You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.
November 16 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle fan- I come in peace.


Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 2.13pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

Firstly I simply don't believe you are somehow interested in our views in a mutual exchange of bonhomie. You have too much history with Pardew.

You are getting the same response as we would get on your forums if we came on telling you what was wrong at your club.

Thirdly there is more of a tendency to keep our criticism of club or personalities in house rather than have dozens and dozens phoning in to 606 every week like your fans. Not saying it doesn't happen just that we don't have the same culture of victimhood are you have.


Bye

I agree. If he had been on here looking for a sensible football chat, after the first couple of people gave him some abuse he probably would've gone "these people are morons, I won't get any decent football chit chat on here". But in actual fact, he's still here isn't he? He's just said he's not getting what he claims he came here for and yet he is still here.

Delwboy, is that you? You rascal!!

 




Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 17 Aug 16 2.16pm

I find it quite sad that the online Newcastle fanzine the Mag seems to enjoy posting various opinions knocking Pardew. Even I question his dire tactics from time to time, but the Mag seems to do it in a near obsessive manner that could warrant a restraining order.

We get it that Geordies don't like Pardew. But I bet that if he does get the sack (a question of when rather than if), then maybe, just maybe, they'd ditch the whole self-righteous twaddle and constant need for sniping opinions on Pardew while worrying about their own season in the Champinoship.

Just my two cents.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 2.17pm

Originally posted by Part Time James
My personal opinion though is that protests, after one league game of the season (and possibly further into the season) are probably going to make things worse on the pitch. We've had a pretty decent and positive atmosphere at Selhurst for a while now and I am not entirely convinced us boycotting Palace, chanting Pardew out or painting protest signs are actually going to make things better. Innocent question, but did you feel those things at Newcastle resolved anything when that kind of thing was going on? I'm not trying to point score, you might actually say yes.

I think without the protests Pardew would have stayed. I think that had Pardew stayed we would have failed to escape the inevitable pull of relegation. I think that had Pardew stayed we would still operate under the buy-to-sell manifesto which ultimately rendered my club a zombie; listlessly stumbling through the season existing for no reason more worthy than advertising the owner's shop.

I wish that it hadn't needed to get that far but our owner wasn't going to push and Pardew wouldn't have jumped. We forced their hands with our action and while we didn't get what we wanted immediately (a quality replacement for Pardew), we have that now and so yes, I think that justifies our actions.

re: Crystal Palace fans actions... It probably is too early for boycotts and marches, but I think a message that this isn't good enough should be made to your owner. Benitez failed to turn round the mess McClaren left despite the former being much, much better tactician than the latter.

 

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 2.22pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I think without the protests Pardew would have stayed. I think that had Pardew stayed we would have failed to escape the inevitable pull of relegation. I think that had Pardew stayed we would still operate under the buy-to-sell manifesto which ultimately rendered my club a zombie; listlessly stumbling through the season existing for no reason more worthy than advertising the owner's shop.

I wish that it hadn't needed to get that far but our owner wasn't going to push and Pardew wouldn't have jumped. We forced their hands with our action and while we didn't get what we wanted immediately (a quality replacement for Pardew), we have that now and so yes, I think that justifies our actions.

re: Crystal Palace fans actions... It probably is too early for boycotts and marches, but I think a message that this isn't good enough should be made to your owner. Benitez failed to turn round the mess McClaren left despite the former being much, much better tactician than the latter.

Fair comments. As somebody posted earlier on, I do feel our owners are a bit different to Ashley and actually I don't think Pardew's form in 2016 has gone unnoticed. I wouldn't be surprised if they had already told him to buck his ideas up.

One thing that may keep him in his job is IF (and I am not in the know at all here) the owners felt at all responsible for our lack of attacking signings. After all, they sign the cheques and play a part in negotiations.

I think given that a lot of people who support this club have some degree of trust in our owners (some less than others I know) that actually we probably don't feel that as fans we need to do anything in particular to force out an under performing manager when the time comes. I might be alone in this opinion, but I trust the board to reach the conclusion at the right time. I think they will. I think they know now is not the right time, but pressure will be increasing I'm sure.

 




Ian Winner Flag London 17 Aug 16 2.24pm

Not really interested in hearing from the Geordies about Pardew. We know our manager better than anyone.

Think he'll turn it around soon. Calling for his head after one game is pathetic given the summer we've had and the injuries we struggled with last year and the lack of options up front. Give him 10 games at least! Or until Christmas, and if he hasn't shown signs of progress - then there's a transfer window available for any new replacement. Chopping and changing now would destabilise the club and make us unattractive to other managers/players.

Don't think it will come to that though as I'm confident we only need a piece of magic from Zaha, or Cabaye to rediscover his form when he first moved here and we'll be a fret to most teams in the league. We can't compete with the top half sides, but maybe with a bit more backing from the board we could. We need the fans on-side again.

No one has taken us closer to a trophy in my lifetime, I'm behind Alan.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Aug 16 2.24pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I think without the protests Pardew would have stayed. I think that had Pardew stayed we would have failed to escape the inevitable pull of relegation. I think that had Pardew stayed we would still operate under the buy-to-sell manifesto which ultimately rendered my club a zombie; listlessly stumbling through the season existing for no reason more worthy than advertising the owner's shop.

I wish that it hadn't needed to get that far but our owner wasn't going to push and Pardew wouldn't have jumped. We forced their hands with our action and while we didn't get what we wanted immediately (a quality replacement for Pardew), we have that now and so yes, I think that justifies our actions.

re: Crystal Palace fans actions... It probably is too early for boycotts and marches, but I think a message that this isn't good enough should be made to your owner. Benitez failed to turn round the mess McClaren left despite the former being much, much better tactician than the latter.

Seems like a rational argument. However, when you delve into it, it doesn't really hold water. The Pardew out stuff seemed a bit inexplicable really - you don't seem to be able to acknowledge that you weren't doing that badly with him as your manager. you still have plenty of players left that he signed and they have done worse without him.
The Pardew out campaign seems almost unexcuseable - is there a chance that the protests, bitching and boycotts soured your team somewhat?

 


Red and Blue Army!

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 17 Aug 16 2.24pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I think without the protests Pardew would have stayed. I think that had Pardew stayed we would have failed to escape the inevitable pull of relegation. I think that had Pardew stayed we would still operate under the buy-to-sell manifesto which ultimately rendered my club a zombie; listlessly stumbling through the season existing for no reason more worthy than advertising the owner's shop.

I wish that it hadn't needed to get that far but our owner wasn't going to push and Pardew wouldn't have jumped. We forced their hands with our action and while we didn't get what we wanted immediately (a quality replacement for Pardew), we have that now and so yes, I think that justifies our actions.

re: Crystal Palace fans actions... It probably is too early for boycotts and marches, but I think a message that this isn't good enough should be made to your owner. Benitez failed to turn round the mess McClaren left despite the former being much, much better tactician than the latter.

OK you have provoked me into one more response. Which part of "f*** of we don't need you to tell us how to support our club" are you having difficulty with here.

 

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 2.24pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe
Firstly I simply don't believe you are somehow interested in our views in a mutual exchange of bonhomie. You have too much history with Pardew.

I'm not controlled by my bias. I can have reasoned and reasonable discussions with Palace fans, Villa fans and yes, even mackems. Aren't you able to shelve bias for the sake of a conversation?

You are getting the same response as we would get on your forums if we came on telling you what was wrong at your club.
If you came on the board with insight, with respect and with good humour you'd get a similar response. Obvious there'd be the odd child, but mostly the conversations would be reasonable.


Thirdly there is more of a tendency to keep our criticism of club or personalities in house rather than have dozens and dozens phoning in to 606 every week like your fans. Not saying it doesn't happen just that we don't have the same culture of victimhood are you have.
Are you honestly suggesting that 606 or talkSport are actual representative of a fanbase? No wonder you think all Geordies are illiterate. I suppose you think all Liverpool fans expect the title every year, every Everton fan is bitter, every Arsenal fan is more bothered about balance sheets than team sheets... Good grief man.

Talkradio exists to court controversy, if there's a valid considered point to be heard, you won't get it from stations who deliberately employ people that divide their own audience.

Bye

See ya.


 

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 2.28pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Fair comments. As somebody posted earlier on, I do feel our owners are a bit different to Ashley and actually I don't think Pardew's form in 2016 has gone unnoticed. I wouldn't be surprised if they had already told him to buck his ideas up.

One thing that may keep him in his job is IF (and I am not in the know at all here) the owners felt at all responsible for our lack of attacking signings. After all, they sign the cheques and play a part in negotiations.

I think given that a lot of people who support this club have some degree of trust in our owners (some less than others I know) that actually we probably don't feel that as fans we need to do anything in particular to force out an under performing manager when the time comes. I might be alone in this opinion, but I trust the board to reach the conclusion at the right time. I think they will. I think they know now is not the right time, but pressure will be increasing I'm sure.

I truly hope your last paragraph is accurate (or as near as possible), I think that's a major factor that's overlooked with our protests. We had zero trust in Ashley to do what's right for the club outside the accounts.

Thanks for the considered reply though.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Aug 16 2.28pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I have made a suggestion, but I'll reiterate.

Apply pressure on your owner to make a change. This can be done with protests, chants, boycotts* or public appeals for change.


*I don't think you need to go that far just yet.

The only real method of protesting is to organise a campaign that has impact - Owners don't really care too much about chants from a few malcontents - plus you're still buying tickets and season tickets.

Businesses generally make decisions based on financial impact. Protests should be targeted at Televised games for example. You need to be organised, numerous, and use the media in advance (because if your in the ground complaining you're paying). Local and rival broadcasters are much more likely to cover a protest than Sky - and the protest has to really be such that it distracts from the 'broadcast experience' of the fan at home. Because what you should be doing is creating a situation where the broadcaster doesn't want to cover you teams games.

If your buying tickets and complaining about the 'owners' you're really contradicting yourself. You have to understand that the Owners and the Club are the same thing.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Lalas Flag 17 Aug 16 2.32pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

We are not a massive European force of a club like Newcastle and, in general, we accept that.
We want to do better and Pardew does not have long to prove himself - a poor run at the beginning of the season and he will be gone - based on results - not on delusions of Granduer or from social media campaigns.


So you think Newcastle are a higher profile club and yet you'll get rid of Pardew much sooner and for far less? Interesting.

Newcastle fans not liking Pardew to start or turning on him entirely is a myth anyway. People put up with a huge amount with barely a murmur of discontent. He bred such apathy and disinterest until it eventually got to the point where his ineptitude, ridiculous excuses and apologist attitude became utterly offensive. A lot of people almost literally woke up and decided enough was enough.

Even when Pardew chose to leave for more money, a good 30% or more of fans wanted to keep him. The 'how did that work out for you' argument is utterly absurd, no one wants bad managers but in a stick or twist situation, it can feel worth the gamble. If the options were Blahdew or Carver, it's an easy decision but no one could have anticipated it being that bad.

 

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 2.34pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC
Seems like a rational argument. However, when you delve into it, it doesn't really hold water. The Pardew out stuff seemed a bit inexplicable really - you don't seem to be able to acknowledge that you weren't doing that badly with him as your manager. you still have plenty of players left that he signed and they have done worse without him.
The Pardew out campaign seems almost unexcuseable - is there a chance that the protests, bitching and boycotts soured your team somewhat?

I can understand why a casual observer may think that. The headline grabbing success of the year we finished 5th obscures the seasons that followed. The scorelines, the Match of the Day highlights and the history books don't go into detail about the quality of football and 12th looks very much like 15th at the end of a season. But Pardew had us flirting with relegation, took us on our worst run of form in decades, lost successive derbies, made inexplicable tactical choices, substitutions and his behaviour off the pitch was even worse. Headbutting a player, calling a respected manager swearwords that this site will filter out, and so on.

Do I think the protests had a negative effect on the morale of some of the mercenaries? Yeah, probably, but we needed to change something because if we didn't nothing would change. The players who understood that this wasn't good enough were shipped out (Barton, Nolan, Enrique) or treated appallingly (Jonas, R.Taylor) by the club.

It's easy to say the protests lead to our relegation, but that's just not anywhere near a full picture.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Aug 16 2.35pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Fair comments. As somebody posted earlier on, I do feel our owners are a bit different to Ashley and actually I don't think Pardew's form in 2016 has gone unnoticed. I wouldn't be surprised if they had already told him to buck his ideas up.

One thing that may keep him in his job is IF (and I am not in the know at all here) the owners felt at all responsible for our lack of attacking signings. After all, they sign the cheques and play a part in negotiations.

I think given that a lot of people who support this club have some degree of trust in our owners (some less than others I know) that actually we probably don't feel that as fans we need to do anything in particular to force out an under performing manager when the time comes. I might be alone in this opinion, but I trust the board to reach the conclusion at the right time. I think they will. I think they know now is not the right time, but pressure will be increasing I'm sure.

Utterly different. They're not c**ts, they've delivered year on year of success to the club. They've taken us from oblivion, to stability at a cost to themselves, and delivered us premiership experience and survival against the odds.

They've even brought in high profile managers in Holloway, Pulis and Pardew (whether you liked what they did or not) and even to an extent Burley.

They backed Freedman, a fan favourite and he delivered.

Anyone who even remotely thinks our owners are on a par with Ashley needs to start taking their medication immediately, or seek psychiatric intervention.

They were reluctant purchasers of the club in the first place, and Palace fans long before many of us were. Like Jordan, he might have been a c**t, but the reasons behind what he did, and what he risked and ultimately lost for the club, means he was at least our c**t.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 2.37pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721
The only real method of protesting is to organise a campaign that has impact - Owners don't really care too much about chants from a few malcontents - plus you're still buying tickets and season tickets.

Businesses generally make decisions based on financial impact. Protests should be targeted at Televised games for example. You need to be organised, numerous, and use the media in advance (because if your in the ground complaining you're paying). Local and rival broadcasters are much more likely to cover a protest than Sky - and the protest has to really be such that it distracts from the 'broadcast experience' of the fan at home. Because what you should be doing is creating a situation where the broadcaster doesn't want to cover you teams games.

If your buying tickets and complaining about the 'owners' you're really contradicting yourself. You have to understand that the Owners and the Club are the same thing.

I agree that it's hard to oust an owner from the club, but if the owner is committed to the club, as yours are, they'll listen to the crowd's call for change of (or at least some accountability for) the manager.


Charlton showed you can protest even after you've got your tickets with tennis balls and inflatables, didn't they?

 

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 2.38pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Utterly different. They're not c**ts, they've delivered year on year of success to the club. They've taken us from oblivion, to stability at a cost to themselves, and delivered us premiership experience and survival against the odds.

They've even brought in high profile managers in Holloway, Pulis and Pardew (whether you liked what they did or not) and even to an extent Burley.

They backed Freedman, a fan favourite and he delivered.

Anyone who even remotely thinks our owners are on a par with Ashley needs to start taking their medication immediately, or seek psychiatric intervention.

They were reluctant purchasers of the club in the first place, and Palace fans long before many of us were. Like Jordan, he might have been a c**t, but the reasons behind what he did, and what he risked and ultimately lost for the club, means he was at least our c**t.

Well, I agree. And although Jordan did and said some silly things, I still have a lot of respect for him.

Less so with Goldberg though, but even he meant well.

As I say, at risk of someone trotting out a thing about being up Parish's arse (which is apparently what you are if you don't think he's the antichrist), I am still a big fan of the CPFC2010 consortium and place a fair bit of trust in them.

 




Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 2.39pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I agree that it's hard to oust an owner from the club, but if the owner is committed to the club, as yours are, they'll listen to the crowd's call for change of (or at least some accountability for) the manager.


Charlton showed you can protest even after you've got your tickets with tennis balls and inflatables, didn't they?

Sounds like a circus!

 




TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 2.47pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Sounds like a circus!

It was incredible, but it got national press coverage and with all due respect to Charlton they're not a club that traditionally gets the benefit of national exposure very often. Now most football people know about Charlton's morass

Oh and I'm not saying Pardew is as toxic for your club as Duchatelet is for theirs, but it shows that fans still have a voice, whether they've paid up for season tickets or not.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Aug 16 2.47pm

Originally posted by Lalas

The 'how did that work out for you' argument is utterly absurd, no one wants bad managers but in a stick or twist situation, it can feel worth the gamble. If the options were Blahdew or Carver, it's an easy decision but no one could have anticipated it being that bad.

Well Pardew is an experienced manager, with some very good pedigree, who's history tends towards runs of form, and you were sitting 10th I believe. The fact you could lose your manager to a club that was bottom and nailed on for relegation, with an on paper worse squad, lower profile and less capital, suggests that had Pardew been more popular, he might well have stayed, or at least been offered the money.

I think its a very valid, rather than absurd argument, provided one allows for hindsight, as it displays the often myopic and uninformed emotional nature of football fans, and how irrational they are.

Football fans, for some reason, have a preponderance to the idea that any change is better than the problem they perceive, without rationally addressing the problem and trying to ascertain if there is even really a problem.

They also have a tendency towards 'bias' in their evidence. Last season, in THE LEAGUE, we were poor from December onwards, but we also had an incredible FA Cup run in which the weakest opponent was Reading, a club that has a very impressive recent FA Cup form - The rest were premiership teams.

Coppell, the last manager to take Palace to an FA Cup final, had a much much easier cup run.

But when you listen to fans, they'll tell you the bits that support their case, and wilfully ignore the contributory factors. Injuries, the FA Cup and the fact that the preceding 12 months were possibly the best 12 months that the club has ever had.

You'd think to listen to some, we 'were lucky to avoid relegation'. When in fact we never even came close. Certainly there was cause for concern, but effectively we'd done enough to stay up by Dec 12th.

So that's why its relevant and not absurd, its because its rational to consider that getting shot of a manager after one game of the season, isn't even remotely for rational reasons.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Aug 16 2.48pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Charlton showed you can protest even after you've got your tickets with tennis balls and inflatables, didn't they?

You can protest, but its rarely effective, until it hits the owners or the business in the pocket.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 17 Aug 16 2.49pm

Originally posted by TheFish

I can understand why a casual observer may think that. The headline grabbing success of the year we finished 5th obscures the seasons that followed. The scorelines, the Match of the Day highlights and the history books don't go into detail about the quality of football and 12th looks very much like 15th at the end of a season. But Pardew had us flirting with relegation, took us on our worst run of form in decades, lost successive derbies, made inexplicable tactical choices, substitutions and his behaviour off the pitch was even worse. Headbutting a player, calling a respected manager swearwords that this site will filter out, and so on.

Do I think the protests had a negative effect on the morale of some of the mercenaries? Yeah, probably, but we needed to change something because if we didn't nothing would change. The players who understood that this wasn't good enough were shipped out (Barton, Nolan, Enrique) or treated appallingly (Jonas, R.Taylor) by the club.

It's easy to say the protests lead to our relegation, but that's just not anywhere near a full picture.

I thought he'd given you five years in the Premier league while you got relegated either side of him being in charge? I thought he'd won manager of the year during that too?

As for calling a respected manager a few things. It's not like Mourinho, Wenger and Ferguson etc have done that is it?

You didn't even succeed in having him sacked. He walked out on you, and it's no surprise to anyone why.

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.