Quote davenotamonkey at 05 Aug 2015 3.52am
Oh, a lovely report from an EU-funded research group. The co-author of which predicted 5,000-13,000 Poles would emigrate to the UK. How did those figures work out then?
Here's the rebuttal to that report: Plain Assumptions and Unexplained Wizardry Called in Aid of ‘The Fiscal Effects of Immigration to the UK’ (Stone, Emeritus Professor of Statistics at UCL)
[Link]
Meanwhile, via a non-partisan, non governmental body, and authored by a Cambridge Economics Professor:
[Link]
(as posted previously, p66 for conclusions, but much more in there than the following):
"The focus of this report has been on the economic and demographic consequences of large scale immigration. These consequences are mostly negative for the existing population of the UK and their descendants, although there may be some minor benefits."
"If many of the immigrants fail to get jobs, or if they end up in low skill jobs or displace native workers, large-scale immigration will have a negative impact on GDP per capita and on government finances. Thus, the impact could be positive or negative but either way it is unlikely to be very large."
I will deal with your laughable "but we already have a points-based immigration policy" later, ditto your 'I'm going to brush 50% of immigration policy under the carpet "because EU"' when it's not so late.
Reasoned posts that critique what I've posted welcomed.
But,lets take a look at some of your own biases.
EU funding (so you say)of "research group" ,in fact University College London academics, equals: report must be dodgy.
Attack on that report by academic funded by Civitas, free market think tank,ideologically of the right and with its roots in that think tank incubator of Thatcherism the Institute of Economic Affairs: neutral by definition and no problem at all.
Lord Harris, enobled by Maggie and who had led the IEA and had spoken of Rupert Murdoch as the "saviour of what we used to know as Fleet Street",was Civitas' chairman and a leading light in "setting its direction of travel"
Surely you don't have double standards depending on whether you agree with the academic in question or not?
Presumably as a "neutral" observer,you also took the trouble to familiarise yourself with the authors' of the first report's rebuttal of Stones "critique" and the PR spin put out about it by (that ever so impartial,restrained and neutral organisation) Civitas?
Here it is:
"In conclusion, we welcome constructive comments on our analysis. We are pleased that our report is so thoroughly publicly scrutinised, and we believe that this interchange will help improve the way we inform the public debate on this important and sensitive issue. However, we reject the offensive tones used by Civitas’ press release, and we believe that if accusing someone of "schoolboy errors", as done by Civitas’ director David Green, you ought to be able to point to more actual errors".
[Link]
Do also look at this November 2014 journal paper:
[Link]
"We investigate the fiscal impact of immigration on the UK economy, with a focus on the period since 1995. Our findings indicate that, when considering the resident immigrant population in each year from 1995 to 2011, immigrants from the European Economic Area (EEA) have made a positive fiscal contribution, even during periods when the UK was running budget deficits, while Non-EEA immigrants, not dissimilar to natives, have made a negative contribution. For immigrants that arrived since 2000, contributions have been positive throughout, and particularly so for immigrants from EEA countries. Notable is the strong positive contribution made by immigrants from countries that joined the EU in 2004."
No doubt Civitas have commissioned a critique of this too.
As for "I'm going to brush 50% of immigration policy under the carpet" that's a little silly.I've made clear I agree with freedom of goods,services and labour within the EU.I respect others don't.But that's its own huge topic involving far more than just immigration needing its own thread.,so it is not illegitimate to make points in this thread relating to non EU migration,particularly given the present heated debate here re immigration stems from non EU migrant matters in Calais and the lengthy thread on that..
I look forward to reading your critique of my reference to the UK's non EU migrant "points-like" rules.
Perhaps you'd start with reference to the actual immigration rules,which I posted a link to?
Edited by legaleagle (05 Aug 2015 9.57am)
|