You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 3.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 82 of 91 < 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Feb 20 4.55pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

You write as if we were relegated two seasons ago from this league and are now falling into the third tier and oblivion.
We have two players who should have been well able to steady our ship both at opposite ends and both failing miserably to do anything, injury, luck and confidence has contributed to making Parish look worse then he is and I'm not mentioning all the other players we have tried our luck on and as to date had very little in return, we can only gamble with players even the two I mentioned who were actually brought in as the finished article and at a cost that is quite possibly the reason for most of your anger, Gayle was a gamble he looked great at Peterborough and at times looked great with us but it has been proved that he cannot quite step up for the rough and tumble of this league sad as it is Meyer looks to be in the same book ..he has been given enough opportunities to shine.

Whatever Parish does is to a large degree a gamble, look at West Ham and the games they have to play, awful situation bet they wish they had Mr Hodgson.

I don’t remember Sakho or Benteke playing right back or left back where we’ve again taken chances with, or on the wing or behind the striker. And I don’t recall FDB or Hodgson ever playing football that suits Benteke who Parish bought a year before. It’s this sort of thing that puts us in these situations.

Parish has obvious faults. Should have had someone qualified making football decisions. Not himself, Freedman or anyone else who protects his wages when he agrees with everything suggested.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Feb 20 4.57pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

You write as if we were relegated two seasons ago from this league and are now falling into the third tier and oblivion.
We have two players who should have been well able to steady our ship both at opposite ends and both failing miserably to do anything, injury, luck and confidence has contributed to making Parish look worse then he is and I'm not mentioning all the other players we have tried our luck on and as to date had very little in return, we can only gamble with players even the two I mentioned who were actually brought in as the finished article and at a cost that is quite possibly the reason for most of your anger, Gayle was a gamble he looked great at Peterborough and at times looked great with us but it has been proved that he cannot quite step up for the rough and tumble of this league sad as it is Meyer looks to be in the same book ..he has been given enough opportunities to shine.

Whatever Parish does is to a large degree a gamble, look at West Ham and the games they have to play, awful situation bet they wish they had Mr Hodgson.

I don’t remember Sakho or Benteke playing right back or left back where we’ve again taken chances with, or on the wing or behind the striker. And I don’t recall FDB or Hodgson ever playing football that suits Benteke who Parish bought a year before. It’s this sort of thing that puts us in these situations.

Parish has obvious faults. Should have had someone qualified making football decisions. Not himself, Freedman or anyone else who protects his wages when he agrees with everything suggested.

 


COYP

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 23 Feb 20 5.12pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Football is a results business. Looking at our league position and points tally I think we are roughly around where we deserve to be from a performance and strength of squad perspective. In fact I think the manager deserves credit for getting us this far with the available resources .

In terms of a transfer policy, I'm not seeing signs that there is one. The long ago stated aim of buying young players with potential and therefore a decent sell on value never materialised. Then came the expensive ( Benteke, Sakho ) purchases that have not delivered value for money although both felt right at the time. Succession planning for players is difficult given the average turnover of managers at most clubs, and succession planning for managers is virtually unheard of and subject to change. I bet City fans thought Arteta was a shoe in to replace Pep at some point.

Younger players being fast tracked into the first team won't happen unless the Academy is invested in to make Palace more competitive for the talent that they are currently missing out on. So I get the investment in that, it needs to happen.

To me it sounded like the stadium redevelopment hinges on doing a deal with Sainsburys ( that's assuming funding is available ). I would contend that the deal with them should have been agreed at least in principle before Parish revealed the plans for the new stand.

It's difficult not to be cynical about Parish's interview given that it was conducted ' in house '. A more probing set of questions by an independent journalist may have teased more out of him.

Yes l, I think I agree with everything you are saying here, but it all boils down to the fact that Parish really didn’t deal with the issues that are outstanding at our club in that interview. We are pottering along, we are not looking like a club that wants to dramatically improve.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Feb 20 5.46pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle


maybe its just me...but i am proud the club is run in a sustainable manner, and it should be something that is lauded.

But is it being run in a sustainable manner? Our wage bill is far too high and if we are relegated then we are up s*** creek

 

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 23 Feb 20 6.13pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

But is it being run in a sustainable manner? Our wage bill is far too high and if we are relegated then we are up s*** creek

Sustainable enough to keep us in the top tier for seven seasons so we haven’t been relegated and don’t look like like it again for now. So we won’t be up s—- creek but won’t win the league or play in Europe. What exactly do you expect?

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 23 Feb 20 6.31pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

But is it being run in a sustainable manner? Our wage bill is far too high and if we are relegated then we are up s*** creek

any club that has spend a prolonged period of time in the PL is up s*** creek if relegated...you cant compete in this league on £30k a week salaries. in fact 50% of championship clubs are f***ed & havnt been promoted in years.

we have no debt and on course for another mid-table finish...if thats not sustainable then i dont know what is...our wage bill is more or less comparable to where we finish most seasons.

i bet if parish brought neymar & built a 50k stadium you would still moan about s*** hotdogs.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Feb 20 6.39pm

Originally posted by Jamesey

Sustainable enough to keep us in the top tier for seven seasons so we haven’t been relegated and don’t look like like it again for now. So we won’t be up s—- creek but won’t win the league or play in Europe. What exactly do you expect?

It’s more the next season or two or three that is concerning everyone. After Roy had them take Newcastle on rather than do the same the situation this season has changed a bit.

We really are in a lot of trouble if things aren’t handled properly, and that doesn’t mean spending as little as possible or trying to dictate to everyone how business is done, especially when we need the business to be done and they know it.

I agree with Parish on the twitter morons but some of the stuff we were supposed to be won over by was jaw dropping.

Part of me thinks that if he didn’t say anything then the flack would continue, but by saying what he did, which was in all intents and purposes nothing apart from regarding the academy, Parish may as well have just released a couple of statements on the academy and Roy’s contract and possibly a ‘reasonable offer’, whatever that means to Sainsbury’s after how many years is it since they released plans but didn’t speak to Sainsbury’s at the time. Hmmm. Now what would we be thinking here? Sounds like lloyds II and how we do transfer business (we don’t do).

People were critical of handling of transfers, football strategy and things before Freedman came in and I don’t think we’ve seen much to convince us the Parish-Roy-Freedman relationship has improved things apart from Guaita and James McCarthy.

The proof will be in the summer but it’s understandable we aren’t convinced we’re going about things in ways that will solve even more testing squad issues than we’ve had in recent memory, and with the comment the younger signings block academy players just takes the piss out of our intelligence tbh.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Feb 20 6.47pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

any club that has spend a prolonged period of time in the PL is up s*** creek if relegated...you cant compete in this league on £30k a week salaries. in fact 50% of championship clubs are f***ed & havnt been promoted in years.

we have no debt and on course for another mid-table finish...if thats not sustainable then i dont know what is...our wage bill is more or less comparable to where we finish most seasons.

i bet if parish brought neymar & built a 50k stadium you would still moan about s*** hotdogs.

The classic, ‘well if it’s not £110k-130k per week it’s £30k. Nothing in between, that’ll negate your point.

Our wage bill was 9th when our revenue must be about 14th. I don’t expect 9th, Europe £130k or £30k per week players. I expected when we hired a DOF he’d be experienced and the relationship between him, the manager and owners would be one in harmony. I’ve seen little to suggest it is other than a few players everybody knew were available plus Guaita. It’s this area we should be getting right. We aren’t, and I’m not confident we will when the need to get more of them done in Windows becomes greater and greater. They’ve sussed the market for stop gap older players, but that’s it.

 


COYP

davehuggins Flag 23 Feb 20 7.19pm

Our recruitment IMO over the last few windows has been a complete shambles apart from a couple of good bits of biz. With huge amounts of money at stake for me this is the one area we must get right sooner rather than later!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Feb 20 7.49pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

we have no debt and on course for another mid-table finish...if thats not sustainable then i dont know what is...our wage bill is more or less comparable to where we finish most seasons.

i bet if parish brought neymar & built a 50k stadium you would still moan about s*** hotdogs.

If we have no debt then it's because we needed to sell players to pay it off and I'm not sure you understand what sustainable means anyway.

Your final paragraph is particularly stupid and I'll take your word for the state of the hotdogs as I don't eat that sort of crap and will happily bow to your greater experience of them


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Feb 20 8.15pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

If we have no debt then it's because we needed to sell players to pay it off and I'm not sure you understand what sustainable means anyway.

Your final paragraph is particularly stupid and I'll take your word for the state of the hotdogs as I don't eat that sort of crap and will happily bow to your greater experience of them

He nicked it off Jordan on the back of the advertiser. One of his panacea answers that say nothing and mean nothing.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (23 Feb 2020 11.39pm)

 


COYP

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 23 Feb 20 8.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It’s more the next season or two or three that is concerning everyone. After Roy had them take Newcastle on rather than do the same the situation this season has changed a bit.

We really are in a lot of trouble if things aren’t handled properly, and that doesn’t mean spending as little as possible or trying to dictate to everyone how business is done, especially when we need the business to be done and they know it.

I agree with Parish on the twitter morons but some of the stuff we were supposed to be won over by was jaw dropping.

Part of me thinks that if he didn’t say anything then the flack would continue, but by saying what he did, which was in all intents and purposes nothing apart from regarding the academy, Parish may as well have just released a couple of statements on the academy and Roy’s contract and possibly a ‘reasonable offer’, whatever that means to Sainsbury’s after how many years is it since they released plans but didn’t speak to Sainsbury’s at the time. Hmmm. Now what would we be thinking here? Sounds like lloyds II and how we do transfer business (we don’t do).

People were critical of handling of transfers, football strategy and things before Freedman came in and I don’t think we’ve seen much to convince us the Parish-Roy-Freedman relationship has improved things apart from Guaita and James McCarthy.

The proof will be in the summer but it’s understandable we aren’t convinced we’re going about things in ways that will solve even more testing squad issues than we’ve had in recent memory, and with the comment the younger signings block academy players just takes the piss out of our intelligence tbh.

It's not concerning "everyone" that I have contact with...quite a few. Just you making sweeping statements.

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Painter Flag Croydon 23 Feb 20 9.26pm

Originally posted by doombear

EXACTLY. it was noteworthy that SP spoke about the younger teams (U16s etc) as having promising players. I reckon apart from Pierrick and a couple of others who have trained/are training with the first team squad, there may not be anything exciting in the pipeline for a couple of years or so during which time we will have to manage with our ageing squad and possibly a few new younger additions over the coming windows.

The results of the U23s gives an indication as to the potential being nurtured for the first team, it doesn't look encouraging. Upgrading the academy is a start, but it takes time.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Feb 20 9.56pm

Originally posted by Painter

The results of the U23s gives an indication as to the potential being nurtured for the first team, it doesn't look encouraging. Upgrading the academy is a start, but it takes time.

I'm not sure I've implied anything different form what you are saying. The current U23s are NOT our future, hence we will need to wait for the younger teams. Perhaps I should have said five or so years.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Feb 20 11.45pm

Originally posted by Jamesey

It's not concerning "everyone" that I have contact with...quite a few. Just you making sweeping statements.

Maybe not everyone, but, as you say, quite a few.

Hopefully the actions speak louder than the words because the words are mostly contradictory bollox. As a fan I want Parish to be our most successful chairman but we’re currently built on sand.

 


COYP

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 23 Feb 20 11.59pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Maybe not everyone, but, as you say, quite a few.

Hopefully the actions speak louder than the words because the words are mostly contradictory bollox. As a fan I want Parish to be our most successful chairman but we’re currently built on sand.

Maybe I phrased my post badly - I meant quite a few people who I have contact with don't agree with your view and are not concerned that the club is being run badly.

That's all from me...quibbling is such a waste of time for us all really.

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Feb 20 10.53am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

He nicked it off Jordan on the back of the advertiser. One of his panacea answers that say nothing and mean nothing.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (23 Feb 2020 11.39pm)

From Jordan? Just goes to show moaning about the club is nothing new and it doesn’t change anything.

 

PatrickA Flag London 24 Feb 20 11.07am

I have been a strong critic of Hodgson this season and have felt we could have maybe collected more points if we attacked more- as we did v Newcastle.
Having watched his press conference after the game though I got a better understanding where he is coming from in his approach.
With him he doesn't get swayed by results reasoning that you can lose unluckily or win luckily.
Therefore he's more concerned with solid performances and attitude.
If you get those right the chances are you will get enough good results as reward.
Over his time at Palace he has succeeded in this.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Feb 20 11.33am

This is true but it is tough to watch with the refusal to put a sub on when it is so obvious nothing is going to happen without one.

Plus the whole mindset on the pitch v Newcastle was completely different to every other league game at Selhurst I can remember under Hodgson, right from the start. We weren’t relying on a chance maybe presenting itself. We made the game present the chances by imposing ourselves on the opposition rather than being so far away from them it’s like watching a training drill or preseason match. The approach for so long has been exactly the same, whether we play bottom 3 or top 3 teams, apart from on Saturday. It never ever changes and there’s never ever any real intent to change the dynamic of the game when we need to.

We have better better at this under Roy. Now we’re usually stuffed if we don’t get the first goal. If we’re already behind and no sign of an equaliser, which has been the case, why have the subs been defensive, or like for like, asking no questions of the opposition? Or worse, defensive midfielders on for right backs and alike?

Plus I hope our next era is worth this and the ownership issues.

 


COYP

premier fan Flag BR4 24 Feb 20 11.37am

The victory against a very poor Newcastle doesn’t mask the fact that Hodgson struggles to make decisions and have a plan b. The club should prepare for a new manager in the summer.

 

Page 82 of 91 < 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread