like they may struggle to survive.

Nobody is perfect, who do you think is perfect to run our club?

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Feb 18 8.49pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

If you can't live with it find a different team to support. Chelsea Man U Man City. Face the fact we are punching above our weight. Have one of the most expensive squads in Europe. Our squad depth is poor this is mainly due to the fact we have spent our transfer funds on a few players not increase squad depth. Many people on the Hol were calling for Sakho Cabaye and Benteke to be signed and Wilf to get his wage increase. I am not saying these were all wrong but this is where the money went. Due to FPP we have a limited spend.

Thats pretty rude.

You dont know what this club means to me and my life, and what I have sacrificed over the years to see games and support this team.

I find it very rude to suggest I support a different club just because I dont think Parish is running it correctly.

Suggest you learn to understand people have different opinions to you without trying to tell them they have no right to support the Palace.

Our squad depth is poor for one reason, and one reason alone. The person running the day to day operations of this club and the transfers - Steve Parish.

If Guaita had a release clause that was too high, then FIND ANOTHER KEEPER in the entire world that we can sign. For example Ronnow - oh wait we tried but left it too late.....again. If Guaita's club were playing silly buggers, then once again, find another goalkeeper to sign....dont sit and wait, diterhing around, playing mind games, and get burned, just like on Niasse. Talk about history repeating itself.

Dont leave it to the last minute, again, miss out, again, and try to sign Ronnow and foul it up, again.

I will ask again, are you happy with us being 1 back spasm away from Dion Henry as our number 1, and do you even believe in Hennessey - the guy should have been replaced YEARS ago, not just months. We signed Mandanda, he left, then we just forgot to sign another goalie? Maybe Parish didnt set a reminder on his Iphone?

Were you happy with not signing a striker in the last window? Name another team is this league who is thinner in both goal and attack combined. Those are quite important areas. Keeping goals out, and putting goals in.

Edited by Maine Eagle (13 Feb 2018 8.50pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 13 Feb 18 8.50pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

We're in our fifth consecutive season in the top-flight.
We've never been here before in well over 100yrs of trying.

Yes but subsequent to their investment and input, I would say our squad has not lived up to their potential.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 13 Feb 18 8.50pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I get the impression that we weren't in for Tosun. He seems to have been someone that Sam wanted when he was here and we could have had him for half what Everton ended up paying for him.

This. If there was a falling out with between Sam and Parish over signings/budget for the new season this deal may have been part of it. Tosun might well go on to be a wonder signing but it certainly hasn’t started that well in which case we might have to be thankful that with Sam ‘retiring’ when he did we possibly swerved a very expensive dud - in this instance at least.

Edited by cpfc1976 (13 Feb 2018 8.57pm)

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Feb 18 8.59pm

Originally posted by Painter

I read your post with some relief that you aren't perfect and have employed some sh_te people, but you don't accept that other people can make the same error.

Referencing past Chairmen is relevant, as they have all had an opportunity to progress the club and all failed. It doesn't matter what era it is, the task is the same.

I doubt you were or any other poster privy to the negotiations on any transfers, but prefer to make up your own version to suit your agenda.

The harsh reality is, we and all apart from about 8 clubs are going to be relegated at some point. So what is the progression you want? we don't generate the same income as a lot of Premier teams as our match day revenue is limited due to the size of the Stadium, which Parish is trying to address, until then is always going a them and us situation. Past Chairmen haven't been able to improve the Stadium as Noades held the keys and stopped us trying to progress.

Southampton always seem to be held up, as a well run club, we should aspire to be, but it looks like they may struggle to survive.

Nobody is perfect, who do you think is perfect to run our club?

Someone who understood that in the summer window we desperately needed to bring a striker in, and had to get some business done up front at all costs.

Someone who understood that in the last window, we desperately needed to bring a keeper in (even our manager said it 20 times), and had to get some business done in goal at all costs.

Someone who wont take 2 weeks too long to conduct a managerial search, and then appoint a manager who is so horrendously ill-suited to our club that he may aswell have given the reins to Dame Edna.

As I have said before to the 50 times people say "well what should we do then" If I dare to question Parish's position, I believe he should step back from managerial and transfer matters and concentrate on the business side.

He could give those responsibilities to the best person in the club that he believes could take that on. Maybe its Freedman. Heck, I would even be happy to see Brighty have a shot at it because the guy was a player, and he understands the game. I guess Mark Bright wouldn't have let us walk out of the last window without any cover for Benteke.

If no one fits the bill then bring someone in who could take a leading role in those matters. And for the love of God, give it to a football man, not someone who cut their teeth running a marketing firm.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Feb 18 9.07pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

I purely find it strange the number of Holers (many are trolls) (fans) criticising Parish non stop.
We are where we are,and have an excellent chance of a 6th Season.
That will do for me on on this thread.

Nothing to say then apart from Sakho (injured again and more often than not) was good value. Ok.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Feb 18 9.10pm

Originally posted by palace99


The transfer policy is to come up with a list of players to buy - as you say this is the manager's job, not the chairman.

Therefore the POLICY must be driven by the manager.

BFS chose to get 2 left backs in rather than a striker and Pardew asked for and got Benkete.

Yes the chairman determines the overall budget and negotiates the purchases and contracts but the policy is dictated by the manager. Budget and policy are not the same thing.

100% of British managers would walk if they didn't have final say in who their club buys and (to a lesser extent) sells.

If a manager says they want player X and they are in budget any decent chairman would support their manager's opinion as if not why give them the job. SP has over the last few years been pretty supportive of managers in that respect.

Obviously you've never liked SP so consider our current unbalanced squad all his fault.

Last sentence makes you sound 9 years old.

So going by what you've said, what Roy said he needed and those small costs involved, who is at fault recently, or fonyou think it was a success?

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 13 Feb 18 9.15pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Someone who understood that in the summer window we desperately needed to bring a striker in, and had to get some business done up front at all costs.

Someone who understood that in the last window, we desperately needed to bring a keeper in (even our manager said it 20 times), and had to get some business done in goal at all costs.

Someone who wont take 2 weeks too long to conduct a managerial search, and then appoint a manager who is so horrendously ill-suited to our club that he may aswell have given the reins to Dame Edna.

As I have said before to the 50 times people say "well what should we do then" If I dare to question Parish's position, I believe he should step back from managerial and transfer matters and concentrate on the business side.

He could give those responsibilities to the best person in the club that he believes could take that on. Maybe its Freedman. Heck, I would even be happy to see Brighty have a shot at it because the guy was a player, and he understands the game. I guess Mark Bright wouldn't have let us walk out of the last window without any cover for Benteke.

If no one fits the bill then bring someone in who could take a leading role in those matters. And for the love of God, give it to a football man, not someone who cut their teeth running a marketing firm.[/quote

You need to accept Parish isn't going to walk away, why should he. Just because you think you can do better, isn't really going to sway him.

I don't get the taking 2 weeks too long to appoint a manager, what difference did it make, de Boer wasn't the right man, I seem to remember Hodgson was appointed within a week.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 13 Feb 18 10.00pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Someone who understood that in the summer window we desperately needed to bring a striker in, and had to get some business done up front at all costs.

Someone who understood that in the last window, we desperately needed to bring a keeper in (even our manager said it 20 times), and had to get some business done in goal at all costs.

Someone who wont take 2 weeks too long to conduct a managerial search, and then appoint a manager who is so horrendously ill-suited to our club that he may aswell have given the reins to Dame Edna.

As I have said before to the 50 times people say "well what should we do then" If I dare to question Parish's position, I believe he should step back from managerial and transfer matters and concentrate on the business side.

He could give those responsibilities to the best person in the club that he believes could take that on. Maybe its Freedman. Heck, I would even be happy to see Brighty have a shot at it because the guy was a player, and he understands the game. I guess Mark Bright wouldn't have let us walk out of the last window without any cover for Benteke.

If no one fits the bill then bring someone in who could take a leading role in those matters. And for the love of God, give it to a football man, not someone who cut their teeth running a marketing firm.

This is the problem. We are not in a position to get deals done “at all costs” Parish has made mistakes as most recognise. To right them takes money and money we don’t have to blow in one or two windows certainly not a January window. Also we have had problems with managers, I am sure some of the blame lies with the board and SP but equally some of it has been the managers.

SP has backed managers, unfortunately some of the players brought in haven’t been good enough. That’s down to the managers. There’s a big rebuilding program that needs to be done. We cannot pay over the odds

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Feb 18 11.58pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I get the impression that we weren't in for Tosun. He seems to have been someone that Sam wanted when he was here and we could have had him for half what Everton ended up paying for him.

I'm not sure what gives you that impression. It's all over the press what happened, days later he's banging in goals and winners in the champions league, everyone knows about him, Everton have ready cash and a shortage of strikers. You barely even needed to scout him.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Feb 18 12.03am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

we could have spent nearly £30 million on tosun

He was available for just over half of £30 mil.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Feb 18 12.07am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I cant agree more, so many its not my money but i will still complain because I can, because it hasnt cost me millions, im giving my 30 pound every other week means we should be top 4 by now, all the trolls need life counseling because they have no grasp on reality, simple without parish&co you would need to spit your venom elsewhere, we was gone nobody wanted us,in my book someone safes my life im indebted to them the rest of my life no matter what


The above 2 comments sum it up. Too many on here want us to go from a totally skint club staring administration in the face to world beaters in less than 10 seasons.

It would be lovely wouldn't it, but this isn't fantasy league football, it is reality and in reality we are doing well in my opinion to be where we are. So before anyone else moans on here about anyone and everyone in the management structure of our club, take a step back, draw breath and try and think of the reasons why transfers and other significant matters haven't been dealt with exactly the way you want them to, rather than just simply complaining.

Are you ever capable of not going from one extreme to the other, or using both extremes to make a point. Is there nothing in between in your world. Every thing you say is either one extreme or the other.

Ironically it's a bit immature.

 


COYP

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 14 Feb 18 12.20am

[Link]

I guess SP isn’t under the control, threat or pressure as the powers at West Brom. I wouldn’t have SP out, but it’s a little bit like Benteke not having competition.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

CB Flag 14 Feb 18 12.24am

I feel everything right now stems from the summer fdb appointment. From what I've read the failure to acquire players over the summer came from a mismatch of expectations (fdb not having a list and expecting the club to do it vs the club experience of experienced managers who have their list and get their players). We've been playing catch up since then but we have made a lot of progress.

Looking at the longer view sp has done right by us and we should not take that for granted. Right person to take us forward? Not sure who else would match the good things about him - i like having a fan as otherwise you end up like arsenal, the board not caring like we do. If he solves whatever hisvweaknesses are (be they knowledge of infrastructure investments for the club or transfer nouse) by bringing in thr right support then i cant see there's anyone better suited.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Feb 18 12.28am

Is it too much to ask to:

Have 2 strikers when the season kicks off?

Have 3 keepers at any time after the manager mentions it over and over? Just 1 who is actually prem standard?

Not chuck the first 3-4 games every season, which is a big stride into a relegation scrap? Actually make that upnto 7 games or maybe more.

If people think this is acceptable, unavoidable or smart then think again. Anyone with any football appreciation and say with the chairman wouldn't let this kind of stuff happen, and demand it doesn't before joining or walk if it does happen.

 


COYP

Maine Eagle Flag USA 14 Feb 18 1.13am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Is it too much to ask to:

Have 2 strikers when the season kicks off?

Have 3 keepers at any time after the manager mentions it over and over? Just 1 who is actually prem standard?

Not chuck the first 3-4 games every season, which is a big stride into a relegation scrap? Actually make that upnto 7 games or maybe more.

If people think this is acceptable, unavoidable or smart then think again. Anyone with any football appreciation and say with the chairman wouldn't let this kind of stuff happen, and demand it doesn't before joining or walk if it does happen.

How about never making impactful signings which are desperately needed at the START of a transfer window, rather than right at the end (or not at all) thus throwing away even more points with a sub standard team during the window itself.

Parish is clueless when it comes to transfers, and apparently when it comes to keeping manager's happy. Also when it comes to knowing when to fire someone. Also when it comes to hiring anyone other than a well established name that anyone could think of. He also cant seem to ever sell any of our deadwood.

Hes got a nice plan for the new stadium though, so I guess its ok.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 14 Feb 18 1.20am

Originally posted by Painter

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Someone who understood that in the summer window we desperately needed to bring a striker in, and had to get some business done up front at all costs.

Someone who understood that in the last window, we desperately needed to bring a keeper in (even our manager said it 20 times), and had to get some business done in goal at all costs.

Someone who wont take 2 weeks too long to conduct a managerial search, and then appoint a manager who is so horrendously ill-suited to our club that he may aswell have given the reins to Dame Edna.

As I have said before to the 50 times people say "well what should we do then" If I dare to question Parish's position, I believe he should step back from managerial and transfer matters and concentrate on the business side.

He could give those responsibilities to the best person in the club that he believes could take that on. Maybe its Freedman. Heck, I would even be happy to see Brighty have a shot at it because the guy was a player, and he understands the game. I guess Mark Bright wouldn't have let us walk out of the last window without any cover for Benteke.

If no one fits the bill then bring someone in who could take a leading role in those matters. And for the love of God, give it to a football man, not someone who cut their teeth running a marketing firm.[/quote

You need to accept Parish isn't going to walk away, why should he. Just because you think you can do better, isn't really going to sway him.

I don't get the taking 2 weeks too long to appoint a manager, what difference did it make, de Boer wasn't the right man, I seem to remember Hodgson was appointed within a week.

I never said I could do better, I am not a football person who learned the game from a young age and can draw on that experience now - but I am the same as Parish in that regard.

I said someone else could do better.

Taking 2 weeks too long to hire FDB further compounds how calamitous that error truly was. Just sit down and think about that, he hired an Ajax product who likes to play patient possession based football. Sounds like a perfect fit, right?

My 3 year old cousin could have figured that one out.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Den1923 Flag 14 Feb 18 2.17am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

That 'salary' was the only income he'd taken & it was widely reported at the time that the Americans insisted he took a salary that year - something to do with his personal expenditure in getting the deal with them done & the way the buy-in was structured.

As for the whole 'taking the club forward' argument it wholly depends on what you take into consideration. If it's just footballing matters then there's a debate but if you factor in ground improvements, training ground improvements, moves to rebuild the academy, better medical facilities, sound financial base & an ambitious redevelopment plan then I think it's fair to =say we've come a long way already.

Ok, it'll mean less if we did get relegated but these are the areas where the Southamptons of the world are way ahead of us & (probably) need addressing as quickly as possible.

Does SP make mistakes - yes.
Could we do better - possibly.
Could we do much worse - definitely.

CP is a business investment for SP! He is not doing this for fun as you suggest or out the goodness of his heart, as for developing the ground etc that's all great stuff but not a lot of use in the championship which thanks to SP mistakes now looks highly likely!

 

Page 8 of 16 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us