This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Why do you think that article links to your question? II read it and there is no suggestion that anything done in the past was wrong! All it talks about it was is proposed in the future. A future which involves a different set of circumstances. Questions are being raised about the wisdom of the decision, which feels to me to be, at least partly, based on financial considerations. However, we are no longer at the start of a pandemic when mass vaccination was considered necessary so the context of the decision is entirely different. No connection at all. What should others do when it’s obvious they have been wrong all along? Learn from their mistake and stop misleading others. If they choose to save face and do it quietly that’s up to them. The important thing is that they do it, so people aren’t misled and possibly harmed. Why do you think it doesn't? The vaccine is no longer available for the majority so even if the unvaccinated changed their mind there's nothing to be done. The authorities obviously don't think it's too vital either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Why do you think it doesn't? The vaccine is no longer available for the majority so even if the unvaccinated changed their mind there's nothing to be done. The authorities obviously don't think it's too vital either. Because, as I patiently explained what I regard as totally obvious, the circumstances are now different to when the vaccination programme was introduced. I am unaware of any new variants causing major concerns so imagine that herd immunity has started to play a role in the thinking.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Because, as I patiently explained what I regard as totally obvious, the circumstances are now different to when the vaccination programme was introduced. I am unaware of any new variants causing major concerns so imagine that herd immunity has started to play a role in the thinking. So why not just leave people alone instead of trying to shame them for a vaccination they didn't want to have when they might have had valid reasons.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
So why not just leave people alone instead of trying to shame them for a vaccination they didn't want to have when they might have had valid reasons. When I comment it is inevitably as a consequence of spurious claims being made. Claims which reveal an underlying selfish attitude and a disregard for any acceptance of a responsibility for the welfare of others. Maybe you don’t think that’s worth calling out. I do. If anyone has a valid reason for not being vaccinated then that’s different but I have not yet read one here.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
When I comment it is inevitably as a consequence of spurious claims being made. Claims which reveal an underlying selfish attitude and a disregard for any acceptance of a responsibility for the welfare of others. Maybe you don’t think that’s worth calling out. I do. If anyone has a valid reason for not being vaccinated then that’s different but I have not yet read one here. If 60% had refused it that might be a point but I don't see how 7 people in every 100 present a threat to the population by not having a vaccine which doesn't affect transmission.
|
|
|
This comic says it better than any shill government experts. Edited by Mattconrov (20 Aug 2023 6.17pm)
" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
If 60% had refused it that might be a point but I don't see how 7 people in every 100 present a threat to the population by not having a vaccine which doesn't affect transmission. This obsession with the fact that transmission remains a possibility whether vaccinated or not, is to entirely miss the point. The primary benefit, and the original expectation, of the vaccines was always to mitigate the severity of any infection. Reducing symptoms should, in turn, indirectly reduce infections, thus gradually introducing herd immunity. Anyone, whatever the % of the population, who could have participated in the effort to beat this disease but refused without a valid reason to do so, deserves to be called out in the hope that they would not do it again should a similar event ever occur again. Selfish behaviour is something that I find intolerable.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
This obsession with the fact that transmission remains a possibility whether vaccinated or not, is to entirely miss the point. The primary benefit, and the original expectation, of the vaccines was always to mitigate the severity of any infection. Reducing symptoms should, in turn, indirectly reduce infections, thus gradually introducing herd immunity. Anyone, whatever the % of the population, who could have participated in the effort to beat this disease but refused without a valid reason to do so, deserves to be called out in the hope that they would not do it again should a similar event ever occur again. Selfish behaviour is something that I find intolerable. Why would it introduce herd immunity any more than catching it?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mattconrov
This comic says it better than any shill government experts. Edited by Mattconrov (20 Aug 2023 6.17pm) Yep, the logic makes no sense. Also, if someone gets vaccinated and then thinks they are protected their social interactions are going to increase significantly exactly because of that belief....hence the transmission rate isn't going to decrease. This is exactly what the statistics showed once the vaccines started. But hey, it isn't about actual reality just whatever fantasy they choose to obsess about.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
This obsession with the fact that transmission remains a possibility whether vaccinated or not, is to entirely miss the point. The primary benefit, and the original expectation, of the vaccines was always to mitigate the severity of any infection. Reducing symptoms should, in turn, indirectly reduce infections, thus gradually introducing herd immunity. Anyone, whatever the % of the population, who could have participated in the effort to beat this disease but refused without a valid reason to do so, deserves to be called out in the hope that they would not do it again should a similar event ever occur again. Selfish behaviour is something that I find intolerable. What, like not having gas appliances serviced?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mattconrov
This comic says it better than any shill government experts. Edited by Mattconrov (20 Aug 2023 6.17pm) The “comic”, apart from not being the least bit funny, is missing the point completely. As it seems so do you and those who rush to agree with you. The issue was never about whether the unvaccinated could infect the vaccinated, or visa versa. That’s quite obviously a ridiculous idea. The issue was about the unvaccinated being likely to demand greater NHS resources, should they become infected, than would have been the case had they been vaccinated. At a time when the NHS was already under strain, with waiting lists growing, any avoidable additional strain imposed unnecessarily by people without good reason was selfish. This wasn’t just a theoretical problem. For a time during the roll out of the vaccines the hospital wards that were devoted to Covid patients were full of overwhelmingly unvaccinated people. That people over relaxed as soon as the vaccination programme started and began to ignore the other measures like social distancing and hand washing is another issue completely. One that no doubt will be addressed by the enquiry. I have no doubt that clearer messaging will be given in any new outbreak. That does not excuse the selfish behaviour of the unvaccinated.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The “comic”, apart from not being the least bit funny, is missing the point completely. As it seems so do you and those who rush to agree with you. The issue was never about whether the unvaccinated could infect the vaccinated, or visa versa. That’s quite obviously a ridiculous idea. The issue was about the unvaccinated being likely to demand greater NHS resources, should they become infected, than would have been the case had they been vaccinated. At a time when the NHS was already under strain, with waiting lists growing, any avoidable additional strain imposed unnecessarily by people without good reason was selfish. This wasn’t just a theoretical problem. For a time during the roll out of the vaccines the hospital wards that were devoted to Covid patients were full of overwhelmingly unvaccinated people. That people over relaxed as soon as the vaccination programme started and began to ignore the other measures like social distancing and hand washing is another issue completely. One that no doubt will be addressed by the enquiry. I have no doubt that clearer messaging will be given in any new outbreak. That does not excuse the selfish behaviour of the unvaccinated. Some of whom will spend their entire working life contributing to paying off the debt incurred by closing the country down to protect the NHS. The selfish so-and-so's.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
I made an informed decision to remain unvaccinated for health reasons. My decision affected absolutely no one else. I don't care if you got vaccinated or did not get vaccinated or even got your 12th Booster at the weekend. I fully support anyone's decision. Indeed, whatever decision an adult takes on their health is their business and this attempt at shaming people is about as ridiculous as it gets. When it comes to shame this guy should evidently look in the mirror.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Why would it introduce herd immunity any more than catching it? It wouldn’t, but that’s again not the point. The purpose of the vaccines was to protect both against infection by the original virus and against severe disease from the anticipated variants. I remember the lady working at Oxford on what became the AstraZeneca vaccine saying that they were confident their vaccine would continue to protect against severe disease when the mutations began to circulate. She was proved correct. Many of us, vaccinated or not, caught the variants and thus gained some immunity as a consequence. However the unvaccinated were more at risk of severe disease and then tying up NHS resources unnecessary. Now we have reached the point where it looks we will adopt a similar strategy to that we use for flu. Whether it’s enough, time alone will tell.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Some of whom will spend their entire working life contributing to paying off the debt incurred by closing the country down to protect the NHS. The selfish so-and-so's. Non sequitur! The whole country will bear the costs involved in trying to mitigate the impact of the pandemic yet some of them refused to participate in the efforts to reduce those costs.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It wouldn’t, but that’s again not the point. The purpose of the vaccines was to protect both against infection by the original virus and against severe disease from the anticipated variants. I remember the lady working at Oxford on what became the AstraZeneca vaccine saying that they were confident their vaccine would continue to protect against severe disease when the mutations began to circulate. She was proved correct. Many of us, vaccinated or not, caught the variants and thus gained some immunity as a consequence. However the unvaccinated were more at risk of severe disease and then tying up NHS resources unnecessary. Now we have reached the point where it looks we will adopt a similar strategy to that we use for flu. Whether it’s enough, time alone will tell. The unvaccinated 7% would have tied up the NHS? How? A lot of them would've caught it before the vaccine was available.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Non sequitur! The whole country will bear the costs involved in trying to mitigate the impact of the pandemic yet some of them refused to participate in the efforts to reduce those costs. Except those most at risk won't bear the cost for the next 50 years when those hundreds of billions could have been spent more beneficially.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
I made an informed decision to remain unvaccinated for health reasons. My decision affected absolutely no one else. I don't care if you got vaccinated or did not get vaccinated or even got your 12th Booster at the weekend. I fully support anyone's decision. As I have said to you countless times you did not make an “informed” decision. You made a disinformed decision. One based on, at best, misinterpretations of the situation. That was your right, but it was still selfish of you to take it and, in my opinion, it should have had greater consequences than it did. Those who did get vaccinated also have rights, no less important than yours. One of those is the right to be informed of who was, and who was not, vaccinated so an informed decision could be made by them on whether they wanted any association with the unvaccinated. Therefore vaccine passports to enter venues should have been introduced, in my opinion. Society as a whole also has a right to expect people to support the efforts of the NHS if they expect it to support them. There should also have been consequences for those who wilfully ignore their duty to provide that support. That you, and the few who think and behave as you do, get upset because this behaviour is being called out is besides the point. It needs to be pointed out. If you feel ashamed as a consequence that’s your responsibility. I somehow doubt those here will, given the degree of irrationality normally seen in their posts. We don’t live in a society in which everyone can take whatever decision they want. We live in a democracy in which decision making is shared for the common interests of us all. One governed by laws, rules and common standards of behaviour. You advocate for anarchism. That’s not what we have. That some of the measures taken in the early days of the pandemic proved to be superfluous is yet another diversionary argument. It’s what happens when you are in unknown territory surrounded by jeopardy on all sides. You tend to reach for both your belt and your braces. That was a response by government. I am talking about individual, personal responsibilities to society.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.