You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 1.45pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 98 of 166 < 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 09 Apr 19 10.32am

Unfortunately we'll have to take the financial hit. No one is going to be daft enough to take a striker who has only scored a couple in two seasons.
It would be sensible to plan afresh for next season with Benteke on the fringes until his contract expires, unless some miracle happens whereby he shows some aptitude and interest. Not seen it so far this season though.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 09 Apr 19 2.42pm


i have two answers to those who say 'give Benteke more time, he will come good'

- we did
- he wont

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Apr 19 2.58pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Benteke's problem with Liverpool was the change of manager as Klopp doesn't play to Benteke's strengths so he became surplus to requirements.

I wonder how he would play if he played alongside Batshuayi

I agree with the assertion that Klopp doesn't play to Benteke's strengths and that is why he became surplus to requirements at Liverpool.

We haven't been playing to Batshuayi's strengths so it might be useful for him to feed off Benteke up front. Burnley have been playing Wood and Barnes up front, hitting them with long balls and they have proved effective in recent games and possibly even before that.Might work with Benteke and Batshuayi as a strike force.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 11 Apr 19 11.13am

Originally posted by Willo

I agree with the assertion that Klopp doesn't play to Benteke's strengths and that is why he became surplus to requirements at Liverpool.

We haven't been playing to Batshuayi's strengths so it might be useful for him to feed off Benteke up front. Burnley have been playing Wood and Barnes up front, hitting them with long balls and they have proved effective in recent games and possibly even before that.Might work with Benteke and Batshuayi as a strike force.

I think a 4-4-2 with Tekkers and Bats could work against lesser opposition, but against Man City, Arsenal and probably even Everton we would lose the midfield and probably be overrun, unless Wilf were willing to take on more responsibility defensively.

I noticed today that following Luka's penalty he has now overtaken Christian both in terms of goals scored and goals per game. Interestingly (or not) I also noticed that Dann's scoring record is as good as Townsend's. It's easy to forget what a threat he used to be. Hopefully one day we'll sign a player who can score regularly from open play, but until then let's be glad we have man from Serbia

 

Fatherken Flag 15 Apr 19 3.07pm

I have just read Jamesey's views on the game I think he really hates Benteke as in my view his work rate was more in the Man City game than Batshuayi in all the time he has played for us .

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 16 Apr 19 12.56pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

I have just read Jamesey's views on the game I think he really hates Benteke as in my view his work rate was more in the Man City game than Batshuayi in all the time he has played for us .

I listened to the game on radio london and they only praised him, good work by benteke, nice touch benteke, good defencive header from corner , a goal would have been great but shows he was doing his bit in other areas!

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 16 Apr 19 2.06pm

Win , but usually Direct them to opposition. Every game his back passing ends up With non-Palace player - in short, cut the losses and let go!!!

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 16 Apr 19 2.10pm

Benteke did well last time out but don’t expect goals just now.

End of the day he needs to play to get into some kind of form to be remotely useful to us or worth any money on the market.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Apr 19 2.21pm

Our main problem seems to stem from committing players to attack when we do have the ball. We have no clear attacking shape.
Are our full backs attacking? They seem to get forward all the time and get caught out - particularly PVA. However, surely our wingers should be the ones providing attacking width. Yet they are not on the wings bombing forward when we have the ball. They are often tracking back and not backing up the attack. This would be addressed by making our back four a straight flat back four. Our full backs would attack less and our wingers would be in attack when we win the ball. In this way Benteke could be in the box ready for a cross.
The same problem arises in our center midfield. Surely one of our centre midfielders should have an attacking role? One of them should always be ready to get forward at every opportunity. Yet, who is this? None of our midfielders seem to provide this - it looks like Jimmy Mac is trying to do this but is also being asked to defend. Surely two CMs can provide adequate defensive cover - which ours seem to be pretty good at? I guess one solution is to use either Meyer or Kouyate as attacking midfielders. I reckon MacArthur is more of a holding midfielder and seems to tire in games these days.
Another possibility is putting Shlupp or Sako as attacking midfielder and Jimmy Mac and Milo as holding midfielders.
Playing like this we would have 6 outfield players essentially performing the defensive duties and 4 players really getting forward and staying forward. I believe this would help Benteke and our home form considerably.

 


Red and Blue Army!

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 16 Apr 19 7.50pm

I was at the game Benteke did alright but was frightfull when in possesion inour own half, often giving the ball to city in the form of a backpass that inevitably set them up for a dangerous attack.

COYP

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 16 Apr 19 8.04pm

I posted a while ago that through roys system benteke will never score what he is capable of.
The wingers dont put the ball in fast enough.
CB is on the edge of the last defender when we are going forward but the ball doesnt come in.
It could be delivered from the by line or 30 yards out.
This is his strength as he will find the ball.
Roys cautious approach has kicked CBs ability to bits.
Form is temporary and class is permanent.
When he goes and is played properly we will see that.

 

AERO Flag 16 Apr 19 8.18pm

Anyone who has played at a decent level or has any kind of football brain can see Benteke is out of his depth.He might have been half decent once but for whatever reason he is done .We got turned over by Liverpool. There is no off the ball movement ,as we saw Sunday some straightforward touches go amiss. He can’t even close down the opposing defenders well .And some might say it was one of his best games recently. Well for 30 Mil great . Get rid in summer ,cut our losses.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 16 Apr 19 8.22pm

He was totally isolated on Sunday and won much in the air but there was zero players within 20 yards of him. He did well in the air from Citeh corners etc. but he isn't going to score from there. I would like to see us set up deliberately around him in a few games this season to give him a chance to see what he may be able to do. However as others have stated I cannot see how he can work with any other attacking player in the team at the moment.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Den1923 Flag 16 Apr 19 10.48pm

Originally posted by AERO

Anyone who has played at a decent level or has any kind of football brain can see Benteke is out of his depth.He might have been half decent once but for whatever reason he is done .We got turned over by Liverpool. There is no off the ball movement ,as we saw Sunday some straightforward touches go amiss. He can’t even close down the opposing defenders well .And some might say it was one of his best games recently. Well for 30 Mil great . Get rid in summer ,cut our losses.

Correct, Klopp put one over on Parish who is clearly out of his depth and competence level in PL!

 

sprites Flag Auckland 17 Apr 19 12.02am

Originally posted by AERO

Anyone who has played at a decent level or has any kind of football brain can see Benteke is out of his depth.He might have been half decent once but for whatever reason he is done .We got turned over by Liverpool. There is no off the ball movement ,as we saw Sunday some straightforward touches go amiss. He can’t even close down the opposing defenders well .And some might say it was one of his best games recently. Well for 30 Mil great . Get rid in summer ,cut our losses.

Haha. Always love it when people make statements like that. I've played at a decent level, am currently in the middle of coaching courses (so you'd hope my football brain's on point) and I disagree with you.

He's not out of his depth. If that 'depth' is PL level, he's shown both with Villa and us that he's absolutely in his depth.....the issue is our system doesn't suit him. Agree we need to either tweak things to get balls in the box quicker and play to his strengths, or he needs to move on.

That's quite different to being out of your depth though.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 17 Apr 19 7.13am

How can anyone still defend Our main striker after top the missing chances chart in PL?
3 goals in 2 Seasons, something like that for Tekkers. Not to compare, but when Messi netted two vs United yesteray - it was his 45th goal in 42 games this season!!!!

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Apr 19 7.57am

Benteke is over. The only reason he is at Palace now is money.
This summer we so badly need to buy a decent striker. Not another cart horse like Sorloth.
Just get shot of Benti. Cut our losses. He’s worse than ever. Just move him on.
His one asset is he can jump high. He is not fast anymore. He can’t run with the ball. He is really lazy. He is so weak. He never tackles. He never tracks back. He is not ever aggressive. His very occasional shot is embarrassing. In fact the whole saga is totally embarrassing.
Please get shot and move on.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Apr 19 8.04am

Despite us supposedly "not playing to his strengths" he has had numerous chances to score and has contrived to miss the vast majority of them.
His first touch is dreadful, his anticipation is virtually non-existent, and his movement... he might as well have pockets sown into his shorts.

 

xomnea Flag 17 Apr 19 9.29am

Just wondering if anyone who chastised me for calling out his lack of basic footballing ability in December 2016 has had a re think?

[Link]

 

EddieMac Flag 17 Apr 19 11.07am

If we were a team who crossed the ball then Benteke would maybe score a few goals with his nut. I always pray that he will score when he plays but I have now resigned myself to the fact that he is finished as a player for us.
I reckon he will play the majority of games now till end of the season to try get him in the shop window and move him on.
Bats wont be here next year (not that I want him to be).
He is a bang average football player with no football brain.
There has got to be a decent striker out there who can do a job for us.

 

Page 98 of 166 < 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread