You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 97 of 122 < 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Sep 18 4.59pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I agree with a lot of what’s been said. Self entitled, having a Cheek (I wish we had him), all about them etc.

They could’ve just waited for the main stand to go up when there’s more options for fans behind the goal to move elsewhere so where the safe standing is going the HF can stand. But no, their immaturity takes over. But then I start thinking maybe they’re going elsewhere in the ground or indeed nowhere in the ground for a season or 2 so that if the atmosphere is pretty low Parish and others will be desperate to see them back.

I’ll miss some of what they bring but I won’t miss the drum or the constant singing and jumping up and down from 20 lads to a song nobody else knows, and that would either go on for the first 20 minutes or when the game is looking lost. There’s enough people and enough song starters like how we used to do it to create an atmosphere without them so I doubt they’ll be that missed and they should really get over themselves.

But this is young people today. Very thin skinned, sensitive and believe their lives are followed closely by the outside world when really people mainly don’t care. Or do all young people closely care what the 700 people they follow are doing?

No more drum. Fvcking get in!!!!!

The above was your first post on this thread in July. You seem to have changed your view considerably since then

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 23 Sep 18 5.12pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The above was your first post on this thread in July. You seem to have changed your view considerably since then

Wow, has someone hijacked his account? To say he's changed his tune is an understatement. ..

 

est1905 Flag 23 Sep 18 5.51pm

Originally posted by Eagleshavelanded

I was in the Legends Lounge yesterday talking with Neil Shipperley. He is adamant the team needs the support and noise created by the HF referring back to times where support of the crowd makes a difference.

More importantly he muted something might be on the horizon.

From what I have seen over the season so far we the crowd have a responsibilty to our team to help them as we have demonstrated over many season prior.

Noise = Energy = Improved Performance.

This is again an opion dressed up as a fact. In truth I dont agree with Neil Shipperley. Is that allowed? What with him being famous and an ex player and me just a fan?
Probably not in some peoples eyes on here

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Sep 18 7.11pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The above was your first post on this thread in July. You seem to have changed your view considerably since then

Is changing your mind not allowed in this alter cyber world? Or does everyone have to as stubborn as possible on this?

I changed my mind on

1) the atmosphere after witnessing Liverpool and Southampton (Newcastle has been just as bad. Worse if you consider we didn’t concede and it was a game a bit of extra support could’ve made a difference except at corners) And the missing of the HF and the rest making up for it. Away games are now apparently sinking too.

2) The HF’s approach to the whole saga when it finally came out how badly it was handled by the club and the communication the HF thought was coming with all fans of Palace fans didn’t happen. We then get their literature which wasn’t given a chance either.

This isn’t North v South. I changed my mind? So what? Some maybe should too, or will when it happens, which is the rumour and of course what Parish actually wants if it came with nobody being put out. He may do that anyway.

 


COYP

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 23 Sep 18 7.39pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Is changing your mind not allowed in this alter cyber world? Or does everyone have to as stubborn as possible on this?

I changed my mind on

1) the atmosphere after witnessing Liverpool and Southampton (Newcastle has been just as bad. Worse if you consider we didn’t concede and it was a game a bit of extra support could’ve made a difference except at corners) And the missing of the HF and the rest making up for it. Away games are now apparently sinking too.

2) The HF’s approach to the whole saga when it finally came out how badly it was handled by the club and the communication the HF thought was coming with all fans of Palace fans didn’t happen. We then get their literature which wasn’t given a chance either.

This isn’t North v South. I changed my mind? So what? Some maybe should too, or will when it happens, which is the rumour and of course what Parish actually wants if it came with nobody being put out. He may do that anyway.

Good on you Rudi.

Well done for changing your mind and seeing the harsh reality of the lack of HF.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 23 Sep 18 7.54pm

Originally posted by BarEagle

Good on you Rudi.

Well done for changing your mind and seeing the harsh reality of the lack of HF.

What harsh reality???? Last season with the HF at this stage P6 L6 NO Goals and N0 points and rock bottom of the table. This season without the HF P6 W2 D1 four goals and seven points and 11th in the table.

Get some perspective for goodness sake.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 23 Sep 18 7.59pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

What harsh reality???? Last season with the HF at this stage P6 L6 NO Goals and N0 points and rock bottom of the table. This season without the HF P6 W2 D1 four goals and seven points and 11th in the table.

Get some perspective for goodness sake.

PZ, thanks for the humour. and facts. or FACTS
made me smile

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Sep 18 8.02pm

Dare I suggest that if support does make such a difference, why has our home form been poor for many seasons?
I like a noisy ground because it's good for the image and makes the players feel wanted, but changing results?
I'm not sure our atmosphere has ever been good enough for that. It ain't the Nou Camp.

 

AERO Flag 23 Sep 18 8.17pm

No ,But keeps the positivity ,rather than like playing in a morgue

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 23 Sep 18 9.45pm

Originally posted by AERO

No ,But keeps the positivity ,rather than like playing in a morgue

This. That dreadful game we saw on Saturday would've been a lot more interesting had people in Block C around me actually bother to try and make noise (yes I did try).

@Rudi: Away games have still been solid wherever I've been stood tbf (went Watford and Hudders).

Edited by Dan1994 (23 Sep 2018 9.59pm)

 


[Link]

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 23 Sep 18 10.11pm

What if everyone on Holmesdale online made a pledge that at a pre-arranged time they would all stand up - wherever they are - and get a chant going?

If everyone had the confidence that they wouldn't be doing it alone, that would be encouraging.

for example, the first time Palace win a corner, everyone from this forum (I'm not sure how many people that is) should leap out their seat - no mater where they sit in the ground - and chant: "oooh, it's a corner."

Edited by OhthisbloodyPC (23 Sep 2018 10.12pm)

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 24 Sep 18 11.30am

Atmosphere on Saturday reminded me of the dire days in the late 90's and early 00's. My wife who comes once every couple of years when my mate can't make it asked me what had happened to all the noise (the part she likes the best).

The team showed a distinct lack of urgency in the second half too and these things must be related - i'd come to think that we didn't only sing when the team was playing well so the onus must be on us.

Whatever happened with the HF it has left everyone worse off. As someone mentioned above it doesn't necessarily guarantee points but it helps with our identity and the players see it as a positive.

This needs to be addressed. Our club identity needs it and we need every advantage we can get. For the first time in years I'd say that we were outsung by the away fans.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 24 Sep 18 11.39am

Originally posted by zico murphy

Due to holidays today was my first visit to Selhurst post HF. Although at times the atmosphere was quite good it never sustained and large parts of the game was very quiet. The overall affect is the atmosphere is not as good and I just don’t see an upside to that. In my opinion the HF were very good for the club and I just can’t get my head round why some people don’t agree with that. I don’t know how this situation gets sorted but I really hope it can be.

^^^this.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 24 Sep 18 11.42am

Originally posted by becky

Since there hasn't been time for a 'consultation' if this is true, then the bullies win


As i posted before on this thread..at the end of the season the club can do what they like with the seating arrangements...what consultation needs to be had if the club want it to happen?

None of us have ANY right to our seats other than for the period we've paid for them.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 24 Sep 18 11.49am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

So why didn't they get round a table instead of flouncing like spoilt children. They could easily have
stayed where they were and tried to sort it out for next season.

Simples.

Agree with this. They miscalculated, which is good as they'll think twice about doing it again. Clearly based on the rumour mill they've now done just that (sit round the table) and come to a compromise..

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

michaelpearce Flag grays 24 Sep 18 12.09pm

this post as go round in circles again and again,

yes the work the HF done was great ,why couldnt they have carried on,then getting all the supporters on there side,showing they have pride in support for the team,but they lost all credibility by going on strike,

as a long time fan its so sad that they cant see whats going on between fans ,unless thats what they want,

they need to start showing they support the team,not there egos,

as anyone actually canvased E block,the HF could have done that before making a suggestion of moving, its not down to the club, it was the HF who made the bid on moving, so if they done the ground work first they may have know that a move, may not happen due to upsetting to many supporters in that block,

you cant start treating them as a special case,means we cant start putting them on a pedestal,that can only divide support which is what it is doing,
this is not what this club stands for, as long as i have supported the club never had this issue.

ONE TEAM ONE CLUB

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 24 Sep 18 2.19pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

this post as go round in circles again and again,

yes the work the HF done was great ,why couldnt they have carried on,then getting all the supporters on there side,showing they have pride in support for the team,but they lost all credibility by going on strike,

as a long time fan its so sad that they cant see whats going on between fans ,unless thats what they want,

they need to start showing they support the team,not there egos,

as anyone actually canvased E block,the HF could have done that before making a suggestion of moving, its not down to the club, it was the HF who made the bid on moving, so if they done the ground work first they may have know that a move, may not happen due to upsetting to many supporters in that block,

you cant start treating them as a special case,means we cant start putting them on a pedestal,that can only divide support which is what it is doing,
this is not what this club stands for, as long as i have supported the club never had this issue.

ONE TEAM ONE CLUB

I keep coming on this thread to see if anything new has been added and not just going round in circles.

Have to say this us one of the more sensible posts and I agree 100%.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 24 Sep 18 2.45pm

Was chatting to my dad last night, a longtime season ticket holder in block H of the Holmesdale. He had no idea about any of this drama with the HF flouncing, and didn't think many people sat around him did either, certainly it had never come up in any Palace-related chat. Made me realise there's probably a whole section of fans that are blissfully unaware of this whole pathetic situation and in the grand scheme of things it doesn't matter a much as a lot of people think.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (24 Sep 2018 2.46pm)

 

becky Flag over the moon 24 Sep 18 2.51pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


As i posted before on this thread..at the end of the season the club can do what they like with the seating arrangements...what consultation needs to be had if the club want it to happen?

None of us have ANY right to our seats other than for the period we've paid for them.

By the same token, none of them have any right to someone else's seat either - especially those who PREFER to watch from behind the goal

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

roman eagle Flag South London 24 Sep 18 3.03pm

I sit in Block L in the Upper Holmesdale - above where the HF usually stand. Everyone I've spoken to sitting nearby miss the noise and passion of the HF and want them back asap. Without them the atmosphere is flat and now it's more that the players are rousing the crowd rather than the other way around.

I've supported Palace since 1976 and been a season ticket holder for most of that time. The atmosphere in the ground since the HF came on the scene has never been better in my opinion. I really hope this issue can be resolved asap.

It's not only fans who miss this vibrant atmosphere - read Garth Crooks' blog on the BBC website today [Link] - scroll right down to the end. Btw - we haven't scored a goal at home since the HF disappeared - maybe the players are affected more than we might think - Wayne Hennessy remarked about this in an interview on the CPFC website.

 


Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC)

Page 97 of 122 < 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread