You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Niasse Dive
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Niasse Dive


Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Nov 17 11.26am

Originally posted by chateauferret

The use of VAR would need to be carefully designed oc course but FFS it would be hard to make the quality of decision-making any worse than it is now.

Referees get 98% of decisions right which of course is a high percentage.

Of course on occasions the the 'Big' decisions can be called into question but I can understand the reasons from a referee's perspective.

When players seek to deceive the referee in the penalty area (And outside) perhaps the focus of ire should be trained on them.It almost seems as though simulation is part of their daily training !!!!

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Nov 17 11.31am

Originally posted by Willo

Referees get 98% of decisions right which of course is a high percentage.

Of course on occasions the the 'Big' decisions can be called into question but I can understand the reasons from a referee's perspective.

When players seek to deceive the referee in the penalty area (And outside) perhaps the focus of ire should be trained on them.It almost seems as though simulation is part of their daily training !!!!

That would suit you wouldn't it? Deflect the attention from the people whose job it is to stop players cheating.

It is precisely because the standard of refereeing is so poor that these players get away with it.

I've explained why that 98% isn't as impressive as it sounds already but I guess you took no notice of that because it didn't suit your agenda.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 11.32am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Nov 17 11.56am

Originally posted by chateauferret

That would suit you wouldn't it? Deflect the attention from the people whose job it is to stop players cheating.

It is precisely because the standard of refereeing is so poor that these players get away with it.

I've explained why that 98% isn't as impressive as it sounds already but I guess you took no notice of that because it didn't suit your agenda.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 11.32am)

I was criticised for not producing hard facts and when I do I get pilloried and the facts are discredited. Now who is talking about an 'Agenda' ?

Regards "Deflection" all the focus on HOL has been centred on the referee so I'm not taking any lectures about my so called stance on the matter.

I really don't accept that refereeing standards in the PL are "So poor".Of course in the modern game referees need assistance and would welcome the introduction of technology to assist them.


Edited by Willo (23 Nov 2017 11.58am)

 

The Dolphin Flag 23 Nov 17 11.57am

Willo
Your "Referees get 98% right" is a little on the high side in my opinion and in Mr Taylor's case on saturday I would say that he got towards 50% wrong!
I am pleased that someone has been pulled for cheating but it doesn't help the team that was cheated and that is why video help is needed for big stuff.
The ref's aren't helped by players who cheat (most of them do at some point)but they are highly experienced specialists and they should be able to spot a dive when they are that close.
It is just plain wrong!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Nov 17 12.04pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Willo
Your "Referees get 98% right" is a little on the high side in my opinion and in Mr Taylor's case on saturday I would say that he got towards 50% wrong!
I am pleased that someone has been pulled for cheating but it doesn't help the team that was cheated and that is why video help is needed for big stuff.
The ref's aren't helped by players who cheat (most of them do at some point)but they are highly experienced specialists and they should be able to spot a dive when they are that close.
It is just plain wrong!

All to do with angles and the referees view. Happens very fast and the referee has to consider if any contact was made and the degree of contact etc etc.Trust me, it can be very difficult - we see incidents umpteen times in 'Slow-Mo'.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Nov 17 12.06pm

A huge amount rides on the big decisions in football, literally millions of Pounds

Of course some clubs train people to cheat and sledge referees and - as it appears we don't - more fool us.

If it's impossible to train referees well enough to make them reasonably fool-proof then they need help.

In general rugby referees make fewer big mistakes despite having a more complex game. Yet in their case they also brought in video assistance.

It is outrageous in the technological age that football hasn't dealt with this many many years ago.

 

KLEAGLE2 Flag Shirley 23 Nov 17 12.33pm

Originally posted by Willo

All to do with angles and the referees view. Happens very fast and the referee has to consider if any contact was made and the degree of contact etc etc.Trust me, it can be very difficult - we see incidents umpteen times in 'Slow-Mo'.

This is 100% correct. From my view in the Holmesdale near the tunnel, it was an obvious and outrageous dive. Interested to know the thoughts of fans sitting in the AW with the same view as the ref.

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Nov 17 12.47pm

Originally posted by Willo

I was criticised for not producing hard facts and when I do I get pilloried and the facts are discredited. Now who is talking about an 'Agenda' ?

Regards "Deflection" all the focus on HOL has been centred on the referee so I'm not taking any lectures about my so called stance on the matter.

I really don't accept that refereeing standards in the PL are "So poor".Of course in the modern game referees need assistance and would welcome the introduction of technology to assist them.


Edited by Willo (23 Nov 2017 11.58am)

I didn't discredit the only fact you've actually given except to observe that it comes from PGMOL and appears in an article clearly designed as an apology for s*** referees so is hardly impartial. However, faute de mieux.

What I did do was point out that five mistakes per match still meas, conservatively speaking, 25% or so of matches being perverted by officials' errors and that is really quite s***e.

I think you'll also find that 90%+ of those decisions are totally routine such that my cat could call them correctly.

If you think that amounts to your being "pilloried" I suggest you get psychiatric help.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 12.53pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

The Dolphin Flag 23 Nov 17 1.05pm

Originally posted by Willo

All to do with angles and the referees view. Happens very fast and the referee has to consider if any contact was made and the degree of contact etc etc.Trust me, it can be very difficult - we see incidents umpteen times in 'Slow-Mo'.

In Saturday's case he blew way too quickly and he knew it.
He knew that an offence had been committed so a whistle was fine to stop play - but he should have had a think first.
He was waving his arms almost instantly - he could not wait to give it and I was flabbergasted as I was with the decision not to send Davies off for a terrible tackle, as I was for not pulling up the constant Everton niggling fouls, as I was for the two handed shove on (Wilf I think)in the first half in the penalty area that attracted no whistle.
Mr Taylor did his best, even to an unbiased observer, to appear to have had a vested interest in the result of the game and that is the first time I can EVER remember thinking that!

Edited by The Dolphin (23 Nov 2017 1.05pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 23 Nov 17 1.14pm

Originally posted by Willo

All to do with angles and the referees view. Happens very fast and the referee has to consider if any contact was made and the degree of contact etc etc.Trust me, it can be very difficult - we see incidents umpteen times in 'Slow-Mo'.

If it is all to do with angles and it is very difficult, then why go with the penalty option. Does the defender not get the benefit of the doubt unless the ref clearly sees an offence has been committed? If that is the case he must have clearly seen Niasse's legs hacked away from him, yes? Or, was he just guessing? Far more likely in my opinion and hence the reason why he should never have pointed to the spot.

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Nov 17 1.18pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

If it is all to do with angles and it is very difficult, then why go with the penalty option. Does the defender not get the benefit of the doubt unless the ref clearly sees an offence has been committed? If that is the case he must have clearly seen Niasse's legs hacked away from him, yes? Or, was he just guessing? Far more likely in my opinion and hence the reason why he should never have pointed to the spot.

Is the correct answer.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Littlebogreek Flag 23 Nov 17 1.39pm

Don't have the motivation to read all 15 pages and anyway, I expect them to be filled with Willo defending the refereeing so not really worth reading.
The ban is literally zero consolation to me and just one decision of the millions that have gone against us this season. I honestly can't remember a season where the poor decisions against us haven't been evened up by the ones that have gone with us but we are going to have to get a hell of a lot for the rest of the season for it to even come close.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Nov 17 1.39pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

If it is all to do with angles and it is very difficult, then why go with the penalty option. Does the defender not get the benefit of the doubt unless the ref clearly sees an offence has been committed? If that is the case he must have clearly seen Niasse's legs hacked away from him, yes? Or, was he just guessing? Far more likely in my opinion and hence the reason why he should never have pointed to the spot.

The referee pointed to the spot without any hesitation so he must have been convinced it was a penalty.

As Dermot Gallagher said, from the refs angle it is a penalty from the camera behind the goal it paints a different picture.

Would love to continue this debate but my wife and I are about to go out and not back until tomorrow.

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Nov 17 1.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

The referee pointed to the spot without any hesitation so he must have been convinced it was a penalty.

As Dermot Gallagher said, from the refs angle it is a penalty from the camera behind the goal it paints a different picture.

Would love to continue this debate but my wife and I are about to go out and not back until tomorrow.

You've proven right there exactly why the decision was *not* competent.

He would have needed to take several seconds to be convinced it was a penalty so that's bollocks straight away. He blew up before Niasse even hit the ground FFS.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 1.52pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Littlebogreek Flag 23 Nov 17 1.58pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

You've proven right there exactly why the decision was *not* competent.

He would have needed to take several seconds to be convinced it was a penalty so that's bollocks straight away. He blew up before Niasse even hit the ground FFS.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 1.52pm)

Made this point at the time that he had given the penalty before Niasse hit the floor. Literally gave himself no time to think at all which isn't smart in any situation. Interesting that Willo see's this as him doing his job better rather than worse, almost as if he has an agenda to deliberately annoy people.

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Nov 17 2.00pm

Originally posted by Littlebogreek

Made this point at the time that he had given the penalty before Niasse hit the floor. Literally gave himself no time to think at all which isn't smart in any situation. Interesting that Willo see's this as him doing his job better rather than worse, almost as if he has an agenda to deliberately annoy people.

Blown himself up with his own fart.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 2.00pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Littlebogreek Flag 23 Nov 17 2.01pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Blown himself up with his own fart.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 2.00pm)

Sadly not for the first or last time.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Nov 17 2.44pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Blown himself up with his own fart.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Nov 2017 2.00pm)

Dear me.

The tone has really been lowered in this debate.

Finally about to get in car and depart !

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 23 Nov 17 3.14pm

The papers talk of a two match ban. Everton (no points deducted) and their next two opponents have benefitted; Palace suffering is still in force. The FA have not said which two matches and an Everton appeal will delay implementation of the ban.

Two matches would ideally mean against next two Everton opponents and banned individually (whatever his team) for the next two against Palace matches for which he is fit (with deceptive injuries resulting in further FA sanction).

I am not sure whether Croydon Market could provide sufficient ready to throw produce for any Selhurst Park stocks that might be installed.

COYP

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 23 Nov 17 8.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

The referee pointed to the spot without any hesitation so he must have been convinced it was a penalty.

As Dermot Gallagher said, from the refs angle it is a penalty from the camera behind the goal it paints a different picture.

Would love to continue this debate but my wife and I are about to go out and not back until tomorrow.

If you really are trying to defend the referee, you aren't doing a good job

 

Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Niasse Dive