You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 83 of 91 < 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 >
samprior Flag Hamburg 24 Feb 20 11.48am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

This is true but it is tough to watch with the refusal to put a sub on when it is so obvious nothing is going to happen without one.

Plus the whole mindset on the pitch v Newcastle was completely different to every other league game at Selhurst I can remember under Hodgson, right from the start. We weren’t relying on a chance maybe presenting itself. We made the game present the chances by imposing ourselves on the opposition rather than being so far away from them it’s like watching a training drill or preseason match. The approach for so long has been exactly the same, whether we play bottom 3 or top 3 teams, apart from on Saturday. It never ever changes and there’s never ever any real intent to change the dynamic of the game when we need to.

We have better better at this under Roy. Now we’re usually stuffed if we don’t get the first goal. If we’re already behind and no sign of an equaliser, which has been the case, why have the subs been defensive, or like for like, asking no questions of the opposition? Or worse, defensive midfielders on for right backs and alike?

Plus I hope our next era is worth this and the ownership issues.

I often feel the same and agreed when I read this but then I did think of a few occasions where this wasn't the case so thought I'd look a little further.

Surprisingly a 3rd of our points (11) have come from games where we didn't score first. Which considering we haven't scored many at all is actually probably quite a decent tally.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 24 Feb 20 11.57am

Agreed. The other time i’ve seen us really attack a team this season was Newcastle at their place. They are a poor team with a very defensive mindset and not much threat going forward.

The victory against a very poor Newcastle doesn’t mask the fact that Hodgson struggles to make decisions and have a plan b. The club should prepare for a new manager in the summer.

 

PatrickA Flag London 24 Feb 20 12.02pm

I think the point to emerge from the press conference is that Hodgson is looking for consistent performances over a series of games and is not deflected by individual games.
This accounts for the rigidity and lack of plan B as frustrating as it can be to watch.
Over a season his methods are likely to get results.
Although I would prefer a new approach under a different manager I am trying to be objective and understand his reasoning.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Feb 20 12.23pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

This is true but it is tough to watch with the refusal to put a sub on when it is so obvious nothing is going to happen without one.

Plus the whole mindset on the pitch v Newcastle was completely different to every other league game at Selhurst I can remember under Hodgson, right from the start. We weren’t relying on a chance maybe presenting itself. We made the game present the chances by imposing ourselves on the opposition rather than being so far away from them it’s like watching a training drill or preseason match. The approach for so long has been exactly the same, whether we play bottom 3 or top 3 teams, apart from on Saturday. It never ever changes and there’s never ever any real intent to change the dynamic of the game when we need to.

We have better better at this under Roy. Now we’re usually stuffed if we don’t get the first goal. If we’re already behind and no sign of an equaliser, which has been the case, why have the subs been defensive, or like for like, asking no questions of the opposition? Or worse, defensive midfielders on for right backs and alike?

Plus I hope our next era is worth this and the ownership issues.

We are 6th in the table of points gained from losing positions. From 16 occasions of conceding the first goal or going behind we have won 2(both Wet Spam, drawn 5 and lost 9, so 11 points gained from losing positions). Compare that to some more illustrious teams and we're not that bad at getting back into a game:
Chelsea 1 win, 1 draw and 9 defeats
Everton 1 win, 2 draws 11 defeats
Manure 1 win 3 draws 8 defeats
as for the teams at the bottom, these stats tell the tale:
Norwich 0 wins 0 draws 17 defeats
Watford 0 wins 1 draw 13 defeats
Wet Spam 0 wins 1 draw 14 defeats
Bournemouth 0 wins 1 draw 15 defeats

Having said that I do agree that Roy's substitution policy is frustrating. Having clearly said this last week that football is now a 14 man game we had to wait ages to see the first sub made.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Feb 20 12.46pm

Originally posted by doombear

We are 6th in the table of points gained from losing positions. From 16 occasions of conceding the first goal or going behind we have won 2(both Wet Spam, drawn 5 and lost 9, so 11 points gained from losing positions). Compare that to some more illustrious teams and we're not that bad at getting back into a game:
Chelsea 1 win, 1 draw and 9 defeats
Everton 1 win, 2 draws 11 defeats
Manure 1 win 3 draws 8 defeats
as for the teams at the bottom, these stats tell the tale:
Norwich 0 wins 0 draws 17 defeats
Watford 0 wins 1 draw 13 defeats
Wet Spam 0 wins 1 draw 14 defeats
Bournemouth 0 wins 1 draw 15 defeats

Having said that I do agree that Roy's substitution policy is frustrating. Having clearly said this last week that football is now a 14 man game we had to wait ages to see the first sub made.

Rugby have led the way for some time with dynamic substitutions, our footballers, midfielders in particular should be running their asses off to dominate such that they are totally spent with 20 mins to go and can be replaced. I see Ayew doing it, I see McArthy and McArthur put massive shifts in. Can't say I've ever thought Benteke should come off because he looks tired though. Crap possibly, but not tired.

 

AERO Flag 24 Feb 20 12.51pm

It's a really tough call ? We get another manager in who plays more on front foot ! Makes plenty of substitutions.Look what's happening at Norwich, Brighton, and West Ham.Be careful "what you wish for"

 

jeeagles Flag 24 Feb 20 12.55pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Rugby have led the way for some time with dynamic substitutions, our footballers, midfielders in particular should be running their asses off to dominate such that they are totally spent with 20 mins to go and can be replaced. I see Ayew doing it, I see McArthy and McArthur put massive shifts in. Can't say I've ever thought Benteke should come off because he looks tired though. Crap possibly, but not tired.

Completely agree. That's why Eddie Jones calls them the finishers. If you know you are only playing 30 minutes you can run around like a mad man, particularly beneficial when you have bigger/older players. Roy just runs our players into the ground, hence the injury crisis.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Feb 20 12.57pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

This is true but it is tough to watch with the refusal to put a sub on when it is so obvious nothing is going to happen without one.

Plus the whole mindset on the pitch v Newcastle was completely different to every other league game at Selhurst I can remember under Hodgson, right from the start. We weren’t relying on a chance maybe presenting itself. We made the game present the chances by imposing ourselves on the opposition rather than being so far away from them it’s like watching a training drill or preseason match. The approach for so long has been exactly the same, whether we play bottom 3 or top 3 teams, apart from on Saturday. It never ever changes and there’s never ever any real intent to change the dynamic of the game when we need to.

We have better better at this under Roy. Now we’re usually stuffed if we don’t get the first goal. If we’re already behind and no sign of an equaliser, which has been the case, why have the subs been defensive, or like for like, asking no questions of the opposition? Or worse, defensive midfielders on for right backs and alike?

Plus I hope our next era is worth this and the ownership issues.

I would suggest a two week break, after a gruelling run of fixtures, had a lot to do with Saturdays performance, along with Newcastle being over run in midfield.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 Feb 20 1.05pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

The interview was good PR and well presented, this doesn't change my view that the last few transfer windows have been nothing short of a disaster IMO. Let us just hope lessons have been learnt and we now go forward but I feel new investors are required asap.

When you look at the team from Saturday it included the following players picked up for minimal cost over the recent transfer windows:
Cahill - many consider him to be a contender for POTY
Ayew - arguably our best forward player this season and another contender for POTY
McCarthy - the more he plays the better he gets.
Kouyate - solid, dependable and an excellent squad member.
Tosun - loan that hasn't had much opportunity to shine yet due to injury.

Over the summer we managed to sell a right back for 50 mil even though he had played 1 season in the prem. This went some way to balance the books for previous failings and meant we could keep Zaha. With the benefit of hindsight perhaps we should have taken the money offered for Zaha, but at the time most felt keeping him offered our best chance of staying in the division.

My point being is I think there has been nothing wrong with the last few windows. The problems have been created by previous signings for big fees on inflated wages: Benteke, Sakho, or even Meyer (squad player on c120k a week?).

The key now is to try and integrate a bit of youth to our ageing squad. This will be easier said than done with minimal cash, unless we can offload Wilf for a decent sum.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Feb 20 1.23pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

My point being is I think there has been nothing wrong with the last few windows. The problems have been created by previous signings for big fees on inflated wages: Benteke, Sakho, or even Meyer (squad player on c120k a week?).

The key now is to try and integrate a bit of youth to our ageing squad. This will be easier said than done with minimal cash, unless we can offload Wilf for a decent sum.

Basically, I agree with you. My one quibble would be that Benteke and Sakho did the business for us initially and helped us maintain our Premier League status. I suspect we were desperate and Liverpool knew that and so we paid over the odds.

We need to avoid being seen as desperate in the coming windows. Difficult given the age profile of our squad but (if SP is to be believed) it does seem that financially at least we are better placed than we have been for some time.

Talking of SP, I was intrigued at his mention of researching loan-type options that wouldn't damage us.

 

dg1937 Flag 24 Feb 20 1.44pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

When you look at the team from Saturday it included the following players picked up for minimal cost over the recent transfer windows:
Cahill - many consider him to be a contender for POTY
Ayew - arguably our best forward player this season and another contender for POTY
McCarthy - the more he plays the better he gets.
Kouyate - solid, dependable and an excellent squad member.
Tosun - loan that hasn't had much opportunity to shine yet due to injury.

Over the summer we managed to sell a right back for 50 mil even though he had played 1 season in the prem. This went some way to balance the books for previous failings and meant we could keep Zaha. With the benefit of hindsight perhaps we should have taken the money offered for Zaha, but at the time most felt keeping him offered our best chance of staying in the division.

My point being is I think there has been nothing wrong with the last few windows. The problems have been created by previous signings for big fees on inflated wages: Benteke, Sakho, or even Meyer (squad player on c120k a week?).

The key now is to try and integrate a bit of youth to our ageing squad. This will be easier said than done with minimal cash, unless we can offload Wilf for a decent sum.

The list of Saturday's starters missed out Guiata, another strong contender for POTY.

I agree that the business we have done isn't as bad as some people make out. Of course it's the business we haven't done that people get most exercised about.

Edited by dg1937 (24 Feb 2020 1.44pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Feb 20 3.00pm

Surely only having a squad of 23 players, (20 of which are outfield), rather than 25 sums up our situation. Any other teams in the PL without a full first team squad? I tell you what I'll go and try and find out.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 Feb 20 3.02pm

Originally posted by dg1937

The list of Saturday's starters missed out Guiata, another strong contender for POTY.

I agree that the business we have done isn't as bad as some people make out. Of course it's the business we haven't done that people get most exercised about.

Edited by dg1937 (24 Feb 2020 1.44pm)

Indeed. It just feels like he has been here a lot longer!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 Feb 20 3.04pm

Originally posted by doombear

Basically, I agree with you. My one quibble would be that Benteke and Sakho did the business for us initially and helped us maintain our Premier League status. I suspect we were desperate and Liverpool knew that and so we paid over the odds.

quote]

Fair point and I think at the time of each purchase the vast majority of supporters (including me for Sakho) would have been delighted. So my comments are clearly with the benefit of hindsight.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Feb 20 3.20pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Surely only having a squad of 23 players, (20 of which are outfield), rather than 25 sums up our situation. Any other teams in the PL without a full first team squad? I tell you what I'll go and try and find out.

I've just checked on FotMob and it shows us only having 22 senior players, 19 of which are outfield. I have listed these below, because the rest are just kids or new signings which are not going to be playing.

It is difficult to work out if other teams have youngsters down in the first team squad as I don't know the players well enough, however what does make interesting reading is as follows:

Our recognised senior players

Guaita, Hennessey, Henderson

Cahill, Dann, Sakho, Tomkins, Ward, Kelly, Van Aanholt, Schlupp, Riedewald,

McArthur, McCarthy, Kouyate, Milivojevic, Townsend, Meyer,

Benteke, Ayew, Tosun, Zaha

That is 19 senior players of which Sakho, Schlupp, Kelly and Tomkins are currently injured. So we basically have just 15 outfield players to choose from. It is little wonder our players are knackered and susceptible to injury.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 Feb 20 3.32pm

An the alternative argument demonstrating the strength in the squad we have got is that despite this small squad numbers and a crippling injury list for a sustained period we are 9 points above relegation and a similar distance off a Champions League place.
Surely some credit is due?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Feb 20 3.36pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

An the alternative argument demonstrating the strength in the squad we have got is that despite this small squad numbers and a crippling injury list for a sustained period we are 9 points above relegation and a similar distance off a Champions League place.
Surely some credit is due?

Yep, got no problem with that at all, but it does highlight a few deficiencies in our transfer activity.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 Feb 20 3.54pm

I think we all agree there is room for improvement in that respect. I do feel that the club are going in the right direction and have realised this, however the strategy of "regenerating" the squad with proven premier league quality players that are cast offs (Tomkins, Kouyate, McCarthy, Ayew and even Cahill) has served us well.
We just need to balance this with a few younger signings (which so far we have been less successful with (Meyer, Sorloth, Jach)

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 24 Feb 20 6.35pm

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 24 Feb 20 6.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

He nicked it off Jordan on the back of the advertiser. One of his panacea answers that say nothing and mean nothing.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (23 Feb 2020 11.39pm)

actually it does mean something...and its quite simple really...however well a club is doing, or however much money has been spent there will always be unrealistic ungrateful fans banging their drum about some sort of perceived misjustice.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Page 83 of 91 < 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread