You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > De Boer set for talks about future
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

De Boer set for talks about future


Page 9 of 13 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
YT Flag Oxford 28 Aug 17 2.42pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Apparently it's all because of players not doing as they're told.

[Link]

Would a footie manager really tell his players to "improve their decision-making"? Is it really that simple i.e. "I want you to become a better player overnight; got that, son?"

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 28 Aug 17 2.42pm

Chris Waddle repeats it every time England gets knocked out of a tournament. Little boys (and little girls these days) in Britain grow up in a footie playground culture of wanting to score more goals than their opponents. In FdB's Dutch playground the kids want to show their peers how clever they are at trapping and holding onto the ball as long as possible.

 

YT Flag Oxford 28 Aug 17 2.44pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

Chris Waddle repeats it every time England gets knocked out of a tournament. Little boys (and little girls these days) in Britain grow up in a footie playground culture of wanting to score more goals than their opponents. In FdB's Dutch playground the kids want to show their peers how clever they are at trapping and holding onto the ball as long as possible.

One of those two things would be a start...

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

gambler Flag Kent 28 Aug 17 2.45pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

Chris Waddle repeats it every time England gets knocked out of a tournament. Little boys (and little girls these days) in Britain grow up in a footie playground culture of wanting to score more goals than their opponents. In FdB's Dutch playground the kids want to show their peers how clever they are at trapping and holding onto the ball as long as possible.

What's your point slimey? Is scoring more goals than your opposition a bad thing? Not sure from that comment which you prefer?

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 28 Aug 17 2.45pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

Stubborness will get him the sack

[Link]

He thinks he can be arrogant like Wenger. Difference is Arsene manages a top six club, regularly gets into Europe and makes the owners a profit.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 17 2.47pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Basically you've realised I've put some thought into an assessment and it directly goes against the black and white nature of your posts so you decide it would be easier to stop engaging in debate and call me "Mr De Boer" and "Franks Relative" instead, despite the fact I never defended him or his tactics.

Mature and well thought out, mate.

It's because you're either blind or haven't any idea what's going on in the match, mate.

We struggle to break teams down at home so you're saying we're playing 3 at the back because Frank wants us to become more defensive. Have a recap on your understanding of football and come back when you have.

The players don't suit 3 at the back and we don't have the money to acquire them. That brings Frank under heavy scrutiny.

 


COYP

europalace Flag Europe 28 Aug 17 2.49pm

Originally posted by europalace

Zaha wasn't on the pitch either.

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

And how effective was he against Huddersfield under our 'new system' (being kicked to buggery notwithstanding)?

Well, Liverpool aren't a team that have just been promoted to the PL. They also aren't a team that kick other teams off the pitch. Zaha would have been very at home playing against them weekend before last. We definitely missed his skills during that game.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 28 Aug 17 2.49pm

Originally posted by gambler

What's your point slimey? Is scoring more goals than your opposition a bad thing? Not sure from that comment which you prefer?

You learn to command the ball first in places like Holland. There is nothing wrong with counter-attacking route one football - to be honest I prefer it the philistine that I am.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Aug 17 2.50pm

It is very easy for plausible stories to emerge about such meetings between the Board and managers to discuss futures.My goodness a similar story has emerged about W.Ham and they have a de-brief every Monday after a game anyway!

So do you think that Steve Parish having appointed De Boer would say to him after a mere 3 games when transfer activity has been limited, "Sorry, it's not working you have to go" ? I would be staggered.

It is more likely that FDB will be given time to revive our fortunes but if it is patently not working out, Parish appoints Freedman as an "Interim" and if he has a decent spell will appoint him full-time.

Edited by Willo (28 Aug 2017 2.52pm)

 

Mstrobez Flag 28 Aug 17 2.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It's because you're either blind or haven't any idea what's going on in the match, mate.

We struggle to break teams down at home so you're saying we're playing 3 at the back because Frank wants us to become more defensive. Have a recap on your understanding of football and come back when you have.

The players don't suit 3 at the back and we don't have the money to acquire them. That brings Frank under heavy scrutiny.

Again, your missing my point. I'm not defending his system. Im not saying his tactics shouldn't be under heavy scrutiny. I'm questioning people who believe the decision to 3 at the back was his idea of a more attacking move despite the fact he's always played with 4 at teams who can actually afford to be free flowing.

If you actually bothered to read my replies, you'd see the bit where I said "I'm not a fan of 3 at the back" and I never have been. So I really don't see what your getting at in response to my initial point.

Edited by Mstrobez (28 Aug 2017 2.53pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

chateauferret Flag 28 Aug 17 2.52pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

He thinks he can be arrogant like Wenger. Difference is Arsene manages a top six club, regularly gets into Europe and makes the owners a profit.

And has been there twenty years, not five minutes.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 17 3.02pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Again, your missing my point. I'm not defending his system. Im not saying his tactics shouldn't be under heavy scrutiny. I'm questioning people who believe the decision to 3 at the back was his idea of a more attacking move despite the fact he's always played with 4 at teams who can actually afford to be free flowing.

If you actually bothered to read my replies, you'd see the bit where I said "I'm not a fan of 3 at the back" and I never have been. So I really don't see what your getting at in response to my initial point.

Edited by Mstrobez (28 Aug 2017 2.53pm)

Right well if your posts are questioning why is he playing 3 at the back then it should be asked why is he playing 3 at the back he doesn't have the players for. With regards to having 5 players defending, that only happens when defence and midfield are behind the ball anyway. Therefore if you had 4 in defence you're likely to have 9 outfielders behind the ball. With 3-4-3, only 7. With 3-5-2, 8 or possibly 9.

Where this fails is teams don't wait for us to get them behind the ball and target ward or PVA or just knock the ball behind them because they're advanced.

To add, have you noticed how we have Benteke and punch standing on the halfway line when we defend corners? 2 oppo mark them and then there's their free man in 30 yard free radius in the hole. So there's no Benteke defending the corner and that risky set-up. Yep, really defensive. The league need to get with Frank's football education and quick or they'll all be left behind.

 


COYP

Mstrobez Flag 28 Aug 17 3.09pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Right well if your posts are questioning why is he playing 3 at the back then it should be asked why is he playing 3 at the back he doesn't have the players for. With regards to having 5 players defending, that only happens when defence and midfield are behind the ball anyway. Therefore if you had 4 in defence you're likely to have 9 outfielders behind the ball. With 3-4-3, only 7. With 3-5-2, 8 or possibly 9.

Where this fails is teams don't wait for us to get them behind the ball and target ward or PVA or just knock the ball behind them because they're advanced.

To add, have you noticed how we have Benteke and punch standing on the halfway line when we defend corners? 2 oppo mark them and then there's their free man in 30 yard free radius in the hole. So there's no Benteke defending the corner and that risky set-up. Yep, really defensive. The league need to get with Frank's football education and quick or they'll all be left behind.

I don't disagree with that at all. But doesn't that make you question what on earth Parish and him discussed prior to the appointment?

I personally believe Frank would've been so confident (rightly or wrongly) in his own abilities that he would've probably been the least inclined to demand a radical turnover of players at Palace. I suspect the real reason for Sam leaving was the fact that he made it clear after the 5-0 loss to City and the dire performance against United kids towards the end of the season that we'd still be in a lot of trouble this year without investment. Pellegrino and maybe even Silva probably said this as well and I think the fact Frank was probably the most laid back about it in his interview was the reason Parish wanted him.

It's always surprised me how relaxed Frank has seemed in interviews at the lack of transfer activity and the seeming confidence he's had in a squad which is quite clearly not of Premier League standard beyond the first 11.

Edited by Mstrobez (28 Aug 2017 3.09pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 28 Aug 17 3.13pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I don't disagree with that at all. But doesn't that make you question what on earth Parish and him discussed prior to the appointment?

I personally believe Frank would've been so confident (rightly or wrongly) in his own abilities that he would've probably been the least inclined to demand a radical turnover of players at Palace. I suspect the real reason for Sam leaving was the fact that he made it clear after the 5-0 loss to City and the dire performance against United kids towards the end of the season that we'd still be in a lot of trouble this year without investment. Pellegrino and maybe even Silva probably said this as well and I think the fact Frank was probably the most laid back about it in his interview was the reason Parish wanted him.

It's always surprised me how relaxed Frank has seemed in interviews at the lack of transfer activity and the seeming confidence he's had in a squad which is quite clearly not of Premier League standard beyond the first 11.

Edited by Mstrobez (28 Aug 2017 3.09pm)

Take out Sahko, and this first eleven managed 0.85 points a game under Sam. We are not even that good.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 17 3.17pm

If you look on the BBS you'll see line ups like this:

Mensah. Dann. Tomkins. PVA

Milivojevic

Zaha. Cabaye. Cheek. Townsend

Benteke

2 quality additions (by Frank and his big name), a new CB to come in, possibly a new keeper, cheap back up striker like Shane Long and players played in position. The bench wouldn't be that bad either, and with Wickham and Souare back at X as then even better.

This can be tweaked to 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3, 4-5-1, and once you have your full strength team available, do what West Ham did, work on 3 at the back in training and their only knowledge of it being 1,hour before kick off, not 2 months before with plenty of pre season pedestrian footage to pick apart.

It has been done very amateurishly, putting the club at risk.

 


COYP

Mstrobez Flag 28 Aug 17 3.21pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If you look on the BBS you'll see line ups like this:

Mensah. Dann. Tomkins. PVA

Milivojevic

Zaha. Cabaye. Cheek. Townsend

Benteke

2 quality additions (by Frank and his big name), a new CB to come in, possibly a new keeper, cheap back up striker like Shane Long and players played in position. The bench wouldn't be that bad either, and with Wickham and Souare back at X as then even better.

This can be tweaked to 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3, 4-5-1, and once you have your full strength team available, do what West Ham did, work on 3 at the back in training and their only knowledge of it being 1,hour before kick off, not 2 months before with plenty of pre season pedestrian footage to pick apart.

It has been done very amateurishly, putting the club at risk.

I was gonna say Sam did play us with a back 3 (unsuccessfully) a couple of times. Chelsea away was one example of where it worked out though because effectively, a bit like Liverpool away this season, we was playing with a back 5.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Petereagle Flag Brockley 28 Aug 17 3.21pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I don't disagree with that at all. But doesn't that make you question what on earth Parish and him discussed prior to the appointment?

I personally believe Frank would've been so confident (rightly or wrongly) in his own abilities that he would've probably been the least inclined to demand a radical turnover of players at Palace. I suspect the real reason for Sam leaving was the fact that he made it clear after the 5-0 loss to City and the dire performance against United kids towards the end of the season that we'd still be in a lot of trouble this year without investment. Pellegrino and maybe even Silva probably said this as well and I think the fact Frank was probably the most laid back about it in his interview was the reason Parish wanted him.

It's always surprised me how relaxed Frank has seemed in interviews at the lack of transfer activity and the seeming confidence he's had in a squad which is quite clearly not of Premier League standard beyond the first 11.

Edited by Mstrobez (28 Aug 2017 3.09pm)

[Link]


I would normally be very supportive of a new manager, especially one of Frank's track record, and giving him more time to turn things around. But this time its so obviously a bad fit, and frank's stubborness ( OK commitment to his passing style of play) just means we are going to leak more points. So sadly its time to part company with him as soon as the transfer window closes

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 28 Aug 17 3.29pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If you look on the BBS you'll see line ups like this:

Mensah. Dann. Tomkins. PVA

Milivojevic

Zaha. Cabaye. Cheek. Townsend

Benteke

2 quality additions (by Frank and his big name), a new CB to come in, possibly a new keeper, cheap back up striker like Shane Long and players played in position. The bench wouldn't be that bad either, and with Wickham and Souare back at X as then even better.

This can be tweaked to 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3, 4-5-1, and once you have your full strength team available, do what West Ham did, work on 3 at the back in training and their only knowledge of it being 1,hour before kick off, not 2 months before with plenty of pre season pedestrian footage to pick apart.

It has been done very amateurishly, putting the club at risk.

That sound a good team. Shows that with a couple of additions on the bench/injury back-ups we have the resources to be better than fight relegation.

Parish needs to tell FdB that Palace is not his pet project and has to put the club's interest first. So SP has either implied to FdB that he can do what he likes or FdB has assumed he can.

 

Jacey Flag 28 Aug 17 3.32pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

[Link]


I would normally be very supportive of a new manager, especially one of Frank's track record, and giving him more time to turn things around. But this time its so obviously a bad fit, and frank's stubborness ( OK commitment to his passing style of play) just means we are going to leak more points. So sadly its time to part company with him as soon as the transfer window closes


A bad fit, accused of stubbornness after just 3 games??
Surely,he must be given 10 ,a fair crack of the whip to turn results around or we really will become the laughing stock and just who in their right mind would accept the manager's role with our track record??
Parish had over 6 weeks to consider and evaluate candidates for the job and must now surely back his judgment,giving Frank realistic funds to bring in some much needed new faces including, hopefully, Sakho.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 17 3.39pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

That sound a good team. Shows that with a couple of additions on the bench/injury back-ups we have the resources to be better than fight relegation.

Parish needs to tell FdB that Palace is not his pet project and has to put the club's interest first. So SP has either implied to FdB that he can do what he likes or FdB has assumed he can.

He can of course build his project over a few Windows which is what fair minded people say it takes anyway, not a few months and 6+ players needed immediately with £30 mil net. It's bonkers.

 


COYP

Page 9 of 13 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > De Boer set for talks about future