This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Dan89
Other clubs like West Ham have the funds to bring in a top striker, for a club like ours it isn't as easy to say sell Benteke and replace him for like. The lack business from us so far suggests it difficult to bring players in. Edited by Dan89 (12 Jul 2017 11.45am) Where are West Ham going to find a 15+ goals a season striker?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
You write as if he were some kind of special player. A one-off. He's not. Couldn't make it at Liverpool and has played reasonably well but not outstanding for us. I think £40-45mill would be fantastic on paper if we were to sell. But, then again, i have very little confidence in others having a dossier on potential replacements, unknown or otherwise, to fill the gap. Mark Bright was better. Brightly was better. Possibly my favourite Palace forward of all time, but that was then and this is now. Techy is a proven goal scorer, he is the best we've got by a mile, and to replace him would cost just as much as we'd get for him, but would be unproved in our setup. Techy stays. End of.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
You write as if he were some kind of special player. A one-off. He's not. Couldn't make it at Liverpool and has played reasonably well but not outstanding for us. I think £40-45mill would be fantastic on paper if we were to sell. But, then again, i have very little confidence in others having a dossier on potential replacements, unknown or otherwise, to fill the gap. Mark Bright was better.
|
|
|
bleeding Armstrong was better but hes the best we have right now, and hes still pretty awesome.
|
|
| miles18 |
|
|---|---|
|
It's not gonna happen. Benteke isn't a World Class striker and not good enough for a team that will be challenging for the title.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
You write as if he were some kind of special player. A one-off. He's not. Couldn't make it at Liverpool and has played reasonably well but not outstanding for us. I think £40-45mill would be fantastic on paper if we were to sell. But, then again, i have very little confidence in others having a dossier on potential replacements, unknown or otherwise, to fill the gap. Mark Bright was better. Wilf couldn't make it at Man Utd. CB couldn't make it at Liverpool because the manager who signed him, Brendan Rogers, was sacked. Klopp came in during the Autumn and didn't play a system to get goals and the most out of CB, which was probably the best for LFC long term, although it damaged their effort that 15/16 season. Klopp didn't get the ball to CB early, with possession in the oppo half, LFC centre halves on the halfway line and ample space in front of Benteke for Liverpool to get the ball to him. Instead they tried to work and pass the ball through full backs and centre backs about 6 times, ignoring Benteke's calls every time. (Carragher went nuts over this on Sky after matches) Something to think about with 'total football' or whatever the actual goal is. I don't claim he's a superstar, but did you notice those bullet headers he scored that were hardly there on a plate? At Sunderland and Everton for example? As others have said, you only need to look at other clubs' struggles to get high scoring forwards in, yet you would sell, for a price that looks good on paper, yet have little confidence in us having a replacement? What good is money on paper? Doesn't keep us in the league. Signing a couple of unknowns who can't cut it in England is very likely. Signing 'known' foreign players can fail. Ask Leicester, Spurs, West Ham (Zaza was a loan). Benteke will be in his 2nd season. He may get better. He scored 1 in 2 with Palace and Villa, and he didn't even have a proper number 10 with us. Plus he had a shyte manager for 4 months with very little knowledge compared to SA and FDB. If you want unknowns or cheapy cheap foreign players then it's probably best to bring them in and get them settled and then sell your guaranteed performer rather than trade the money instead of the abilities. Buying anyone proven in England with 1 in 2 will not only cost a fortune but they won't come here. Where do the rest of the goals come from? I don't see an of our players chipping in with 5/7 league goals. Barely assist that many times.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
bleeding Armstrong was better but hes the best we have right now, and hes still pretty awesome. I don't know why Brighty is being compared to Benteke. May as well compare Johnny Byrne. Kermit is a few years behind vauations. It went silly last Summer and it's going silly again.
COYP |
|
|
In this current climate I find that remark nothing less then astonishing!! But out of interest, who would you have in mind spending those 40m on? Originally posted by Kermit8
He's not even in the Belgian starting XI so we would be crazy to turn down £40mill plus for him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
In this current climate I find that remark nothing less then astonishing!! But out of interest, who would you have in mind spending those 40m on? 2 players for under £20 mil who we sell back to the country we bought them from 1.5 years later for half the amount. Which division we end up in is another punt. If we want to sign on the cheap then we're better off doing it with Benteke still here, or eek more out of him before the decline starts. I think that's the art of managing your transfers out the best you can. Fergie at Man U always sold as they were about to start the descent in their career. Edited by Rudi Hedman (12 Jul 2017 5.08pm)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
you make a lot of good points Rudi but what price would you say was acceptable? 45m? 50m? 60m? 100m? and, once you accepted that amount, what would you do with it? me, I suspect tekkers wants out. no reason at all, just too long supporting palace to think good players will want to stay. as such, I'd want us to push him toward Chelsea for Zouma and Batshuayi if he did want out. Chelsea must hate Everton for selling lukaku to the Mancs...maybe they would enjoy sticking one in their eye. for me, it's better to try and trade cleverly IF players want out, not out up barriers. If he doesn't want out then selling probably isn't wise or necessary. I would take a straight swap for those 2 or even chuck them a few bob. He's buying a house in London, is in a dressing room with French being the 2nd language. Unless Chelsea want him then I'm not sure he'd want the upheaval of Everton. If Chelsea did want him they'd probably have started bidding during the Loftus Cheek loan deal. We can also get more out of Chelsea . I'd start at over £50 mil. £60 mil. See what happens. Get £55. If it ends up being £50 and Benteke ends up wanting a move then we've done all we can. I wouldn't go weak at the knees for £40 mil like Gordon Brown selling off UK's gold and I doubt Parish would either. Thank God. If he does go we're going to have to get someone in pretty good or we're in trouble. That's going to cost us after selling an expensive player, same as it should to Everton.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Bullhorn76
It bothers me that Steve parish hasnt came out and stated that benteke is not for sale , spuds have done it with Eric dier knowing that man ure are sniffing around after him Maybe Parish doesn't want to rise to silly tittle tattle in the press.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.