This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It’s not individuals suffering personal side affects that I was referring to. It was the fact that in a capitalist system where profit is the driving force there will always be scope for corruption. No less, of course, in most other systems but we are discussing the USA. The question therefore is whether the benefits outweigh the harms? In the US I'd say that paying to be adversely affected is also a factor. Plus, the whole medical insurance scam. I can't answer the whole question as an individual. There's the greater good, of course - but if that comes at a cost, or harm to others then there's a massive ethical question. The same debate could be had about many things but going into it would be nothing to do with this.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
So you claim that the FDA isn't in bed with the drug companies but wont back that up. Just look at the mass lawsuits against Purdue. The man at the FDA who approved it's use joined Purdue a year later. So I will give you a brief summary. - Oxycontin is simply Heroin in tablet form. - The FDA approved the use of the drug for general use despite warnings from doctors and researchers that it has the same addictive qualities are heroin. - Their application to the FDA contained many lies e.g. only 1% of patients would become addicted (nonsense claim it's heroin for god sakes). - The guy who approved it at the FDA joined the company on a fat salary after they groomed him for months whilst he kept rejecting their application and then he changed his mind. As of today there have been congressional hearings and the company is now controlled by the courts whilst various lawsuits are ongoing. At best the FDA failed completely to investigate the application at worst some of their staff colluded with Purdue and the FDA had no oversight to prevent this. I think 'in bed with' implies no independence whatsoever / acting at their beck and call. Knowing a good deal about this subject (further reading after watching Dopesick) it's not as simple as that, or as comprehensive. It's not just the FDA that is the issue. It's the whole chain – companies like Purdue lying about studies that showed addiction incentivising sales people to aggressively sell the same lie to doctors across the US with the promise of bonuses, incentives, not just for them but also the doctors themselves – effectively bribes... the list was endless. Some held out, others bought the propaganda, some knowingly. In this particular case the FDA was certainly a big part of the problem through mislabelling, allowing the dry to be effectively prescribed for anything, rather than specific cases with adequate addiction warnings. As you state, there is a revolving door between the FDA and pharmas, much like there is in government. Constant lobbying just like in many corporate industries. Self-regulation of prescription advice after approval. All these are obvious issues. All that said, it doesn't mean that absolutely everything to do with Pharma or the FDA is problematic or tainted. The whole thing was nuts, and the US is still suffering now, fentanyl etc – opioids permanently rewire the brain, and not in a good way.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I think 'in bed with' implies no independence whatsoever / acting at their beck and call. Knowing a good deal about this subject (further reading after watching Dopesick) it's not as simple as that, or as comprehensive. It's not just the FDA that is the issue. It's the whole chain – companies like Purdue lying about studies that showed addiction incentivising sales people to aggressively sell the same lie to doctors across the US with the promise of bonuses, incentives, not just for them but also the doctors themselves – effectively bribes... the list was endless. Some held out, others bought the propaganda, some knowingly. In this particular case the FDA was certainly a big part of the problem through mislabelling, allowing the dry to be effectively prescribed for anything, rather than specific cases with adequate addiction warnings. As you state, there is a revolving door between the FDA and pharmas, much like there is in government. Constant lobbying just like in many corporate industries. Self-regulation of prescription advice after approval. All these are obvious issues. All that said, it doesn't mean that absolutely everything to do with Pharma or the FDA is problematic or tainted. The whole thing was nuts, and the US is still suffering now, fentanyl etc – opioids permanently rewire the brain, and not in a good way. I agree with this post. When I said in bed it's short hand as you rightly point out Purdue are the real villains here but that is the job of the FDA to safeguard the public. This drug is an opiate and its origins are over 100 years old. The idea that addiction could not be foreseen is laughable.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I agree with this post. When I said in bed it's short hand as you rightly point out Purdue are the real villains here but that is the job of the FDA to safeguard the public. This drug is an opiate and its origins are over 100 years old. The idea that addiction could not be foreseen is laughable. Fair. Have started watching the Netflix version - a bit more towards the ‘entertainment’ angle but watchable Dopesick goes into a lot more detail and feels a bit less hammy, more authentic and well researched. If you have Disney+ and can stomach a back to back, highly recommend.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Fair. Have started watching the Netflix version - a bit more towards the ‘entertainment’ angle but watchable Dopesick goes into a lot more detail and feels a bit less hammy, more authentic and well researched. If you have Disney+ and can stomach a back to back, highly recommend. Thanks I have watched 4 of the episodes and agree I wanted it to be more serious. I don't have Disney at the moment but will think about it.
One more point |
|
|
[Link] - Ex-medical chief Jonathan Van-Tam takes job with Covid vaccine giant Moderna
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
[Link] - Ex-medical chief Jonathan Van-Tam takes job with Covid vaccine giant Moderna It’s very easy to put a negative spin on things like this but if you step back and away from any inbuilt cynicism and look at things objectively then a different picture can be seen. Those with the specialist knowledge and experience of Professor Van-Dam are in a very small pool with lots of people fishing in it. The fishers will come from Government, Industry or Academia. So it’s hardly surprising to see people holding jobs in all three during their careers. It’s surely beneficial for everyone to have people with a well rounded knowledge and broad experience in positions of responsibility. Van-Dam always struck me as someone who communicates well and has a high sense of integrity. For him to be advising a pharmaceutical producer gives me comfort rather than fears.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It’s very easy to put a negative spin on things like this but if you step back and away from any inbuilt cynicism and look at things objectively then a different picture can be seen. Those with the specialist knowledge and experience of Professor Van-Dam are in a very small pool with lots of people fishing in it. The fishers will come from Government, Industry or Academia. So it’s hardly surprising to see people holding jobs in all three during their careers. It’s surely beneficial for everyone to have people with a well rounded knowledge and broad experience in positions of responsibility. Van-Dam always struck me as someone who communicates well and has a high sense of integrity. For him to be advising a pharmaceutical producer gives me comfort rather than fears. And he is the Muscles from Brussels so can fight his way out if necessary.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It’s very easy to put a negative spin on things like this but if you step back and away from any inbuilt cynicism and look at things objectively then a different picture can be seen. Those with the specialist knowledge and experience of Professor Van-Dam are in a very small pool with lots of people fishing in it. The fishers will come from Government, Industry or Academia. So it’s hardly surprising to see people holding jobs in all three during their careers. It’s surely beneficial for everyone to have people with a well rounded knowledge and broad experience in positions of responsibility. Van-Dam always struck me as someone who communicates well and has a high sense of integrity. For him to be advising a pharmaceutical producer gives me comfort rather than fears. That's one way of looking at it. Of course another way is that Moderna are buying his credibility. Only Nixon can go to China.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Anyone who believes that covid just happened to appear in Wuhan on coincidence where the Chinese have a centre studying highly infectious diseases (which was partly funded with US taxpayer money) but that instead it came from bats or other animals..was brought in locally...or from elsewhere (take your pick)....(with the first victims among those from the centre)...or just about any theory that distances itself from anyone taking actual responsibility who could be named......Mmmmm...yeah. Anyone who seriously believes that when there has never been any firm supporting evidence....is either an idiot or someone who has interests connected to spreading that misinformation or someone who is just a mental weirdo dedicated to negativity trolling. I'll leave it to others to mix and match which could be which. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Aug 2023 7.25pm) There are idiots out there who actually still think that a man eating a bat from a market in Wuhan caused covid. Didint that evil man fauci completely lie that he had nothing to do with the lab in Wuhan? And then it found out months later that he actually did and was caught out?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The “nit-picking” video was made by an eminent and genuine expert in this field. If they were “nits” he found then I would not want to encounter one. It would eat you alive! I am perfectly content for people to make up their own minds on these pieces of what I regard as obvious propaganda designed to support the prejudices of the cynical whilst enriching the maker. My purpose is to also encourage scepticism but this time over the maker’s integrity and motives. I am just very surprised and disappointed that others claim not to recognise this and are continuing to assist with the spreading of disinformation. It’s not responsible behaviour. The “nit-picking” video, for those who missed it can be found here:- There is no census on the origins of the virus, despite the claims to the contrary and the desire of some to suggest it was definitely a leak from the lab. Professor Tucker-Kellogg disagrees and believes that the outbreak originated in live animals but that there is a lot of data we don’t know and that the Chinese authorities are being untruthful about what happened at the market. I doubt we will ever really know. On the balance of probability though. If there was an outbreak of chocolate poisoning in Bournville is it more likely to have come from the local pet shop or, you know, the chocolate factory?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
On the balance of probability though. If there was an outbreak of chocolate poisoning in Bournville is it more likely to have come from the local pet shop or, you know, the chocolate factory? I don’t think anyone is suggesting that a link between the lab being there and the outbreak starting there is likely to be unrelated. On the balance of probability it seems overwhelmingly likely. That thought is not the issue. The issue is what is the relationship. There are those who believe that some experimental work on manufactured viruses went wrong, infected workers and got spread. People like Gregg Tucker-Kellogg disagree and believe the virus originated from a live animal. What the lab was doing with live animals isn’t known but the limited data sets he has seen leads him to that hypothesis rather than the other.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Here are a couple of links that Gregg Tucker-Kellogg has reposted on his Tweeter feed.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don’t think anyone is suggesting that a link between the lab being there and the outbreak starting there is likely to be unrelated. On the balance of probability it seems overwhelmingly likely. That thought is not the issue. The issue is what is the relationship. There are those who believe that some experimental work on manufactured viruses went wrong, infected workers and got spread. People like Gregg Tucker-Kellogg disagree and believe the virus originated from a live animal. What the lab was doing with live animals isn’t known but the limited data sets he has seen leads him to that hypothesis rather than the other. So what did this mean? "the desire of some to suggest it was definitely a leak from the lab"? It either came from the lab or it didn't.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.