You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 8 of 27 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
dg1937 Flag 28 Nov 18 5.04pm

Ray Lewington was guest speaker at the Supporters' Trust AGM on Monday and I took the opportunity to ask him what Meyer's best position was. He ran through the positions that aren't his best: defensive midfielder (not strong enough in the tackle); wide right (prefers not to play there); or in the No.10 role (he doesn't like playing there). He concluded that the position he played at Old Trafford was his best (essentially on the left side of a midfield four). Ray also suggested that the performance at Old Trafford had been very good and the shirt was more or less his to lose.

Obviously things might change but I don't think we'll see Meyer in the No.10 role for some time. So, although Maine might be right about Andros being the one to drop out, I think MM will be part of a supporting four.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 28 Nov 18 7.41pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Be tempted to replace Andros.

WH
AWB - JT - MS - PVA
JM - LM - CK
MM
CB - WZ


I'd rather drop AT back into midfield where he's generally been more comfortable and let hime replace Jimmy Mac, who may have played wellbut has rarly looked menacing in attack or better defensive cover than Andros on the right of midfield.

 

est1905 Flag 29 Nov 18 5.45pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Only just saw the game and I gotta feel sorry for Meyer. It’s inevitable fans will start turning on him.

He can’t get a game, and when he does, he’s being played out of position. He’s a creative midfielder. Not a defensive one.

To me this just stinks of utter incompetence from our scouting department, who seem to be unable to differentiate between “deep” and “defensive”.

He played one season for Schalke “deep” in a Jorginho type role, and they seemed to of translated that to someone who could replace Cabaye.

The guy is not a defensive midfielder, he’s a creative one. I’ve said it since the start, were not gonna get the best out of him playing him in Cabayes role, it’s really as simple as that.

So frustrating to watch Schlupp and Mccarthur as our furthest forward midfielders when Meyer is on the pitch. He’s being completely wasted.

I guess it’s all rather academic, considering he can’t get a game in the league anyway. But, still, it would be utterly criminal for us to waste what is arguably the most technically gifted player we’ve ever had at the club in this way.

Why can’t Roy see this?

Edited by Mstrobez (01 Nov 2018 4.47am)

Attillio Lombardo in his prime would wipe the floor with Max. Dont get me wrong, I very much like Meyer and agree he is not being used as effectively as he could be but its stretching it to call him the most technically gifted player we've ever had. At this stage he isn't even the most technically gifted player in our current team! That would be Wilf.

 

Mstrobez Flag 01 Dec 18 5.03pm

MOTM today for me. And that’s why I’ve been crying out to see him in that position for so long.

Against lesser opposition than utd and Chelsea especially. He could be absolutely unreal for us.

The 442 is a system that has quite simply worked for us under Roy. Gives us defensive consistency. But as I said. The left position allows him to get creative and come inside during attacks. Did so and linked up with Wilf and co all game.

Gotta be nailed on as a starter now. Looks like the slow integrating of him in the team may well have just come down to fitness.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Dec 18 5.43pm

Meyers passes into channels to run into are perfection. Bring on the gimps on Tuesday.

 


COYP

W12 01 Dec 18 5.45pm

Going to be a very important player for us.

Other than a striker he’s been the player we have been crying out for, for a few seasons now. We now have a link between midfield and attack. World class 23 years old on a 3 year contract. Got to give Parish, Freedman and co massive respect for this signing.

When our first choice 11 are fit we are a match for anyone in this league. Barring another crisis I expect us to shoot up the league between now and the new year. Get RLC and a striker and we could be in dream land (and not the Margate one).

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Dec 18 6.58pm

Originally posted by W12

Going to be a very important player for us.

Other than a striker he’s been the player we have been crying out for, for a few seasons now. We now have a link between midfield and attack. World class 23 years old on a 3 year contract. Got to give Parish, Freedman and co massive respect for this signing.

When our first choice 11 are fit we are a match for anyone in this league. Barring another crisis I expect us to shoot up the league between now and the new year. Get RLC and a striker and we could be in dream land (and not the Margate one).

Yeah but it’ll be with Wilf leaving in the summer probably, although hopefully with players already here to take over.

I doubt we’ll get RLC with Meyer playing well. It’s not Parish’s way.

 


COYP

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 Dec 18 7.06pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yeah but it’ll be with Wilf leaving in the summer probably, although hopefully with players already here to take over.

I doubt we’ll get RLC with Meyer playing well. It’s not Parish’s way.

Why do we need RLC - if Meyer doing the job?

Stop looking in the past - look here and now..!!

COYP

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 01 Dec 18 9.10pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Why do we need RLC - if Meyer doing the job?

Stop looking in the past - look here and now..!!

COYP

I'd argue getting RLC would be a massive step into the future not past.

 

AERO Flag 01 Dec 18 9.18pm

Think a goal scorer takes priority in Jan , anything else is bonus

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 01 Dec 18 10.09pm

Originally posted by dg1937

Ray Lewington was guest speaker at the Supporters' Trust AGM on Monday and I took the opportunity to ask him what Meyer's best position was. He ran through the positions that aren't his best: defensive midfielder (not strong enough in the tackle); wide right (prefers not to play there); or in the No.10 role (he doesn't like playing there). He concluded that the position he played at Old Trafford was his best (essentially on the left side of a midfield four). Ray also suggested that the performance at Old Trafford had been very good and the shirt was more or less his to lose.

Obviously things might change but I don't think we'll see Meyer in the No.10 role for some time. So, although Maine might be right about Andros being the one to drop out, I think MM will be part of a supporting four.

Interesting to read that, would've like to have been there given Ray was so open. In his post match interview today Meyer corroborated that he prefers not to play DM but hinted he doesn't mind getting forward, so perhaps his best position is to play in the middle, perhaps on the left as you said, with license to drive forward as he did today, operating between no. ten and no. 8 roles more or less. Its working a charm.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 01 Dec 18 10.44pm

quality today, really looking like he has acclimatised to english football...has an aura of quality about him

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


bicycle repair man 01 Dec 18 10.55pm

Quite simply,Meyer was magnificent today.

 

chateauferret Flag 02 Dec 18 12.21am

He looked the business today. Absolute class. Controlled everything, kept the ball, sent men running forward and had a few pretty good shots as well. Unlucky not to score. Looks like a natural creative player, more so than say Cabaye, and adds more than a veneer of class and precision to our play.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 02 Dec 18 1.54am

Originally posted by chateauferret

He looked the business today. Absolute class. Controlled everything, kept the ball, sent men running forward and had a few pretty good shots as well. Unlucky not to score. Looks like a natural creative player, more so than say Cabaye, and adds more than a veneer of class and precision to our play.

Totally agree, he looked really classy yesterday. I thought he'd scored the goal that was credited to McArthur ... who also played well ... but he hadn't of course.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 02 Dec 18 8.40am

If he strengthens up a bit more (nice to see him make a full-blooded challenge towards the end) we are looking at a very special player.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Dec 18 8.45am

Originally posted by chateauferret

He looked the business today. Absolute class. Controlled everything, kept the ball, sent men running forward and had a few pretty good shots as well. Unlucky not to score. Looks like a natural creative player, more so than say Cabaye, and adds more than a veneer of class and precision to our play.

I thought he scored. No??

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 02 Dec 18 9.41am

He will be the difference between us and Brighton on Tuesday night. Get him on the ball near the box and we will cash in...

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Dec 18 10.02am

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

If he strengthens up a bit more (nice to see him make a full-blooded challenge towards the end) we are looking at a very special player.

Turns on a sixpence off either foot which is the sign of a well balanced player. Great vision and weight of pass. Defensively he is average at best and needs to up his game a bit in that respect but when Milivojevic and Kouyate are on the pitch his defensive duties are reduced.

His favourite position we are told is left midfield cutting in and supporting the strikers. I think we saw the best of that yesterday, it was an impressive performance and he was my man of the match although Kouyate and a few others ran him close in that respect.

We effectively played with 4 attacking midfielders yesterday but importantly kept width in our play for the entire match. It stretched Burnley’s pedestrian defence to breaking point. We won’t be playing defences like that every week unfortunately but if we stick to that style of play we will cause problems for every team.

Meyer has earned his starting spot and unless we are playing a game where we want to shut up shop I now think he will start every match. Well played Max!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Dec 18 10.26am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

He will be the difference between us and Brighton on Tuesday night. Get him on the ball near the box and we will cash in...

That’s my thinking. It’s a shame we don’t have a striker to slide balls through for, but their defenders aren’t suited to him or the way we’re playing. They’re all guys and thunder and we’re playing with more style and sophistication and 4 tough players at CB and def makes d areas. I hope I haven’t jinxed us. We’re on the up so a good time to face them in their subbetteo stadium.

 


COYP

Page 8 of 27 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread