You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > roy out
November 20 2026 7.40pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

roy out


Page 9 of 231 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
EddieMac Flag 07 Oct 20 6.31am

You would think Roy had been handed a 20 year contract by the way some of you are carrying on. What do you want ? Roy at his age to go back and learn and how to play football like Bielsa?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 07 Oct 20 6.34am

Originally posted by EddieMac

You would think Roy had been handed a 20 year contract by the way some of you are carrying on. What do you want ? Roy at his age to go back and learn and how to play football like Bielsa?

No, a new manager to come in and coach like Bielsa

 

Den1923 Flag 07 Oct 20 8.32am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

No, a new manager to come in and coach like Bielsa

Succession planning is important but with dysfunctional board little chance of attracting anyone in the class of Bielsa, the best you could hope for to succeed Roy when the times comes would be someone like Rooney who is desperate for a break to prove himself!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 07 Oct 20 8.37am

Originally posted by Den1923

Succession planning is important but with dysfunctional board little chance of attracting anyone in the class of Bielsa, the best you could hope for to succeed Roy when the times comes would be someone like Rooney who is desperate for a break to prove himself!

Not many clubs have had a successful succession planning strategy. Man United have never replaced Ferguson Arsenal may or may not have replaced Wenger and how many managers did Liverpool go through before Klopp?

I think the best you can hope for is to pick the best available manager at the time and then hope to god you get it right.

 


One more point

Den1923 Flag 07 Oct 20 8.40am

Originally posted by Badger11

Not many clubs have had a successful succession planning strategy. Man United have never replaced Ferguson Arsenal may or may not have replaced Wenger and how many managers did Liverpool go through before Klopp?

I think the best you can hope for is to pick the best available manager at the time and then hope to god you get it right.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 07 Oct 20 8.49am

Parishes choice at the time was frank de boer

 

beak Flag croydon 07 Oct 20 8.56am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

No, a new manager to come in and coach like Bielsa

We couldn't afford the bucket he sits on.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 07 Oct 20 9.18am

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Roy will never change and his methods are successful to meet the expectations of the board and owners. That’s it. Despite the better than usual transfer window, I read we spent the 18th highest on transfer fees (brighton 19th, Burnley 20th) this window. That tells you everything, just stay up is must with a cash flow like ours.

The point regarding 20k fans shouting. No manager is going to be influenced by fans during a game. If he/she was, then they wouldn’t be a top flight manager for very long. Although, it would make for a great post match interview.

I'm not advocating Roy out, because as you say, he's meeting his expectations... but when we're 2-0 down at 50-60 Mins, It would be nice if he show some attacking intent and (for example) take off a DM, and put of an AM, or CF, rather than like-for like? is he that worried about goal difference?

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 07 Oct 20 11.15am

Yes he is.. Plan A was blown so his history at CP is bring on defenders so we can try and save on a negative goal difference, he done it so many times, he basically gives up and this rubs off on the players for sure, no doubt Wilf!!

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I'm not advocating Roy out, because as you say, he's meeting his expectations... but when we're 2-0 down at 50-60 Mins, It would be nice if he show some attacking intent and (for example) take off a DM, and put of an AM, or CF, rather than like-for like? is he that worried about goal difference?

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 07 Oct 20 11.33am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3563618]

Ok, hands up, that was a rant from me. But the 'Roy out' brigade are just exasperating. Every time we lose, the same hackneyed phrases are touted. "No plan b", "won't use players with flair", "Always plays his favorites", "Dinosaur", "Football has moved on" etc.&etc. Hardly any of these posters are around when we win. They never give credit for finishing mid table. It's just they don't like the style of football. Well, to be fair, nor do I mostly. But if you want to debate it, then bring something to the table. Bielsa and Santo or not available, so not worth a mention. Dyche has been mentioned I believe, but that's a 'like for like substitution' (see what I did there?), as has Howe, who got relegated recently. I'll debate if you have a suggestion as to how we move to a different phase.

I think that all the reasons the 'Roy out' brigade give are valid and i don't think it's the fans' job to identify a new manager. Unless you're a global manager scout (does that role even exist?) you're just not going to have the intel to know who will evolve our first team. I certainly don't, and neither do a lot of clubs which is why crap managers can walk straight into new jobs. But there's evidence that clubs (mentioned in this thread) with less resource than ours are able to identify these more progressive managers. It's not a cop-out and it doesn't make the reasons for being highly dissatisfied any less valid though. And it allows us to talk about the ingredients of a new manager, what we'd like to see, which is good stuff to get into conversationally.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (07 Oct 2020 11.37am)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 07 Oct 20 1.47pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Yes he is.. Plan A was blown so his history at CP is bring on defenders so we can try and save on a negative goal difference, he done it so many times, he basically gives up and this rubs off on the players for sure, no doubt Wilf!!

I'm pretty sure this is it. I can't think of one positive substitution when we go 2 down, he's happy to lose but keep the score down. He probably rationalises it as damage limitation. I can't begin to imagine how it motivates the players.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (07 Oct 2020 1.49pm)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 07 Oct 20 2.00pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I'm pretty sure this is it. I can't think of one positive substitution when we go 2 down, he's happy to lose but keep the score down. He probably rationalises it as damage limitation. I can't begin to imagine how it motivates the players.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (07 Oct 2020 1.49pm)

His positive options were limited, I expect your referring to Benteke and Meyer. Benteke with a fabulous recent scoring record and Meyer who gets pushed out the way too easily. With those options what would you do?

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 07 Oct 20 2.04pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I'm pretty sure this is it. I can't think of one positive substitution when we go 2 down, he's happy to lose but keep the score down. He probably rationalises it as damage limitation. I can't begin to imagine how it motivates the players.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (07 Oct 2020 1.49pm)

on the Flip side of this, how often have we gone into the final throws of The season saying 'our goal difference is worth another point' ? If it Wasn't for this attitude in games, we wouldn't have this.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 07 Oct 20 3.36pm

Originally posted by Painter

His positive options were limited, I expect your referring to Benteke and Meyer. Benteke with a fabulous recent scoring record and Meyer who gets pushed out the way too easily. With those options what would you do?

I'd bring benteke on. Although he doesn't score much, two things he can do are hold the ball up, and win headers. We were crying out for that saturday.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 07 Oct 20 4.08pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I'd bring benteke on. Although he doesn't score much, two things he can do are hold the ball up, and win headers. We were crying out for that saturday.

Yes we were and I was calling for that sub before half time because we were not holding the ball long enough for the midfield to help out. This was exactly the sort of game where an early substitution and a change of tactics could have been beneficial and tilted it in our favour. We’ll never know though because we just ploughed on regardless! I want to see some ballsy calls by Roy, not just hoping we are going to get something out of it despite being totally outplayed.

Edited by Eaglecoops (07 Oct 2020 4.09pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Oct 20 4.42pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Succession planning is important but with dysfunctional board little chance of attracting anyone in the class of Bielsa, the best you could hope for to succeed Roy when the times comes would be someone like Rooney who is desperate for a break to prove himself!

It will be Eddie Howe, Carl on Twitter reckons our new manager is taking a break from football or will it be Poch?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 07 Oct 20 6.11pm

Desperate stuff here. Benteke good at holding the ball up ? Since when ? For a bloke of his size it’s absolutely pathetic and his complete lack of contribution at times has been as big a problem as his goal scoring.

 

EddieMac Flag 07 Oct 20 6.12pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

It will be Eddie Howe, Carl on Twitter reckons our new manager is taking a break from football or will it be Poch?

Eddie Howe will be back in a job well before Roy retires.

 

jeeagles Flag 07 Oct 20 6.29pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Succession planning is important but with dysfunctional board little chance of attracting anyone in the class of Bielsa, the best you could hope for to succeed Roy when the times comes would be someone like Rooney who is desperate for a break to prove himself!

Putting our board on comparison with other premiership clubs.

City, United, Chelsea, Liverpool, Spurs, and Arsenal are in a different league, but only Liverpool and Spurs are run efficiently.

Leicester have spent loads and done a fantastic job, Wolves have also done very well too.

West Ham, Southampton, Brighton, Newcastle Leeds, and Everton are all far less efficient. I wouldn't swap our owners with theres.

We've overtaken Fulham and West Brom in recent years.

Jury is still out on Sheffield United.

Pound for pound the only club out performing us has been Burnley.

Not to mention all the clubs that have been religated since CPFC 2010 took over.

QPR, Hull, Cardiff, Swansea, Watford, Sunderland were all light years ahead of us a decade ago.

Out of all the clubs that haven't received massive investment, we are one of the best run clubs in the country. With the 9th biggest wage bill, we have very little wriggle room to invest more based on our income. Effectively, we are the second best run club of our size and resources in the country.


 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 07 Oct 20 6.34pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Well last season we won 11 out of 38.. so its probably more the case we had little opportunity

I doubt that you commented on any though. Or that we finished mid table. And I'd bet that you didn't comment on the two wins this season.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Page 9 of 231 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > roy out