This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Grumbles
That's not quite correct. Ukraine solely owned the nuclear weapons on its soil at the breakup of the CIS. At that point they theoretically had possession of 30% of CIS weapons. However to use the strategic ballistic missiles it would have required a total new strategic control structure; which Ukraine could not afford. Russia could not launch them. The silo's were positioned incorrectly for a strike on anyone but the US or Eastern Russia, the cruise missiles were “made non-operational” by the Russians prior to leaving them on Ukrainian soil. On the political side, it was a likely if Ukraine kept the nuclear weapons they would have been at least shunned by both sides. So instead they decided to get rid of them for “compensation” and protection assurances from all sides under the Budapest Memorandum. Nowadays several nationalist parties want them back [for some resason].
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Of course it owned them as part of the CIS.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I hope I'm wrong but I'm starting to think that the peace negotiations aren't that serious and that both sides have settled on their paths. The west/Ukraine might have decided on not agreeing ceasefire terms and instead playing the long game of guerrilla warfare.....that means the cities get flattened and hundreds of thousands of people will die. For the west, the Democrats get to the November elections with them and the wall to wall media blaming everything on Putin. They also get to bleed Russia. Putin then has two decisions to make, provide better peace terms...which give the Ukraine and the US pause for thought ....or flatten the Ukraine and then get as many foreign mercenaries to hold it as possible...and I can see how that would go. Whatever transpires I'm starting to think that the Ukrainian civilians are the least of these power blocks concerns. It's a fecking disaster that was fully avoidable. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2022 11.12am) There are very few things we actually know about all of this, but as our understanding of Putin's thinking becomes clearer, there are some things we can be pretty confident about. One of those being that there is nothing we could have done, that would have avoided this. If you believe Ukraine to be a sovereign state, which most of the world, except Putin, does, then you cannot interfere in it any more than he can. It might be in our interests to see a swift end and a settlement which disfigures Ukraine, but that's not ours to negotiate. This is 100% Putin and any blame shifting suggests to me his clever propaganda via social media in the west is working. As it has in other areas in recent years. He is grinding his poison into the wounds which divide us. We are already in Cold war 2. It's going to last the rest of my lifetime and beyond. It will have many consequences, some already apparent, some yet to be seen. Energy and food security will become priorities. We will still need gas and oil whilst we move to renewables and nuclear, which cannot just be turned on. We need a bridge to them. I think Putin will lose. He has made massive miscalculations about the west's resolve and the way Ukrainians think. The economic hardships within Russia will demand his attention more than prolonging a war he now knows he can never win completely. China probably holds the keys and can broker a way out for him. Let's hope so.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There are very few things we actually know about all of this, but as our understanding of Putin's thinking becomes clearer, there are some things we can be pretty confident about. One of those being that there is nothing we could have done, that would have avoided this. If you believe Ukraine to be a sovereign state, which most of the world, except Putin, does, then you cannot interfere in it any more than he can. It might be in our interests to see a swift end and a settlement which disfigures Ukraine, but that's not ours to negotiate. This is 100% Putin and any blame shifting suggests to me his clever propaganda via social media in the west is working. As it has in other areas in recent years. He is grinding his poison into the wounds which divide us. We are already in Cold war 2. It's going to last the rest of my lifetime and beyond. It will have many consequences, some already apparent, some yet to be seen. Energy and food security will become priorities. We will still need gas and oil whilst we move to renewables and nuclear, which cannot just be turned on. We need a bridge to them. I think Putin will lose. He has made massive miscalculations about the west's resolve and the way Ukrainians think. The economic hardships within Russia will demand his attention more than prolonging a war he now knows he can never win completely. China probably holds the keys and can broker a way out for him. Let's hope so. I'm not going to continually go over the same ground over how we got here and where the blame lies for what. You can think what you want and other opinions are available. You think Putin loses....cool. I think everybody loses, especially the poor. I hope a pathway back can be found either with or without Putin as I regard the odds of surviving cold war 2 without a nuclear attack as less likely than cold war 1.....as at least those past politicians seemed to take it more seriously. There are just too many flash points around the world for this level of distrust and twitchy fingers. I view a China/Russia block as a disaster for the west both economically and for world peace. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2022 2.42pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There are very few things we actually know about all of this, but as our understanding of Putin's thinking becomes clearer, there are some things we can be pretty confident about. One of those being that there is nothing we could have done, that would have avoided this. If you believe Ukraine to be a sovereign state, which most of the world, except Putin, does, then you cannot interfere in it any more than he can. It might be in our interests to see a swift end and a settlement which disfigures Ukraine, but that's not ours to negotiate. This is 100% Putin and any blame shifting suggests to me his clever propaganda via social media in the west is working. As it has in other areas in recent years. He is grinding his poison into the wounds which divide us. We are already in Cold war 2. It's going to last the rest of my lifetime and beyond. It will have many consequences, some already apparent, some yet to be seen. Energy and food security will become priorities. We will still need gas and oil whilst we move to renewables and nuclear, which cannot just be turned on. We need a bridge to them. I think Putin will lose. He has made massive miscalculations about the west's resolve and the way Ukrainians think. The economic hardships within Russia will demand his attention more than prolonging a war he now knows he can never win completely. China probably holds the keys and can broker a way out for him. Let's hope so. In BOLD: 1. Agree there, any continuation of war is of course a catastrophe however idealistic dreams of shaking of hands and a jolly down the battle cruiser is highly delusional. I'd suggest any resolution will be an act of damage limitations as opposed to a happy ending, which certainly isn't on the cards for Ukraine. 2. I can't see any blame that can proportionally put at anyone else's feet asides from Putin. Speculation regarding his views on NATO etc will only remain as such as I haven't seen any indication that he has deviated from his nonsensical, fabricated reasoning's for the war. If I am incorrect there, very sincerely happy to apologise for my ignorance and would welcome any enlightenment. 3. Yes agree, it may not completely mirror the first however this does seem to be very much the second instalment. Again would hold hands up happily to any gaps/shortcomings in my understanding or knowledge there. 4. I do also believe perhaps not that he will 'lose' but certainly what he had in mind is not going to become a reality. The longer this stretches on the more I see his position weakening but conversely also becoming more dangerous. Ironic that China may hold the key in this and it may well play into their own aspirations with regards to relationships with the west for them to play a significant role in drawing any semblance of a conclusion to this.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'm not going to continually go over the same ground over how we got here and where the blame lies for what. You can think what you want and other opinions are available. You think Putin loses....cool. I think everybody loses, especially the poor. I hope a pathway back can be found either with or without Putin as I regard the odds of surviving cold war 2 without a nuclear attack as less likely than cold war 1.....as at least those past politicians seemed to take it more seriously. There are just too many flash points around the world for this level of distrust and twitchy fingers. I view a China/Russia block as a disaster for the west both economically and for world peace. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2022 2.42pm) It does, at the very least, pave the way for terrifying possibilities/circumstances for the rest of us.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
It does, at the very least, pave the way for terrifying possibilities/circumstances for the rest of us. It is funny how the Zeitgeist changes in 20 years, if you ever read T Clancy's the Bear and the Dragon. Trash novel, but it is the thinking on geo-politics compared to now that interests me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'm not going to continually go over the same ground over how we got here and where the blame lies for what. You can think what you want and other opinions are available. You think Putin loses....cool. I think everybody loses, especially the poor. I hope a pathway back can be found either with or without Putin as I regard the odds of surviving cold war 2 without a nuclear attack as less likely than cold war 1.....as at least those past politicians seemed to take it more seriously. There are just too many flash points around the world for this level of distrust and twitchy fingers. I view a China/Russia block as a disaster for the west both economically and for world peace. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2022 2.42pm) For sure we all lose, at least in the short to mid-term. Ultimately, if a new era of reality emerges, we could win something. Ukraine could be seen as a watershed moment. I don't see a China/Russia "block" arising from this. I think China are very uncomfortable about Putin's behaviour and surprised at the west's reaction. The Chinese are much more measured and pragmatic than the Russian's under Putin. They need us as consumers. Russia doesn't consume nearly so much as we do. China is now the dominant partner in that relationship and may well, in time, expand its influence in Russia. It will certainly use its natural resources. This is the Chinese century, just as the 20th was the USA's, but that doesn't mean they want to wage wars. They want us to remain as customers, not see us obliterated.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
A return to brinkmanship would have avoided the whole thing. The USA President should have told Putin any incursion into the Ukraine would not be tolerated and would be an act of war. The west is so weak no wonder he just walks all over it. We have no morals except property, assets and the debts to service them, so rather than get our hands dirty fighting we will 'sanction oligarchs', wait until we send in the accountants. You can hear the Ukrainians cheering at their barricades. What would your Jezza have done? Mmmm
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
What would your Jezza have done? Mmmm 'Jezza' voted for the Trident deterrent.
|
|
|
Listening to a former Russian FM today. 'The only calculation made is force'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
'Jezza' voted for the Trident deterrent. Salisbury?
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
For sure we all lose, at least in the short to mid-term. Ultimately, if a new era of reality emerges, we could win something. Ukraine could be seen as a watershed moment. I don't see a China/Russia "block" arising from this. I think China are very uncomfortable about Putin's behaviour and surprised at the west's reaction. The Chinese are much more measured and pragmatic than the Russian's under Putin. They need us as consumers. Russia doesn't consume nearly so much as we do. China is now the dominant partner in that relationship and may well, in time, expand its influence in Russia. It will certainly use its natural resources. This is the Chinese century, just as the 20th was the USA's, but that doesn't mean they want to wage wars. They want us to remain as customers, not see us obliterated. China doesn't need a block, it is a block! Ultimately though it all brings home the importance of being energy independent, which is more than possible. As much as people like to moan about the teething problems with that inevitability, they clearly overlooked the much more pressing issue of supply issues from other countries and the politics and world events that can 'really' raise prices. As opposed to smaller temporary rises for initiatives and options that form a path to giving those who have us 'over a barrel' the middle finger. Arguably that's one aspect that Trump had a point on. Looking close to home (or indeed at home!) for energy needs. Though of course oil is one limited, and temporary option, and a wider look at renewables, nuclear and so on is also needed. Still, the overriding point is that with a sensible and deliberate push, it eliminates the need to rely on other nations, something that often comes with a whole host of problems. Edited by BlueJay (15 Mar 2022 4.45pm)
|
|
|
A couple of excellent videos worth watching. The first is the role the Azov regiment plays in Ukraine This one about potential escalation Its worth noting too that Iran launched a missile strike against the US consulate in Iraq just the other day & the US failed to act, this to me is quite telling. Edited by Ouzo Dan (15 Mar 2022 6.37pm)
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
China doesn't need a block, it is a block! Ultimately though it all brings home the importance of being energy independent, which is more than possible. As much as people like to moan about the teething problems with that inevitability, they clearly overlooked the much more pressing issue of supply issues from other countries and the politics and world events that can 'really' raise prices. As opposed to smaller temporary rises for initiatives and options that form a path to giving those who have us 'over a barrel' the middle finger. Arguably that's one aspect that Trump had a point on. Looking close to home (or indeed at home!) for energy needs. Though of course oil is one limited, and temporary option, and a wider look at renewables, nuclear and so on is also needed. Still, the overriding point is that with a sensible and deliberate push, it eliminates the need to rely on other nations, something that often comes with a whole host of problems. Edited by BlueJay (15 Mar 2022 4.45pm) Quite right! The comment was made because of the suggestion that the biggest fear is the emergence of a "China/Russia" block, whereas I have heard another opinion that the only country ever likely to invade Russia is China. Which I very much hope isn't true, either. Apparently, the Chinese people are not being shown pictures of the devastation the Russians are causing, and their media are full-on blaming the USA for causing this by "allowing Nato to threaten Russian security". So Putin propaganda in Beijing too. Nevertheless, the Chinese leadership is savvy. It might disapprove of western decadence, but it won't want to kill the golden goose. They seem to me to be the best hope we have of reigning Putin in, allowing the sanction to then bite and for the Russian people to eventually sort themselves out. Containment until change can happen seems the safest option.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Nevertheless, the Chinese leadership is savvy. It might disapprove of western decadence, but it won't want to kill the golden goose. They seem to me to be the best hope we have of reigning Putin in, allowing the sanction to then bite and for the Russian people to eventually sort themselves out. Containment until change can happen seems the safest option. Yes, they're currently playing both sides, and even in a situation where they were deemed somewhat more pro Russian it would be incredibly lopsided, and more akin to being held back, which is no doubt how Putin chooses to perceive the West currently. The exchange of one problem for another. Clearly nobody knows precisely how things will pan out, but it certainly appears at minimum that Putin has royally screwed over his own people. Yes, hopefully sanctions will have an impact significant enough that a fair solution to end this madness is agreed upon.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
'Jezza' voted for the Trident deterrent. With all the sincerity he could muster
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I keep hearing this line that the Ukraine gave up nukes. Firstly those were soviet nukes housed in the Ukraine, so the argument that they were Ukrainian is far fetched. Secondly they had no control of those nukes as they were in systems controlled in Russia. They would have had to deconstruct the soviet systems, which considering they weren't on bad terms with Russia wasn't a realistic reality. So 'far fetched' that they signed an agreement pledging to respect the sovereignty of Ukraine if they gave them up. I thought agreements (as in the NATO one) were what was to be valued and stood by? Some comments here are unfortunate self flagellation and fear at Russian threats that would still be present even if they took over Ukraine and set their sights elsewhere. We are where we are. There is zero wrong with our basic level of support for the Ukrainian people to give them a fighting chance. If Russia are bombing hospitals day after day (which is something actively happening 'now' as matter of importance unlike this panicked 'bio lab' Russia propaganda push that is lapped up) the deficit of movement towards peace is a ball in their court. Putin doesn't respect weakness and is fueled by purpose, not by playing nice because we've been 'fair'. Edited by BlueJay (16 Mar 2022 12.37am)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.