This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The Judge would soon put an end to any such possibility in the minds of the jury. Who are the only ones who matter. Whatever the Court of Public Opinion has previously decided is irrelevant to the outcome of a court case. Should he be found not guilty his reputation would quickly be restored and that of the media making the claims ruined. And how would the judge do that? Put yourself on the jury.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That is a common misconception. That they were aware is true, but not that they didn't act. Their actions were to try to work with social services to eradicate the evil at source. A policy which has since been widely discredited but nonetheless was an action. I sympathise with the over-stretched police commanders who are trying to spread thin resources over many societal problems. They are inevitably going to fall through some gaps and be condemned as a consequence. An action which allowed future suffering for an unknown number of children over the course of several years.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Kevin Spacey has not sued for defamation, as far as I am aware. Will he? If so would he succeed? He was cleared of the charges against him which required he be proven guilty beyond any reasonable doubt. Proving defamation requires another standard of proof. If he is unsure would he risk it? Best let it lie! If Brand is so certain everything that was done was consensual and that the hard evidence of texts and videos can be explained then he has a golden opportunity to profit. We will see. Had Spacey been accused on national television he might have done.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
There is no evidence in the Brand case. Nor is there currently legal re-dress in process. Yet the story currently saturates the media to the extent the things that matter are in the small print on the inside pages. Wisbech, you pick and chose due process when it suits you. You championed the Government's right not to be judged by media reporting and wait for the Covid Inquiry findings. Yet you are willing to see a man destroyed because you don't like what he's done,...according to the media. You seem very confused about this. There is lots of evidence. Some of it is hearsay but of a type by which patterns can be established and the probability of truth being established. There is also hard evidence by way of text messages, recorded phone calls and videos. Whether and when this moves to a legal process seems to me to be only a matter of time. You don't turn up and publish this kind of evidence without being sure it can be substantiated. How news editors decide to treat it is a matter for them. You are free to disagree with their judgement but don't have their job at the moment. I don't support trial by media. I want to see due process being followed, the claims and defence tested and justice done. That it needed a piece of investigative journalism to bring that about might be regrettable but it's a reflection of the world we live in. To conflate my view over Covid with this is ridiculous. I have no problem with people wanting to criticise past Government policy if they wish to. I just think it's a pointless waste of time and effort and the only place we can actually learn useful lessons is via an objective analysis such as the current enquiry is intended to facilitate. If Brand is destroyed by this then it will only be because he brought it upon himself. If he has a believable defence he is free to make it. I am quite sure it would be given every opportunity. Especially if and when it reaches a court where should be acquitted, he would emerge with an enhanced reputation. Brand has nothing to fear but himself.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You seem very confused about this. There is lots of evidence. Some of it is hearsay but of a type by which patterns can be established and the probability of truth being established. There is also hard evidence by way of text messages, recorded phone calls and videos. Whether and when this moves to a legal process seems to me to be only a matter of time. You don't turn up and publish this kind of evidence without being sure it can be substantiated. How news editors decide to treat it is a matter for them. You are free to disagree with their judgement but don't have their job at the moment. I don't support trial by media. I want to see due process being followed, the claims and defence tested and justice done. That it needed a piece of investigative journalism to bring that about might be regrettable but it's a reflection of the world we live in. To conflate my view over Covid with this is ridiculous. I have no problem with people wanting to criticise past Government policy if they wish to. I just think it's a pointless waste of time and effort and the only place we can actually learn useful lessons is via an objective analysis such as the current enquiry is intended to facilitate. If Brand is destroyed by this then it will only be because he brought it upon himself. If he has a believable defence he is free to make it. I am quite sure it would be given every opportunity. Especially if and when it reaches a court where should be acquitted, he would emerge with an enhanced reputation. Brand has nothing to fear but himself. You can be very patronising. Your first line is not a requirement to make your point. If an opinion is different to yours it could well be you who are confused !
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
You can be very patronising. Your first line is not a requirement to make your point. If an opinion is different to yours it could well be you who are confused ! If you check the comment I responded to you will see it made some unjustified accusations. Hence the first line, which is actually quite a polite comment.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Not a fan of Russel Brand. I have also not watched his YouTube videos. However...Regardless of hearsay, or potential evidence the law is Innocent until proven guilty. With the ridiculous "evidence" put into the media before the courts it makes it almost impossible to convict. Maybe they knew he was innocent but just wanted him cancelled? Interesting they won't do an interview or an "expose" on the Epstein client list. With regard to your last sentence, we have said exactly the same. Interesting isn’t it
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That is a common misconception. That they were aware is true, but not that they didn't act. Their actions were to try to work with social services to eradicate the evil at source. A policy which has since been widely discredited but nonetheless was an action. I sympathise with the over-stretched police commanders who are trying to spread thin resources over many societal problems. They are inevitably going to fall through some gaps and be condemned as a consequence. The playing down and mitigation by the likes of you, of the scandal of pakistani-heritage paedophile gangs carrying out mass sexual abuse on children in several towns while the police were fully informed of what was going on, is truly sickening.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
In a perfect world where abused women had complete confidence in a police force with the time, skills and resources to thoroughly, sympathetically and anonymously investigate every complaint and no media company was motivated by a desire to sell newspapers or attract viewers, that might be true. We don't live in such a world. So enabling the stories of possible victims to be told and evaluated through the work of investigative journalists who have been given the time and resources to investigate can be seen as a responsible compromise. If it throws up evidence that causes the police to investigate so much the better. I remain convinced that no media company would risk publishing this kind of story unless they were totally sure the evidence was there to support it. Never forget what happened with the "grooming gang" stories. Some here were full of praise for the newspapers who were headlining them, and indeed for Yaxley-Lennon's videos, but scornful of the police. Can you see the hypocrisy and double standards being employed? Especially when the police were investigating and resented the stories because they resulted in them having to divert resources. Nevertheless, these stories did ensure more attention was given and the police were criticised, somewhat unfairly in my own opinion given their under-resourcing. I criticised some of the stories, not because they were highlighting criminal behaviour but because of the way the tabloids spun them. There is no such spinning involved here. I'm not arguing the values of investigative journalism; when done right it's a valuable tool. But that names and reputations should be left out of it, and handed to the relevant authorities to preserve the rights of that individual(s) until such a time that guilt can be proven. You've mentioned Jury's in another post - these are supposed to be unbiased members of the public. How can a jury be assigned to this case now (if it makes it that far) when the media have done as much they can to bias public opinion? The stories told by mainstream media (especially when celebrity scoops are involved) cannot be relied upon. The evidence they present are designed to prove one point; their point. All without the possibility of cross examination = and people lap it up and believe every word. They (the media) have too much control and too much influence, up to a point now that I have stopped really listening to what they have to say. There is still plenty of high quality journalism out there, but its undiscernible from the sensationalist rhetoric spouted by their colleagues and peers.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Not a fan of Russel Brand. I have also not watched his YouTube videos. However...Regardless of hearsay, or potential evidence the law is Innocent until proven guilty. With the ridiculous "evidence" put into the media before the courts it makes it almost impossible to convict. Maybe they knew he was innocent but just wanted him cancelled? Interesting they won't do an interview or an "expose" on the Epstein client list. A Judge would direct a jury to disregard all they had heard or seen before and evaluate only the evidence put before them in court. This situation has occurred many times and is not a barrier to justice. Why no list of Epstein’s clients hasn’t emerged isn’t known. Perhaps it was only in his head and never written down. Perhaps it was destroyed along with other computer records. Perhaps it hasn’t yet been discovered. If it exists and had been found it would have leaked by now. There are more than enough outlets who would eagerly publish such data and more than enough people willing to pass it to them and get rich doing so.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
I'm not arguing the values of investigative journalism; when done right it's a valuable tool. But that names and reputations should be left out of it, and handed to the relevant authorities to preserve the rights of that individual(s) until such a time that guilt can be proven. You've mentioned Jury's in another post - these are supposed to be unbiased members of the public. How can a jury be assigned to this case now (if it makes it that far) when the media have done as much they can to bias public opinion? The stories told by mainstream media (especially when celebrity scoops are involved) cannot be relied upon. The evidence they present are designed to prove one point; their point. All without the possibility of cross examination = and people lap it up and believe every word. They (the media) have too much control and too much influence, up to a point now that I have stopped really listening to what they have to say. There is still plenty of high quality journalism out there, but its undiscernible from the sensationalist rhetoric spouted by their colleagues and peers. Part of the reason for naming the individual is to encourage others to come forward so that a case can be put together. It’s just letting the genie out of the bottle. A jury can be instructed to disregard all they have heard before. It’s not unusual. The Judge will tell them how to do this. You can distrust the media all you wish but you cannot disregard the personal testimony of those making the claims. It’s for us to judge their authenticity at this stage and reach our own conclusions. Alongside that is other, hard, evidence. The texts and videos. This wasn’t done by a tabloid trying to create a splash headline. It is a lengthy, thorough piece of investigative journalism by serious newspapers and broadcasters.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
A jury can be instructed to disregard all they have heard before. It’s not unusual. The Judge will tell them how to do this. You can distrust the media all you wish but you cannot disregard the personal testimony of those making the claims. It’s for us to judge their authenticity at this stage and reach our own conclusions. Alongside that is other, hard, evidence. The texts and videos. This wasn’t done by a tabloid trying to create a splash headline. It is a lengthy, thorough piece of investigative journalism by serious newspapers and broadcasters. A robust defence of Rupert Murdoch's policies.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Part of the reason for naming the individual is to encourage others to come forward so that a case can be put together. It’s just letting the genie out of the bottle. A jury can be instructed to disregard all they have heard before. It’s not unusual. The Judge will tell them how to do this. You can distrust the media all you wish but you cannot disregard the personal testimony of those making the claims. It’s for us to judge their authenticity at this stage and reach our own conclusions. Alongside that is other, hard, evidence. The texts and videos. This wasn’t done by a tabloid trying to create a splash headline. It is a lengthy, thorough piece of investigative journalism by serious newspapers and broadcasters. If the suspect isn't a celebrity there is no genie to be let out of anywhere. Media outlets report on famous people to increase their sales not out of any kind of altruism or public spirit.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Part of the reason for naming the individual is to encourage others to come forward so that a case can be put together. It’s just letting the genie out of the bottle. A jury can be instructed to disregard all they have heard before. It’s not unusual. The Judge will tell them how to do this. You can distrust the media all you wish but you cannot disregard the personal testimony of those making the claims. It’s for us to judge their authenticity at this stage and reach our own conclusions. Alongside that is other, hard, evidence. The texts and videos. This wasn’t done by a tabloid trying to create a splash headline. It is a lengthy, thorough piece of investigative journalism by serious newspapers and broadcasters. Maybe so, but it's not the Media that should be building the case, it's the police. As such the name should ONLY be released when the police have given the OK to do so. Edited by CrazyBadger (20 Sep 2023 10.31am)
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
Maybe so, but it's not the Media that should be building the case, it's the police. As such the name should ONLY be released when the police have given the OK to do so.
A judge should actually make that decision on a case by case basis.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
A judge should actually make that decision on a case by case basis. Interesting, so even the Police do not have the authority to do that? That surprises me.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The playing down and mitigation by the likes of you, of the scandal of pakistani-heritage paedophile gangs carrying out mass sexual abuse on children in several towns while the police were fully informed of what was going on, is truly sickening. Well said. Degenerate and disgusting.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.