You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 87 of 91 < 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 09 Mar 20 10.15pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Danny Murphy on motd last night said he told his squad at Fulham he wanted them to aim for zero goal difference or better.

The downsides to this are that it’s a tough watch, games can be decided, predicted early on or written off and it could prove difficult to sign attacking or flair players. Look at Benteke and zaha. Both depreciated in value. Many will say that’s a cost to staying in the Prem and I see the viewpoint and understand that there are costs and conflicting issues like in many businesses, but how long can that football strategy that can depreciate the club’s highest value players give the club the financial edge our size of club needs? AWB is a one off, unless our transfer profit is going to come from progressing defensively minded players.

The irony isn’t lost on me of Parish saying before hiring FDB ‘’we must move away from counting on the lucky bounce of the ball as we’ve done in our history and create those definite chances ourselves because that is more....’’ sustainable long term or something.

Now I fully understand why Roy has been hired on a business decision but it isn’t issue free but really the point is that even roy said yesterday after the Watford win that we could easily be 9 points worse off. It could actually be even more if you took away Guaita’s excellent form and us not winning the last 3 games that could’ve been 4 or 5 points. But that’s where I’ll make my main criticism. We’ve forced these 9 points more by being less passive than we’ve been for 6 months. I expect someone to say ive contradicted myself regarding the last 3 wins but I’m saying that our chances of that happening have a higher probability than watching whoever knock it about like brazil while we watch and rely on blocks or Guaita.

Finally there isn’t much synergy within the higher levels of the club. I have stressed issues I think have come about because of whichever of the 3 (Roy, Freedman, Parish). Meyer the German Messi I think Parish signed and had him pose for photos on the rooftop in the hope he’d be that flair player we coined it in with.

Roy is fine regarding our percentage chances of surviving each season but the issues I’ve raised are things I hope those at the top are discussing between themselves. We need some good transfer windows.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Mar 2020 11.57pm)

Screenshot (9623).png Attachment: Screenshot (9623).png (72.78Kb)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 09 Mar 20 10.43pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Benteke is worth virtually nothing now. We couldn’t give him away. Strikers will always be worth money if they score. The football tactics have had an effect on Benteke. Not all, but the tactics have. He was fine until Allardyce left and since it’s gone wrong.

Your theory of valuation is incredibly naive. Try selling your house for 100% more than what anyone anywhere will pay for it. That will not be the value of your house but your fantasy, same for Zaha.

My points on pur transfers was that we’re not signing any flair or creative players and might struggle to with our tactics, or the ones we have haven’t featured/been successful or again don’t fit in with the tactics. Danny Murphy paid out what Roy was all about several times when Roy joined Palace what Roy does and Roy likes but what I’m saying is it’s not all without underlying issues and problems to surface n future.

Roy has achieved above and beyond the target in the end this season but it doesn’t come without things to consider for Parish and Freedman with Roy, if they do or can tolerate each other for long enough.

Do not forget Benteke had been carrying a nasty knee injury for quite some time before he had his opp and he has had numerous opportunities to score since ..as much as two in every game, composure is difficult especially if you're worrying about injuring your knee again, I feel he has been given the right amount of encouragement by Hodgson throughout the time he has been manager and also I feel Benteke is actually at the moment starting to appear much more confident and hugely more alert, it is quite possible that the injury he suffered (and nobody knows exactly how long he had put up with it) is the real culprit for his failings in front of goal, lets just all see if he can actually do it before the season ends, I think he can.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 10 Mar 20 7.15am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

free transfers and loans..great news

What do you mean by that ??

 


Old, Ungifted and White

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 10 Mar 20 8.09am

Originally posted by pssguy

Our young players may not be good enough but it is pretty damning on the development at the club that we have just one player, Brandon Pierrick, who has appeared in the league for us this year who has been aged 21 or under. And he has appeared just once - as a late substitute

Man U have had 10 and Chelsea 11, respectively; and it's not as though they have not had points to fight for

And do you know how many of the top talent they hoover up between them?
And how many in their academies don't go on to play for them?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Mar 20 8.15am

Originally posted by stuckinbristol


And do you know how many of the top talent they hoover up between them?
And how many in their academies don't go on to play for them?

Probably quite a lot but is their overall record worse than ours which is quite poor

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Mar 20 8.17am


CPFC_NEWS_HQ is just another recycler of rumours and guesswork. I watched Roy being interviewed by the BBC on Saturday and he was very evasive about any promises of a transfer pot

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 10 Mar 20 9.05am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

free transfers and loans..great news

did you did what I did, and first read it without the important 2 words "More than" !


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 10 Mar 20 10.49am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

did you did what I did, and first read it without the important 2 words "More than" !


 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 10 Mar 20 10.56am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Probably quite a lot but is their overall record worse than ours which is quite poor

Can't honestly say, but didn't they have 30+ players out on loan last year?
If you buy enough pigs one will turn out to be a prize winner!
Sorry, don't mean to sound testy, but had this conversation with a Chelsea supporting mate of mine at the weekend. "Look at all our youth products"he happily barked when they played on Sunday.
Oh yeah, that lad Gilmore, from just round the corner from the bridge!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Mar 20 11.37am

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

Can't honestly say, but didn't they have 30+ players out on loan last year?
If you buy enough pigs one will turn out to be a prize winner!
Sorry, don't mean to sound testy, but had this conversation with a Chelsea supporting mate of mine at the weekend. "Look at all our youth products"he happily barked when they played on Sunday.
Oh yeah, that lad Gilmore, from just round the corner from the bridge!

I think it's 'Gilmour', and he'll be no Scott Banks!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Mar 20 1.25pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Our young players may not be good enough but it is pretty damning on the development at the club that we have just one player, Brandon Pierrick, who has appeared in the league for us this year who has been aged 21 or under. And he has appeared just once - as a late substitute

Man U have had 10 and Chelsea 11, respectively; and it's not as though they have not had points to fight for

Chelsea were sanctioned by FIFA in regards to their behaviour in signing under 18s. I suspect a number of the big clubs are similarly guilty, but didn’t get caught.
Whilst we don’t have Academy 1 status, playing the better teams, why would a youngster choose us, we currently are attracting the left overs.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 10 Mar 20 2.34pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

But what about the blocking of our academy talent Parish spoke about during that in house interview? Lol lol

Well it would have been interesting if he had elaborated on that and clarified how this "blocking" might be overcome.

I don't know what influence SP has with regard to team selection but I would guess Roy has the last word, and if so, it is he who is reluctant to give playing time to academy players.

This would be understandable if Roy is under pressure to achieve one of SP's other aims, mentioned by him in the interview i.e. to finish as high up the table as possible for financial reasons. Roy may well feel that bringing in untried youngsters, at the expense of experienced first teamers, could upset the apple-cart and be counter-productive in respect of that aim.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Mar 20 3.55pm

Yes, don’t expect any of Parish’s aims and objectives to not contradict the others.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Mar 20 3.58pm

Originally posted by Pete53


Well it would have been interesting if he had elaborated on that and clarified how this "blocking" might be overcome.

It would have been interesting if he had been interviewed by a rottweiler and not a poodle

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Mar 20 4.19pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

It would have been interesting if he had been interviewed by a rottweiler and not a poodle

His own pet poodle.

 


COYP

Maine Eagle Flag USA 02 Apr 20 6.05pm

Here is a moan about Roy Hodgson.

His man management is dog w*** at times.

Please see Sorloth, Alex. Yes the Turkish league is not the premier league but he clearly has some talent. I cannot guarantee you that if Hodgson had given him a fair crack at things, he would have worked out. What I can guarantee you is that the way he was used was always going to produce a failure. Not even Lionel Messi would have made it if treated the same way. In fact Messi wouldnt get a game as hes too lightweight.

Dribs and drabs here and there. Stop start stop start. You MUST be given a run of games to get going in a new league. Hodgson did the same s*** with Meyer.

Football is about confidence.

Look at what has happened to Benteke mostly on Roy's watch. Sorloth, Meyer and Benteke all have/had the same problem when playing for Palace, crisis of confidence based on being used incorrectly or too infrequently to get any rhythm going.

Clearly Sorloth is a decent player NOW. Dont bother digging up old comments of mine slating him, as they do exist. That was before he banged in 25 goals in Turkey and looked the best player in the league.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Teddy Eagle Flag 02 Apr 20 7.59pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Here is a moan about Roy Hodgson.

His man management is dog w*** at times.

Please see Sorloth, Alex. Yes the Turkish league is not the premier league but he clearly has some talent. I cannot guarantee you that if Hodgson had given him a fair crack at things, he would have worked out. What I can guarantee you is that the way he was used was always going to produce a failure. Not even Lionel Messi would have made it if treated the same way. In fact Messi wouldnt get a game as hes too lightweight.

Dribs and drabs here and there. Stop start stop start. You MUST be given a run of games to get going in a new league. Hodgson did the same s*** with Meyer.

Football is about confidence.

Look at what has happened to Benteke mostly on Roy's watch. Sorloth, Meyer and Benteke all have/had the same problem when playing for Palace, crisis of confidence based on being used incorrectly or too infrequently to get any rhythm going.

Clearly Sorloth is a decent player NOW. Dont bother digging up old comments of mine slating him, as they do exist. That was before he banged in 25 goals in Turkey and looked the best player in the league.

What’s dog walking got to do with it?

 

mrgins Flag 02 Apr 20 8.48pm

Just picked up on this thoroughly depressing thread. What a bunch of whiners! You sound like spoiled man u "fans". As someone mentioned, the loss to barnet was basically our u-23 team, but as for the lack of depth, how did we manage to fill those spots left open by injured players? Because the players dug deep and were playing for their careers. I have confidence in the three people mentioned in the thread title and I'm glad we don't have some others who are having a lot less fortune than we are.

 

jhillman Flag USA 02 Apr 20 8.53pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Here is a moan about Roy Hodgson.

His man management is dog w*** at times.

Please see Sorloth, Alex. Yes the Turkish league is not the premier league but he clearly has some talent. I cannot guarantee you that if Hodgson had given him a fair crack at things, he would have worked out. What I can guarantee you is that the way he was used was always going to produce a failure. Not even Lionel Messi would have made it if treated the same way. In fact Messi wouldnt get a game as hes too lightweight.

Dribs and drabs here and there. Stop start stop start. You MUST be given a run of games to get going in a new league. Hodgson did the same s*** with Meyer.

Football is about confidence.

Look at what has happened to Benteke mostly on Roy's watch. Sorloth, Meyer and Benteke all have/had the same problem when playing for Palace, crisis of confidence based on being used incorrectly or too infrequently to get any rhythm going.

Clearly Sorloth is a decent player NOW. Dont bother digging up old comments of mine slating him, as they do exist. That was before he banged in 25 goals in Turkey and looked the best player in the league.

So how many games did Obi Wan-Bissaka need to acclimatise to the Premier League?


Edited by jhillman (02 Apr 2020 8.54pm)

 

jhillman Flag USA 02 Apr 20 8.56pm

Originally posted by mrgins

Just picked up on this thoroughly depressing thread. What a bunch of whiners! You sound like spoiled man u "fans". As someone mentioned, the loss to barnet was basically our u-23 team, but as for the lack of depth, how did we manage to fill those spots left open by injured players? Because the players dug deep and were playing for their careers. I have confidence in the three people mentioned in the thread title and I'm glad we don't have some others who are having a lot less fortune than we are.

Well said!

 

Page 87 of 91 < 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread