You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Gareth Thomas Documentary – Alfie v Homophobia – T
November 16 2026 8.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gareth Thomas Documentary – Alfie v Homophobia – T


Page 1 of 25 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
lanepe1 Flag Portslade 27 Jul 17 11.24pm

Dear all,

I have just seen the documentary made by Gareth Thomas, it was on BBC Wales tonight, and will be on the 6th of August 2017 on BBC TWO

Can I please urge all Crystal Palace fans to watch this.

As a gay man, I am proud to support Crystal Palace, but on the programme this site was shown and at least 5 abusive messages. The language and content was disgusting and must be removed

Can the mods please ensure that all abusive messages on this site are deleted and that these members are banned.

This forum needs to demonstrate this is not tolerated.

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 27 Jul 17 11.35pm

The thred was embarrassing and people need to realise that although this site is not officially linked to the club it reflects upon it.
I don't think those numpties are homophobic I think they just need to grow up.
I didn't agree with what GT was doing on here as I knew it would draw out the less desirable element and reflect poorly on us as a whole which I believe to be unfair.
I do agree that anyone spouting homophobic abuse should be banned.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 27 Jul 17 11.37pm

Will watch the documentary when it's available on iPlayer. Do hope it doesn't paint HOL as a homophobic site by claiming that the responses of people like Parchmore are reflective of the general opinion.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 28 Jul 17 12.02am

Originally posted by lanepe1

Dear all,

I have just seen the documentary made by Gareth Thomas, it was on BBC Wales tonight, and will be on the 6th of August 2017 on BBC TWO

Can I please urge all Crystal Palace fans to watch this.

As a gay man, I am proud to support Crystal Palace, but on the programme this site was shown and at least 5 abusive messages. The language and content was disgusting and must be removed

Can the mods please ensure that all abusive messages on this site are deleted and that these members are banned.

This forum needs to demonstrate this is not tolerated.

You should read the whole thread mate. A few people were on a bit of a wind up but most were uncomfortable with that. It doesn't matter what the truth is, I.e. We are a highly welcoming club where most people of any nature should feel at home. There was an agenda from Mr Thomas from the off and he persevered (and persevered) until he got the quotes he wanted.

Or I could be wrong. As a gay bloke do you ever feel picked on or disapproved of at Palace or on this site? If you do then I shall feel ashamed for my community.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 28 Jul 17 12.35am

Okay, have now watched the relevant part of the documentary. I was correct that Parchmore was one of the fools quoted, surprise surprise.

I was intrigued to see Gareth quote one of my responses as an example of an opinion which causes him to put his head in his hands - a state of despair which could perhaps have been avoided if he'd read the whole message, or even the whole sentence. Here is what I wrote:

'I don't think many people who join in the 'Brighton take it up the bum' chants have any real malicious intent, and are being knowingly juvenile for a laugh. But the chants do effectively put all homosexuals on the wrong side of the 'us vs them' divide, and equate them with a range of undesirable characteristics. Considering the history of instances of homophobia in football, the fact that these massed chants perpetuate intolerance, and the fact that there's little room for subtlety when it comes to a whole crowd chanting, I should think this sort of thing is best avoided - especially given the media profile of our club now.' (https://www.holmesdale.net/page.php?id=106&tid=166166&page=2)

Gareth only quoted the section in bold. Furthermore, the documentary makes it sound as if the author of my statement was also the author of the message underneath, the content of which I did not agree with.

Here is the other thing I had to say in another thread on the matter, which perhaps makes me clearer:

'If I can offer an overly intellectual opinion, I did make an interesting note from Randall Collins' book on the micro-sociology of violence recently:

'Despite the use of sexist epithets to insult men they do not like, the hooligans of the 1980s were ardent admirers of Margaret Thatcher and the queen—presumably because these could be used to assert English solidarity and superiority, and to put down respectable educated liberals and leftists; although in Italy they chant ‘f*** the Pope!’, at home they defend the Catholic church, out of hostility to the Anglican establishment (Buford 1993: 95). The pattern is much like that analyzed by Katz (1999) in his study of freeway road rage: curses are brought to one's lips because they fit the particular target one is confronting at the moment; they need not be based on deeply held beliefs, and the repertoire can be inconsistent and contradictory from occasion to occasion.'

I'd suggest that homophobic taunts are a similar phenomenon: those chanting mostly aren't deep-seated homophobes, but instrumentalise a background convention of homophobia, as Anthony King has argued in the case of most racist chanting.

So I don't think that most people joining in with these chants are particularly hateful; but intent is somewhat irrelevant when the effect is chanting that equates homosexuality with all sorts of negative traits. There's no room for subtlety in a crowd.' (https://www.holmesdale.net/page.php?id=106&tid=166664&page=2)

Gareth only quotes one message of opposition to homophobia, when these constituted the majority of responses. I posted in opposition to the 'gays = paedophiles' remark which he showcased, for example (https://www.holmesdale.net/page.php?id=106&tid=166866&page=4).

So if Gareth believes that I am one of the culprits of internet homophobia, then I would be very happy to talk directly with him as he requests and show him that I am not.

The thing is, Gareth: I'm on your side! I think homophobia is a blight on football and on society, and should be eradicated. But if you have to distort facts to prove that point, you're playing into the hands of the conspiracy-theorist homophobes who claim there's a gay agenda distorting the facts!

This sort of thing is entirely unnecessary, and I have to wonder if you did it deliberately, in order to prove your point that homophobia in football is (I quote) 'slowly but surely getting out of control'. You do not provide adequate evidence for this claim, and while I think homophobia in football is a problem which still exists and urgently needs to be addressed, most football fans and at least these experts who reported to a parliamentary select committee (https://www.theguardian.com/football/2016/may/18/football-fans-more-accepting-homosexuality-uk-homophobia-sport-inquiry) will inform you that in fact it is slowly but surely decreasing.

I will also send this message to Gareth.

Edited by Bangell (28 Jul 2017 12.38am)

 

lanepe1 Flag Portslade 28 Jul 17 12.46am

I go on this site because I am interested in the players we are bringing in or leaving.
I am 38 YO looking on this site, but if I was a teenager and thinking I was gay, and then read those comments, how would I feel? It is not how I feel, but about others

 

lanepe1 Flag Portslade 28 Jul 17 1.05am

'I don't think many people who join in the 'Brighton take it up the bum' chants have any real malicious intent, and are being knowingly juvenile for a laugh'

So if a footballer and heard this? how would expect them to react?

If you heard this in the work place how you react

Can I suggest that you read the Equality and Diversity Act

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 28 Jul 17 1.10am

Originally posted by lanepe1

'I don't think many people who join in the 'Brighton take it up the bum' chants have any real malicious intent, and are being knowingly juvenile for a laugh'

So if a footballer and heard this? how would expect them to react?

If you heard this in the work place how you react

Can I suggest that you read the Equality and Diversity Act

Can I suggest you read the rest of my post, where I said that I do not condone the chanting?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jul 17 6.30am

Originally posted by lanepe1

'I don't think many people who join in the 'Brighton take it up the bum' chants have any real malicious intent, and are being knowingly juvenile for a laugh'

So if a footballer and heard this? how would expect them to react?

If you heard this in the work place how you react

Can I suggest that you read the Equality and Diversity Act

I was at an Ashes test match a few years ago and the great Glenn McGrath was fielding quite near where I was sitting. Now I often find cricket banter very funny and it was this time until a couple of the less intelligent shouted out that his wife took it up the bum.

Likewise David Beckham used to hear those very same taunts about his wife at every game he played in.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jul 17 6.32am

Originally posted by Bangell

<snip>

I will also send this message to Gareth.

Why waste your time. He set out to make a TV program and did exactly what he set out to do. Do you really think that if he found no comments that he could use he would have cancelled the program?

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 28 Jul 17 6.44am

Well there's a surprise.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 28 Jul 17 6.53am

Originally posted by lanepe1

I go on this site because I am interested in the players we are bringing in or leaving.
I am 38 YO looking on this site, but if I was a teenager and thinking I was gay, and then read those comments, how would I feel? It is not how I feel, but about others

Whilst I agree there's no place for homophobia.. This is a classic case of throwing the baby out with the bathwater...one thread...one in how many hundred focus upon...and even then just a few posts within it.

I think the cause would be much better served by not undertaking such a contrived approach to making a mountain out of a molehill...context is everything.

The irony that a programme trying to portray a stereotype..is in fact through the lack of context promoting its own stereotypes of how it perceives football fans... You couldn't make it up.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 28 Jul 17 7.04am

Originally posted by Lyons550

Whilst I agree there's no place for homophobia.. This is a classic case of throwing the baby out with the bathwater...one thread...one in how many hundred focus upon...and even then just a few posts within it.

I think the cause would be much better served by not undertaking such a contrived approach to making a mountain out of a molehill...context is everything.

The irony that a programme trying to portray a stereotype..is in fact through the lack of context promoting its own stereotypes of how it perceives football fans... You couldn't make it up.

It was definitely agenda driven but unfortunately clowns like Parchmore couldn't wait to jump in.

I hope he's enjoying his fifteen minutes of fame.

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 28 Jul 17 7.06am

Originally posted by Bangell

Okay, have now watched the relevant part of the documentary. I was correct that Parchmore was one of the fools quoted, surprise surprise.

I was intrigued to see Gareth quote one of my responses as an example of an opinion which causes him to put his head in his hands - a state of despair which could perhaps have been avoided if he'd read the whole message, or even the whole sentence. Here is what I wrote:

'I don't think many people who join in the 'Brighton take it up the bum' chants have any real malicious intent, and are being knowingly juvenile for a laugh. But the chants do effectively put all homosexuals on the wrong side of the 'us vs them' divide, and equate them with a range of undesirable characteristics. Considering the history of instances of homophobia in football, the fact that these massed chants perpetuate intolerance, and the fact that there's little room for subtlety when it comes to a whole crowd chanting, I should think this sort of thing is best avoided - especially given the media profile of our club now.' (https://www.holmesdale.net/page.php?id=106&tid=166166&page=2)

Gareth only quoted the section in bold. Furthermore, the documentary makes it sound as if the author of my statement was also the author of the message underneath, the content of which I did not agree with.

Here is the other thing I had to say in another thread on the matter, which perhaps makes me clearer:

'If I can offer an overly intellectual opinion, I did make an interesting note from Randall Collins' book on the micro-sociology of violence recently:

'Despite the use of sexist epithets to insult men they do not like, the hooligans of the 1980s were ardent admirers of Margaret Thatcher and the queen—presumably because these could be used to assert English solidarity and superiority, and to put down respectable educated liberals and leftists; although in Italy they chant ‘f*** the Pope!’, at home they defend the Catholic church, out of hostility to the Anglican establishment (Buford 1993: 95). The pattern is much like that analyzed by Katz (1999) in his study of freeway road rage: curses are brought to one's lips because they fit the particular target one is confronting at the moment; they need not be based on deeply held beliefs, and the repertoire can be inconsistent and contradictory from occasion to occasion.'

I'd suggest that homophobic taunts are a similar phenomenon: those chanting mostly aren't deep-seated homophobes, but instrumentalise a background convention of homophobia, as Anthony King has argued in the case of most racist chanting.

So I don't think that most people joining in with these chants are particularly hateful; but intent is somewhat irrelevant when the effect is chanting that equates homosexuality with all sorts of negative traits. There's no room for subtlety in a crowd.' (https://www.holmesdale.net/page.php?id=106&tid=166664&page=2)

Gareth only quotes one message of opposition to homophobia, when these constituted the majority of responses. I posted in opposition to the 'gays = paedophiles' remark which he showcased, for example (https://www.holmesdale.net/page.php?id=106&tid=166866&page=4).

So if Gareth believes that I am one of the culprits of internet homophobia, then I would be very happy to talk directly with him as he requests and show him that I am not.

The thing is, Gareth: I'm on your side! I think homophobia is a blight on football and on society, and should be eradicated. But if you have to distort facts to prove that point, you're playing into the hands of the conspiracy-theorist homophobes who claim there's a gay agenda distorting the facts!

This sort of thing is entirely unnecessary, and I have to wonder if you did it deliberately, in order to prove your point that homophobia in football is (I quote) 'slowly but surely getting out of control'. You do not provide adequate evidence for this claim, and while I think homophobia in football is a problem which still exists and urgently needs to be addressed, most football fans and at least these experts who reported to a parliamentary select committee (https://www.theguardian.com/football/2016/may/18/football-fans-more-accepting-homosexuality-uk-homophobia-sport-inquiry) will inform you that in fact it is slowly but surely decreasing.

I will also send this message to Gareth.

Edited by Bangell (28 Jul 2017 12.38am)

Unfortunately Gareth, won't give a Fck that you send him your message, him and his BBC cronies are just self serving publicly seekers, trolling for a non story.

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 28 Jul 17 7.08am

All are welcome at Palace.

 


[Link]

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jul 17 7.46am

Originally posted by Lyons550

Whilst I agree there's no place for homophobia.. This is a classic case of throwing the baby out with the bathwater...one thread...one in how many hundred focus upon...and even then just a few posts within it.

That's not really true though. Every time the word "Brighton" is mentioned all of the homophobic comments are trotted out and although I don't look at other football club forums I'm willing to bet that it's only us that focuses on the homosexual connotation that Palace fans seem to be fixated on with Brighton.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 28 Jul 17 8.09am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

That's not really true though. Every time the word "Brighton" is mentioned all of the homophobic comments are trotted out and although I don't look at other football club forums I'm willing to bet that it's only us that focuses on the homosexual connotation that Palace fans seem to be fixated on with Brighton.


Ok... Hopefully you'll be bored again today Your task is to look at all Brighton threads on this forum and work out the % of posts within them that have homophobic text...I bet it's far far less than you imagine.. Even though you'd be narrowing your search by looking for those specific threads.

.. But that's my point.. The programme targets 'the beautiful game' in its title, not a specific rivalry, in which it looks at a narrow section of threads and even then find a few specific posts to try and find and then justify a stereotype...exceedingly poor journalism.

Even amateurish... Once you've found the % we then need to find what % that is of the hundreds of thousands of posts on here.. Just one message board for one club.... Only then can their claims be placed in any sort of meaningful context.


Edited by Lyons550 (28 Jul 2017 8.10am)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

c_block_shedevil Flag London 28 Jul 17 8.10am

Just been reading on Twitter. The homophobic posts are getting dogs abuse from people. Someone even suggested we are like Millwall!

How about the homophobic palace fans go and f*** off and support Millwall instead. They won't be missed here. Especially if they are turning my club into a national disgrace.

This site once used to be moderated to bits. What's happened? Why were these posters not banned?

 


I'm tough. I'm ambitious. I know exactly what I want. If that makes me a bitch, I'm OK with that.

Part Time James Flag 28 Jul 17 8.13am

Originally posted by c_block_shedevil

Just been reading on Twitter. The homophobic posts are getting dogs abuse from people. Someone even suggested we are like Millwall!

How about the homophobic palace fans go and f*** off and support Millwall instead. They won't be missed here. Especially if they are turning my club into a national disgrace.

This site once used to be moderated to bits. What's happened? Why were these posters not banned?

And why was the well poisoner not banned and his thread shut down?

 




Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Tez Flag Epsom 28 Jul 17 9.02am

As several people said (off the top of my head PTJ was the first to suggest it) the thread should have been closed and deleted as soon as it appeared on the forum and Mr Thomas should have been red carded.

Regardless of if a journalist or TV producer works for the BBC, ITV, Channel 4, Sky, Fox News, they are always going to sensationalise and manipulate facts according to their own agenda.

Gareth Thomas clearly came to this forum with the express intention of getting a few screenshots from a minority of fans making 'gay' jokes and because of the lack of action from the mods, he succeeded.

Hope lessons can be learned from this.

 

Page 1 of 25 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Gareth Thomas Documentary – Alfie v Homophobia – T