You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should we sell Benteke in Jan...?
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should we sell Benteke in Jan...?


Page 9 of 27 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 03 Dec 17 8.27pm

The ansWer is,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,NO!

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 03 Dec 17 8.31pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

The ansWer is,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,NO!

What even if we were offered £35mill for the lump?

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 03 Dec 17 9.20pm

i love bentekkers but we seem to play better without him in the team.

if woy can find a way of playing well with him then its all hood, sam did so its possible.

when hes on form hes a 1 in 2 PL striker, in a top team he would bag 25 goals every season.

unless everton bid £40m+ in jan i cant see him leaving

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


mattteo Flag 04 Dec 17 10.46am

Originally posted by Kermit8

What even if we were offered £35mill for the lump?

Nobody will give you that money for a striker who hasn't scored in half a year

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 06 Dec 17 12.09am

Originally posted by mattteo

Nobody will give you that money for a striker who hasn't scored in half a year

But if they did? Do we take it...?

I'd only entertain an offer of £30m+ but even then im not sure taking it is the solution or not.

He's on a bad run of form that happens. But if he gets his mojo back then he's worth every penny. Maybe someone with deep pockets would take that risk.

Chelsea / Everton both could afford him and both have been mentioned in the past...

So if the £35m is offered?

Let's not forget big Sam paid a ransom for Schulpp and PVA, would it be surprising if he came in for Benteke at £35m, maybe surprising but not out of this world.

Edited by Goldfiinger (06 Dec 2017 12.12am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Dec 17 1.11am

Bite his hand offfor£30+

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 06 Dec 17 2.47am

Seems the games without Benteke showed we're better off without a hoofball target up front. And top PL striker with zero goals after playing 10 games - a bit like Pardew at his worst...

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 06 Dec 17 7.02am

Originally posted by 60 yrs a palace fan


How on earth you can compare Benteke with the others.

Gayle is not a premier league striker and never will be . His record against Benteke record is inferior.

Murray was a mistake selling him we all know that. Murray would have been a useful squad member but not the answer.

Benteke will come good.


Ladopa and Kaikai are not the answer either.

Keep telling yourself this, the 2 games he has started he scored away at Man Utd and away at Chelsea. Now by my reckoning that is 2 more than Tekkers. Go on tell me i am wrong....

 

Aray Flag South London 06 Dec 17 7.51am

Cannot believe anyone with a braincell is entertaining us selling our only fit striker.

We only have ONE fit striker. Just in case you cannot count. That is one less than TWO. In an ideal world we'd have three.

Selling Benteke would require us having to buy two strikers and then we'd be trying to integrate two players at a key part of the season. For real?

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 06 Dec 17 8.20am

This thread is a nonsense! Sell Benteke, if we get £30 million + then grab it, we play better without him etc etc

With this reckoning - we should just sell, don’t even bother replacing him (as last time we did that by selling Gayle & Murray that worked out really well) & invest the money into the main stand development ... Puncheon will no doubt hit form and bag us the goals we need to secure safety anyway!!!

He’s been injured, off form and playing in a dire side. He’s come back and trying to find his feet in a side that now plays differently! He’ll come good ...

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Dec 17 10.38am

Originally posted by Aray

Cannot believe anyone with a braincell is entertaining us selling our only fit striker.

We only have ONE fit striker. Just in case you cannot count. That is one less than TWO. In an ideal world we'd have three.

Selling Benteke would require us having to buy two strikers and then we'd be trying to integrate two players at a key part of the season. For real?

You have rather answered your own question there as to what needs to be done. As for integration into the team I would argue that the player struggling to integrate most of all is Benteke because we have scored more goals and looked more dangerous with him out the side than in. No-one on here has suggested we should sell and not replace, of course that would be stupid. If we can find a player that can fit into a mobile front 3 then we can then use the rest of the money to get a cheaper lump replacement. If Benteke truly wants to integrate into this team he needs to be asking himself questions about how to do it. He is definitely not the player to be building the team around.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 06 Dec 17 10.43am

Seems Benteke keeps his place due to price tag. Sell and get 2 new strikers in. Would not be surprised if Dougie work on such a solution. 10 games played and ZERO goals.....say no more!

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 06 Dec 17 11.08am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You have rather answered your own question there as to what needs to be done. As for integration into the team I would argue that the player struggling to integrate most of all is Benteke because we have scored more goals and looked more dangerous with him out the side than in. No-one on here has suggested we should sell and not replace, of course that would be stupid. If we can find a player that can fit into a mobile front 3 then we can then use the rest of the money to get a cheaper lump replacement. If Benteke truly wants to integrate into this team he needs to be asking himself questions about how to do it. He is definitely not the player to be building the team around.


The first four games this season were under de Boer and can be discounted as no one in the team understood the tactics. In the fifth game Benteke was injured and has only made two starts since his return from injury, being on the bench for the previous two games. We have six points from those games, the results of which he has contributed to without scoring (you can't ignore the headers won, the knock downs, etc.).

He was the leading scorer last season with a very creditable 15 PL goals, without running around like a headless chicken. Put Zaha back on the wing, with Townsend on the other and RLC through the middle and the goals will come. With our inability to sign strikers there's no way anyone in their right mind would advocate selling last season's leading scorer in the hope of signing two better in January.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 06 Dec 17 11.19am

Originally posted by bexleydave


The first four games this season were under de Boer and can be discounted as no one in the team understood the tactics. In the fifth game Benteke was injured and has only made two starts since his return from injury, being on the bench for the previous two games. We have six points from those games, the results of which he has contributed to without scoring (you can't ignore the headers won, the knock downs, etc.).

He was the leading scorer last season with a very creditable 15 PL goals, without running around like a headless chicken. Put Zaha back on the wing, with Townsend on the other and RLC through the middle and the goals will come. With our inability to sign strikers there's no way anyone in their right mind would advocate selling last season's leading scorer in the hope of signing two better in January.

Everyone seems to agree with this apart from hodgeson. Seems to want to play 4-2-4 wether it's working or not. I thought when he played Zaha and Townsend up front, we finally had a plan B.....seems not.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Dec 17 11.20am

Originally posted by bexleydave


The first four games this season were under de Boer and can be discounted as no one in the team understood the tactics. In the fifth game Benteke was injured and has only made two starts since his return from injury, being on the bench for the previous two games. We have six points from those games, the results of which he has contributed to without scoring (you can't ignore the headers won, the knock downs, etc.).

He was the leading scorer last season with a very creditable 15 PL goals, without running around like a headless chicken. Put Zaha back on the wing, with Townsend on the other and RLC through the middle and the goals will come. With our inability to sign strikers there's no way anyone in their right mind would advocate selling last season's leading scorer in the hope of signing two better in January.

You can't live in the past with football. If he comes good great, but what if he doesn't and this barren run just continues, do we just shrug our shoulders and go, "oh well, he was really good last season, shame we have been relegated and he wants to leave at half price now"?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Dec 17 11.23am

Oh, by the way Dave, if we are sticking with Benteke then I agree with your team set up, Zaha cannot play through the middle with him. He must go out wide and RLC play no 10 role.

 

Aray Flag South London 06 Dec 17 8.44pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You have rather answered your own question there as to what needs to be done. As for integration into the team I would argue that the player struggling to integrate most of all is Benteke because we have scored more goals and looked more dangerous with him out the side than in. No-one on here has suggested we should sell and not replace, of course that would be stupid. If we can find a player that can fit into a mobile front 3 then we can then use the rest of the money to get a cheaper lump replacement. If Benteke truly wants to integrate into this team he needs to be asking himself questions about how to do it. He is definitely not the player to be building the team around.

Not sure what you understand what my question is. For the avoidance of any doubt, I am asking is anyone seriously thinking we can buy 2 strikers in the next window and integrate in time for them to be effective. I am as unhappy with Benteke's form as the next guy but selling at this moment would be unwise in my view, very. Let's hope Roy works out a formation soon that works coz right now it ain't

 

Den1923 Flag 07 Dec 17 5.32pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You can't live in the past with football. If he comes good great, but what if he doesn't and this barren run just continues, do we just shrug our shoulders and go, "oh well, he was really good last season, shame we have been relegated and he wants to leave at half price now"?

not sure we would get that much for him anyway! it would be good if we could recoup our investment but on current form unlikely!

 

homes Flag New Eltham 07 Dec 17 8.37pm

You must be bonkers selling Benkeke would be suicide.

 


IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".

Den1923 Flag 08 Dec 17 4.09pm

Originally posted by homes

You must be bonkers selling Benkeke would be suicide.

What is he doing then? apart from missing sitters!

 

Page 9 of 27 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should we sell Benteke in Jan...?