You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Brook vs golovkin
November 22 2026 12.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Brook vs golovkin


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
rikz Flag Croydon 07 Sep 16 9.55pm

Looking forward to this fight, I'm a massive fan of brook but he stands next to no chance, not only is golovkin a monster, naturally bigger and stronger, forget what brook has said this week, I've yet to hear a boxer move up in weight who dosnt feel stronger untill they lose and it was one step too far, massive difference between fighting weight and walking around. Also a lot of people look past the fact that golovkin has far superior technical ability than his given credit for even so I will be cheering brook on and hoping he can pull off a massive upset. I will stupidity stick on a brook/smith double, only as it's about 50/1.

But it looks as tho the wool is getting pulled over the boxing fans eyes again. Brook has pretty much confirmed this week he won't be moving back down to light welter, "too hard to make the weight" name me a boxer that dosnt struggle, just so happens as spence Jr who is probably the best prospect out there is now his mandatory. Also means we won't get a massive unification fight against thurman/garcia even Bradley/khan would sell well and be a risk. Expect to see brook go to light middle/super welter with the easier option on paper of lara/the charlo twins, a British fight vs smith or an ageing and well past his peak cotto.

I'm getting fed up of every boxer pretty much doing all they can to avoid the best in their division. There's probably more fights at a catch weight these days than unification fights.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 07 Sep 16 10.15pm

Agree I think brook loses but then says that triple G was too big. Same as Khan v Canelo. He knows if he loses he goes back down 2 weights.
In reality GGG v Canelo and brook V Khan should have been the fights.
Hope I'm wrong but I can't see Brook winning , a natural heavy handed middle weight is too strong for a pumped up welterweight.
Hope brook wins , but I think when Golovkin lands flush, game over.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Sep 16 10.22pm

Originally posted by rikz

I'm getting fed up of every boxer pretty much doing all they can to avoid the best in their division. There's probably more fights at a catch weight these days than unification fights.

Get used to it pal and less people watching it for more profit and purse as well.

 


COYP

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 07 Sep 16 11.25pm

Originally posted by rikz

Looking forward to this fight, I'm a massive fan of brook but he stands next to no chance, not only is golovkin a monster, naturally bigger and stronger, forget what brook has said this week, I've yet to hear a boxer move up in weight who dosnt feel stronger untill they lose and it was one step too far, massive difference between fighting weight and walking around. Also a lot of people look past the fact that golovkin has far superior technical ability than his given credit for even so I will be cheering brook on and hoping he can pull off a massive upset. I will stupidity stick on a brook/smith double, only as it's about 50/1.

But it looks as tho the wool is getting pulled over the boxing fans eyes again. Brook has pretty much confirmed this week he won't be moving back down to light welter, "too hard to make the weight" name me a boxer that dosnt struggle, just so happens as spence Jr who is probably the best prospect out there is now his mandatory. Also means we won't get a massive unification fight against thurman/garcia even Bradley/khan would sell well and be a risk. Expect to see brook go to light middle/super welter with the easier option on paper of lara/the charlo twins, a British fight vs smith or an ageing and well past his peak cotto.

I'm getting fed up of every boxer pretty much doing all they can to avoid the best in their division. There's probably more fights at a catch weight these days than unification fights.


I slightly disagree, whilst like everyone else I also believe GGG will win, I dont think you can say that Brook has almost no chance.

Brook (like GGG) is undefeated, a world champion, is 4 years his junior and is also the home fighter.

Personally I think if Brook uses his skill and fights at range then this could be interesting.

Having said all that, I would still put my house on a GGG win.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 08 Sep 16 8.02am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


I slightly disagree, whilst like everyone else I also believe GGG will win, I dont think you can say that Brook has almost no chance.

Brook (like GGG) is undefeated, a world champion, is 4 years his junior and is also the home fighter.

Personally I think if Brook uses his skill and fights at range then this could be interesting.

Having said all that, I would still put my house on a GGG win.


Agreed. Golovkin the worthy favourite but I don't believe that he's as nailed on as everyone seems to think. It will require a career best performance from Brook but he is in with a shout.

Usually always cheer on the British fighter and I like Brook (despite him having Keith Lemon's voice) but wouldn't be too devastated if GGG wins as am a big fan, he is magnificent. Can't wait anyway.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 08 Sep 16 11.31am

Triple GGG's movement will be too much for Brook alas...GGG in 5

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 08 Sep 16 1.54pm

Brook on points. Heard it here first.

Not really. Hope so though.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 09 Sep 16 10.34am

I am awaiting dannyh contribution to this thread, would like it to be a good fight but experts seem to think brook has little chance, brook just announced on ssn that he will shock the world, we'll see.

 

Jimbo Flag South Shields tyne & wear 09 Sep 16 1.00pm

Boxing one punch and that's all it takes can be miles behind on points , The was a guy in 80's Don Curry best pound for pound fighter got smashed by Lloyd Hunnigan I think was his name curry never fought again , Kell has never been beaten

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Sep 16 3.48pm

The fact that anyone thinks Brook could win this fight is a testament to the gullibility of sports fans.
Sky and the promoters have done a good of selling the fight.
Let's remember that Brook only took this fight because they couldn't get anyone in the right weight divison to take on the task. Golovkin is a freak of nature and people in the fight game know that. Brook is on a win win. He gets loads of money, exposure and kudos for bravery and when he loses, no one will hold it against him.
If he were to win it would be among the most astonishing victories of all time. Unless Golovkin contracts flu in the next 24 hours, it's not going to happen.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Sep 16 4.13pm

Golovkin with a mid-late round KO for me.

 


Optimistic as ever

SurreyEagle16 Flag Next Door 09 Sep 16 5.08pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The fact that anyone thinks Brook could win this fight is a testament to the gullibility of sports fans
.
Sky and the promoters have done a good of selling the fight.
Let's remember that Brook only took this fight because they couldn't get anyone in the right weight divison to take on the task. Golovkin is a freak of nature and people in the fight game know that. Brook is on a win win. He gets loads of money, exposure and kudos for bravery and when he loses, no one will hold it against him.
If he were to win it would be among the most astonishing victories of all time. Unless Golovkin contracts flu in the next 24 hours, it's not going to happen.

The fact that some think Golovkin is unbeatable is testament to the gullibility of sports fans. Every great fighter looks unbeatable right up to the point that they get beaten.

For the record, I think Brook is long odds to win this fight. But the image of Golovkin as an unbeatable monster is every bit as much a product of promotional spin as Brook's chances in this fight.

Golovkin's record is impressive, no doubt. But a huge proportion of his wins (as brooks) have come against fighters below elite level. The best name on his record is arguably David Lemieux...you wont find many casual boxing fans who have even heard of him.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 09 Sep 16 5.25pm

Originally posted by SurreyEagle16

The fact that some think Golovkin is unbeatable is testament to the gullibility of sports fans. Every great fighter looks unbeatable right up to the point that they get beaten.

For the record, I think Brook is long odds to win this fight. But the image of Golovkin as an unbeatable monster is every bit as much a product of promotional spin as Brook's chances in this fight.

Golovkin's record is impressive, no doubt. But a huge proportion of his wins (as brooks) have come against fighters below elite level. The best name on his record is arguably David Lemieux...you wont find many casual boxing fans who have even heard of him.

Who he completely dominated with a jab, also take into his account his amateur record which is over 350 wins with 5 loses and numerous amateur titles even if they was the same weight he would be odds on favourite. No one's unbeatable but it's still another case of another massive fight with the odds already being hugely stacked against one fighter. I can appreciate it from a buisness point of view but as a competitive sport it's a bit of a joke.

 

SurreyEagle16 Flag Next Door 09 Sep 16 7.17pm

I don't think the fight is a joke at all.

As I said, I do think Golovkin will win. And I make you right for mentioning his boxing skills as evidenced by a glowing amateur CV.

But I don't think he is as good as his professional record suggests. Or at least I think it is hard to justify his reputation given the opposition he has proven it against.
Also, Brook does lose a lot of weight to make light welter. The height/reach/physique is not a factor in the fight. Brook has looked every bit as dominant in his fights, despite not having the knockout power Golovkin has and at a lower weight.
He has proven a lot of his credentials (chin against Carson Jones, bollox against Shawn Porter, Power against Frankie Gavin)...certainly to a degree that makes me confident he will at least be competitive.

Martin Murray who, whilst I respect hugely as a fighter, is not as good as Brook in any department and he extended Golovkin to 11 rounds.

So yes...I think Golovkin will win...but not by the walkover that most on here think.

Edited by SurreyEagle16 (09 Sep 2016 7.20pm)

 

rikz Flag Croydon 09 Sep 16 8.01pm

Originally posted by SurreyEagle16

I don't think the fight is a joke at all.

As I said, I do think Golovkin will win. And I make you right for mentioning his boxing skills as evidenced by a glowing amateur CV.

But I don't think he is as good as his professional record suggests. Or at least I think it is hard to justify his reputation given the opposition he has proven it against.
Also, Brook does lose a lot of weight to make light welter. The height/reach/physique is not a factor in the fight. Brook has looked every bit as dominant in his fights, despite not having the knockout power Golovkin has and at a lower weight.
He has proven a lot of his credentials (chin against Carson Jones, bollox against Shawn Porter, Power against Frankie Gavin)...certainly to a degree that makes me confident he will at least be competitive.

Martin Murray who, whilst I respect hugely as a fighter, is not as good as Brook in any department and he extended Golovkin to 11 rounds.

So yes...I think Golovkin will win...but not by the walkover that most on here think.

Edited by SurreyEagle16 (09 Sep 2016 7.20pm)

Don't get me wrong I like brook and rate him but come on, we all know there's a difference between fighting weight and the weight you walk around at. Unless your a heavyweight every boxer will cut to get as much of an advantage as possible. Brook might walk around 12lbs heavier but he was on behind the ropes complaining about how hard it is to eat 8-9 meals a day, that dosnt look to me like he can make middleweight naturally. I really hope brook can cause an upset but he is at a massive disadvantaged. It's a good payday for him and matchroom and a cherry pick for golovkin.

 

SurreyEagle16 Flag Next Door 09 Sep 16 8.34pm

That's true...but some boxers don't get better cutting weight. Bellew was a prime example. Bellew was killing himself to make light heavy and struggled twice against Chilemba, lost to Cleverley wide and got annihilated by Stevenson.

Up a weight division he is a different animal and knocked out someone who most though would beat him easily.

And Khan didn't lose to Alvarez because of weight. He was outboxing him before getting hit by one big shot...the same as he had against Willie Limmond years earlier. He was strong and fast at the weight and had to gain a lot more than Brook has.

Bernard Hopkins...middleweight to light heavy
Roy Jones...middle to heavy
so many more

Elite boxers have climbed through weight divisions for decades. Putting weight on with the amount of science they have behind them is nothing new and has seen plenty of success in the past.

If brook loses I don't think it will be because of weight...it will be because Golovkin can fight.


 

Casual Flag Orpington 09 Sep 16 8.37pm

Originally posted by SurreyEagle16

I don't think the fight is a joke at all.

As I said, I do think Golovkin will win. And I make you right for mentioning his boxing skills as evidenced by a glowing amateur CV.

But I don't think he is as good as his professional record suggests. Or at least I think it is hard to justify his reputation given the opposition he has proven it against.
Also, Brook does lose a lot of weight to make light welter. The height/reach/physique is not a factor in the fight. Brook has looked every bit as dominant in his fights, despite not having the knockout power Golovkin has and at a lower weight.
He has proven a lot of his credentials (chin against Carson Jones, bollox against Shawn Porter, Power against Frankie Gavin)...certainly to a degree that makes me confident he will at least be competitive.

Martin Murray who, whilst I respect hugely as a fighter, is not as good as Brook in any department and he extended Golovkin to 11 rounds.

So yes...I think Golovkin will win...but not by the walkover that most on here think.

Edited by SurreyEagle16 (09 Sep 2016 7.20pm)

Murray never extended him at all, he dominated him without coming out of 2nd gear.
Macklin said that when he felt GGGs jab, he couldn't live with them for long, a f**king jab!?
I've heard a few people that have fought him say that Glovkin makes a big ring feel tiny, by cutting the ring off. Long 36 minutes for Brook I think, hoping he makes the last bell.
He's got some b**locks though and is a very good welterweight.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 09 Sep 16 8.39pm

Originally posted by SurreyEagle16

That's true...but some boxers don't get better cutting weight. Bellew was a prime example. Bellew was killing himself to make light heavy and struggled twice against Chilemba, lost to Cleverley wide and got annihilated by Stevenson.

Up a weight division he is a different animal and knocked out someone who most though would beat him easily.

And Khan didn't lose to Alvarez because of weight. He was outboxing him before getting hit by one big shot...the same as he had against Willie Limmond years earlier. He was strong and fast at the weight and had to gain a lot more than Brook has.

Bernard Hopkins...middleweight to light heavy
Roy Jones...middle to heavy
so many more

Elite boxers have climbed through weight divisions for decades. Putting weight on with the amount of science they have behind them is nothing new and has seen plenty of success in the past.

If brook loses I don't think it will be because of weight...it will be because Golovkin can fight.


Good post , but I think Stevenson would smash Bellew even if scouse Tone was 18 stone

 

SurreyEagle16 Flag Next Door 09 Sep 16 8.42pm

Originally posted by Casual

Good post , but I think Stevenson would smash Bellew even if scouse Tone was 18 stone

Any man hard enough to enter the ring to the superman tune wearing a cape must be hard! :-)

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 10 Sep 16 8.29pm

Originally posted by SurreyEagle16

Any man hard enough to enter the ring to the superman tune wearing a cape must be hard! :-)

Any decent streams?

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Brook vs golovkin