You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread


Page 9 of 12 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Putitout Flag Oxford 31 Aug 22 10.27am

Originally posted by palace chick

I’m not with the full on criticism of Luka coming on. All that was required was a bulking up of the midfield with perhaps Ayew on the right and Luka alongside Dacoure and Schlupp. It was messing around with the defence and practically all the others on the pitch that caused the problems. PV screwed up a win last night and thank goodness we got a point.

On paper you are right PV screwed up ,but only because the players he trusted to do a job screwed up a simple defensive situation. We need an old head in these situations to make sure the doors are closed, because the young lads we have obviously don’t read these situations anywhere near well enough, it is happening to often. Going by his interview even the usually cool PV is getting annoyed with the situation.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Aug 22 10.30am

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Well, sorry to disagree chick, but I am....in spades. He is no longer able to make any worthwhile contribution to our game. As I recall from last night, the first thing he did was commit a foul and give away a free kick. Please desist from playing him PV.

We're we really that tired towards the end of the game? Our marking in the build up to their goal was woeful. But, disappointing as last night's result was, we're still only 5 games in. No cause for alarm.

I am in total agreement.

Milivojevic's contributions are merely fouling and giving away free kicks inviting pressure.Slow,cumbersome, unable to copy with the intensity of the PL. A total liability.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 31 Aug 22 10.44am

When Brentford Scored PV was really animated on the touchline last night, you could easily see was pretty upset.

Originally posted by Putitout

On paper you are right PV screwed up ,but only because the players he trusted to do a job screwed up a simple defensive situation. We need an old head in these situations to make sure the doors are closed, because the young lads we have obviously don’t read these situations anywhere near well enough, it is happening to often. Going by his interview even the usually cool PV is getting annoyed with the situation.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 31 Aug 22 10.51am

Originally posted by Willo

Milivojevic provides no freshness at all, slow, not mobile enough for the rigours of the PL.I shudder when he is introduced into the fray and I admit to exhaling a walrus moan when he ran on to the hallowed turf.

Apropos the centre-backs I have been consistently critical of Andersen as a defender and I have not been overly impressed with Guehi either.

For the darned equaliser we had 4 players around 2 Brentford players before the cross was delivered, Andersen was in acres of space marking nobody and Brentford had a 2v2 situation in the centre of the box.Mitchell caught ball-watching and should have got closer to Wissa.A catalogue of woe.

Edited by Willo (31 Aug 2022 9.57am)

Agree regarding Luka. When he came on , it was like everyone in the holmesdale had received a text that their mother in law was coming to stay.
Currently he is such a poor player, zero mobility, just stands in the semi circle at the edge of the penalty box and gives away the occasional foul.
The only instance I could see him coming on , that would be a benefit, would be at the end of extra time in the cup if we needed a penalty taker.
The result wasn’t his fault yesterday, but he should be no where near a premier league match day squad, let alone playing.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 31 Aug 22 10.53am

Surprised by the Luca criticism as I saw the true offender as Mitchell. He made error after error after coming on; and he was literally marking no-one when THAT cross came over.

I am with Wilf with the frustration as he must have watched that free header and thought: WTF.

Depressingly, Mitchell (and Olise - almost there) needs a bit more game time before he was the beast who all but fended off Man City single handed last season.

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 31 Aug 22 10.57am

Maybe PV should sing his song in his head before making substitutions.

"He knows exactly what we need....Olise in attack, Mitchell at the back"....

Replacing Olise with Mitchell was exactly what we did not need.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 Aug 22 11.02am

Originally posted by Putitout

On paper you are right PV screwed up ,but only because the players he trusted to do a job screwed up a simple defensive situation. We need an old head in these situations to make sure the doors are closed, because the young lads we have obviously don’t read these situations anywhere near well enough, it is happening to often. Going by his interview even the usually cool PV is getting annoyed with the situation.

I would propose that if you are the manager it is your duty to choose the right tactics and players for any situation you assess, and to have trained them, therefore PV is at fault. He could well be animated at Johnstone coming on and missing a last minute penalty we might of won but would again be responsible if Johnstone taking it is his decision. Bad worker - tools springs to mind.

The context here being that I don't think there's need for massive reaction just yet but it is something PV needs to address and he has to take responsibility for not managing us to see that game out yesterday which I, and I think many others (including Wilf), are inclined to believe we could have done.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

The groover Flag Danbury 31 Aug 22 11.34am

I think even PV he understands that he screwed up. By changing the team so dramatically we had no attacking outlet. We went from Eze, Olise, Wilf, Eddie and schlupp to eddie and wilf.

We should have brought on Eboiwei if we were going 4-5-1. or 5-4-1

That would at least have given us another attacking option. We just kept feeding the ball back to them.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 31 Aug 22 11.38am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

There is nothing wrong in just saying Brantford deserved their point, they caused us problems from the very start and can understand our subs based on our slender lead.

Agree with you there TP. They did what they were allowed to and had to do to get the respected point. Shame we didnt . Has anyone counted the ammount of points we have lost from winning positions ? 2 of the best attacking players taken off last night and replaced with Royball players . Attack is the best form of defence IMO . But fair play to Brentford they took advantage of it . Hate that German t*** though smug crout.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 Aug 22 11.39am

Originally posted by The groover

I think even PV he understands that he screwed up. By changing the team so dramatically we had no attacking outlet. We went from Eze, Olise, Wilf, Eddie and schlupp to eddie and wilf.

We should have brought on Eboiwei if we were going 4-5-1. or 5-4-1

That would at least have given us another attacking option. We just kept feeding the ball back to them.

Another great point!

I bemoaned that last night given as we fended off one wave, we had nothing to do with the ball asides from lose it and prepare for the next... 1-1.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

dreamwaverider Flag London 31 Aug 22 11.58am

Can someone tell me how they got their goal. From where I was sitting all i could see was a Brentford forward with a free unmarked header right in the middle of the penalty area

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 31 Aug 22 12.03pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I would propose that if you are the manager it is your duty to choose the right tactics and players for any situation you assess, and to have trained them, therefore PV is at fault. He could well be animated at Johnstone coming on and missing a last minute penalty we might of won but would again be responsible if Johnstone taking it is his decision. Bad worker - tools springs to mind.

The context here being that I don't think there's need for massive reaction just yet but it is something PV needs to address and he has to take responsibility for not managing us to see that game out yesterday which I, and I think many others (including Wilf), are inclined to believe we could have done.

It’s obvious PV did not make a right decision hence the result, of course we can’t be sure their five forward thinking substitutions would not have got them that result if he had not changed the set up. In the same way in most respects Considering the obvious limitations of some players, Viera tactics have achieved some remarkable results. All because he trusts the players to carry out instruction. So why should last night have been different ,other than sometimes your players respond sometimes they don’t.
Wilf, might be right, but then again , he might reflect that his own contribution outside of a fantastic one off strike could have been better, and his opinions maybe should be aired in the changing room, and left there.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 31 Aug 22 12.04pm

The most disappointing thing for me was to see Ward, who I thought had a great game until he was displaced from left back and then didn’t appear to know where to play.

We were in total control defensively as a four and in my opinion the way to counter an all out attack should be by bolstering the midfield, not the defence. I would have preferred to see us finish the game in 4-5-1 which can translate back into a 4-3-3 in transition. All we really did by going 5 at the back was to say, see if you can break us down which they did once and could have scored twice more.

If they have been practicing 5 at the back then it was very poor in its execution but you have to question its wisdom in the first place.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 31 Aug 22 12.24pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Can someone tell me how they got their goal. From where I was sitting all i could see was a Brentford forward with a free unmarked header right in the middle of the penalty area

Yes that just sums it up really free header unmarked around the pen area a bit of power in it to be fair. If Vincente was a bit braver he could have came out and took his head off or at least put him under a bit of presure .

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 31 Aug 22 12.25pm

Another thing I noticed was Olise quite clearly not impressed he was taken off, huffing and blowing in the dugout.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 31 Aug 22 12.33pm

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

Yes that just sums it up really free header unmarked around the pen area a bit of power in it to be fair. If Vincente was a bit braver he could have came out and took his head off or at least put him under a bit of presure .

I am having my doubts about him this season. I notice he doesn't seem to come for high balls in the area that he should be able to collect and wonder if he is just not verbally commanding 'his manor'?

 

Mathers Flag 31 Aug 22 12.33pm

PV needs to learn that “shutting up shop” and messing around with the back 4 simply doesn’t work.

Last year he tried he against Brighton (twice), arsenal away and again last night. All 4 games we conceded in the 87th minute or later.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 31 Aug 22 12.53pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

I am having my doubts about him this season. I notice he doesn't seem to come for high balls in the area that he should be able to collect and wonder if he is just not verbally commanding 'his manor'?

Yes agree with you there ST , He doesnt command the area very well and i think there is a lack of calls on wether he is collecting the ball. I think it makes the defenders a bit nervy . There was a few occasions he could have came out and claimed the ball but left it. Dont get me wrong a great keeper but could be more commanding . Just my opinion .

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 Aug 22 1.05pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

I am having my doubts about him this season. I notice he doesn't seem to come for high balls in the area that he should be able to collect and wonder if he is just not verbally commanding 'his manor'?

I don't think he ever has really ST from my memory, very much a 'stay at home' keeper, or 'shot-stopper' to put a more positive spin on it.

Anyway you look at it, over the course he has been a fantastic signing for us and a brilliant keeper, one of our best for x amount of time I'd argue. Butland was brought in but very much looked the polar opposite to VG unhelpfully, might be tall and (I'm guessing don't actually know) commanding but looked 'Hennessey-esque' at times, liable to concede any 'worldy' fired at him from range.

In an ideal world, you'd want a keeper that could command a box including aerially but also have faith in one-on-ones or 'shot-stopping'. I was under the impression Johnstone could be that but I personally haven't seen anything of him yet, at all, literally. On that note is he still out or being left out?

I think VG's tenure is reaching the end of it's lifespan and I genuinely wish him all the best whatever happens and will be eternally grateful but I am hoping Sam J will step up to that proverbial plate.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 31 Aug 22 1.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

Milivojevic's contributions are merely fouling and giving away free kicks inviting pressure.Slow,cumbersome, unable to copy with the intensity of the PL. A total liability.

agreed. He was an excellent player, maybe 5 years ago. Now ? time to ply his trade in the Championship or to think about a coaching career.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 9 of 12 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread